In tomorrow’s Sunday edition, the New York Times published the results of their sample of 260 people who died during or shortly after Hurricane Katrina hit New Orleans and the Gulf Coast:
More than 100 of them drowned. Sixteen died trapped in attics. More than 40 died of heart failure or respiratory problems, including running out of oxygen. At least 65 died because help – shelter, water or a simple dose of insulin – came too late.
What is worse is that most of them survived the hurricane itself.
They died, however, from the flooding and the sometimes bloody anarchy that seized New Orleans and its citizenry in the aftermath.
Reporters Shaila Dewan and Janet Roberts wrote this disclaimer:
The results are not necessarily representative of the 1,100 people who died in the storm-ravaged part of the state. The 268 deaths examined by The Times were not chosen through a scientific or random sample, but rather were selected on the basis of which family members could be reached, and which names had been released by state officials.
The rate at which the Ninth Ward and other lowlying areas flooded is now known to have been much faster and far deadlier than previously imagined. Not unlike, for example, the tsunami that inundated Thailand last year. If someone was swept away, and a relative or friend tried to grab hold of them, the current could pull both of them down to drown.
Water – rising as fast as a foot every 10 minutes – overtook many who thought the worst had passed. In St. Bernard Parish, just east of the city, Joan Emerson, 57, was on the phone with her son at midmorning on Monday when he heard her screaming, then the phone went dead, a family friend said. Her body was found 18 days later.
In Arabi, the St. Bernard town adjacent to the Lower Ninth Ward, the water came so fast that Kenneth Young did not have time to save his wife of 56 years, Gloria, who was partly paralyzed and bedridden, relatives said. He stayed with her until the last possible moment, watching her drown before he narrowly escaped to the attic, where the couple’s daughter waited.
More statistics:
Most of the victims were elderly–65 years old on up.
Of the adults below that age who died, a quarter were bedridden because of illness or disabled. In other words, they needed medical assistance to get out, but there was none.
Three quarters of the black victims were members of the New Orleans working class.
Many died alone.
Eddie Cherrie Jr. stayed behind with his mother, Onelia, who relied on a walker and blood pressure medication. “It’s true nothing stopped us from leaving,” he said. “But also, it’s not that easy to leave with a 91-year-old woman.”
They survived the storm but were later taken by helicopter to the airport, where officials separated a badly dehydrated Ms. Cherrie from her son, leaving her to die alone, he said. Mr. Cherrie said if the levees had not broken, she would have survived. “That’s malfeasance,” he said.
Although these elderly were nearing the ends of their lives, their survivors maintain that they deserved to die with dignity, and not in the manner in which they were allowed to die, in one survivor’s words for his uncle, like a rat.
At least these survivors knew what had happened to their loved ones, but for others not knowing is hardest to bear.
More than 60 families told The Times that they still did not know how or in some cases even where their loved ones perished. As a result, a full portrait remains impossible.
Lord have mercy. Read it.
(Shaking head throughout all this typing and cutting and pasting.)
Bush and his minions deserve to burn in the hell of incessant suffering for all time.
Amen. To suggest that someone who intentionally and willfully causes this kind of suffering, and does not repent, is in any way Christian sickens me. I wouldn’t wish Hell on anyone… But I do wish that, when he dies, Bush has to watch through the eyes of everyone whose death he caused and those who suffered because of those deaths, until he understands the magnitude of the suffering he has caused.
Elders and the sick in hospitals and nursing homes, steamed, others roasted alive on rooftops and expressways, others died of thirst.
Exterminated. Cleansed. Reducing the region’s Medicare costs considerably, making way for a terrific investment opportunity.
May God accept their martyrdom.
I don’t know how this administration can live with itself knowing that it allowed a city to be destroyed with its most vulnerable citizens still in it.
“Oh fuck,” said little chief. They will kill us all.
.
My diary :: AMERICAN SHAME:
The Edgar Hollingsworth Story :: May he R.I.P.
Mon Sep 26th, 2005 at 11:16:15 PM PST
9/20/2005, 9:12 a.m. CT
The Associated Press
NEW ORLEANS (AP) — A 74-year-old survivor of Hurricane Katrina found trapped in a New Orleans home for about two weeks has died of complications related to dehydration and malnutrition, the California National Guard said.
Edgar Hollingsworth, an Army veteran of the Korean War, died Saturday at a hospital, four days after he was found Sept. 13 buried under rubble, said Air Force Capt. Brenda Hendrickson, spokeswoman for the California National Guard.
Hollingsworth was scheduled to be buried Tuesday with military honors at the Port Hudson National Cemetery, which is 10 miles north of Baton Rouge.
