From the Boston Globe, we have the usual round-up of stories of people who couldn’t afford to get out of the path of the approaching storm. As usual, the poor are left behind to fend for themselves.
Do I sound weary of this story? I am weary. After the Superdome, after the Convention Center, I am weary. I am tired of reporting that in America, you can get out of harms way if you have the money, and if your car runs well.
”After tomorrow, we don’t have nowhere to go,” said one of them, Rebecca Jones, 24, a cashier at a fast-food restaurant in Galveston who had no bank account and no money left. ”They told us to go. They should have given us vouchers or something. They gave us nothing — no food, no nothing.”
At another hotel, a group of about 10 Katrina victims from Louisiana who had bounced around shelters in Baton Rouge, La., and Houston were kicked out of the building until an out-of-town reporter began interviewing them. Suddenly, rooms became available.
I am weary of knowing that places like Cuba, as poor as Cuba is, takes care of their own, in the event of a hurricane.
Sometimes, actually often, it is the poor taking care of the poor in this country.
Sedonia Jouiner, 23, a security guard who came with her four children, did not complain about the conditions.
”I’m glad I got out,” she said. ”I can’t afford to lose my babies.”
And let it also be said, that in the President’s home state, they sometimes don’t take care of their own.
With Hurricane Rita breathing down Houston’s neck, those with cars were stuck in gridlock trying to get out. Those like Skinner — poor, and with a broken-down car — were simply stuck and fuming at being abandoned, they say.
“All the banks are closed, and I just got off work,” said Thomas Visor, holding his sweaty paycheck as he, too, tried to get inside the store, where more than 100 people, all of them black or Hispanic, fretted in line. “This is crazy. How are you supposed to evacuate a hurricane if you don’t have money? Answer me that?”
If we as a nation do not address the issue of the working poor, of hungry people in our own country, of the homeless, of the sick, impoverished and destitute, then we fail our own promise to ourselves:
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. –That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed
If you think it can’t happen to you, if you believe that you will never be one of the hungry and thirsty fleeing the ravages of a storm, of any storm, of an economic storm, think again.
If the least of us are vulnerable, then we all are.
“Being poor is getting angry at your kids for asking for all the crap they see on TV.
“Being poor is having to keep buying $800 cars because they’re what you can afford, and then having the cars break down on you, because there’s not an $800 car in America that’s worth a damn.
“Being poor is hoping the toothache goes away…”
In it’s last lines, Scalzi writes of Katrina’s poorest survivors, and the plight of poor people everywhere:
“Being poor is knowing how hard it is to stop being poor.
“Being poor is seeing how few options you have.
“Being poor is running in place.
“Being poor is people wondering why you didn’t leave.”
This is a beautifully composed, thought-out, and written story.
It deserves a top spot!
Oh shit- isn’t that always the way?
I know I am waay overprivileged- and I also know I did nothing to deserve it, except for belonging to the privi
leged group.
MY GAWD– if you want to see a bunch of self-satisfied upper-class idiots– take a look at my Cape Cod relatives,who have been fighting for decades about who will be ‘allowed’ to live there. Jews were finally deemed ‘OK’.
Wonder why my family is off-limits to me now?????
GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
One of my cousins went to San Diego and visited my brother there- she had hardly been ‘off Cape’ in her whole life– the sheltered life of the rich.
My bro said she was ‘sheltered’- I said she was a rich-ass snob who should be condemned to life in TiaJuana in her next life. GRRRRRRR
And I am so sorry- I have been trying to help- honestly.
But I am so weary also- it seems like it never fucking ends.
I know you have, and so many here. As for myself, I’ve only just begun, as the Carpenters once said. It is going to be a long struggle, an endless battle, to bring economic justice to this country. I wrote this story, wearied from two storms (I drove through tropical winds and rain to get from Baton Rouge to Gretna yesterday), and, I am tired of the suffering.
As I rest up, and I hope we all will, I’m going to search for ways to call attention to this issue, other than here at booman.
We planned a rally for today in Baton Rouge on the capitol steps, but Rita blew that to heck. But we will hold other rallies, and demand action on this from our reps and senators and the gov.
Here is my flier:
Rally for Louisiana Workers’ Rights
When: Saturday, September 24, 2005
Where: State Capital Steps, Baton Rouge
What time: 2p.m.
Why: To Demand the employment of the citizens of Louisiana to rebuild Louisiana.
To Demand the employment of New Orleanians First to rebuild New Orleans.
To Demand the reinstatement of the Davis- Bacon Act—The Davis-Bacon law, enacted in 1931, sets a minimum pay scale for workers on federal contracts by requiring contractors to pay the prevailing or average pay in the region.
Bush suspended this law right after Katrina hit the Gulf coast.
We demand the reinstatement of the Davis-Bacon Act.
We demand a moratorium on No-Bid Contracts. Post-Katrina No-Bid Contracts have already been awarded to Halliburton, Bechtel and Flour for clean-up and reconstruction on the Gulf Coast. We want these contracts revoked.
We demand the end of the Iraq war to stop the killing and start the rebuilding in our own country.
Where are our Louisiana politicians and why aren’t they speaking up for the workers of our state?
Sponsors: C3/Hands Off Iberville; Lafayette Citizens for Common Sense; Workers Democracy Network; Namdi Okeke, N.O. activist; Mike Howells/N.O. Holdouts
I faxed the flier to reps and senators, and called Landrieu’s office for a comment on the rollback of Davis-Bacon. They essentially didn’t have one.
We have our work cut out for us.
But I am so weary also- it seems like it never fucking ends.
