The U.S. media have been fixated on yet another white, brunette young woman. This one went missing after going out for a marathon run near Atlanta, Georgia. A clump of hair and discarded sweats were found in the woods. Fox’s Greta Van Susteran quizzed former L.A. detective Mark Fuhrmann and medical examiner Michael Baden on the scant clues. Fox’s Bill O’Reilly devoted half his Friday show to the lost young Caucasian bride-to-be.
Only the local police, who for unstated reasons called off the search early yesterday — and Keith Olbermann, who questioned her mental stability and noted how her eyes bugged out in all the photos — seemed to have a clue. This morning, Jennifer Wilbanks turned up safe. She’d run away. (More below.)
Thousands of miles away, another young woman — unknown to U.S. media — faces a firing squad on Monday. There is no photo of her, and only scant publicity. But her story, which includes imprisonment and rape, is vastly more compelling and time-critical (How to help in comments!):
First, a word for those of you who do not live in the U.S.: It is impossible to describe to you adequately the amount of time and resources that U.S. media devoted to Jennifer Wilbanks. CNN, MSNBC, FOX News, the major networks, newspapers — all the media — gave constant updates, interviews with every person who’d ever known this woman, and constant analyses with “experts” on criminal investigations from the FBI, police, and medical examiners’ departments.
She is a white, middle-class brunette bride-to-be, and her fiance looked, on television, slightly suspicious. And those are the key factors — like the Laci Peterson saga — that made her story a “hit” on television. And those maddening factors are what drive the Americans who frequent this blog away from television.
Missing Georgia Bride-To-Be Found with Cold Feet
Jennifer Wilbanks, a 32-year-old medical assistant, called her family early Saturday morning, saying she had been kidnapped while jogging on Tuesday night and taken to New Mexico, where she was released.
She soon recanted her story, telling police in Albuquerque, New Mexico, that she had fled Georgia by bus because she was scared about her upcoming nuptials, according to Randall Belcher, the police chief in Duluth.
I turned to CNN at 9AM PDT. It is now 9:37 AM and, even though she’s been found, this is the only story reported in the last half-hour by CNN.
A Word About Missing Persons:
There are thousands and thousands of other missing people in this country alone. Look at the photos of missing people in Manhattan alone: Stephanie Servio, Last seen 07/03/04, Manhattan (black); Veronica Aguires, Last Seen 12/22/03, Manhattan (Hispanic); Rafine Caballero, Last seen 04/15/04, Manhattan (Hispanic), Lucia Casa, Last seen 04/15/04, Manhattan (Hispanic), and on and on. The police department asks that their photos not be reproduced elsewhere.
Then, as we learned last night from David Brancaccio on PBS’s NOW, the family of Haj Ali — the famous man in the hood — searched for him after he went missing. Haj’s family went to Abu Ghraib and, when they asked if he were a prisoner, were told by U.S. authorities that no, he was not at Abu Ghraib. One can only imagine his family’s suffering, not knowing what had become of him until his abrupt release from Abu Ghraib.
Did we ever hear a word about the Ali family’s search? Or about the search for Stephanie, Veronica, Rafine, or Lucia? Of course not.
_____________________________________________________
From Amnesty International UK — the story the U.S. press ignores –about a 21-year-old woman who was tortured and then confessed to murdering her husband when she was 15 and who subsequently was raped in prison, giving birth to a child, now a toddler:
Yemen: Young mother faces execution for crime committed when 16
Amina Ali Abduladif only escaped the firing squad in 2002 because the executioners noticed she was pregnant, according to reports from her lawyer.
She was reportedly raped by one of the guards at al-Mahaweet prison. As a result she gave birth to a child, who is with her in Sana’a Women Central prison and is now very nearly two years old.
Amnesty International UK Director Kate Allen said:
“We have only four days to stop the execution of Amina. I hope the people and government of the UK will join Amnesty in its campaign to prevent this unnecessary death.
“Amina was only sixteen when her husband was killed. She maintains that she is innocent and that her confession was tortured out of her.
“The death penalty is always cruel, always unnecessary, always wrong. But with Amina the case for commuting the death penalty is stronger than ever.” …
The Yemen Times reports that “Mrs. Shadha Mohammad Nasser, a lawyer at the supreme court appealed, on behalf of Amina Ali Abduladif suspected of killing her husband Hizam Hassan Miqa’el, to the President and Chairman of the Supreme Judiciary Council to repeal the execution of the suspect.”
The total number of news stories after a Google News search: Two. Both from The Yemen Times.
