I have a confession to make: I should have had this post finished days ago. For reasons I still can’t fathom, I found this to be the hardest piece I’ve ever written. Although I wrote pages upon pages of of text, I was just frustrated; unable to find rhyme or reason, structure or theme.
“Can’t you see it, can’t you feel it
It’s all in the air
I can’t stand the pressure much longer
Somebody say a prayer ” (Nina Simone, “Mississippi Goddamn”)
Come Sunday morning–and out of nowhere–I finally broke down and cried. I didn’t “feel emotional” or tear up or weep. I cried. The enormity of it all was just too much.
My heart has never felt such sorrow: The people who were trapped in the Superdome and upon their rooftops. The anguish of Harvey Jackson , who tried to hold onto his wife in the midst of the storm.
And my very being has never known so much fury as I watched in helpless horror that these people–these taxpaying American citizens, NOT refugees–were being left to die. (BTW, damn all the statistics and stereotypes–I’ve never seen so many images of Black men holding their babies and caring for weakened elders when they were tired, sick and feeling weak themselves. I almost never see that portrayed on television. But I digress.)
To be Black is to be despised, no matter how well this society has cloaked it in recent years. You learn how to deal and move on. But never have I seen such brutal confirmation of that disgust and hate than the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. How to write, how to think, how to act–indeed how to function, when your government spits on you?
This government just stood by and watched thousands of us die. That actually makes it sound more benign than it was: Michael Brown–the former horse head, (or is that horse’s ass) of FEMA and Homeland Security head Michael Chertoff were apparently the only two people on the planet who didn’t know of the living hell American citizens were going through at the Superdome and the Convention Center. President Halliburton had other priorities, fly fishing in Wyoming and estate hunting in Maryland. And Shrub? Well, we can’t disturb the emperor’s golf game, now can we?
You know your government has failed when Harry Connick, Jr. arrives at the scene of a disaster before FEMA does.
Rats die with more dignity than this.
This just in while your government looks for a war to win
Flames from the blame game, names? Where do I begin?
Walls closing in get some help to my kin
Who cares? While the rest of the Bushnation stares (Chuck D, “Hell No We Ain’t Alright”)
A six-year old, quite literally, demonstrated more leadership than George Bush. People literally dropped dead, while Shrub did nothing but mouth phony platitudes about law and order and “help is on the way” on his first take. After his performance proved to be lackluster, the White House went into rapid response, presumably instructing Shrub to emote earnestly with the hoi polloi on his do-over.
This damned sure ain’t Florida.
Because if it was, Bush wouldn’t have dithered. In fact, if the Hurricane evacuees were Terri Schiavo (how’s that for proving that in this country, one white person’s life is worth more than 10,000 Blacks), he’d have been hurried back from one of his many vacations. Since this was a real crisis, as opposed to an imagined one, Shrub was no where to be found.
But this was New Orleans. He’s partied there to be sure, but hey … those people don’t write checks. They are not his base. They probably vote Democratic–if they vote at all. So their lives aren’t worth his time.
Lord have mercy on this land of mine
We all gonna get it in due time
I don’t belong here
I don’t belong there
I’ve even stopped believing in prayer (“Mississippi Goddam”)
Even in the midst of human suffering on a scale unseen in this country, Shrub never missed an opportunity to pander. Who said he can’t multi-task?
“Zero tolerance” and “shoot to kill” orders for looting? Of course my first thought–so this filthy Administration wants to commit mass suicide?–soon gave way to the obvious racist subtext.
And this was southern bipartisanship at its best. Well they will be dealt w/ “ruthlessly”, said former RNC head and Gov. Haley Barbour.”
“These troops know how to shoot and kill, and they are more than willing to do so, and I expect they will.” said Gov. Blanco.
Yes … let’s get in touch with folks’ latent plantation fantasies (Race? Perish the thought!) and focus on the one percent of those looting, as opposed to trying to find food–water-logged property, of course, meaning more than the suffering of men, women and children. That’s just criminal.
