Note: This diary has been updated to summarize media coverage and lack thereof.
As if it is not bad enough to see the Bush administration furiously attempting to stall legislation gaining steam in Congress that would ban the use of torture on captured terrorist suspects, Italian State Television has now broadcast a documentary accusing the United States military of illegal use of incendiary bombs in Iraq.
BBC summarises the RAI documentary:
US ‘uses incendiary arms’ in Iraq
Italian state TV, Rai, has broadcast a documentary accusing the US military of using white phosphorus bombs against civilians in the Iraqi city of Falluja.
Rai says this amounts to the illegal use of chemical arms, though the bombs are considered incendiary devices.
Eyewitnesses and ex-US soldiers say the weapon was used in built-up areas in the insurgent-held city.
The US military denies this, but admits using white phosphorus bombs in Iraq to illuminate battlefields.
Washington is not a signatory of an international treaty restricting the use of white phosphorus devices.
Transmission of the documentary… coincides with the first anniversary of the US-led assault on Falluja, which displaced most of the city’s 300,000 population and left many of its buildings destroyed.
The documentary was shown on Rai’s rolling news channel, with a warning that the some of the footage was disturbing.
‘Destroyed evidence’
The documentary begins with formerly classified footage of the Americans using napalm bombs during the Vietnam war.
It then shows a series of photographs from Falluja of corpses with the flesh burnt off but clothes still intact – which it says is consistent with the effects of white phosphorus on humans.
Jeff Englehart, described as a former US soldier who served in Falluja, tells of how he heard orders for white phosphorus to be deployed over military radio – and saw the results.
“Burned bodies, burned women, burned children; white phosphorus kills indiscriminately… When it makes contact with skin, then it’s absolutely irreversible damage, burning flesh to the bone,” he says.
Last December, the US state department issued a denial of what it called “widespread myths” about the use of illegal weapons in Falluja.“Phosphorus shells are not outlawed. US forces have used them very sparingly in Falluja, for illumination purposes. They were fired into the air to illuminate enemy positions at night, not at enemy fighters,” the US statement said.
However, the Rai film also alleges that Washington has systematically attempted to destroy filmed evidence of the alleged use of white phosphorus on civilians in Falluja.
Italian public opinion has been consistently against the war and the Rai documentary can only reinforce calls for a pullout of Italian soldiers as soon as possible, our correspondent says…
The BBC article also includes a box on the effects of White Phosphorus and rules governing its legal use during war time:
WHITE PHOSPHORUS
Spontaneously flammable chemical used for battlefield illumination
Contact with particles causes burning of skin and flesh
Use of incendiary weapons prohibited for attacking civilians (Protocol III of Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons)
Protocol III not signed by US.
Update:
RAI’s documentary is making headlines around the globe, but the U.S. mainstream media is strangely silent on the subject. The Christian Science Monitor is giving it major treatment in a piece by Tom Regan that summarizes the RAI claims and also links to other articles in the world press. The only other original reporting in the U.S. MSM, according to a Google News search is a short UPI piece that plays down the story and misidentifies the source of the allegations in its headline: “Iraq calls U.S. flares chemical weapons.” UPI is owned by the Reverend Sun Myung Moon, an ally of the Bush administration and a major cog in the right-wing media spin machine. The only other U.S. mainstream media outlet that seems to be covering the story is ABC News which has a Reuters piece.
Amy Goodman’s Democracy now, on the other hand, is giving this story prominent play, including a link to the RAI documentary (parental guidance strongly advised. This is gruesome stuff), and a replay of the original piece they carried at the time (there were claims in the immediate aftermath of the “battle of Fallujah” that the U.S. had used White Phosphorus, but then as now, most of the U.S. media ignored the story. Democracy Now was a notable exception.
Finally, uroknet has extensive coverage, including some very disturbing photographs. Again, be forewarned. These photographs are not for the faint of heart.
Great news about a horrific story:
Dahr Jamail reported this at least 6 months ago. Juan Cole, who did not oppose the Iraq war discounted Dahr Jamail report because Dahr Jamail was just a stringer and not apparently an offiicially embedded reporter.