At the request of his wife, Lillian, military personnel and other authorities who helped rescue him will serve as pallbearers, along with his son, Wesley, the California National Guard said in a prepared statement.
AMERICAN SHAME: The Edgar Hollingsworth Story
◊ by RobertInWisconsin @dKos
Wed Sep 14th, 2005 at 09:51:05 PDT
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
Hollingsworth is mentioned in this story, may he rest in peace.
We will never see all of the people lost in this tragedy, and that’s not a random occurrence, I think.
Is it random where the levees were well built? Is it random that over such a wide area, for so many people who tried to take individual action to help, that they were turned away with very few exceptions?
You’d think no one around there knew what rising water could do. But of course, you’d be wrong. There’s not a living adult who’s resided in the Mississippi Delta who isn’t aware of the speed and danger of water, and of the necessity for running at top speed to help people stranded by the flooding. And there are many, many other people as well who know these things. It took willful delay and purposeful consideration of “politics before people” to make this bad storm into a horrific tragedy. A why, I want to keep asking, was it so necessary to vilify and blame the victims of this tragedy?
.
≈ Cross-posted from blksista’s diary — Kiss New Orleans goodbye ≈
The compassionate Republican President has history written all over him with the 100k pp of Governor Blanco and the inadequate response to Liberal NOLA. In GOP states of Mississippi and Texas, when Rita moved across, there were less problems encountered with FEMA. Red-red communicates a lot better with $$$ funding than the mix red-blue which turns everyone purple handling the relief effort.
Gwendolyn Alexander tried frantically to get information on their friends, an elderly couple left behind in New Orleans after she herself was evacuated. After persistance to find out what happened to them: 88 year old Antonio Jackson, called Toni and her husband 97 year old Eddy, Gwendolyn went back to their home again this week.
Outside on the wall next to the front door the text “0 bodies, no one inside” was sprayed on 14 September when officials went by the house.
With New Orleans officials at her side Gwendolyn entered the home and found behind the kitchen door the body of Eddy. Later the officials found the remains of Toni on the living room floor.
VIDEO of interview by CNN I could only locate on Yahoo News site
Hurricane Katrina Survivors
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
I’m not sure that the average, working class family fared much better in Mississippi. I’ve heard other stories. I’m sure though, that we are getting less news of their suffereing. because Balbour, and others, do not want the truth to come out about this republican president.
You know, everytime I read something about NOLA, I am more amazed as to how they actually lasted as long as they did. I am stunned about some of these stories. It seems that we ought to simply demand the levees be done in the right manner this time. We need to demand that the wetlands be restored and then maybe we will have some hope this will not be happening all over again. If we do not do this, we will continue to loose more as the years go by. We must think logically and rationally and get the job done right this time.
The deeply shameful truth is that if the ninth ward had been populated by well off whites, this tragedy would never have have happened in the first place. There would have been strong, well maintained levies able to withstand any storm. Plentiful help would have arrived will in advance of the waters, to evacuate all those needing help to leave, and every honest person with a brain and working heart knows it.
I love what America could be, but not what it is, as illustrated by Katrina. May those who gave their lives to show us what we really are, rest in peace now.
A well-off subdivision, Lakeview, flooded, and flooded badly. People died there, and there were breaches before the storm that were never repaired, neglected and ignored by the powers that be.
It is interesting to note that the ruling class’s treatment of the upper middle class is closing ranks with the shabby treatment of the working poor.
First they came for the least of us.
have stepped up to the plate on this- (TY Brin)-We are trying to make it help and F- the Red Cross (who would trust an agency that had Liddy Dole as directer?the Red Cross was doomed way back then, and that was calculated) and Fema-so I guess this is what ‘privatization’ means- or whatever ‘private contractors’ with guns can accomplish??
Neither of them can accomplish a G_D thing- they are bureaucratic nightmares- which is why I send money to NGO’s.
People on the ground who know what is needed- not some a-hole in an office.
Sorry but I detest paper shufflers- who profess to work-but mostly send internal e-mails to each other, bout how hard their lives are.
That is of course,not the point-the point is to get the help where it is needed,but is very frustrating to people like me-who have nothing to give really,but money.
Hub and I discussed going to volunteer,he is very skilled in just about everything,but me? I would just take up space.
So, the agreement was, that It’s Christmas in New Orleans as much as we can make it.
I’m convinced that it is because of all of our collective efforts, in so many directions, that we were able to prove to Congress and Bush that New Orleans would not be forgetten, hence the funding for the levees.