And this administration knows from criminal, as the five year economic smash and grab proceeds apace: unaccounted billions going to Halliburton; propaganda cash to willing stenographers; money to fix aging infrastructure–say, for example, levees–gone down a shithole in Iraq. We’re spending billions per day for Saddam’s non-existent WMDs as we install an Islamic republic in Iraq. They sure are doing a “heck of a job” as they brazenly loot our federal treasury.
But the face of this tragedy was overwhelmingly Black and poor–a combination in this country as poisonous as the toxic floodwaters in New Orleans–and therefore not worthy of sympathy. We just don’t care. And maybe God did us a favor. Urban renewal by natural disaster, perhaps?
We better look/ what’s really important
Under this sun especially if you over 21
This ain’t no TV show/ this ain’t no video
This is really real/ beyond them same ole “keep it real” (“Hell No We Ain’t Alright”)
I just can’t find the words to register the disgust I feel toward these moral midgets. It’s no surprise then, that many Black folks agreed with Kanye West’s primetime, kept-it-real statement, tut-tutting from Condeleeza Rice (and later from his legal wife) notwithstanding. If anything, West forgot to add “poor” and “working class” last week when he said that “George Bush doesn’t care about Black people.” Why would he care about the help and the cannon fodder–of any color? If anything, West said what many have long known.
Indeed, the Black community is mad –and mobilized. Tom Joyner is mobilizing by radio. Black churches are linking with other churches and doing everything from packing supplies and driving to Louisiana to finding homes for evacuees. All manner of civic, political, fraternal and social organizations are working together to give aid to the survivors. Countless individuals are giving of themselves by offering help and sometimes their own homes. And I’m sure next week’s 35th annual CBC Annual Legislative Conference starting Sept. 21st won’t be business (some say partying) as usual.
But our activity today won’t make us less accountable in our own complicity to the question of poverty in the community and our commitment to the have-nots, too. We’re going to have question the Rev. Dr. Greedygut theology of “blab it and grab it”–turning the concept of “having life and living it more abundantly” on its head and morphing into the belief that the favor God shows is in direct proportion to how much money you have. We’re going to have question the “I got mine” mentality. We’re going to have question whether we’re going to continue the 21st century minstrel show that is corporate hip hop whose stars wallow in materialism and when they get bored, revels in misogyny. This has to be addressed sooner rather than later.
Even before the curtain comes down on the minstrel show, George W. Bush must finally do something he’s never done before: be accountable. Forget the fact that people died–he clearly doesn’t give a damn–this is an issue of national security. The region is one of the largest ports in the world, home to one-third of our domestic oil production, not to mention sugar, rice, poultry and seafood, and there’s no plan? That seems to especially spite the national face.
I find breathtaking that this 50 something year old “man” is still unable to be accountable for ANYTHING he does. He’s the same coddled, spoiled brat he’s always been. Well, I don’t care that his parents don’t like criticism of their precious little boy; he is going to be held accountable, for once.
(Speaking of Babs, she’s just as arrogant as her stupid brat, chuckling about the lucky duckies in Houston. How worthless can you be when you can’t even manage to do noblesse oblige correctly? The apple, indeed, doesn’t fall far from the tree–and they’re both rotten to the core.)
So, to play the part of Our Strong Leader Shrub plans to conduct an inquiry as to what happened–that is, to see if something actually didn’t go right. That’s right–he wants to investigate himself.
And OJ is looking for the real killer.
Son of a Bush, how you gonna trust that cat?
To fix shit when help is stuck in Iraq? (“Hell No We Ain’t Alright”)
It’s too late for Shrub to be photographed with the help, or hug a Black child. No donning of compassionate drag can cloak the massive failure of the federal government, of cretins who WANT the federal government to fail. They seem to think that if thousands die and industries are ill-affected (not to mention the environmental devastation) so what–gotta crack some eggs to make an omelet. Their reason for being, now that they’ve weakened government, is to take the spoils. Talk about looting.
He and his horrible administration are the sorry symbols of crony capitalism, rapacious greed, malign neglect–and the aftermath of the hurricane is but one consequence. No moral being golfs while thousands die and then hides behind his parents and assorted bootlickers when called on his actions. And no phony, camera-ready act of contrition (like the spectacle we’ll surely see on Thursday’s primetime performance) will suffice.
