US journalist in Basra, kidnapped and executed, his body dumped on the side of the highway. His interpreter was shot and is in serious condition in hospital. He is the 64th media person killed in Iraq, the first American journalist.
Vincent was a free-lance journalist who told the truth about the Iraqi security in Basra. That it is infiltrated with Shia extremists who were executing former Baathists.
more…
Vincent had written for Chrisitan Science Monitor and the New York Times. His latest book about Iraq is entitled “In the Red Zone.”
Mr. Vincent is the first American reporter to be killed in Iraq. Others have died from vehicle accidents or illnesses. In August 2004, an Italian journalist was abducted and murdered as he drove south of Baghdad to report on a Shiite revolt in Najaf.
“We of course are deeply saddened by it and have already notified the family and have extended our deepest condolences,” said Pete Mitchell, a spokesman for the American embassy. “We’re working very closely with Iraqi officials in Basra and with the British government to determine who might be responsible for this heinous crime.” New York Times
Mr Vincent also criticised the UK forces, who are responsible for security in Basra, for ignoring abuses of power by Shia extremists.
Iraq
BBC
The organisation [Reporters Without Borders] also paid homage to Steven, describing him as a courageous reporter and writer who had never hesitated to go to difficult places such as Iraq in order to cover the life of their inhabitants.
“This murder once again shows that journalists pay a very high price to report in Iraq,” Reporters Without Borders said. “It is absolutely appalling that insurgents use this kind of barbaric violence against people whose job is just to observe and report, and who just carry a notebook and pen.” Reporters Without Borders
Here is Steven Vincent’s recent OpEd in the New York Times.
Switched Off in Basra […]
From another view, however, security sector reform is failing the very people it is intended to serve: average Iraqis who simply want to go about their lives. As has been widely reported of late, Basran politics (and everyday life) is increasingly coming under the control of Shiite religious groups, from the relatively mainstream Supreme Council for the Islamic Revolution in Iraq to the bellicose followers of the rebel cleric Moktada al-Sadr. Recruited from the same population of undereducated, underemployed men who swell these organizations’ ranks, many of Basra’s rank-and-file police officers maintain dual loyalties to mosque and state.In May, the city’s police chief told a British newspaper that half of his 7,000-man force was affiliated with religious parties. This may have been an optimistic estimate: one young Iraqi officer told me that “75 percent of the policemen I know are with Moktada al-Sadr – he is a great man.” And unfortunately, the British seem unable or unwilling to do anything about it. […]
Update [2005-8-4 13:17:34 by sybil]: Talking Points Memo Café has a blog in memory of Steven Vincent
RIP Steven Vincent
By toppa
From: Top Reader Blogs
Steven Vincent was one of the very few Iraq reporters brave enough to venture outside the Baghdad Green Zone these days. As has been widely reported, he was killed yesterday in Basra. What hasn’t been as widely noted is what a great reporter he was. It’s quite likely that his Switched Off is Basra editorial in last Sunday’s New York Times – in which he described how much of the Basra police force is little more than an extension of the extreme Shiite religious parties – is what got him killed.[…]
Check his blog In the Red Zone and especially his last entry The Naive American.
Rest in peace Steven Vincent, brave journalist and thank you for bringing us your search for the truth.
I wonder if a docudrama about his experiences and death in Iraq might not make a powerful movie. I’m imagining something along the lines of “Hotel Rwanda.”
I am certainly not the person who could put such a project in motion, but maybe someone here at Booman knows someone who could?
…are highly and justifiably critical of American journalism today. Unfortunately, “journalist” has become, in some circles, a term of derision and disgust.
Vincent is one of the many, many journalists who bring honor to the profession.
R.I.P.
Speaking of the media…so little has been mentioned of his death. They couldn’t possibly make room on the MSM tv because we know that Natalie hasn’t been found yet or George Smith disappearance mystery from a cruise ship is still unsolved. Let’s keep our priorities straight now folks <snark> What is one journalist telling the truth or one former CIA agent telling the truth ot 21 Marines killed?
Haven’t had too many of those recently.
