On april 7, 2005 I wrote the following diary, since I wrote this a lot has changed and I am curious how you all would respond today in view of the way this site has developed.
This is the link to the first diary:
http://www.boomantribune.com/story/2005/4/7/91329/56729
I am wondering what is the point of all of these stories constantly brought to our attention. How can we possibly take a viable interest in every one of these issues and if we do what can be done about them?
Sure I agree we should be interested in the whole world, but is that diffusing the problems we have in this country and our ability to take effective action (another question in itself).
What is the purpose of this forum and others like DK, just to endlessly discuss every issue, and then do nothing, take no action, just to know about it and discuss it to death. I am concerned that we are wasting away the time when perhaps we could be actually doing something, become a force of change.
I am not saying I have the answers, but I am asking the question and perhaps we could discuss our purpose, if we have one, or if we don’t, should we?
I see a parade of subjects come up every day on the recent diary list, and very few comments are made. The problem for me and why I do not comment on a lot of these diaries is that I simply have nothing to say. What comment is meaningful to add to news stories and other such articles. On DK a news item is met with a long list of wows, too bad, this is terrible, etc. ad infinitum. Not so bad on this site, where much more substantive comments are the rule and not the exception.
Occasionally one of the topics catches fire and we discuss (or argue) it for days and in the end, what have we done, nothing.
What purpose is this serving except to take up a lot of time for a lot of people that is not doing one damn thing to change anything, just over informing all of us.
I personally think we need to narrow down our focus a bit and limit it to things we may possibly be able to change and start to figure out just what we might be able to do.
Right now the issues presented are scattered over the entire world and no action that I can see is being taken or even asked for, except for a few petitions here and there, a few letters written to media and newspapers and Congress.
So I am asking, “What you think about this; our purpose, the purpose of forums and blogs in general and what changes we could make that would make us (blog world) productive and effective and not just a big political chat room?
Lets talk!
This was Booman’s response:
One purpose of this blog is to cover news that is being ignored or undercovered, or covered in an entirely parochial or jingoistic manner.
Another purpose is to hunt down corruption and to highlight stories about malfeasance in government.
Of course, we are too small to have much effect right now, but that will change…hopefully.
Another purpose is to build a community of politically educated and active people that can be mobilized to take actions…flooding a Congressperson with mail, having a meet-up in Seattle to support a progressive candidate, raising money for a worthy candidate etc.
As I said in my FP article on Israel, we are a government-in-waiting. Too much of our efforts are focused on mere critiques, while alternatives are ignored. Bush will not let us help, or participate. He just nominated a laundry list of the most reviled people in the country to head his second term government. He doesn’t want our help.
But we need to be prepared to take over. And so, we need to talk about global issues.
So, I agree with your critique.
But we also try to have fun here at the Frog-Pond. The next big election is 18 months off. We can’t take ourselves too seriously every day.
So, we should share our foibles and jokes, and not insist everything be framed in a political context.
We’ll ramp up late in the year when we start thinking about primaries.
I guess you could say I brought Booman’s thoughts into the fore when I ended up starting the Froggy Bottom Cafe as well as the Welcome Wagon.
So I am curious what are your thoughts today as we have evolved into the great site we are today and where do you all see or would like to see us going.
I took some flack when I did this subject before that I perhaps was not interested in world affairs and I assure you that I do care and am very interested in the topics all over the world and now we have Euro Trib, so that is just great…
So Let’s talk!!