Hell no, we ain’t alright. But, by God, we will be.
A F’in Men Auntie! best GD diary on the state of this nation since Katrina hit. The real “hurricane” of destruction hit in 2000 when the Supreme court interjected their boy in the White House. Excellent diary my friend.
Thank you! It’s been unreal, going back and forth from sorrow to fury. And then being just busy for the past few days.
Girl, I’m late for this train, but damn, you sure are right, upright, and so tight.
Thank you for voicing what I have been feeling these two weeks!
Hey there. I feel like I haven’t “seen” you in ages.
Anyway, it’s never too late to chime in. This was definitely the most personal thing I’ve written. I earned an “A” in history, so while I know I shouldn’t be surprised, another part is just so shocked that little has changed. Never did I think I would watch such a tragedy unfold.
I’m still processing all that has happened. And I am absolutely blown away by everyone’s responses to the diary! I am really moved by it.
BRAVO…and if this does’nt hit the front page and center column of BooMan, I will be truly disapointed…FACT
Kudos AP…the best I’ve heard, and read…
I agree with you Infidel…Big Time Front Page material! Calling Susan…Booman?
Y’all are gonna get sick of me just saying “thank you” in every other post, so let me try to add just a bit more than that.
From the beginning, I had a bad feeling about this hurricane, but nothing could have prepared me for its aftermath. I didn’t watch TV for most of the weekend preceding the hurricane, when it was still a Cat 1. I literally jumped out of bed when I heard that Katrina reached Cat 5. As I watched the coverage, I could just sense how this was different. The forecasters weren’t screwing around.
The storm passed and the flooding began. Where was Shrub? People were getting desperate. Where was Shrub? I just sat in stunned disbelief for a week. Even he couldn’t be this sorry to just watch people die, I thought. Hell to the yes he could.
What’s really disturbed me is that his minions had to make him a DVD so that he can understand the severity of the tragedy. WTF???? What was this DVD called–Catastrophic Hurricanes for Dummies??? It’s not like he wasn’t briefed beforehand!
But see, folks like National Hurricane Center Director Max Mayfield actually try to do their jobs to the best of their ability. Shrub couldn’t care less. What does he care if he fucks up and people die? Daddy and Mommy are always there to carry his sorry ass.
Brava, my lady, this is an excellent piece and well worth waiting for!
I heard some asshole lecturing Aaron Brown on TV last night for being a “race-baiter” becuase he DARED, DARED talk about black’s perceptions of the response to Katrina on the air, saying “peceptions are dangerous” — you bet your ass they are buddy, especially when they are continually invalidated by whites and other elites who refuse to SEE.
As a professor of mine used to say with frequency and passion:
This country is traumatized around race.
I always had a good idea of what he meant by that, but this month, I felt and lived that trauma — if we don’t deal with it in a REAL way, it will be our undoing, sooner or later.
I applaud you and your thoughts here, AP. Thank you for helping to place perspective on this whole folly. I can’t help but to think that when ti comes time for God to judge these ppl, at the end of their time, it will not be a nice thing. NOt from what I have been taught, anyhow. I just wonder if they do any thinking on this matter at all. But in their own mindthought, I think personally they think they are better than everyone else and that gives them the right to do what ever they want to do to everyone else. This is the attitude I see coming from them. The lack of compassion and the lack of being human, is just that. They are not human! Their minds can not think with what God gave them. Their greed is what will get them in the end. The entire group of them..from top to bottom of the group.
George’s history has already been written as well as the rest of them. The history is in our minds and hearts for all of time. The stories will certainly give to the history. They will tell it like it really was. Hell yes, it aint alright!!!! never was and never will be.
Beautifully said – keep posting ’em.
Thank you Auntie Peachy,
You’ve just expressed everything that has been boiling up inside me for two weeks now. There is no word descriptive enough to explain the depth of disgust and hatred I feel for these sub-humans, nor the anguish I have felt watching what has happened to our brothers and sisters in New Orleans.
George, you bastard, we’re coming for you!
You truly spoke truth to power today, with fire and passion. Probably the finest piece of writing I’ve read on Katrina. God bless you!