Of course it never ends. We’ve neglected even addressing the situation of the bottom 1/3rd of income earners for almost 3 decades now. They subsidize your life. Without the cheap labor provided by the poor (and, depending on how regressive the taxation in your state is, the taxes they are forced to pay) your life would be much harder.
This is a structural problem and a political one and it’s been exacerbated by ‘free’ trade agreements, budget cuts and what the prevous Pope called ‘savage capitalism’.
The response to people who last week were serving you your food when you went to a restaurant and the next week find themselves homeless isn’t to examine the reality of lack of housing for enormous numbers of people (and families), it’s for middle class neighborhoods to band together to evict the homeless.
And so people die of exposure, they sleep under overpasses and, for that matter, your house. They live in secret and hide as much as possible.
I greatly fear for the poor. The only difference between them and you is that they have no money. I fear for their lives and I fear for the societal solutions because the manner in which we structure and prioritize will only lead to greater numbers of people who are unable to access the necessities for basic survival.
I have a house that I offered rent free to anyone who needed it?Does that count?– and yes I am aware of all the people who do the shit work in restaurants,hotels, meat packing houses,crab pickers (locally) and all the rest who support our economy beneath the radar.
I rant about this regularly,to people I know who think that ‘It’s their JOB so we don’t have to tip’.
I worked in a Hyatt hotel that was nearly all staffed by illegals. The lucky ones crowed because they had green cards,the others scattered when the INS started their sweeps.
Almost all the beneath the radar services are provided by people who DO NOT COUNT.
I know this.
All the food we eat, all the restaurants, all the meat packing and chicken plucking, is provided by people who have no rights whatsoever.
What to do?
Should I stop buying food because I disapprove of how workers are treated? This is a sincere question.Unless I can have some sort of business where I can really affect something-and so many people have no idea-so many are so helpless- what choice do you have between Tyson and some other equally noxious company?
A nasty dilemma.
No, but we need to look at how we organize and prioritize our lives. And I’m preaching to myself, because I have much to learn. Can we learn to grow some of our food? Can we learn to eat less meat? Can we buy from local farmers’ markets? Can we drive less, burn less fuel? Can we pressure our reps to push for non-polluting forms of energy?
Can we get involved in our communities to make sure our disaster plans are in order, and that the least of us are considered?
If we don’t do all of this, then we leave our lives in the hands of those who don’t have our best interests at heart.
I am really trying- but I don’t know how to go about it- yes we support our local farmer’s markets- and I support my local fishermen,(who are here called “watermen”),who work their butts off for nearly nothing.
Current plan is to turn our acreage into a somewhat self- sustaining way of life- But, won’t that deprive other people of their livings? The ones who I used to see in the Post Office every day- sending money home to their families in Mexico?
Every day, in front of the Food Basket in Leucadia,Ca, there were all the men who lived up on the hill ,and they would stand there,on the street, waiting to be picked up for day labor. These were men that worked their butts off- all day,every day,and camped out up on that hill with nothing. And somehow managed to work and send home money to their families.
And the thing that really infuriated me was– the yupsters- who hired the cheap labor- were appalled and dismayed that they people they hired were living -OH DEAR- out in the open!As if they could afford to live in yupsterville-Sorry this gets my blood up.
Just as we need to figure out how to fix our country, the same goes for the mexicans. Latin American leaders allowed in Nafta and Cafta, and now they need to answer to their people. But the people need to hold them accountable. We can’t do that for them.
We cannot solve Mexico’s problems for them, no more than they can solve out’s. We are sending money and aid overseas while our own cities crumble and yes, people, here go hungry.
I have unusual views in this area as in the sense that I am a neo-isolationist, a term I just created. But isolationist only in the sense that we must first take care of our own. Then we can help others.
I have to agree with you– we need to take care of our own .So much was hidden- and believe me, I saw plenty of it in Galveston-and now it is macking Dumya in the face– although I can’t tell if he can even feel it. Probablly not.
Thank you Susan. I knew I would have this one to write, before the storm hit. And that is sad.
any good at all…it will be to show up our country for what it is. It is a country now that leaves out the have-nots.
We noticed it here last year. The four hurricanes that hit Florida left many homeless, and there are more becoming homeless still from them. In Punta Gorda the FEMA village of trailers there still has people being admitted.
They are stopping the use of shelters, because it is the poor who usually need them longer. I heard one of the mayors from Texas saying they would not announce when shelters opened..they did not want residents going to them.
Once they let into the shelters the people who have nowhere else to go…then they have trouble getting them out. So now they are manipulating even that avenue of aid and caring.
They have now almost gotten the government out of the business of caring for people.
floridagal. I believe it was the mayor, or emergency head in Houston who would not announce where the shelters are in fear people would go there rather than leave.
Ludicrous logic and thinly veiled racism and classism, as most who were left were the low-income, african americans and hispanics.
Do you remember who said that exactly?
I know it was a man, and it was one of the Texas cities. I think Houston.
The Mayor of Houston is White — I don’t remember hearing any of that though…I don’t think they set up shelters IN Houston proper..all of the ones that were set up were along the evac routes
It was in one of the cities that had to evacuate. I know this because the bum logic was that if the names of the shelters were released, then people wouldn’t evacuate.
Thanks for the report.
There are a lot of people too, who weren’t poor. Maybe they had two kids and 30,000 in the bank a house and a car and a job. All gone
That’s middle class. Middle class with no connections equals the new poor. Nobody is talking about anything except what a good job they have done with Hurricane Rita….which was not as strong…I guess…from the reports…but did devastate a lot of small towns.
Bush is just a cheap criminal. He has to go.