Compare that to the number of stories about Ms. Wilbanks:
Missing woman’s fiancé considers polygraph exam
Atlanta Journal Constitution (subscription), GA – Apr 29, 2005
The fiancé of a Duluth woman missing since Tuesday night has told police he will let … Most of the 14 bridesmaids — who are to wear long black gowns — have …
Organizers halt search for missing bride-to-be Indianapolis Star
$100K Reward For Missing Bride CBS News
Anguish, mystery deepen in search for missing woman Atlanta Journal Constitution (subscription)
The Casper Star Tribune – all 1,183 related »
What might we do for Amina? I didn’t find an “action” suggestion at the UK Amnesty International site.
Our ambassador is Thomas C. Krajeski. If anyone can find an email address for him, post it here.
To contact:
U.S. Embassy in Sana’a, Yemen
Address: Sa’awan Street, P.O. Box 22347
Telephone: (967) 1 303-155 to 159
Fax: (967) 1 303160/1/2/4/5
Emergency only: (967) 1 303166
Can’t find any email addresses yet. Still digging.
To contact: U.S. Embassy in Sana’a, Yemen
Address: Sa’awan Street, P.O. Box 22347
Telephone: (967) 1 303-155 to 159
Fax: (967) 1 303160/1/2/4/5
Emergency only: (967) 1 303166
sorry, forgot some tags…
COOL!
My daughter and I are going to her office early this afternoon to send a FAX!
THANK YOU!
And we can send a message to Condi:
Contact page
What I sent to them all … it’s short, but I think that that’s best. I also sent it to the World News desk at the Los Angeles Times:
FAX #s:
U.S. Embassy in Sana’a, Yemen
Address: Sa’awan Street, P.O. Box 22347
Telephone: (967) 1 303-155 to 159
Fax: (967) 1 303160/1/2/4/5
Emergency only: (967) 1 303166
___
United Nations:
212 980 0021
_____
Sen. Patty Murray:
(202) 224-0238
(FAX your own senator: www.senate.gov)
FAX NOTE:
Amina Ali Abduladif, who is 21 years old and has a 2 year old son (from a rape while she has been in prison), will be executed Monday in Yemen — by firing squad — for murdering her husband when she was 14 years old. She says she was tortured into confessing the murder of her husband. Further, Yemeni law prohibits the execution of someone under 18. The crime was committed when she was 14.
References:
http://www.amnesty.org.uk/news/press/16067.shtml
http://www.yementimes.com/article.shtml?i=836&p=local&a=1
NOTE, please, that the Yemen Times article says that “Mrs. Shadha Mohammad Nasser, a lawyer at the supreme court appealed, on behalf of Amina Ali Abduladif suspected of killing her husband Hizam Hassan Miqa’el, to the President and Chairman of the Supreme Judiciary Council to repeal the execution of the suspect.”
We urgently request that you contact the President and Chairman of the Supreme Judiciary Council.
Thank you for all you can do.
Susan
Port Angeles, WA
susanhu@earthlink.net
I wrote her story today on two blogs:
http://www.boomantribune.com/story/2005/4/30/94624/9337#9
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2005/4/30/13100/4665
I can find no email addresses on the embassy or Krajeski at all, anywhere. sorry.
ever since CNN devoted non-stop coverage to the Scott Peterson trial. It’s disgusting that our press devotes so much time to these trivial gossip stories, yet stories of actual substance are considered uninteresting. Who cares that a woman is about to be executed for a crime she may not have committed? Or that our President lied about Iraq, or that Tom DeLay is so corrupt he makes Ken Lay look honest? Some white person no one knows has gone missing! We don’t have time to worry about human rights or the ethics of our government!
It really is a blight on our nation.
I wrote this then decided to cross-post it at Daily Kos.
Someone posted a note that I should look at Georgia10’s diary in the Recommended list.
She wrote about the same two women!
OMG. Is that freaky or what? We did very different diaries, but the two main subjects are the same.
So I just spoke with Ellen Moore of Amnesty International’s Urgent Action Network…
She will be emailing me shortly contact information. She recommended that calls be made to your Congresspersons and Senators. Faxes will also help. Fax every office, the white house, and the Yemin Consultate here in the US…the UN fax number is 212 980 0021.
I’m assuming that Monday is actually Sunday here in the US….Ellen explained that they will, sometimes delay these MURDERS if there is a flurry of activity and if they know that people are paying attention.
She did say that this is starting to gain some attention. I mentioned dKos, and she definately seemed to understand that knowing this hit dKos was a very good thing. So lets get it together folks…
Maybe if we work real hard, we can get this to this evenings MSM news….
I’m also going to email the morning news talk shows…and hope for a brief showing there. Stephenopolis should have time to get this in, right
jhwygirl on Sat Apr 30th, 2005 at 08:29:12 PDT
on Georgia10’s diary:
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2005/4/30/94835/3481
I’m at my daughter’s office and we’re faxing everybody.
