On January 13, the United States launched a terror raid on Occupied Pakistan, murdering at least eighteen human beings, including fourteen members of the BahktPur family.
There will be no CNN interviews with grieving family members. No cousins and neighbors will tearfully tell you that little Hussain drove his mother (also murdered) nuts asking questions about everything, always with a follow-up “why?” No one will show you Sadiqa’s remarkable drawings of birds, flowers, her brothers and sisters, you will not be told that Nadia Bibi wanted to be a teacher, and loved to make her little brothers “play school,” that Ameer could make any vehicle go, that Tahira’s embroidery was famous for miles around, that Zahid could imitate a chicken so accurately that he used to fool the whole family all the time, even Grandma Noor, who always had room in her lap for one more, always had one more story to tell about the old days, always had an answer for Hussain’s invariable “why?
Maybe none of that is true. None of the victims are considered important enough for CNN, or any other news organization to go to Damadola and ask. Oh, they are in Damadola, but they will not ask about the victims, their producers will not instruct them to prepare heart-rending stories of their lives, to make them real people to you, so that you get to know them, mourn them, and feel appropriate rage at the barbarous and brutal entity that blew them to pieces, little arms and heads and legs all over the place to be collected.
There will be no mention of any witnesses being treated for shock, no one smoothing out the skirt of a doll’s dress, voice breaking as they tell you that Sadiqa received this doll as a gift for her tenth birthday and took it everywhere, that Tahira embroidered the dress with the same artistry as if it were a wedding dress for a princess.
These are not, after all, Israeli victims of a suicide bombing in a pizza parlor, not the families of US gunmen killed in Iraq.
Even the headline in the Frontier Post says “18 Tribesmen Killed”.
Pakistan, it is said, will complain. Call in the Ambassador. They have also dutifully lobbed tear gas at the eight thousand or so “tribesmen” who dared to protest the terror attack on their little home town.
At least they’re just bombing the provinces, it’s not like there are little arms and feet and grandma’s laps lying in the streets of Islamabad or Karachi. Yet.
Yet for all the private sighs of relief in the drawing rooms of the “educated class” in their elegant homes, all the whispers of thank God it is only tribesmen, there is something else simmering under the fine broadcloth western-style shirts and silk kameezes, behind dupattas embroidered with gold threads.
Maybe Americans can understand this if they imagine for a moment that a foreign country bombed a village in deepest Appalachia. Just hillbillies. People who are the butt of jokes on comedy shows, whose accents and customs are burlesqued almost unconsciously to make a comedic point.
But once that foreign country is in the US and bombing those people, shredding their bodies, the soft flesh of their children’s bodies, leaving it all there in the rubble of what were their rustic little mountain cabins for the neighbors to pick up and sort out, hey Dwayne, ain’t that thar’n Homer’s head? Ya’ll put’t in that sack over yonder then, cause this here’n’s already got some o’ Charlene in’t.
At some point, inside the gated communities and across the wide suburban lawns inside the gracious homes where the soccer moms and their professional business casual wearing spouses sip cappucino and set aside the New York Times crossword for when the croissants are ready, pausing a moment to contemplate the headline “18 Mountaineers Killed,” somewhere under the cashmere twinsets and J. Crew polos, something whispers, “they were Americans.”
In the coming days, as there have been on past occasions when the US has launched its terror raids into Waziristan and environs, slaughtering more “tribesmen,” there will be, as there have been, various very feisty editorials and strongly worded statements in the Pakistani press, deploring the slaughter, deploring the occupation, and as much as they dare, the occupiers, the terrorists, the bestial horde, the native puppet Musharaf.
There will even be some angry young men who vow to avenge the murders, the atrocity, just as one might find some angry young American young men who would burn with similar sentiments on seeing the headline “18 Mountaineers Killed.”
Because even though these victims were merely humble tribesmen from a small, remote village that does not have any big buildings or shopping malls or TV stations, they are Pakistanis.
And even more importantly to many young men and women far, far from Pakistan, they are human beings.
May God accept their martyrdom.
The fourteen fatalities have been confirmed by ISPR, as briefed by Maj Gen. Shaukat Sultan.
