According to the Associated Press:
more below the fold:
President Bush, Attorney General Alberto Gonzales and Republicans congressional leaders had lobbied fiercely to make most of the expiring Patriot Act provisions permanent, and add new safeguards and expiration dates to the two most controversial parts: roving wiretaps and secret warrants for books, records and other items from businesses, hospitals and organizations such as libraries.
Feingold, Craig and other critics said that wasn’t enough, and have called for the law to be extended in its present form so they can continue to try and add more civil liberties safeguards. But Bush, Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist and House Speaker Dennis Hastert have said they won’t accept a short-term extension of the law.
If a compromise is not reached, the 16 Patriot Act provisions expire on Dec. 31.
I’m cautiously optimistic that this awful law will finally go the way of the Edsel.
Update [2005-12-17 2:2:10 by James Benjamin]:
From the comments there’s some great info. Apparently the NYT story on Bu$hCo authorizing NSA eavesdropping on US callers had some impact on the vote. Supporting that assertion is this gem from Madman in the Marketplace over at Liberal Street Fighter: Sen. Feingold’s Senate floor statement just prior to cloture:
I hope that this morning’s revelation drives home to people that this body must be absolutely vigilant in our oversight of government power. And I don’t want to hear again from the Attorney General or anyone on this floor that this government has shown it can be trusted to use the power we give it with restraint and care. This shocking revelation ought to send a chill down the spine of every Senator and every American.
Strong words from a very tough Senator. As critical as I have been about the Democrat party, I do certainly believe that those Dems who are willing to stand and be counted deserve a great deal of respect. Feingold has earned that consistently. To see how your Senators voted, check out this link to the roll call vote (thanks to a couple of my commenters).
I imagine that there are quite a few of us here in the frogpond who considered ourselves voices in the wilderness back when the Patriot Act was first enacted, for having the sheer nerve to assert that abuses by Bu$hCo (or really any White House administration) were extremely probable. I’m actually guardedly hopeful for the first time in a long time that the darkness that has enveloped our country is beginning to lift – even if only a little.
To those of you who’ve commented and/or who’ve recommended this diary, thanks!
Herr Fuhrer Bush, Reichminister of Gestapo Gonzales and Reichminister of Disinformation Sensenbrenner from further degrading our civil liberities.
Thank you Sen. Feingold for your courage against these insidious warmongering fascists.
He said he had them, and he didn’t fold them.
We need more Dems with balls like him, male and female.
On Reuters and the AP. Is there really a chance that Republicans would be willing to let their most favoritest evil law die, just to have an “anti-terrorist” bludgeon to use against some Democratic Senate candidates in 2006?
I can’t believe that, although I’d like to. I think a slightly watered-down version of the current Senate USA-P.A.T.R.I.O.T. Act will pass muster within a couple months.
Today I am very proud of Colorado Senator Ken Salazar for his wise vote, and of Wisconsin Senator Russ Feingold for pointing to the outfield fence and then hitting it right outta there.
Ken Salazar is slowly redeeming himself for his vote to confirm Alberto Gonzales’ nomination to AG earlier this year. Feingold has been a stalwart these past few years, and I tend to count him among a select group of Dems who really are worth the bother.
When I looked at the roll call vote for the House from yesterday, I checked how the reps from my state (Oklahoma) voted. The lone Dem (Boren) voted in favor of the renewal of the Patriot act, and one Republican (Lewis) actually voted no. Go figure.
Anyone have a link to where I can see the rollcall? I am very interested to see how the vote played out. Thanks James.
Click here.
You can always go to senate.gov. The external website is much better than it used to be.
patriot act rollcall vote
:<)
But a big :<( goes to …
(((drum roll)))
Tim Johnson (SD) and Ben Nelson (NE), the winners of the this week’s “WTF Were They Thinking When They Voted Yea For That” award.
When Lieberman votes nay, there really is no excuse.
Thank you folks! Sure appreciate you all making the effort to help this ditsy blonde…lol!
I’ll hear none of that “ditsy blonde” stuff!
:<)
Most Americans wouldn’t know where to look to get House/Senate votes. I wish there was a requirement that broadcast news announces that you can see how Reps/Sen voted by visiting house.gov or senate.gov, along with telling how the local delegation voted on issues for the week.