This is a great list with fax #s from FAIR:
http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=111#National%20newspapers
ALL MEDIA:
http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=111
A sad commentary on what passes for journalism in this country.
I had this one all set up and ready to fire, and whoomp! There it was already!
In addition to writing the Yemeni embassy, I would suggest, though I don’t know if it will do any more good, mailing the corporate media with this diary, the contrast is quite striking.
If anybody can figure out how to get in touch with this woman’s lawyer (maybe Amnesty will know?) she might have information about the family’s needs.
What is needed even more is for the East to raise a stink. There is no justification for this, I understand the need for countries to assert their sovreignty etc etc but this young woman is not to blame for western colonialism or hegemony, and it is grotesque and absurd for people who should know better to make her pay for it for the sake of a statement.
There are plenty of other things that Yemen could do that would be less counter-productive, and I had better shut up now.
An update: Darcy and I faxed both our senators, every major newspaper in the country (use the FAIR.ORG links above), Amnesty, ACLU, and the US Embassy in Yeme… and more but I can’t remember. Anyway, here is another suggestion from someone at kos:
From a POST AT DAILYKOS:
Urgent Network’s Ellen Moore. Please note the talking points on the bottom, and expecially the contact info…..
26 April 2005
UA 99/05 Imminent execution
YEMEN
Amina Ali Abdulatif (f), aged 21
Muhammad Ali Said Qaba’il (m), aged 26
Amina Ali Abduladif is reportedly scheduled to be
executed on 2 May. She was reportedly sentenced
to death when she was 16 years old, although the
Yemeni Penal Code expressly prohibits the use of
the death penalty against anyone convicted of
crimes committed when they were under 18.
She was convicted of the murder of her husband,
who had been killed in January 1998, and
sentenced to death on 24 May 1999. She had
reportedly been tortured to force her to confess,
and has since maintained her innocence.
Muhammad Ali Said Qaba’il was also sentenced to
death for the murder, but it is not known when he
is scheduled for execution
The court of appeal did not consider Amina’s age,
and upheld the sentence in July 2001. The
Supreme Court upheld the sentence in July 2002,
and the sentence was ratified by the president
shortly afterwards.
Not long after the president ratified the sentence,
Amina Ali Abduladif was, according to her
lawyer, put before a firing squad. It was only when
the executioners noticed that she was pregnant that
the execution was stopped. According to her
lawyer she had been raped by one of the guards at
al-Mahaweet prison. As a result she gave birth to a
child, who is with her in Sana’a Women Central
prison, where she is now held, and is now very
nearly two years old.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
Amnesty International has longstanding concerns
about the use of the death penalty in Yemen,
particularly as death sentences are often passed
after proceedings which fall short of international
standards for fair trial.
While Amnesty International recognizes the right
and responsibility of governments to bring to
justice those suspected of recognizably criminal
offences, it is unconditionally opposed to the death
penalty in all cases as the ultimate violation of the
right to life.
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Please send
appeals to arrive as quickly as possible:
– urging the President to commute the death
sentence passed on Amina Ali Abduladif and
Muhammad Ali Said Qaba’il, and stressing that the
Yemeni Penal Code prohibits the execution of
people convicted of crimes committed when they
were under 18;
– acknowledging that the government has a right to
bring to justice those responsible for criminal
offences, but expressing unconditional opposition
to the death penalty;
– reminding the authorities that they are bound by
international standards for fair trial in capital cases,
including the right to seek pardon or commutation
of the sentence;
– calling on the authorities to order an investigation
into the rape of Amina Ali Abduladif, allegedly by
a prison guard, and to ensure that she is protected
from any further ill-treatment while she is in
prison.
APPEALS TO:
President:
His Excellency General´Ali ´Abdullah Saleh
President of the Republic of Yemen
Sanaa
Republic of Yemen
Faxes: 011 967 127 4147
Salutation: Your Excellency
Minister of Interior:
His Excellency Dr Rashid Muhammad al-Alimi
Ministry of Interior
Sanaa
Republic of Yemen
Faxes: 011 967 1 332 511
Salutation: Your Excellency
Minister of Human Rights:
Her Excellency Amat al Aeem al Suswah
Ministry for Human Rights
Sana’a, Republic of Yemen
Faxes: 011 967 1 444 838
Salutation: Your Excellency
COPIES TO:
Ambassador Abdulwahab A. Al-Hajjri
Embassy of the Republic of Yemen
2600 Virginia Ave. NW Suite 705
Washington DC 20037
Fax: 1202 337 2017
Email: ambassador@yemenembassy.org
Please send appeals immediately. Check with
the Colorado office between 9:00 am and 6:00
pm, Mountain Time, weekdays only, if sending
appeals after June 7, 2005.
