Analysis on the flip:
I want to look at this whole Plamegate thing from a little different perspective. I want to look at it from Joe Wilson’s point of view.
On Sunday, July 6th, 2003 the New York Times published Wilson’s infamous editorial What I Didn’t Find in Africa. Wilson also made an appearance on Meet the Press, and gave an interview to the Washington Post.
Having laid down the gauntlet, Wilson sat back to see what the reaction would be. At first, his revelations seemed to have the desired effect. On Monday night the administration gave Walter Pincus an official leak:
White House Backs Off Claim on Iraqi Buy
Wilson must have been satisfied to read that admission in his Tuesday morning Washington Post. But things would soon begin to get complicated.
On Monday, Robert Novak called Ari Fleischer and left a message. Fleischer claims he never returned the call, and he departed for Africa later that day.
On Tuesday, Novak called Rove. According to the official account, Novak was already armed with Plame’s identity at that point and Rove merely confirmed it. Later that afternoon, Novak had a conversation with a stranger on the street in Washington. In a coincidence that may wind up being critical to this case, the stranger was a friend of Joe Wilson’s. Here is how Wilson relates the event:
Wilson was obviously alarmed to hear that Novak was aware of his wife’s covert identity and was cavalierly discussing it with strangers on the street. He called Eason Jordan, the head of the news division at CNN. Jordan arranged for Novak to call Wilson, which he did Wednesday morning. However, Wilson and Novak played phone tag that day and didn’t make their first contact until Thursday.
On Thursday, Wilson dresses down Novak for being indiscreet and Novak apologizes. Wilson refuses to confirm that his wife works for the CIA.
But on Friday, Novak writes the column anyway (it will appear on Monday). Also on Friday, Karl Rove has a conversation with Matt Cooper of Time Magazine. Rove warns Cooper not to ‘get too far out’ on the Wilson story because his wife at ‘the agency’ was responsible for this trip. Wilson was blissfully unaware of these events, but he was given another warning on Saturday.
Sometime on Saturday Walter Pincus talked to an ‘administration official’, and is told ‘the White House had not paid attention to former Ambassador Joseph Wilson’s CIA-sponsored February 2002 trip to Niger because it was set up as a boondoggle by his wife, an analyst with the agency working on weapons of mass destruction.’
Pincus didn’t believe this report and he called Wilson to tell him that the administration was coming after him. Meanwhile, Scooter Libby confirmed Plame’s identity to Matt Cooper.
On Monday, Wilson’s wife’s identity hit the newsstands, along with her cover company. Wilson called Novak wanting to know why his sources were two administration officials when Novak had told Wilson his source was at the CIA. Novak says he misspoke when they talked earlier.
One week later, Chris Matthews called Wilson to tell him that Rove said his wife was ‘fair game’.
Is it any wonder that it is of keen interest to Joe Wilson that Karl Rove be frog-marched out of the White House?
Afterthought: where does Judith Miller fit into any of this?
If he wasn’t BEFORE this thing hit the fan…which I seriously doubt…he is now.
AT THE VERY LEAST…
An ally.
An asset.
A husband who is privy to the state of affairs regarding his wife and necessarily HAS been for a very long time. What kind of Top Secret clearance do you need before your mate is allowed to tell you what is going on?
“Sorry, Joe…I have to go away on another one of those business trips. Yes, I know it’s rather last minute. No…I won’t be able to be reached. Yes, I KNOW you’ve got important diplomatic business to attend to and all, but the firm is SO important!!! We’re RIGHT in the middle of some…very delicate oil negotiations. Yes, dear, I love you too. Bye bye. Kiss the kids and tell Chiquita to be VERY careful when she picks them up from school. She and her boyfriend Spike, too. Gotta go…hugs ‘n kisses…”‘
“Oh…and DON”T TRY TO GET INTO THAT OTHER CLOSET!!! YOU know the one…”
“Bye now…”
Give me a BREAK!!!
AG
could easily have been a member of the CIA working with official cover out of various embassies, but it appears he was not. Not that I know for sure..
Like they do in Washington, there’s an informal game of “name the spook” among American expats in foreign capitals. One of the reasons people are counted out is if their diplomatic position is such that it would be too embarrassing for them to be exposed as CIA. Generally, such ones were the ambassadors and the DCMs (Deputy Chief of Mission).
I don’t know that it is never the case that an ambassador cannot also be CIA, but I suspect it is so.
Though our speculation was never very serious and not likely on the money, I think we were probably right to count out the real diplomats like Wilson.
Nor will you ever.
That’s why it is “secret”.
Until the day some Joe Profaci sits in front of a Senate sub-committee and lays out the deal…which day will probably never come…you will NEVER know “for sure”.
BUT…if it quacks like a duck and it is MARRIED to a duck…it is most likely some kind of duckish personage.
Bet on it.
And work off of that premise.
When you do…things clear up enormously.
There is a war going on between two factions of the secret government.
The PermaGov.
ALL other sides and participants…those not in some way connected, allied or in some way controlled by either side.,..are reduced to near invisibility.
Green Partied right out of contention.
Small timed, nickel and dimed, left on the other side of the nightclub rope.
Bet on it.
SpookWorld ’05.
And Ambassadsor Jow is RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE OF THE PARTY.