R.I.P.
He wrote some good stories.
Pretty good interview and sense of the man here:
http://www.shapeofdays.com/2004/12/interview_with_.html
Thank you.
I was amazed when I found out that he was a former art
critic in NYC. It was 9/11 that converted him into a
journalist.
What a great loss.
This makes me sick. And, I am always suspicious of the motives to kill such a one…
He was kidnapped at night and his body was found the
next day. It was an execution to silence him, no
doubt about it. The murder will bring even more
attention to his writings but the cost of that is
too great.
Just FYI because he ain’t no liberal icon or hero and you all should know the truth!
By way of a NYC right wing blogger and writer Ace of Spades I’ve heard Vincent attended several right wing political get togethers here in NY. He was hardly unbiased. In fact, here’s an example of Vincent’s opinion of the “leftist” branding of Iraqi resistance:
The most despicable misuse of terminology, however, occurs when Leftists call the Saddamites and foreign jihadists “the resistance.” What an example of moral inversion! … Anyone who cares about success in our struggle against Islamofascism–or upholds principles of moral clarity and lucid thought–should combat such Orwellian distortions of our language…”
Steven Vincent, “FrontPage: Interview”, December 9, 2004
http://www.frontpagemagazine.com/Articles/ReadArticle.asp?ID=16214
I did not know that Steven Vincent wrote for Front Page. But I agree with his statement that you quoted. The Iraqi resistance is something else altogether and would likely consist of Iraqi family or tribal members seeking revenge for the deaths of their loved ones. You know those that the military calls “the soft targets” or “the collateral damage.”
I don’t like the blanket term ‘insurgents’ either, but for ‘lack of a better word’ I use it.
Vincent was a ‘hawk’ too:
I never thought of S.V. as a left-wing icon but as a courageous war correspondent who was executed, (we assume) for his latest New York Times’ article. He left a life as an NYC art critic after 9/11. Likely if I dig into that I will find out that he hated modern art or something. It would not diminish my admiration for him and his search for the truth.
I meant to thank you for the link. Good catch, thank you.
It’s the contradictons in people that make them interesting.
Politicians, especially those like Bush try to put up a front
of being consistent but you what, they are very boring.
Hi Sybil,
One thing I noted reading the comments was that everyone was ready to embrace this guy because he was a journalist, and of course, I’m sure, because he died doing a noble job that many still have full faith in.
I’m a journalist too. I appreciate the open arm embrace of everyone here, as it speaks well of our Constitution and I think a belief in impartiality. But I thought I’d better cue everyone to the fact that he was definitely a partisan writer, and- in that regard- worthy of a bit of skepticism- the same skepticism I hope folks would have toward me if my writing turned suspect. Like you, I do enjoy complicated people, those who also are able to see life’s gray areas. IMO I do believe, however, that Mr. Vincent did not operate as such a writer. But thank you for reminding me of the possibility.
was shallow, I didn’t look beyond his recent writings. It’s likely due to my hero-worship of courageous journalists. I do prefer them to attempt objectivity as much as is humanly possible.
Now, I hope I do not find out that he trashed my favourite artists while he was an art critic.
All that said, he sure didn’t deserve capital punishment.
SV is slamming all contemporary art that shows political content, November 2004
It is interesting that the article’s title is “Shut-up and Paint” [instead of making political commentary] since one could say to the critic “shut-up and look at the art instead of making political commentary.” He sees torture as a political issue when it is really a universal human rights issue.
http://nationalreview.com/comment/vincent200411160819.asp
<sigh>
According to Armando’s diary on Vincent’s last posts
on Front Page, Vincent was being objective and trying to convince the Front Pagers that it was not going well in Iraq [to put it mildly]. Even though
he was on the ground giving first hand evidence, to them it is party first, to hell with the truth. Over there he was killed for his NYT OpEd, over here he would have had his character assassinated. (example: Joseph Wilson)
http://www.dailykos.com/
In case the article gets pushed off here it is:
You’re absolutely right. He didn’t deserve to die. I should have said that right off the bat.