Dahr Jamail said that poision gas was used, perhaps this is the phosophorous or perhaps it was the same gas Sadaam is accused of using “on his own people”.
So Bush accused Sadaam of torture rooms.
So Bush accuses Sadaam of gassing his own people
So Bush kills at least 100,000 iraqs
And Carl Levin says….Iraq is a now a terrorist center and we must stay there to root out the terrorist that Bush created!
This is all so twisted.
Just Get Out Now!
America is incompetent. It must leave now.
We won’t leave.
We have permenant bases there now.
So, what’s Plan B?
P.S. I’d like to know what Juan Cole thinks about this … will check his site.
it’s quite long. It draws on the exact wording in international agreements.
A couple very incomplete snippets — sans links:
I remeber specifically Juan Cole saying he doubted that napalm or Mark 66 was used in Fallujah. He asked “Why would they do that and risk world scorn?
Here is a quote from an Email Juan Cole sent me after I criticized his academic discounting of Jamail who is or was actually on the ground and Jamail gets no real exposure in the press and apparently is at great risk to his own life. That didn’t seem to be appreciated by Cole who wrote:
Also he is quoted as saying by you susan as saying the following:
I find that very distrubing. It’s not a new thing? So it’s part of thier cultural tradition to be bombed by phosphorous bombs? He has to point this out as a historian? His point seems to be not that this is awful but that it has happened before so it’s not so bad.
Remember Juan Cole wants the US to stay in Iraq. Only recently has he sneakily said that the “ground” troops should leave. But not airpower. He wants the US to bomb the rebels from the air whenever a civil conflict takes place.
Juan Coles website is terrific, but he’s not a straight shooter.
find that very disturbing. It’s not a new thing? So it’s part of thier cultural tradition to be bombed by phosphorous bombs? He has to point this out as a historian?
That’s a blatantly bogus interpretation of his invaluable observations as a historian of the HISTORY of these kinds of devices.
And he has every right to worry about Dahr’s reporting — perhaps he has found it not credible in the past. I doubt there are many people in the world who read more news stories and talk to more experts than Juan Cole … so perhaps he has had good reason to doubt Dahr. And kudos to him for doing so, rather than just blindly believing Dahr based on the fact that he’s a leftie reporter.
‘nuf already .. people can read Cole’s report themselves and use their brains to figure it out..
Well, they could if most of the people on this blog weren’t all dumb Americans.
I don’t understand.
Jamail reported accurately that Naplam was used in December of 2004. Juan Cole said he didn’t think that was right because he’s more knowledgeable etc.
Juan Cole is wrong about Iraq. You have to look into his stuff. He wants the US to stay there in some capacity.
the same thing. From what I know about napalm I don’t think they used it in Fallujah, the evidence isn’t there for it. The evidence is there for white phosphorous though.
said he could tell by the explosions that they were using napalm. He was talking in general, not about any specific city.
I believe the US has admitted to using Mark 66 in Fallujah, it just didn’t jell in the press.
Mark 66 is Napalm with another name.
i think it is generally acknowledged that the difference between Mark 77 and Naplam is like the difference between coke and pepsi.
so enjoy it. I have no idea why you think Juan Cole “wants” the US to stay in Iraq OR why you say he’s not a straight shooter. Any evidence to back up those assertions?
Several months ago, IIRC, Juan Cole said that the situation in Iraq was a mess, but that a withdrawal of US troops would make the situation worse. He compared the Sunni lose of power in Iraq with that of the Christians in Lebanon, and the time that was required for a group losing power to adapt to new political realities, and the need to avert civil war.
My mangled description probably does poor justice to Cole’s reasoning, partly because I don’t agree with his assessment that the troops remaining in Iraq.
There was a lot of discussion at the time on the large blogs – pro and con, some respectful, some not.
I don’t know anything about the supposed Cole/Jamail dispute. I would be interested in finding out more.
