When they married in 1948 my parents like most of their generation, were New Deal Democrats. They were part of what would later be called “The Greatest Generation”, coming of age during the Great Depression and tested by war. Having seen a world with great deprivation and danger, they had a near religious belief in the power of Government to do great good. Their faith was well founded. They had seen first hand a Government that had literally fed the starving, brought light into darkness, educated the ignorant, gave power to the powerless, and defeated unimaginable evil. After a few years, the GI Bill allowed them to move from the crowded city to a small house in the suburbs and start a family. To them this country and its government were the embodiment of the shinning city on the hill.
Around this time their politics started to subtly change. The Cold War and its aura of fear had begun to permeate the American political landscape. In the early 1950’s the Republicans hit upon a strategy to defeat the powerful hold the Democratic Party had earned over the American public. They could play upon the public’s fear of communism and whip them into a frenzy of paranoia. While Joe McCarthy did his best to convince the public that there were communists behind every corner, Nixon mastered the tactic of red-baiting as he came to power. At the height of this period many lifelong Democrats began to see the Republicans as the only party that could keep them safe. Fear appeared to be an unbeatable political weapon, and my parents fell victims to it. By 1960 their faith in Liberal beliefs was shaken and soon a 4×6 poster of Richard Nixon hung in our front picture window.
For the next forty years, the Republican’s used fear to gain power. Goldwater preached a rabid form of anti-communism. Nixon’s “Silent Majority” and “Southern Strategy” played on fears of race, urban unrest, moral decay, change, and the growing youth movement. Reagan had us battling an “Evil Empire” that would require “Star Wars” technology to defeat. As long as they could maintain the level of fear at a fever pitch, they could maintain power.
Something interesting happened to my parents during this period. After nearly thirty years of being staunch Republicans, things began to change sometime during Reagan’s first term. They just got tired of being constantly told to be afraid. They no longer wanted to live in a state of perpetual fear.
The one problem with the politics of fear is that after a while people just can’t continue to live that way. The emotional investment that is required cannot be maintained over long periods of time. My parents had had enough with the paranoia politics of the Republican Party and eventually returned to their progressive roots. It was a long journey but by 1984 there was a Mondale sticker on their car bumper.
The current crop of Republican fear mongers now whip a new generation up with tales of unimaginable horror, dividing them along lines of religion, race and economics. We should never forget the lesson of my parents. During their lifetime, they witnessed Government during its greatest shining moment and its lowest point of cynicism. In the end they chose optimism over apprehension, compassion over hate, equality over injustice, and hope over fear.
. . optimism over apprehension, compassion over hate, equality over injustice, and hope over fear
Well said.
Hopefully the pendulum is swinging back, I surely hope so. I recently saw “Good Night and Good Luck” and it reminded me a my parents political journey.
“They just got tired of being constantly told to be afraid. They no longer wanted to live in a state of perpetual fear.”
I think you’ve hit on something very powerful here – something that applies universally. I’m reminded of how the people of the Soviet Union eventually turned cynical and just emotionally withdrew any and all support from their government, which led to its amazingly swift (to those watching from outside) internal collapse of “political dry rot.”
Should the Republicans maintain power in 2006 and 2008, I believe we’ll be on the same path to collapse: which for the sake of the people of the world, our environment, or our posterity wouldn’t be a bad thing, compared to “1984” forever…
This is a truth Orwell missed – he was observing totalitarianism at its zenith; having an additional 50 years of perspective we have some “gut level” insight into how it decays and collapses as well.
The four freedoms….
FREEDOM FROM FEAR
FREEDOM FROM WANT
FREEDOM OF WORSHIP
FREEDOM OF SPEECH
the thugs four fears
FEAR OF TERROR
FEAR OF POVERTY
FEAR OF CONDEMNATION
FEAR OF DISSENT
We offer freedom they offer fear. As long as we only offer “fear lite” we lose.
The question is whether the “correction” will come from the teeming, simmering domestic underclass, or from a world who realizes it has allowed itself to be placated by sweetmeats from evil Sugar Daddy for too long, and is now obliged to take whatever measures are necessary in order to preserve its own hope of a future.
Whatever the catalyst, the two halves of the pincer will undoubtedly work together, as pincers do.
Today’s bush’ speech on the bird flu potential pandemic is a perfect example of the politics of fear.
Birds, swine, mad cow disease-I am waiting to hear about the new FISH FLU…
You may not have to wait too long…
Zoonotic diseases of fish origin
(Zoonotic diseases are animal diseases that people can also catch, e.g. rabies)
One of the biggest differences between your parents’ era and ours is the power of advertising in today’s media. Even “News outlets” pander to their advertisers and overtly or subliminally influence us – with hi-def clarity and surround sound. We “buy” this stuff, especially when our government is selling it, and still believe that “Truth in Advertising” is not an oxymoron.
Iraqnophobia was packaged and sold as a product, like GAP khakis and Sunny-D. These same marketing strategies are now being used to “sell” military service to our kids, and that frightens me. The strongest fear I now have is that most Americans, being good consumers, will just continue “buying”, especially when told that it’s “for the good of the country”.
You’re quite right about the “selling” of fear. But I’m not quite sure that’s anything new. As a child of the cold-war era I was raised on these fears, as most of us were. “Duck and cover” and “air-raid” drills in kindergarden pretty much give you an ingrained acceptence as fear as the norm. In some ways I think the cuurent crop of thugs running things are still just those scared little chidren we all once were, they just never got over it.