Sometime after I was introduced to marijuana, but before I was introduced to Rene Descartes, the concept that perception is reality crossed my addled mind.
Lying in my room late at night, in a state of extreme paranoia, it dawned on me, that in fact, what a human being believed to be true in the confines of their own mind, was all the reality that mattered. I don’t really remember the etiology of this thought. I was fucking baked beyond existence, really. But I remember it being a powerful truism that lasted until the morning, and has followed me ever since.
Why on earth would I be here making this confessional to a community full of people? I usually save such gems for close friends and acquaintances after bottles of rum. Leading to the logical conclusion that a) I really like you guys and am somewhat inebriated; or b) I have been thinking about perception and reality in the wake of Katrina, and it makes an interesting lead to the thought I wanted to share. I’ll leave you to judge which conclusion is true, if you choose to read on after the flip.
My return to the blogosphere after a 46 days of reading only The New York Times collided with the force of nature, Katrina. It was really a remarkable time to come back. My reality had been shaped by the stoic and slow Times. But just in time for this horrendous catastrophe, I was able to switch on Booman and follow it all in real time. Plus I was able to spew out the venom I was feeling. All in the comfortable confines of this here community of people, who for the most part, are seeing the world at least from the same side of the aisle as I am. It was very cool timing, if one can use the word “cool” to describe death, destruction and despair in the face of seemingly willful neglect.
Things felt kind of revolutionary in those first days, reading and blogging about this disaster. I honestly felt that Katrina, and Bush’s pathetic lack of effective response, were heralding in an era of great change. This was the trumpet sounding the charge from the heavens. People of good will and intelligence were going to seize back their country from self-serving idiots. I was sure of it. And, frankly, I was hearing it not only from within my own heart, but here on the boards. In the diaries and comments. It was an awful tragedy, but in the response of the media, and the folks here, I was sure there was a silver lining.
I was perceiving the world through Booman, and through correspondents like the brave Anderson Cooper, and I was sure. My reality was that Bush’s end was nigh. We were going to march on Washington on the 24th, and put an end to this idiocy. And, it didn’t seem like an idle fantasy. It seemed palpable.
On Saturday, my trite life called me away for a number of hours. Annual fantasy football draft, with mandatory drunken debauchery to follow. (I got up Sunday morning, and read a diary about how a Republican couple had partied Saturday away to the annoyance of a decent Tribber, and I almost felt compelled to confess my sin on the spot). And, during my Saturday hiatus, a set of perceptions entirely foreign to those found on Booman and those flowing from the mouths of the Anderson Cooper’s of the world, flooded my brain.
I come from a little blue-collar town. We suffered in the ’70s. I am from a neighborhood of Democrats that probably helped elect Reagan. A lot of these guys never really came back to the left side of things. And a lot of them passed this blue-state conservatism on to their children. People who hunt, and who are not overly concerned with racial justice, and joined the Army to fight the cold-war Commie enemies. I was one of them at 18. And I am still one of them on fantasy football draft day.
That is not to say I become a Republican on that day. I have drifted so far to the left on the political spectrum that I think I need to self-censor myself to keep from getting banned at dKos. But, I tend not to be too loud with my views around my old blue-collar buddies. We drink and eat and talk sports. A disgusting number of them want to talk NASCAR these days, and that kind of makes me nauseous. But, I tend to avoid politics, because I know where most of them are, and they don’t want to be woken from their cocoons. I keep the peace with that old adage warning against the impolite discussions of politics, religion, and income.
But, this year, I was feeling revolutionary. What with the incredible things that were happening with Katrina and the blogosphere. I wanted to let the boys know that the revolution was coming. I wanted them to have a chance to get on board.
I eased them onto the topic of Katrina and race, talking about Kayne West’s comments on network television. I threw out the idea that some of those helicopters and troops in Iraq could be saving some lives in New Orleans, as we were drafting some of those Saints.
The silence was deafening. I’ve got eleven friends in the room. Most of them know I have drifted way left, and am writing left-wing novels. But, now, I can hear crickets in the background, at mid-day. And, some of them are looking at me like I am Ted Kaczynski.