Thank you very much. God bless you, too.
Thanks for this diary. It manages somehow to rekindle the fury without triggering the despair — no small feat in this post-Katrina house of mirrors.
Somebody frontpage this, please!
Thank you, a thousand times over, for this… powerful, passionate, and beautifully written.
Peace and Blessings to you
You’re welcome a thousand times. :<)
A powerful post. I could feel your conflicting emotions as I read; well done!
Some of the comments I read on the blogs a couple of weeks ago talked about how embarrassed people were over the pitifully slow federal response to New Orleans and the Gulf Coast. I commented then, and restate now that although I understand the comment, I felt something other than embarrassment, I felt fear.
New Orleans was the home to 1,000,000+ citizens, all of the history and the culture, the largest petro-port on the gulf, and what kind of response to the crisis did it get? Precious little on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday while Bush was on vacation. Absolute confusion on the parts of Chertoff and Brown. They didn’t know the folks were at the convention center? Unbelievable! And people are dying!
Doing their best to keep people from food, water, medicine, radios, diapers and the like in the flooded stores though.
I’m thinking to myself, if this is happening (actually Not Happening) in New Orleans, guess the old rust belt area of S.E. Michigan can’t expect much help from these guys either. Matter of fact, we can’t expect an effective response to a large scale disaster anywhere in the country, is what occurs to me.
Reporters got to the abandoned people by Tuesday and Wednesday. The relief convoy, got there on what, Saturday? No drops of supplies from the air? Isn’t that what our fly guys are trained to do?
The contracts are getting signed though, the no-bid kind, going to you know who. This is what a government for hire seems to be about. Take care of the Corporations that are taking “care” of them, seems to be their doctrine.
The country did watch what they could see on CNN. People have since decided to either believe what they saw, or to believe the Rovespin that has predictably followed. For some I guess, what they saw is too frightening to accept; it’s far easier and more comforting to accept the spin. Though I hope race isn’t a factor in that type of denial, I am pretty sure it is for many. For that I am embarrassed, and shamed.
Please keep writing.
It hurt me to see people suffering in the aftermath of Katrina, but now I am sickened by Bush trying to suck up to blacks and black preachers to sway their votes. I hope that people can see the hypocrisy of his actions. He talks the talk, but doesn’t walk the walk.
Thank you for your passionate perspective on things and for working Nina Simone into it.
AuntiePeachy
Breathtakingly, passionately, beautifully written. Thank you for a wonderful piece of writing and for bringing together the feelings and thoughts so many of us have had during this unbelievable mess of NOT handling this disaster.
Peachy: Do you think this is a good time to open a dialogue with black leaders on the issues of civil rights for gays and women? About how civil rights is an ongoing process/battle, not a historical event?
Sadly, if the things I hear come out of the mouths of established black leaders are any indication, it will be a cold day in hell before there is any dialogue on the rights of gays.
While Kos is totally, completely, unequivocally wrong about left-wing special interests dividing the left, it is nonetheless the case that the various left wing groups have utterly failed to provide each other with mutual support. The problem is that bridges aren’t being built in the first place, not that they are being burned.
All of the various civil liberties groups ought to be actively lending support to each other for one simple reason: every time the elite manages to legitimize dividing humanity into first and second class citizens, they make it easier to shift more people into that second class. Why aren’t there women’s activists, union activists, prisoners’ rights activists, homeless activists, gay activists, religious minority activists, hispanic activists, or even environmental activists at rallies for African American rights — and vice versa?
Easy. We’re all united in our shortsightedness and stupidity. We’ve bought into the Republican/DLC lie that what we have is a laundry list of demands. What we really have is one demand: that all people should be treated like, well, people.
The sickening irony of it all is that the elite oppressor class is a tiny minority, and the oppressed are the majority, and they’ve bamboozled us — fully aided and abetted by our own foolishness — into thinking of ourselves as little islands of minority identities. Humanity is not a fucking minority; inhumanity is.
From I political standpoint (by that I mean timing, etc.), I dunno.