I don’t know anything about Cole’s reservations about Jamahl’s reporting … and it sounds like it wasn’t a dispute so much as a concern by Cole about citing Jamail as a sole reliable source for a critical story.
My concern is that we not knee-jerk believe any reporter (Dahr) simply because we like what he/she reports.
Cole is right — for whatever reasons he has — to be concerned about the reliability of his sources. And that does not reflect poorly on Cole. Or it shouldn’t.
Cole mentioned in a column that Dahr was unreliable in his reports on the use of poison gas (turns out to be phospoourous which is a poison gas cloud) and Napalm.
American soldiers report the use of both. Films show the peoples skin melted and the clothes intact indicating gas.
Jamail’s reporting was true Coles criticism proved inaccurate and faulty.
Cole is prejudiced to some extent toward military involvement for reasons that seem very personal.
I don’t pay attention to ratings. I never look at them. I have no idea about them.
We both have such a heavy heart right now. He told me that WHITE PHOSPHORUS is used very rarely by the Army, but can be shot from a helicopter usually in doubles to target mark a position for bombing by the Air Force usually. He says that it is rumored to “work really well on humans” but that is all that he has ever really known about it. I ashamed to be an American at this moment. If this is all too true, I don’t know when I will ever fully recover from all of this. To be too honest with everybody though, did you guys really think that they could have cleared Fallujah with such a low casuality count as they did? I thought to myself that our boys must really be some badass mothafuckas but I have seen them all at a hot dog cook out before and they aren’t really all that specail.
than just two shells huh?
Where are you watchign the video, Tracy? I’ve got Free Speech TV on, via DISH, and Amy’s show is about to start … and people can watch the video excerpt at her site.
Ask your husband to also look at Juan Cole’s piece today — I linked it above in reply to Stu Piddy. I’d be curious what you both think of his highly thorough analysis.
in Jimastro’s diary has that video link. It isn’t a very long portion but I guess because I’m used to focusing on helicopters I can’t help but cue right in on it. It is before or after they show the SAT footage of burned out Fallujah……it is night and two helicopters are hovering side by side and shooting something that looks like fireworks and it is blanketing the ground. I have never seen anything like it, but any helicopter pilot with some seniority knows what all of the rounds coming out of the helicopter in the dead of night look like. Someone pipe up and clarify what the hell they are shooting in the film clip please. I am under the impression that it is a clip from Fallujah, maybe I’m wrong but I don’t think so.
While I was on the phone in the last hour, I had Democracy Now! (via LINK TV) on in the background … I glanced over at the TV and they were showing horrific images of people burned white … burned to their bones … photo after photo … horrible.
in video footage shot my some of the clean up team. It was hard to make out clearly sometimes, but most of the corpses were oddly black and burned and sometimes half a face was burned away and the other half of the face was still there. I noticed it then but didn’t know what the hell I was seeing!
Tracy, the end of the Documentary Video, about Fallujah, was another Incident that got a Tremendous Play Online.
These ‘Chopper’ Pilots are Shooting At Iraqi’s in a Farm Field, with their Trucks, as Suspected Insurgents, this is occuring at night.
If you watch the Film again you will notice that near the end of it, after Firing on the Bigger Truck, the driver comes out and is Crawling On The Ground, after being hit, When Both Choppers Open Up On Him and the Smaller Truck.
In otherwords they Cold Bloodily Killed an Already Seriously Wounded person, Still Not Known if these were just Civilian Farmers or Iraqi Insurgents!!!
Tom Regan at the Christian Science Monitor is excellent on this subject today.
Yesterday I told my Vietnam veteran friend about reports we were using napalm in Iraq. He was surprised that was news. He said he could tell by seeing the explosions on TV.
Heartbreaking.
Thanks for pointing this out. I was just about to add a postscript to my diary pointing out that the European media was covering this extensively, including additional accusations, but that U.S. mainstream media are doing their usual horrendous job. The CSM article links to a lot of the world coverage, but the only other U.S. coverage I saw at Google News was a Reuters piece at ABC News and a UPI (owned by Bush ally Reverend Sun Myung Moon) piece that gave more space to the U.S. denial than to the RAI accusations.