Undeterred, I asked if any of them knew about September 24th, and the protest to change the world. Let’s bring the boys home. “Nobody should die for no purpose right?” I said. More silence.
A friend said, “We gotta work.” Much laughter. Lawyers and writers do not really work, in the perception and reality of my band of brothers, I can assure you.
I eventually gave up. Gave in. Got fucking trashed and danced a jig to the sad state of this fucking country into the wee hours. My perceptions of what is going on in this country had completely changed.
Sunday I nursed a hang-over. Felt guilty for doing little to help the victims, or to even keep myself informed. Today I read the poll numbers. Bush is going to get a pass. The networks are toning down the revolutionary rhetoric — toning down even the challenging questions. Resuming their role as lapdogs.
There is no stopping Bush Co. At least not if the jury of my peers is sitting in judgment. Until the man threatens them and their families personally with death, I do not see them awakening. The neo-cons will spin their way out of this. There will be a white wash commission. And another horrible policy fuck-up will be swept under the rug. And the corporations that eventually write the history books will lionize the boy king. A smirking face chimp will look back at my grandchildren from their laptops (or whatever they are reading from in those days) at school one day, under the banner “Savior of Our Nation.”
It is like we are a nation stuck in identity politics, I think. The working class whites who support this idiocy will simply not be shaken from their uninformed support. It would cause too much cognitive dissonance to their world view. They are now Republicans, because they are Republicans. They can be poor and uncared for, but they would rather be that, than wrong.
I was pretty despondent today. Very much fearing that, for me, reading the great thoughts presented here at Booman, is something like waiting out a hurricane in a small cove. It allows me to perceive the world the way I know it ought to be. It can even give me the illusion that this is reality, so long as I do not leave the cove.
But the minute I step outside, I am surrounded by a shitstorm of willful ignorance, that will not let the world change. I cannot imagine, after viewing this event, what on earth will make any difference.
I hope I am wrong. I still hope that September 24, 2005 might rock the world. But, I am having a hard time seeing it, in my present state of mind.
hey man, dont mean nothing. keep on keeping on. peace…………I have a same feeling as you do. once I can manage to get highly pissed, I then submerge back into my own shell, of sorts. It seems too much for my brain to comprehend. it is just like the old days…
I understand. I know it might not do any good, but things ARE changing. It’s just taking a long time.
I think that sometimes you just have to fight the good fight and wait for others to catch up.
Hang in there.
One sees one version and the other sees the other. And there isn’t any commonality. What is that all about? How in the hell did we get so estranged?
It seems like our schism in this country, between liberal and conservative, was purposefully created. When I read Noam Chomsky, he sometimes says that things like, “You give the people the illusion of choice. You make them believe they are free. But, corporate media limits debate to an acceptable range of opinion with this myth of choice.” I think I believe him sometimes.
I’m with you, except that I don’t even feel comfortable in the “liberal” blogosphere.
Sure, there’s tons of rhetoric about how Bush is going down and the GOP is on its last legs and the DLC is the root of all evil, and “we’ll never forget” the hot topic of the week and all the women and gays and minorities and liberals will gather together and elect a new shining progressive leader.
But, when you get right down to it, in 2006 the people in these blogs will once again vote for the moderate “electable” Democratic candidates and we’ll be in the same situation as now. Maybe a shift of a few points one way or the other, but no revolutionary change. Just like there wasn’t a revolutionary change in 1970. If the country couldn’t elect socialists in 1970, how is there any chance now?
There is simply not a truly revolutionary movement in this country. People will throw blog tantrums and will send money to Cindy Sheehan and Howard Dean and will stay up until 3:00 in the morning typing furiously about how furious they are, but they won’t, in the end, actually vote for a progressive candidate. There have always been progressives to vote for, and they always, always lose.
I hope I’m wrong, but in my heart I know that’s how it’s going to turn out. I have pretty much given up hope…
🙁
and stick around. In 2006 we will make a small difference, but it will get noticed. By 2008 we will have our own well-funded candidates.
I hope you’re right…
Now that is leadership Booman. Taking energy. Even negative energy. And, trying to channel it somewhere it can do some good. You the man. Or, Boo the man.