From a moral standpoint, it’s never too late. Unfortunately, my views seem to be in the minority at this juncture because I have absolutely NO problem with the right to marry. NONE. And the argument that “it’s biblical” holds no water w/ me, b/c there’s lots of things in the bible that are routinely ignored by Christians (None of us are supposed to eat seafood, but I don’t see Focus on the Faci…er, Family boycotting Red Lobster) and quite frankly, ought to be (you know, the one that says “slaves, obey your earthly masters with deep respect and fear…”). The state can’t force a religion/church to recognize it, but religion/church (and that’s all the opposition is, really) can’t force the state from a legal union. It’s just that simple.
For that reason and others, I have had longstanding issues w/ the Church. The hurricane made me go back, but I’m taking it slow b/4 I join again. But I tell you what: I won’t be joining and spending my money in a place where I have to hear a constant harangue about gays & lesbians. As a straight woman, I feel emotionally assaulted by it.
I prefer to call it human rights rather than civil rights b/c I know folks get hung up a/b the terminology. And it makes me sick, too, b/c w/o Bayard Rustin there would be no Dr. King at the March on Washington or likely no Dr. King doing any nonviolent resistance.
I’m not sure of what the winning argument would be, b/c there are so many reasons for the homophobia: some are just straight lackeys; cut from the same cloth as those who opposed Dr. King and any other person who would challenge segregation (as are the wingnut jackasses they suck up to); some find it easier to bash gays and lesbians than to talk a/b issues like, oh, I dunno…poverty; some I think, are genuinely uncomfortable with out gays & lesbians; some may have issues w/ sex; some don’t see gay men as real men, which is damning given those who equate civil rights with manhood; some may privately agree w/ marriage rights but know that it will face a tough sell w/ their congregation, to say nothing of being worked over by the Deacon and/or Trustee Board (in many cases, they have hiring/firing ability–whoever said there were no politics in church?!?!?!)
Take a break from saying thank you and just let me say it to you.
But you know I was close.
So I’ll do this:
:<D
Really, I think the response to all this is so muted.(Not your diary) Everyone points to that clown Anderson Cooper….and he was and is one of the few people who is saying anything…and he does it in a muted way…”Golly, Gosh…yeah…I …guess this ….was….uh …bad…uh.
This whole event is a refection of what the United States Government has become. A kind of dictatorship of the wealthy over, not only the poor, but the less wealthy.
This nation has become awful.
You can really live better in most European countries, Parts of South America and Mexico. Who needs this?
You can really live better in most European countries
I have often wondered where the hell the government gets its standard of living stats from. When I was wandering around West Germany, Austria, and the Netherlands in the 1980’s, it sure seemed to me that people there were living much better than Americans. Their middle class was vast, their poor were fewer and yet still better off, and — but maybe this is the kicker — the rich were hard to find.
It seems as if Americans have been willing to accept poverty for the many as a reasonable price to pay for extravagant wealth for a very few.
Who needs this?
No one, but it’s home. So I’m holding out as long as I can. Plus the German immigration quota is tied to their current unemployment rate, so there aren’t many openings right now. But I can hear Mexico calling sweetly…
It seems as if Americans have been willing to accept poverty for the many as a reasonable price to pay for extravagant wealth for a very few.
Damn. There it is.
And we’re willing to accept it, b/c most of us are willing to play in the lottery called “When I’m Rich.”
The potential winnings from that lottery entices the vast majority of us, and makes us stupid. We want to believe we’re like the rich, so we pretend. We derive great emotional satisfaction from this, even as this works against us.
It gives “hurts so good” a new meaning, doesn’t it?
I had a colleague comment to me a few years back that our union had been so successful in improving the standard of living for it’s members, that we had all become Republicans. I think this is what you are speaking to. If we delude ourselves into thinking that we are actually climbing up the ladder, then the effort of day to day existence is suddenly worth it. It’s even worth spending money we haven’t even earned yet, to give the neighbors the impression that we are better off than they. Maybe even worth putting the Republican Candidate’s sign in our front yard, the month before the next election.
Can’t say that I blame you. Yes, the rich live very well. What about the rest of us? That’s another propaganda trap–that no else has a higher standard of living than the US. No one can do better than we can do. And surely, we can’t ever learn something from anyone other country or tradition.