What? You think the bouncers just let him in because he’s good looking?
FUGGEDABOUDIT!!!
AG
AG
P.S. How much would it cost to get an edit function for comments? I’d GLADLY contribute for THAT feature.
Very early on in this story, I read somewhere that when Wilson and Plame first met, he said something that indicated he had very high security clearance. As he would have, I suppose, having been an ambassador.
As I recall the report, she was vastly relieved because it meant that she could tell him what she really did for work.
from a drunken American, right? Was that Judith Miller? Could Chalabi have outed Plame to Miller, then Miller to Novak?
I love charts and this one is fascinating, but I don’t understand most of it. I know the basic Plame-CIA-Rove-Cooper Joe Wilson story, but I don’t understand the reference to a code break and a raid, and I don’t understand what role Iran played in all of this or anything about a UK Mole or what AQ is. Where does/do the Mystery Guy(s) spring from? Also Ridge and Franklin (whoever they are) aren’t connected to the official leak since no arrows go into them, only out. Plus I don’t understand the distinction between the “illegal leak” and the “illegal leak that is under investigation.” However, it has really peaked my curiosity! The analysis is great but it doesn’t connect the dots for me as far as the chart goes.
AQ is al-Qaeda.
Franklin has been indicted for passing secrets to Israel view AIPAC (a Jewish-American lobbying org).
Franklin had a lot of dealings with Chalabi.
Someone leaked to Chalabi that we had broken the Iranian codes. Chalabi allegedly told the Iranians, leading them to change their codes.
Chalabi was also one of the main sources for Judith Miller, as was John Bolton.
Judith Miller was under investigation prior to plamegate for writing an article revealing an investigation into Saudi charities. Tom Ridge might have been her source.
The mystery leakers are Rove, Libby, and perhaps one (or more) other undiscovered sources.
Did you happen to catch Countdown last night? He had John Dean on there, and they were talking about the (apparently) 6 administration officials spreading the Plame story. The transcript is here. Here is how the interview started, but I thought the entire Dean interview was pretty interesting and worth reading through.
I thought when you said AQ you meant AQ Kahn. YOu konw the nuke guy from Pakistan. Since Val was working on WMD’s/proliferation as well.
First of all, HI, AG!! It was a treat to see your name in the comments.
2nd, your spell check feature just ate my comments!
Now then, this is strange, for quite some time I’ve been commenting that Miller was a key while everyone else was picking away at Cheney, Scooter, Bush, Novak, etc. which your chart doesn’t even list.
Miller is in jail because she can not testify. She is guilty of payola. Miller and Chalabi were both being paid in cash and info by someone hiding in the shadows.
Fitz needs to review Miller’s income prior to Iraq and up to the present. Chalabi is not only a “source” with Miller, a lot of twists and turns are involved in that relationship.
Miller was compromised way before the Iraq invasion and the cash payments just completed her resolve and dictated her actions.
Novak? A sleazy excuse of a journalist. A poster child for late, late term abortion.
“Novak? A sleazy excuse of a journalist. A poster child for late, late term abortion.”
But… this puts the responsibility on the woman to know that she is harboring a future moral sleazebag in her womb. What about, poster child for the tragedy of journalists who become corporate whores?
.
PS There was another Plamegate Timeline diary @dKos, quite extensive, but I couldn’t find it.
~~~
Suspicious ex-journo that I am, the account about Wilson’s friend talking to Novak on the street has always clanged like a bell to me.
The way it’s written, it sounds as if Novak was just walking down the street and some man he didn’t know came up to him and
OK. I suppose it could have happened that way. But then, the friend
That could also have happened. I have no trouble believing that someone as arrogant, unethical, and ultimately stupid as Novak would have said those things.
What bothers me–and perhaps it’s just the way this is written–is the coincidence. I want to know who the friend is, did he just happen on Novak or was he looking for him, and did he already know about Valerie Plame’s NOC status?
I keep thinking there’s something missing in this account, or that there’s more to it than written. Or maybe not.
Maybe Wilson was tipped off as to what was about to happen. He told his wife, His wife arranges for a CIA friend to follow. Novak, presented himself as someone who he would talk to and got some info.
Maybe it’s even more convoluted. Maybe it’s all a CIA set up to get the administration. I was wondering what was taking them so long.
I think Judith Miller is the Key to all this. She is in touch with Chalabi and Chalabi is a favorite of VP’s office at the time and she writes phony articles about WMD in Iraq. It’s all Chalabi’s lies.
Here’s my longer take on this:
http://bushplanet.blogspot.com/
Miller is probably a formal or informal government agent working for the OSP in the VP’s office. Now, she may be doing this vountarily, but essientially she works for the government and plays a reporter for them.
She meets with Libby and he tells her about Plame. Miller then spreads the information around to Novak, to others creating a perfect circle. But she does not write about it because she is a decoy of sorts. Her role is to spread the information around so the source becomes vague. The source is the VP office.
She is in jail-not to protect her source but to keep from incriminating herself. If she testifies truthfully she reveals a lot more than who told her about Valerie Plame.
She is the key to everything. That’s why she is in jail She is an unstable, somewhat paranoid, irritable person. She wouldn’t be able to stand being in jail if it weren’t for the fact that she’s better off doing 5 months now than 5 years later.