To be such a downer with this diary. I can always look on the bright side. At least I have found here, thanks to Booman. And, I have been more active in the past year because of it. Maybe there will be change someday, and I’m just not seeing it from where I was at yesterday (or today).
Hi Joe,
I wasn’t around while you were blogging about the NYT. I’d had my own little burnout crisis – reaching a state of despair similar to the one I read in your words now.
That’s why I wrote my warning diary: Now Is The Time. It was a warning not to take a lefty victory for granted. I was a child of marijuana and Descartes too, but today my version of reality is centered on Buddhist philosophy (when I remember to stick with it – it’s so easy to be swept up in the panic of life). The most basic premise is that reality is in this moment. We have no control over the past and the future is not yet here. Life is this moment. It’s an incredibly hard philosophy to live, but to me, that is what reality is. Each moment leads to the next, so how I live this particular moment is important because that’s all I have. I find that tremendously comforting when I decide what I should be doing in my life and it helps me calm my fears about the future.
So – I guess the moral of the story is that no matter what happens with the coming political situation, I know that I will remain true to myself, true to my compassion, true to my humanity. I will try to get that message out to others, but I know many will not choose to live it. I have to be an example. After I’ve done all I can, I have to let go. I have to do the best I can right now, because I only have right now. I can’t change anyone, but I can change myself so I can have an impact. I believe in the words of Ghandi that one must be the change they want to see in the world. I believe that humanity endures through all struggles because the force of compassion is overwhelming.
Maybe I’m naive. All I know is that I must live with some comfort, with some beliefs that allow me to have faith in myself and in humanity. Individual people fail to get beyond the surface of reality and I’m not responsible for that. I am responsible, however, for being as fully conscious of all of my senses and thoughts in each moment so I can better serve mankind.
Some say Buddhist philosophy is selfish – and it is. However, it is the type of selfishness that leads to selflessness because it moves one to be a better person and that’s all I really have any control over one moment at a time. I fail too, but I recover and move on once I remind myself of what reality is for me.
I don’t know if that’s helpful or makes sense to you. It’s just what your words spurred me to write. We will endure this. No matter what. All we have is right now.
Buddhist philosophy. At least what I understand of it. And I find it comforting to give up my desire, try to calm my mind, and end suffering in that way. To live in the moment.
But, ultimately, I am not learned enough in that way for it to stick. I always find myself drifting back to Western thought. At worst, nihilism. On good days, some kind of humainstic existentialism. Really, I guess my religion and philosophy are the embodiment of living in a secularized post-modern world. I take a bit of whatever on the buffet feels like comfort food for the moment. And, your serving of Buddhism might be just the ticket to get through these days. Thanks for the deep thoughts and advice.
But, ultimately, I am not learned enough in that way for it to stick.
I don’t know that even very learned Buddhists ever feel they are learned enough, but, as with any philosophy – such as using the Golden Rule in Christianity – you use what you do know even if it is the simplest tenet.
I take a bit of whatever on the buffet feels like comfort food for the moment.
I think we all do in any given moment. As they say in 12 step programs: take what you need and leave the rest. It has to be whatever works for you. We’re lucky to have so many philosophies to choose from that we can use to mold our own lives. I admire those great minds that have gone before me and those who surround me now. I worked with the homeless and I learned a great deal from them as well. We’re all just doing the best we can and, as Maya Angelou says, “when you know better, you do better”. Words to live by…
Beautiful words, Catnip. I also try to be in the moment. It is the only way I have to breathe, to let go and think and feel clearly. For me the hardness and uncaring Republicanism that is so apparent in this country was devastating to me. The fact that so many people are OK with torture cut me to the core. That’s when my eyes finally popped wide open.
I continue to cycle through a grieving process… denial, anger, resignation over and over. I truely believe that those unfeeling, uncaring, unempathetic people are to be pitied because there is something very wrong with them inside. I don’t know if they are products of our culture or Republican thought or their own pathetic existence. They avoid responsibility for their fellow humans like the plague, but are the first in line when they are in ‘need’.