As far as I am concerned our media is complicit in the war crimes of this administration. Not only should they be reporting this stuff, they should be investigating it themselves.
Our government are bastard terrorists.
Call your newsstations and DEMAND they investigate it/air it.
I am sick at heart.
The world will hate us and the military now.
Mission Accomplishd Bush… we are hated by ALL.
Janet this has been known for a long time. Check out Dahr Jamail;s website
Whoops…I found the DECEMBER 2004 ARTICLE ON THE NAPALMING OF FALLUHJAH that Juan COle discounter here it is…
READ THIS
http://www.dahrjamailiraq.com/hard_news/archives/2004_12_19.p
Your Juan Cole-bashing point has been made. Move on.
Juan Cole bashed Dahr Jamail. That pisses me off.
Actually there is a more detailed report,…but I can’t find it…where he talks to a doctor who describes the burns on the bodies of Fallujans as caused by gas…….I don’t have time right now but it’s got to be in the area of the above post.
couldn’t put their finger on exactly what happened they couldn’t gain any credibility. I don’t think they napalmed Fallujah and I don’t think they used “poison gas”……I believe they blanketed areas of Fallujah with white phosphorous. We have to KNOW what they did and gather our evidence together before we can say that it is “known”. All we knew before was that something was fishy.
and I wanted these monsters out of power. Maybe I prayed too hard or something or maybe I ought to be careful what I wish for. We are right back to our same fucking Vietnam selves again aren’t we……… Fuck the UGLY AMERICAN, what do you call us when we did it before and now we just turn around and do it again like it didn’t matter the first time? Maybe American Psycho is a fucking documentary!!!!!! Perhaps my Uncle knew something that I didn’t, that they would do all this all over again….and he wasn’t going to stick around this fucking piece of shit world in this piece of shit nation to go through it all fucking evil filth again. FUCK YOU BUSH! FUCK YOU CHENEY! FUCK YOU POWELL YOU FUCKING PUSSY! FUCK ALL OF YOU UP THERE AND FUCK WHOEVER IN THE PENTAGON SIGNED OFF ON THIS CORRUPT GROTESQUE FOUL EVIL DISGUSTING ENGAGEMENT OF THE ENEMY! YOU GUYS ARE THE FUCKING ENEMY! BUSH IS THE FUCKING ANTICHRIST!!!!! I want to be a citizen of a different country…….I hate this country today, I could just vomit!
You expressed so well what I cannot bring myself to say aloud. I am so ashamed to be an American today, so terribly ashamed. I feel like I could vomit, too, but I have to pretend everything is OK because I am joined at the hip with my 86-yo demented mother. If she saw this anger, which she cannot understand, she would feel it was her fault. So thank you for saying it, so now I can, at least here.
TORTURE ALL OF THEM FOR THE REST OF THEIR LIVES!!
Here a snip from an article in our only statewide paper, the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, which may be behind a subscription wall. It’s about Arkansas infantrymen going from Kuwait to Iraq, and describes their training in Kuwait using white phosphorus. They’re going to “Camp Cooke, northwest of Baghdad.” (emphasis added)
and bury some evil fuckers!
They can tell where the round hit and that helps the soldiers learn how to use the equipment accurately when they use the rounds they are supposed to use in combat. If these guys though used the training rounds on the enemy that’s different.
Every day, it gets worse. Every day, another new report. We don’t torture, except when we do. Now we don’t use white phosphorus and fucking napalm except when we do?
Torture. Chemical weapons. We are now everything our propaganda says Iraq was.
I’m sitting here right now listening to Democracy Now, and the Italian producer just called the Lt Colonel accidentally a Lieutenant and they are both on the air together arguing all of this out. In my mind’s eye the Lt Colonel just fell on the floor thrashing violently unable to breathe over some damn Italian exposing this and calling him a Lieutenant on the air in front of God and everybody. He just fucking did it again…….OH GOD I’m roaring!