Amnesty International is a worldwide grassroots movement that
promotes and defends human rights.
This Urgent Action may be reposted if kept intact, including
contact information and stop action date (if applicable). Thank
you for your help with this appeal.
Urgent Action Network
Amnesty International USA
PO Box 1270
Nederland CO 80466-1270
Email: uan@aiusa.org
http://www.amnestyusa.org/urgent/
Phone: 303 258 1170
Fax: 303 258 7881
HAVE AT IT!
……….
SUGGESTION FROM SOMEONE:
However, I tried a number of different variations on the email address until I found one that did, and sent the below letter:
mohammed@yemenembassy.com
ATTN: AMBASSADOR
Please commute the death sentence passed on Amina Ali Abduladif and Muhammad Ali Said Qaba’il. The Yemeni Penal Code prohibits the execution of
people convicted of crimes committed when they were under 18.
The government has a right to bring to justice those responsible for criminal offences, but they are bound by international standards for fair trial in capital cases, including the right to seek pardon or commutation , of the sentence.
I also call on the authorities to order an investigation into the rape of Amina Ali Abduladif, allegedly by a prison guard, and to ensure that she is protected
from any further ill-treatment while she is in prison.
Thank you,
Judy Brown
Here is the latest from some Yemeni news sources:
Controversy in case of Amina flares up: http://www.yobserver.com/news_6216.php
New law for freeing Yemeni women from unjust laws: http://yementimes.com/article.shtml?i=838&p=opinion&a=4
It appears that Amina Ali Abduladif has been spared through a Yemeni Presidential suspension of her execution. Her lawyer says it’s not clear how long the suspension is for, although the gist of The Times’ story suggests that the outlook is optimistic.
It includes the following:
Thank you everyone who pursued this case. I’ll take on the task of watching for further developments.
That is fantastic news. Keep us posted.
[posted earlier on another thread – a bit confused]
#
Re-read your recent diary and had previously Googled for Amina Al-Tuhaif. Now understand the similarity in the LETTER doc found and the article in Weekly Yemen Observer. I used a copy of the latter as reference in a personalized version of appeal to all persons and Email addresses provided!
http://www.presidentsaleh.gov.ye/en/index.php?option=contact&Itemid=6
His Excellency, Minister of Human Rights Ms. Amat Al Alleem Soussua,
mshr@y.net.ye
His Excellency, Minister of Foreign Affairs Mr. Abubaker ALQIRBI
His Excellency, Ambassador Abdulwahab Abdulla Al-Hajjri
ambassador@yemenembassy.org
Subject: Appeal for Reconsideration Sentence of Mrs. Amina Al Tuhaif
YOUR PUBLICATION ON HUMAN RIGHTS OF THE CHILD
Yemen ratified the Convention on the rights of the Child in 1991.
I. LEGISLATION ON THE RIGHTS OF THE CHILD
A- Definition of the child in Yemeni legislation
Various Yemeni laws and legislative enactments set different legal ages for the exercise of various rights and obligations:
The Constitution, the Electoral Act, the Compulsory National Service Act and the General Reserve Act set the minimum age for exercising those rights at 18 years. For example, in the Civil Service Act it is set at 18 and in the Civil Status and Civil Registration Act at 16. The Rights of the Child Law of 2002 defines the child as every person who has not passed the age of 18 as long as he has not reached maturity. The Penal Code sets the age of the “juvenile” under 15 years of age while the Passport Act entitles any person over 16 years of age to passports and travel documents.
In reference to a publication in the Yemen Observer on April 30, 2005 and a number of concerns voiced by global NGO’s who’s focus is the care of children.
Appreciation of the efforts and tasks performed by the Yemeni government, its leaders and society as a whole to meet the challenges of the 21st century and provide security and welfare for its citizens.
As an individual person, respectfully do appeal to Your Excellence to do all possible within the power and compassion befitting your position, in accordance with the Constitution and Judicial Acts of the Yemen Sovereign Nation.
Personally, my believe is that capital punishment should be reserved by the state for the ultimate and extreme crimes against society. The state should also show compassion, where it’s required by unusual circumstances of events, and certainly in the case of Mrs. Amina Al Tuhaif, a minor when alleged crimes were committed and mother of child.
In trust that your decision will be JUST, I respectfully extend my good wishes to the leadership of the Republic of Yemen and the representation of the People of Yemen.
With Cordial Greetings,
– – – – Oui – – – –
The Hague, the Netherlands
Article Yemen Observer about Mrs. Amina Al-Tuhaif with child.
PS HOME PAGE for additional links to Yemen.
Oui – Liberté – Egalité – Fraternité