Maybe they were always there and became emboldened by the heartless incompetence in power. They are loud and crass and unapologetic. The most heartening thing to me is that I truely believe that those people are in the minority.
My brother who lives near Philia works in and out of neighborhoods where folks are not so well off. In fact, he thinks many many people in the inner cities are sinking fast. They are the working poor and they’re not making it. They have nowhere to turn, nowhere to go and the anger is palpable. He truely believes that if things don’t change for the better, instead of the litany of grief coming their way, things are going to explode. He likened it to the legendary riots some of us remember, but worse. He believes that civil war, started as a class war, is a possibility.
So that adds another dimension to this discussion. If the silent majority doesn’t cry out and force change, the class war of the Republicans may take a turn they don’t expect, to put it mildly. I just don’t think the status quo will remain static… I can’t see Bush being exhulted as our savior… nah, that future is just a Rovian wet dream. Bush and his legacy is finished, one way or the other. It’s just a question of how much more damage they can do with the time they have left.
It seems like you felt you were like a kid getting their feet wet, and they knew it. I’ll bet this is the first time you had ever brought up politics with them, and that was really bold. Keep it up, lower your expectations a little bit, and maybe they’ll come around.
In a long time. Since we got out of the Army, got drunk, and I learned they were all voting for George Herbert Walker Bush. Don’t want to change “horses in mid-stream” kind of bullshit.
So well. They will get what they deserve. Unions are in tatters. No workers are coming out of these Republican administrations with anything but debt and insecurity. No social safety net, or at least one that is greatly reduced. It is their country, too. I just don’t know what it will take to wake them from their slumber. I thought a CAT 5 hurricane with a completely fucked disaster response might do the trick. I guess I will have to wait for a nuclear winter, or something.
If only Democrats could see the forest through the trees…. Instead, we become fractured, point fingers, get frustrated, and some even give up.
We’re not going to have a revolution on September 24th and we’re not going to frog march Bush (or Rove for that matter). It’s all wasted energy if you ask me. If only each individual participating in the 9/24 event would put all their energy into their local congressional race.
What we have absolutely being handed to us is change in the manner that our government was set up for change. Paul Hackett showed us how it’s done. He wasn’t afraid to express his outrage and to call a spade a spade. That’s exactly what should take in every congressional district in 2006 and the race for the White House in 2008. That’s how change will be made. That’s how control will be taken. That’s how history books will be rewritten.
By the way, when dealing with semi-wingnuts like your friends, if you really want to have a chance to make headway, frame things in terms of the “government.” Stay away from specifics, or ease into them.
“I’m so saddened and frustrated. These are American citizens. We pay all these taxes, and we are assured our government is doing everything to be ready for a disaster, and yet they are cutting badly needed infrastructure? What if there is a nuclear terrorist attack? Clearly these goons have no idea what they are doing.” Etc. etc. etc.
If you start right in on Bush the kool-aide will kick in and you will get nowhere.
Spokesman for the cause. It is easy to write here. With time to think, and the Internets as a useful research aid just in the next window. But, with my buds, I am a stuttering idiot. Not unlike the public defender from “My Cousin Vinnie” if you remember that movie.
Even so, I don’t think Robert Kennedy, Jr., whom I think is a great spokesman for the left, would have much impact on these dudes. Their ears and minds are closed, mostly, I am afraid.
Joe, I recognize myself in your comments. I pretty much have given up on discussing any politics with known wing-nuts. I learned my lesson long ago that it’s a useless endeavor, time wasted that only leads to frustration. I have also tried to understand their point of view over and over and, at times, I have made headway. I gave Bush much credit in the post-9/11 days and weeks. I also gave him credit when we rushed in to Baghdad and chopped down the statue of Saddam. How wrong I was!
But, the 2004 election was very hard on me. The choice could not have been clearer, and to think that Bush got a better percentage of the electorate to vote for him than in 2000, after all the disasters of the previous four years? Hard for me to take, let alone understand.
Sorry for the ramble, but my point is this. I think you are better off enjoying your friends for what you have in common and leaving the politics to different areas of your life. If they haven’t been convinced by now…..
in some of those individual minds. I know the feeling of being a “stuttering idiot,” especially in a group that has their minds made up in a different direction. The silence is ghastly, but perhaps it is because you’ve spoken a truth that frightens them. Given more time and exposure to more information, individual minds may change.
