In my news-lacking world, I had an epiphany over the past few days. I guess it is not an extraordinary revelation as I start to try to boil it down to the written word. In fact, I know I’ve read it on dKos and BMT in the past. It just didn’t have such palpable meaning to me then.
The Booman Tribune and Daily Kos are much, much more that a place for Democratic activism. Even if they don’t want to be. They just are. To me, they are (or were, until a little less than two weeks ago when this experiment started) my primary source of news. They help shape the stories that I want to read about. And, they allow me a place to respond on those occasions when sitting idly by and reading the news is not enough. They are like a gigantic town hall. A place of civic gathering and sharing. And a world without these venues is far dimmer than the one where they exist.
The part about the news dawned on me yesterday, as I was reading through my fifth consecutive day of the NYTs where I just didn’t really give a shit. I am having a hell of a time staying motivated to make it all the way through articles. Maybe this is just a problem with me – I don’t know. But, I think it is simply a paradigm shift that has happened in the news. I’ve been reading a newspaper everyday since I was a boy. But, the way I read the newspaper since the advent of the bloggosphere (or at least my introduction to it) has completely changed. My attention span is gone. My willingness to put up with corporate slanted reporting and opinion is gone. And the past week or so of reading the NYT has been awful. So freaking disjointed. You can’t believe it.
In the world of the NYTs, Rove is just a whisper. It is not a full blown scandal. The falling apart of the unions in the face of global corporatism is just a blip on the screen (I mean there has been significant coverage, but to what end – I don’t see it). Roberts is a staunch conservative, but there is little inkling that he is about to go the way of the Bork. Abortion is about to be subjected to the tyranny of the masses, and I am not really reading that in the NYTs. I have to be able to read between the lines. The energy bill – it’s not so bad according to the editorial page, except the cowards need to take on gas mileage. The news is completely sanitized. You would never imagine that the very globe is shaking – bleeding. We are just here passing through. Nothing is the end of the world. It will all be okay.
I have taken to browsing Wikipedia – not for news mind you. Just to try to educate myself on progressive ideas. And, I came across a quote my Noam Chomsky. I can’t remember it verbatim, but to paraphrase – the ideal system for pacifying people is to allow for a completely free debate, but only within the narrow confines that are acceptable to the ruling class. That way people think they are free, but nothing is really said or changed.
It made me think of the corporate media. And America. Even dKos (and far less so BMT IMHO) sometimes limits debate I think. But, these venues are so far superior to the MSM.
I originally thought 30 days would be too short for this experiment, so I put the deadline at the end of the summer. But, now that seems like a terribly long way away.
Last word. A couple of stories in the disconnected soup that have stuck in my mind. I read in that the DOD is ignoring a District Court order to release abuse photos. It was one story buried somewhere. And I haven’t seen anything since. I mean, isn’t this similar to the Saturday (?) Night Massacre when Nixon fired the Attorney General. If the Military ignores the civilian courts, aren’t we kind of by definition in some sort of Totalitarianistic Funhouse?
And, this story. I have to share one line verbatim. It is one of the few stories in the NYT that just keeps coming back. Almost daily. Our good friend and USA supporter Ayad al-Sirowiy. He is the thirteen year old Iraqi, blinded in one eye by a U.S. cluster bomb. Surely you recall it. The feel good story of the war. Brought by American generosity, to America, for American surgery to restore his sight.
Ayad is going home today or yesterday, or whenever it is according the NYTs Standard Time. He is still blind in one eye. But, I think he got contacts for his remaining eye. And, he has had laser surgery to remove the scarring on his face, though he will need to return for future operations if he wants to keep the process of regaining a normal face again moving in the right direction.
So how does Ayad feel about it all. He loves it here. He is drinking a lot of Pepsi. That’s right. Pepsi is in the first paragraph. (And the Pepsi quote is blocked out in case you missed it in the lead.) And, he thinks President Bush is a very, very good man. There is a nice photo of him saluting a photo of fearless leader. Of course, Ayad and his father were last seen on American soil begging to stay here. They love America. I don’t think their motivation has anything to do with the fact that they are returning to a country where unexploded cluster bombs are a threat to your existence. Nor, do I think their motivation has anything to do with daily suicide bombings. Heck, America is just the greatest country on the damned planet, and that is that.
Ayad’s father is a little disillusioned as he waits for his plane home. He thought Americans could grant him any wish. He thought he could stay. But, Ayad still wants to come back.
But, the line that makes it memorable for me. “He was injured at the beginning of the Iraq war after his cow accidentally set off an American cluster bomb, which drilled tiny pieces of shrapnel into Ayad’s face, blinding him in one eye and printing a map of pin-prick scars across his skin.”