The bombardment by the Allied forces, fell on Damadola Burkanday area of tehsil Mamoon in Bajaur agency at 3:00 am PST, completely flattening the homes of BakhtPur, Muhammad Rahim and Bacha Khan.
According to local eyewitnesses, fourteen members of BakhtPur family along with four others died, due to indiscriminate bombing. The dead included eight children, and four females. The dead included, 9-year old Nadia Bibi, 10-year old Sadiqa, 9-year old Tayyeb, 7 year old Zahid ullah, 5-year old Hussain Nawaz. Others included 20-year-old Ameer Muhammad, 25-year-old Nazir Muhammad, 50-year Noor Pari, 40-year old Shahi Badan, 30-year-old Qari Saeed, 30-year-old Tahira Bibi, and others. Some of the dead were unidentified.The locals reported that the allied warplanes violated the Pakistani airspace from Afghanistan territory by 19 kilometers and targeted the said homes. The resultant explosions rocked the area far and wide, shattering windows.
The sources also reported reconnaissance flights spying on the area for the past few days.
The assistant Political Agent of the Nawagai region, Abdul Qayum acknowledged blasts heard at 0300 hrs, but said that since the reported area is located far away, no immediate details were available.
A team has been dispatched by the officials for further investigations. Bajaur Agency is located parallel to the Kunar Province of Afghanistan.It is feared that the dead could well exceed 18. In the past about eight persons had died due to such bombings and the government had lodged strong protests to the American Administration.
The Bajur attack happened few days after Pakistan lodged protest with U.S.-led forces in Afghanistan about firing in the North Waziristan tribal area on Saturday night that had killed eight people.
Bajur border Afghanistan’s eastern Kunar province, where Taliban and Hekmatyar-led Hizbe-e-Islami are active.nerdified link (site is down today, here is alternate link to Dawn story with much of same info.
I read the obscure article posted by CNN this morning.
Not worthy for a headline like the lies and claims of Zawahari’s death.
Shame doesn’t begin to express how I feel about my country’s murder of these people. Rage is insufficient too. I feel insufficient this morning and all too comfortable. My children are safe here….
so far.
Tell me again, who’s the terrorist?
Sadly the terrorists have been America for some time.
The Guardian
From AP this morning:
Some 10,000 people rallied in Karachi, Pakistan’s biggest city, chanting “Death to America” and “Stop bombing against innocent people.” Hundreds massed in the capital, Islamabad, and in Lahore, Multan and Peshawar burning U.S. flags and demanding the withdrawal of U.S. troops from Afghanistan.
The so called leadership of this “our” country continues to make “mistakes”. I am sure George okayed this strike because of some “wiretap” here in the US that told them the “terrorists” were having dinner there <snark> WTF are they getting us into now?
I will remember the victims of unbridled US aggression. I also remember that this is how to create terrorism. These lives will cry out for reprisals.
If the CIA were to suspect that an al qaeda member fled to Canada, what would stop them from bombing across our border one day, under the bastard Commander-in-Chief Bush?
urge me, especially in light of the celebration of what would have been Dr. King’s 77th birthday.
to answer your question with the two words:
“white skin.”
I am sorry.
Thank you for remembering these victims.
that you were not correct in that thought.
it tolls for the whole fucking world.
Its hard to get one’s head around the fact that some of the people who run our gov’ment really believe Jesus wants them to help bring about the end of time.
They really believe this. aargh.
My disgust for the actors in this is overwhelming. And to boot, this also came just 2 weeks prior from yet another incident of the likes. The incompetence of this is just heart wrenching. The emotional and political fallout on this is going to become prostanding and everlasting. Thanks, DTF…hugs
.
I assumed article meant as a news item for the NATO forces moving into provincial territory deeper into the interior. Apparently I was mistaken!
KHANDAHAR (ABC/AP) Jan 15, 2006 — A suicide car bomb hit a Canadian military convoy in the southern Afghan city, killing two civilians and wounding 13 people. The blast occurred as the convoy was driving near the Canadian base in Kandahar city, a former Taliban stronghold, said Interior Ministry spokesman Dad Mohammed Rasa. He said at least two civilians were killed and 10 were wounded. He said an unspecified number of Canadian troops were also hurt.