Please don’t be too discouraged.
WOW powerful and effective- well done Joe and btw – one of my nicks is Willfull Baroness – just for giggles GAWD we gotta try
Powerful and effective. I am touched by all these responses this morning though. All the good vibes, advice, etc.
It reminds me, oddly, of a favorite movie scene, from “Parenthood.” A good one to see, if you haven’t. Keanu Reeves, when he was just a boy actor, plays this teenager who is growing up, about to have a baby, and is learning what it means to be a man. He is forced to give a life talk with another troubled young man he is living with. After the talk, he is giving a report to the troubled young man’s mother. He gives a long, profound speech about “how any butt-reaming asshole can be a father… you know you need a license in this country to drive a car, or catch a fish… but they will let anyone be a parent.” It is a pwoerful and effective observation, coming out of a character who has been an idiot throughout the movie. Then, at the end, the character realizes the words that have been coming out of his mouth, and he gives this body-jerk shudder, and goes on with his idiotic life. Like he can’t believe he said those things. I feel a little like that (though, I realize my thoughts aren’t Keanu Reeves worthy).
Wow, that is a long way to go to make a small point.
Look, these folks have been lying to themselves for years, decades maybe. The worse things get, the more defensive they get, because they are invested in the lie.
This is what “identity” politics means–they have invested their identities in the lie. And they know it’s a lie–but it’s their lie. And they cling to it.
Would they like a way out? Would they like truth instead? Sure, in theory. But that would require risk. That would require a step into the unknown… letting go of the identity they have adopted for themselves. That would require… courage.
Not the phony baloney courage of sending someone else halfway around the world to die. But the real courage involved in facing nameless dread, the unnamed fears that are so intimidating you would rather cling to a lie than face them. Not many people have that kind of courage. Some, but not many.
So forcing people to that point of change or no-change is not a winning strategy. It just isn’t. But that doesn’t mean there’s no way to win. It’s just that it takes more finesse.
That’s Michael Moore’s big secret. He knows how to do that. You don’t bash people. You make fun of them, fun of everyone, yourself included. Doing that creates space for alternatives. You say, “C’mon. We all know it’s not like that. It’s sorta like that, maybe, sometimes. And then it’s exactly the opposite.”
Of course this is very hard to do with folks that you have history with. Which is why you shouldn’t use this kind of encounter as a way to gauge anything. Other people who have much less history with them have a much better shot at facilitating a shift.
Me, I know that they have lost some people forever. How many, I don’t know. Not as many as I’d like, I’m sure. But all across the land, I’m sure it’s millions. And they’ve increased the doubts for tens of millions more. The key for us is not to defeat ourselves.
I’ll say it again, because I think it’s the most important thing: The key for us is not to defeat ourselves.
Your post makes a great deal of sense to me. MM was on TV the other day. He was speaking so simply (so much so it almost seemed ludicrous to me) and yet so to the point, but also in a humorous way, (think Voltaire), that the absolute last thing anyone would think is that he was talking down to them.
MM is brilliant at making a connection to the so called average Joe/Jane.
I think many of these folks with the “identity crisis” just can’t bridge the gap from Bush to say Hillary? Even though that particular gap is much to narrow for my satisfaction.
We are all in the shadow of Michael Moore. My town is just north of Flint. Michael is one of us. He speaks our language well. But, I have to tell you, he has become a polarizing figure to these folks. He invokes more hatred in them than Hillary Clinton, and that is saying something.
But, I agree with you both, that a little wit in delivering the bitter wake up message is required. I try. But, you know, who am I.
One of the most useful distinctions I know is that between producers and consumers. I first encountered it in a book called Political Hysteria in America, about the post-WWI Red Scare. At that time there was a very clear distinction between the producers and consumers of Red Scare hysteria.