That IS hilarious. I missed that … will have to lie down and watch it again this afternoon.
Wouldn’t it be something if Amy Goodman’s show were on CNN everyday?
You can see photos of these atrocities here, but I warn you, they are horrible to look at. Definitely not for the faint of heart.
It is horrible. Their last seconds of life must have been pure agony.
I suppose what hit them first was no oxygen. The burns came second.
I put up the Italian Documentary here in Macromedia Flash 8 streaming video as well as a backed up wmv file on my server folks.
Link to Italian Documentary video here:
Fallujah: Napalm By Any Other Name
I saw you have the DN Link but don’t have time to see if you had both from today’s show, so I’ll keep it with Malloy’s Link here!!
* U.S. Broadcast Exclusive – “Fallujah: The Hidden Massacre” on the U.S. Use
of Napalm-Like White Phosphorus Bombs *
Democracy Now! airs an exclusive excerpt of “Fallujah: The Hidden Massacre,”
featuring interviews with U.S. soldiers, Iraqi doctors and international
journalists on the U.S. attack on Fallujah. Produced by Italian state
broadcaster RAI TV, the documentary charges U.S. warplanes illegally dropped
white phosphorous incendiary bombs on civilian populations, burning the skin
off Iraqi victims. One U.S. soldier charges this amounts to the U.S. using
chemical weapons against the Iraqi people.
Listen/Watch/Read
* A Debate: Did the U.S. Military Attack Iraqi Civilians With White
Phosphorous Bombs in Violation of the Geneva Conventions? *
We speak with a former U.S. soldier who witnessed orders being given to drop
white phosphorous bombs over Fallujah; a Pentagon spokesperson in Baghdad
who admits such bombs were used but denied they were used as a chemical
weapon; and the news director of RAI TV, the Italian TV network that
produced ³Fallujah: The Hidden Massacre.²
Listen/Watch/Read
^^^^^^^^^^
10PM-1AM Tonight 11-08-05 Stream It If You Don’t Have A Local Radio Connection To ‘Air America’
The Independent UK:
“Powerful new evidence emerged yesterday that the United States dropped massive quantities of white phosphorus on the Iraqi city of Fallujah during the attack on the city in November 2004, killing insurgents and civilians with the appalling burns that are the signature of this weapon.
Ever since the assault, which went unreported by any Western journalists, rumors have swirled that the Americans used chemical weapons on the city.
On 10 November last year, the Islam Online website wrote: ‘US troops are reportedly using chemical weapons and poisonous gas in its large-scale offensive on the Iraqi resistance bastion of Fallujah, a grim reminder of Saddam Hussein’s alleged gassing of the Kurds in 1988.'” The full story — accompanied by a very graphic and disturbing video produced by Italian television and scheduled for broadcast tonight can be found HERE:
Once again, the rest of the world is shown graphic proof of US troops, acting on orders from George W. Bush, committing war crimes; incinerating civilians, destroying hospitals, bombing neighborhoods, obliterating whole sections of a city in a mad act of revenge against “terrorists” who have the temerity to resist the invading US military.
This is all — the war, the political corruption, the inability to function in the aftermath of natural disasters at home, the ruining of our financial resources, the domestic criminality of the ruling clique, the sanctioning of torture (!) — becoming much worse than the inability to perform even the most basic functions of government (which is an incompetence the Bush Crime Family demonstrates daily).
It is taking on the nightmarish feel of a horrific dream from which one struggles to escape.
The most recent example of the uselessness of Bush himself was the so-called economic summit of hemispheric leaders in Argentina. Bush walked out after making one of his useless press conference cum photo op appearances. No meetings, no discussions, no plans made for regional economic security. Nothing. Bush arrives. People violently protest his presence in their country. Bush struts for the cameras. Bush leaves and flies to a fund-raiser in Virginia after a quick stopover for another photo-op, this one in Panama.
It is all appalling.
It is disgusting.
And we have another 39 months of this.
Or do we?
Join me tonight for the discussion.