It was not a lying President. Or an oil thirsty administration. Or a negligent intelligence apparatus. Or WMD. Or al-Qeada. Or Sadaam. Or a manufacturer of cluster bombs. None of those things are pertinent to this tale. In sum, the tragedy of the Iraq War, as it relates to 13-year old Ayad, can be parsed for causation. And the culprit is his own cow. The cow was not malicious, this much we know. Nor, was the cow negligent in its efforts at bomb disposal. It was all an accident.
I feel better. I think I can sleep at night now.
I can really relate to your comments on the community aspects at BMT, and how we collectively discuss and decide what’s important. A function that the barber, the corner deli, the general store, the post office, the blacksmith served for previous generations. The agora.
Re your comment: The news is completely sanitized. You would never imagine that the very globe is shaking – bleeding. We are just here passing through. Nothing is the end of the world. It will all be okay. Of course the news cannot be too bad, if everyone were in a panic who would patronize the corporate sponsors?
You get a 4 for the story of Ayad and his cow. Even Aristotle discussed several types of “cause”; the NYT story blurs the distinctions between the causes that you point out: more muddy thinking.
This is sure getting interesting to read about.
Several times I’ve stopped taking our local newspaper because every morning when I opened it I felt as if they were reporting on an alternate universe. It was a really nice universe where presidents didn’t lie and nobody stole elections and wars were so minor they could be reported in a handful of little wire stories in the far back inside pages. But it didn’t look anything like the world I saw when I raised my eyes from the newspaper again, much like the world I see reported here.
Story placement, as much as anything, began to seem enormously important to me.
Are you sure you can stand to do this all summer?
Chomsky’s book on Media is an instructive little book. He makes it very clear that the people who rise to top jobs in the mass media do not really think they are being censored. All the ones who make waves are weeded out as in a garden until only those who are not going to cause trouble,ever,are left. It is just their mentality to report news, not make it. It is not a master plan put in operation by a someone,but the system itself. When we were young and hippies we knew that. How did so many of us forget?
The first time I posted at dkos I spent a lot of time posting about facts relating to 9-11 and they are myriad. Only to find out one night I could no longer post. I stayed away from November until just recently when I went back under a different ID,the one I am using here. I made sure I was very careful in what I said in posts. I had decided to only support those who had factual,out of the mainstream info. I made about three references to 9-11 citing the excellent Harper’s (Atlantic Monthly?)article in the Nov 04 issue. It was a critical analysis of the commission report and the part in it where Bush was interviewed in the oval office and out and out lied to them. They knew it,but also knew if they called him on it the entire government would totter,so they ignored it. It is footnoted 50 pages away as other people had testified under oath info that was in direct opposition to what Bush told the commission.
And guess what happened at dkos. Banned again. Also some others who posted quite intelligently about 9-11. Many people know these facts. Books have documented them,but no major publisher will touch them. Why are we piddling around with all the other crap he does when treason is the real issue. Everyone now knows Pearl Harbor was planned. And all these years later no one cares at all. Same with the Lusitania that started WWI and the Maine in Havana for the Spanish American War. Why try something new when the old model works so well?
Let’s see what happens to me here. Dkos is busy being a blog star and making $ with lucrative ads.
The part about the news dawned on me yesterday, as I was reading through my fifth consecutive day of the NYTs where I just didn’t really give a shit.
Looks like my comment from your last series was prescient Joe. Sadly prescient 🙁
I think sometimes that’s what the commercial media is designed to do – get your mind so stoned on rapidfire entertainment and shock and zip that the average person becomes so inundated that they are unable to concentrate on anything, even something as simple as “soldiers dying for a lie”.
Let’s also not forget the NYT and Fox don’t make their money from the subscriptions but from the AD CONTENT. That’s what the news is designed to do, SELL ADS. Period. The end.
Pax
It seems any articles in papers that are any good are few and far between and almost never on the front page. The good ones are ferreted out by bloggers and linked on this site and others for us to read.
Good Lord was there really a photo of Ayad saluting a picture of bush? Some ‘feel good’ story-are the people writing stories about him purposely ignoring the fact of how/why he was injured so horribly in the first fucken place? And if he is going to need so many more operations on face why is he and father being sent back to Iraq? One or two stories out of thousands of Iraqi children maimed beyond belief because of our invasion and this is supposed to show how ‘wonderful’ the US is?…something wrong with that whole line of feel good thinking.
I wonder what will be on the front page a month from now?