The producers were political elites–folks like Attorney General Palmer, young up-and-comer J. Edgar Hoover, big business and big media. The consumers were folks who bought the Red Scare newspapers and swallowed all their lies. Many of them were workers, who were being screwed by the large manufacturers, and whom the unions wanted to help. But the unions had lots of socialists, anarchists, Bolsheviks, and just plain old immigrant foreigners in them, and so culture readily trumped class for them.
Fast forward through the McCarthy Era, through Nixon, Reagan/Bush and Gingrich to our present day. The dividing lines between producers and consumers are much more blurred. But there are still some classic examples that represent the cores of both, even if there’s a lot more nuance in between. The producers remain folks like Murdoch, Robertson, Rove, Coors, Mellon-Scaife, etc. And the consumers… well, some of the folks who just cracked under the pressure of what they saw last week, and threw up their hands in disgust.
Now, Michael Moore is a polarizing figure because the producers absolutely hate him. And why? Because he can talk to the consumers, and woo them away. Now, because the lines are a lot more blurred than ever before, it’s hard to say who those consumers are, how to measure them, who represents them. And it’s a lot easier for the producers to appear to speak for them. (O’Leilly and Oxy-Rush do it all the time.) But the more they rail, the more they protest, the more you know that Michael Moore is a threat to them.
As they say down South, a stuck pig squeals.
Over the past few days I have been feeling quite the same as you are Joe. I have continually butted heads with my sister and I know better. I know , just for me, that it is futile and only causes more pain to even enter into the dialogue with her. I honestly feel there are such people that even if George ate a baby alive in the Oval Office they would say, well it was for the good of the country. I am learning, too slowly sometimes that I must take my frustration and anger in a different direction. Tonight I will be attending my first meetup. I have to put myself into action. Some days I say to myself, like you, what’s the use and then I look into my grand daughter’s beautiful eight year old blue eyes and say to myself I must not lose hope, I must continue to be the change I want from the world. I owe her that.
Got hope. I am not dead either. Woke up this morning feeling a little better. Just gotta keep sloggin on. Who knows what will happen?
I felt much the same way as you after Bush won the second time. I knew that Kerry won, but he rolled over and played dead.
The Republican working class people I work with are clueless. Some of them have an inkling that something is wrong, but only because gas prices are high and filling up the F-150 or Explorer is much more expensive.
If Democrats roll over and play dead on hurricane Katrina, Roberts, Iraq and all of the other daymares we are having we will end up with a facist theocracy that just looks like the U.S on the surface. We need to create our own reality and drag people into it.
Just one last comment on yesterday’s diary. An update really. More energy is seeping back into me. Maybe all is not lost. Maybe the initial Bush polls and my own weekend experience were wrong.
Went to the barber today (a super cuts like place). Woman I don’t know cut my hair. I said nothing political at all. She started talking about New Orleans. About the poor people left to die. About the lack of anyone to help them.
She didn’t seem like a politico of any sort. Just an average Jane. Someone who may have voted for Bush, or maybe not. Not real distinctive. But, she felt comfortable enough to talk about problems in the relief effort, in front of someone who was going to tip her (or not). So maybe this issue will really end up biting the idiot and his lackeys. I sure hope so. It seems like it is going to be a big battle of spin, to determine the reality of American public opinion. I am so sick of spin. But here we are again.
Still, just being in the game (where a bad spin on something will damage this fucking administration) means that there could still be something positive that could emerge from this disaster. I am still hoping.
Okay. On to a new day. A new moment to live in.
glad to have you back BostonJoe.
“Shitsotrm of willing ignorance”
so sad, so true, so deadly
the hurricane, the flood, the terrible aftermath, the government lethargy and incompetence, the continuing horror of New Orleans, the death toll predicted at 40,000. 40,000!
I had watched WWLtv from Louisiana and read Interdictor’s blogs from New Orleans, read NOLA.com besides booman.trib and dailykos.com for days. After watching Oprah today I realize I knew nothing. I didn’t know that it was dark in the Astrodome all night and all day. I didn’t know that even now, rescues are slow and there are more military in pick-up trucks than rescue vehicles. I didn’t know there were so many bodies, so much indignity to human beings.
How much information do we need to receive to give us an honest perception of New Orleans? It is so horrible it is beyond imagining.