But it depends upon the standard, and it seems that when it comes to emergency preparedness, health care, education and a whole host of other measures, we’re faltering…and measured by other industrialized countries, we positively suck.
I always wanted to live abroad for a while to gain perspective–even if it’s European. I always thought that beyond language, the societies were quite similar, but in many ways, that doesn’t seem to be the case. Now may be the time, if I could get a job in Amsterdam.
(And feel slightly ashamed)
Why?
Ten years ago I thought that we were beyond the real need for unions. (I was wrong…)
A few years ago I had begun to think that affirmative action was no longer a neccessity. While I believe that this is more of a “class issue” (POOR vs RICH), there is no denying that it is only amplified by the reality of the plight of minorities in the USA.
I really don’t know what to say? I had thought that America was beyond this very real issue.
I no longer believe we are.
I feel like I have failed.
You weren’t the only one. Not by a long shot.
Everyone was becoming a millionaire, remember? You were nobody if you didn’t have an announcement date of your IPO.
We were told that the labor force held all the cards, remember? You too could learn the holy tech skills needed to quit a job one day and cross the street and work for your competitor the next. The beauty of the tight labor market…remember that? And if you drank the “growth forever” Kool-Aid, then you thought that this would be the reality for forever and ever, amen.
And then the bubble burst.
The paper profits went poof.
The jobs were outsourced.
But hey, here’s a service job w/ next to no benefits and a cut in pay that you’re overqualified for.
It was really easy to believe that. I worked w/ folks who thought unions were a relic.
But hey…we’re all rich now (or pretend we are) so we can’t get all blue collar all of a sudden. /snark.
… that he’s “responsible” for the failure of the federal government respond to Katrina, then he knows he’s responsible for the death of the sick, the old, the poor, and the helpless who did not have the means to evacuate ahead of a catastrophic hurricane.
He knows people drowned in their attics and died in their hospital beds because no help came in time. He knows that a beautiful city will never be the same and that hundreds of thousands are homeless, and jobless, and will have to start their lives all over again because he did not provide leadership at a critical moment.
He knows he killed legislation and dismantled regulations that could have slowed global warming.
He knows he deflected precious resources into an unnecessary war, and slashed funding that could have shored up New Orleans levee systems.
He knows he bankrupted the US treasury with generous tax breaks to the richest Americans, and generous no-bid contracts to his corporate mobster friends.
He knows he crippled FEMA by “folding it into” homeland security, leaving this country and its poorest citizens vulnerable to the worst that nature can do.
He knows that he didn’t take the hurricane seriously, was too involved in his self-indulgent wag-the-dog photo ops to give local and state officials the support they needed to protect their people.
He knows he appoints incompetent people to important positions of power and responsibility just to scratch their backs because they scratched his.
He knows he is ignorant, unprincipled, poorly educated, selfish, without conscience, greedy, arrogant, and utterly underserving to be President of the United States.
He knows he cheated, lied, and slandered to win public office, and that he has never and will never care about anyone or anything except himself.
If he knows he’s responsible, then he knows he should RESIGN IMMEDIATELY!
If he knows he is responsible, then he knows he is accountable, and he knows that he should be arrested, tried, and punished for his crimes.
But bush is a moron who can barely learn his lines before he takes center stage in his own personal drama starring only him, and is truly incapable of taking responsibility for anything
The world owes you nothing. It was here first. — Mark Twain
There isn’t a more apropos signature for the mess that is george w. bush.
Wow. What an incredible, well-articulated diary. You really touched me with your writing, AP. It’s evident that you invested a great deal of yourself into this piece, and I can only imagine the tremendous amount of time (and tears) involved in crafting your work. You also did a great job in selecting and positioning the song lyrics to align with your writing.
(Speaking of music, I can’t help but choke-up each time I see the Red Cross commercial with Johnny Cash singing Bridge over Troubled Water. The sadness/weariness of his voice so aptly portrays the emotions at hand.)
Bless you, AP and thank you for sharing the fruits of your labor. This is powerful and moving.