Now THAT would be useful.
Most Americans wouldn’t know where to look to get House/Senate votes. I wish there was a requirement that broadcast news announces that you can see how Reps/Sen voted by visiting house.gov or senate.gov, along with telling how the local delegation voted on issues for the week.
It would be fun to have the box score and report with color commentary a la SportsNight the hilarious, too smart comedy/drama that got lost.
if enough people asked for it …
Ben Nelson (in addition to being pretty darn conservative, in Democratic terms), seems to be playing things very shrewdly in order to prevent a Republican challenger in 2006 from having anything to work with in that deeply red state (66% for Bush in 2004).
Tim Johnson, although not up for re-election until 2008 (and some believe he may decide to retire anyway), faces a similar electoral demographic in South Dakota. Johnson, as we should recall, won by only 524 votes in 2002, so he’s very careful about not seeming to get too far out of step with his state. And Daschle lost last November, partially because Thune was able to tar him as the leader of the “obstructionist Democrat opposition”.
What I would like to find out is whether Nelson and Johnson had been given a green light by Reid to vote in favor of cloture, seeing as how the vote today wasn’t even close. If the GOP leadership had been in a position to potentially win this vote, Reid might have tried much harder to keep them within the Democratic fold. How would Nelson and Johnson voted under those circumstances, I wonder?
Yeah, I know how it works, but I’d be A LOT more sympathetic if there weren’t other right-wing senators voting nay.
Including, might I add, Chuck Hagel–of Nebraska.
I’m sure Durbin/Reid had the whip count secure so if anyone had to “defect” (so to speak) they could do so. But still–to me, this should have been an easy vote to cast.
ESPECIALLY Nelson of Nebraska.
In Oklahoma my Senators are Inhofe and Coburn, both just to the right of Mussolini and Attila the Hun. Naturally, they voted Yes according to the roll call. They’d probably vote “yes” on a law to make soap from the fat of illegal immigrants or Ay-rabs, knowing those two.
It also didn’t hurt that the today’s story in the NYT about Shrub authorizing the NSA to spy on Americans ran TODAY, after having sat on it for a year.
The motion is seconded. Any discussion?
Thanks! If there ever was a true “feel good” story with substance this is it.
Is the NYT credited w/ the scoop on NSA domestic spying? Sure seems to have been timed to influence the PA vote. What has changed in the past year (they sat on it!) that made its dislosure a danger to national security then to no longer be a problem?
Dodd was a not voting? Is he away? My two fine Senators voted nay. I can always count on Boxer but one never knows with DiFi!
Good question.
for this constitutionally horrendous civil rights violating fascist law. But of course both my wingnut Senators are fascist so that was to be expected.
I feel for you Ghostdancer. God, it is so good to see you here again. Hope all is well with you and yours.
Progressing forward with my ongoing battle with PTSD, thankfully the episodes are less debilitating than they once were. Of course 18 years in recovery from self medication and tons of therapy and other good stuff over these last 18 years has helped trememdously.
All are well in my family and we are looking forward to christmas and the rest of the holidays, thank you very much.
Senate rejects reauthorization of USA Patriot Act
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
December 16, 2005, 1:58 PM EST
They do know how divisive the Patriot Act is, right? It’s not just Dems who oppose it.
Oh goody! I hope the Repug’s are so stupid as to make this a Mid-term election issue. We’ll win a massive majority of Independents and split the Libertarians off from the GOP.
Oh please, please, please make this an election issue!
let ’em try to play the issue. then we’ll just demurely * cough * remind them that it was GOoPer “leadership” that refused a 3-month extension to allow further debate.
there just ain’t enough lipstick in the world for that one…
What war on terror?
The one terrorizing our own citizens?
to be fighting it.
Halla-fuckin’-lujah!
This is some good news for a change. My little celebration at Liberal Street Fighter is here.
Make sure to drop in at Tablefor One and check out Senator Feingold’s posts over the last week about his battle, including a link to his comments this morning from the floor. There are also good links in the comment threads.
There are soom great comments over there. Not mine of course, but others.
I <3 Russ!
The Patriot Act didn’t stop the suicide bomber at the Oklahoma football game earlier this fall, did it?