Cross posted from The Mystery of the Haunted Vampire and My Left Wing
Here’s an American history lesson to remember: Persecution of people is not a good thing. That wouldn’t seem hard to forget, but some people have thick skulls and small brains, walking proof for the theory of de-evolution.
Interesting article on Salem witch hunts in The Telegraph:
Spectral apparitions, red rats and talking cats; a community threatened by unseen demonic powers; and finally, a collective hysteria that left hundreds unjustly accused, and almost two dozen innocent victims hanging from the town’s gallows: it is not hard to see why the witches of Salem – the Massachusetts village 17 miles north of Boston – have constituted a troubling presence in America’s otherwise generally sunny, go-getting historical consciousness.
Within a few years of the event, the great “witch-hunt” of 1692 was already regarded, almost embarrassingly, as the dark side of the Pilgrim Fathers’ zealous puritan piety; a nasty blot of medieval superstition on the decent copybook of God-fearing American rationality. Little wonder that Arthur Miller reworked the story in his 1953 play, The Crucible, as an allegory of Senator McCarthy’s anti-Communist witch-hunts, then sweeping the US.
And, of course, it is Miller’s version of those events with which we are most familiar. Yet, as Richard Francis ably demonstrates in this new book, the historical truth was even stranger – and no less dramatic – than Miller’s fiction. The events at Salem constituted not simply a self-contained outburst of irrationality, Francis argues, but a defining moment in the history of early America: one in which can be discerned both the demons of the puritan past (the preoccupation of the Miller play), and also the harbingers of “modernity” – of a new, and far more sceptical attitude within the colony to the values and prejudices of the first generation of New Englanders.
This reminds me of something…Something more recent…The treatment of prisoners, including young children raped and people beaten to death at Abu Ghraib? Nasty blot there. Michelle Malkin’s defense of racism? Possibly. The glorification of the shooting death of an innocent electrician on a London subway? Maybe. The second-class citizenship for gay people? The disrespect shown to people of no faith or to Wiccans and people of other faiths besides Christianity? Or the failure of the administration to protect Americans after spending four years and billions of dollars supposedly preparing federal efforts to protect Americans? Hmmm. An abundance of riches for future embarrassments and “nasty blots” on our national heritage.
Lucy, I’m home.
Carnacki!!!!
We’ve missed you!!!!
Off-topic, but are you going to the DC march next week?
Cabin Girl, please shoot me an email at arkhamnative AT yahoo.com. I’ve been out of the loop. Pastor Dan had asked me too, but I haven’t received any information about the plans. I may not be able to get off work (I work a second job on Saturdays), but should be free that evening. I’m having lunch with jsmdlawyer tomorrow.
I’ll send you an email, and I owe jsmdlawyer one too! Quite a few of us from BooTrib are meeting up there Friday and Saturday-I’ll send you the details.
Welcome back! We missed you. Did you have a good break?
The summer went past too quickly, but the family is healthy and life is good. How have you been? I’ve missed my online friends a lot. It really does feel like coming home.
is how I’ve been. Went to Canada, went to Crawford, semester started, Katrina survivors arrived here in Austin and getting to know some of them (awesome stories they have to tell), just flew to Baltimore and drove my new car back to Texas in two days. I’m tired. But life is good and my family’s healthy too. So I can’t complain – just whine a little about being tired . . .
Online friends – got to meet MilitaryTracy and alohaleezy when they came to Austin on the way to Crawford. Way cool.
You’re home? Well, Ricky–er, Carnacki. You gotta lotta ‘splainin’ to do!
It is incredible how many new stains have appeared on the reputation of the United States in just 4.5 short years…
Nasty blots indeed. Great to have you back Carnacki!
After the last two weeks, think you might be up to hosting a “Happy Story” diary on Friday? I think we could all damn use one…
Wonderful to see your name in the diary section — I read a book about the Salem witch trials many moons (25 years) ago as part of my History 17A course. Wish I could remember the name. (The section I took, with Prof. Larry Englemann of San Jose State University, had 7 required books — 1 main texts and 6 supplementary books; it was known as the “Book of the Week” course. Fortunately I loved to read, and still do…)
(theme music from Welcome Back Kotter) good to see ya back …. KUDOS
Carnacki, welcome back home. It is very good to see you and once again find your good thoughts on things here. Hugs
Late to the party but glad to see your post!
Welcome back….saw you over on dKos….
Recommended reading – “Never Again the Burning Times”
Great read on witch burnings and intolerance…glad you are back. Take care of yourself and your wonderful family.