U.S. military spokesman Lt. Col. Jerry O’Hara said three soldiers were wounded in a bomb attack on a U.S.-led coalition convoy, but declined to identify their nationalities. Calls to a spokesman for the Canadian force in Kandahar went unanswered. Canada has about 650 troops in Afghanistan, nearly all in Kandahar.
Shopkeeper Rahim Gul said he saw a sedan vehicle blow up as it was passing the convoy. “The explosion was so big. It destroyed one jeep and blew it totally to the other side of the road,” he said, adding that he saw at least three wounded soldiers.
The blast is the latest in a string of suicide attacks that represent a new and disturbing security threat in Afghanistan. Violence across southern and eastern Afghanistan spiked last year, leaving about 1,600 people dead, the most since U.S.-led forces ousted the Taliban in 2001 for hosting Osama bin Laden.
Latest News :: Canadien Among Dead
KABUL (The Scotsman) Jan. 13, 2006 — HUNDREDS of foreign Islamic fighters are gathering in Afghanistan ahead of the deployment of 4,000 British troops to the country in the spring.
British intelligence sources have told The Scotsman Islamic radicals sympathetic to al-Qaeda see Afghanistan as their new frontline and are starting to shift the focus of their anti-western campaign from Iraq.
The fighters, including Jordanians, Yemenis, Egyptians and Gulf Arabs, stepped up their campaign two months ago with a series of suicide bombings against NATO peacekeepers, United States troops and Afghan government leaders.
“Attacks in Afghanistan are now running at more than 500 a month – it’s getting as dangerous for westerners as Iraq in some places,” said a British officer involved in planning the NATO peacekeeping mission in the south-west of the country.
DAMADOLA, Pakistan (ABC/AP) Jan 15, 2006 — Pakistani officials on angrily condemned a purported CIA airstrike meant to target al-Qaida’s No. 2 man, saying he wasn’t there and innocent civilians were among at least 17 men, women and children killed in a village near the Afghan border.
Tribesmen stand by their home
damaged by Friday's air raid Al Jazeera
Thousands of tribesmen staged protests and a mob set fire to the office of a U.S.-backed aid agency as Pakistan’s people and government showed increasing frustration over a recent series of suspected U.S. attacks along the frontier that appear aimed at Islamic militants.
Pakistani Anger and Protests in Karachi
Protesters hold anti-U.S. signs during a protest in Islamabad, Pakistan. Islamic groups staged nationwide protests against a CIA airstrike that Pakistan says killed innocent civilians instead of the apparent target, top al-Qaida lieutenant Ayman al-Zawahri. AP Photo/Anjum Naveed
≈ Cross-posted from my diary —
NYT & Patrick Lang Beating the War Drums Exacerbates Fear of Iran ≈
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
…was an official from Foreign Affairs. 3 Canadian soldiers were injured and taken to hospital, 2 in critical condition. (Links: Foreign Affairs official killed in Afghanistan, Canadian diplomat killed, three soldiers injured in Afghanistan bombing).
And how’s this for conservative compassion,
Unfortunately. Collateral. Oh yes. It’s war baby.
One thing that really disgusts me about the media coverage and the U.S. public reaction is the casual assumption that carnage like this would be okay if some bad guys got killed. And to that I say No! Even if you knew for sure that bin Laden himself was in a house with one innocent person, you could not lawfully and morally blow up the house. Every American is just dripping with gallons of guilty blood, which will never wash off.
I was shocked they did this because this is going to hurt the secular leader Mushaaraf and strenthen the fundamentalists in Pakistan, a nuclear power. Bush is a proponent of fundamenatlism….it doesn’t matter what fundamentalism….any will do. He’s put a fundamentalist gov in Iraq, wants to take down a secualr syrian gov, put fundamentalist in there, wants to get rid of Mubarak in Egypt….
And of course….a DTF says nobody cares about the people. If Zarquawi saw the drones circling overhead for days before the attack, did it occur to the genius CIA that maybe he would leave the area?
And what difference does killing him make? NONE. He doesn’t matter anymore.
All these people and more killed for nothing.
The bomb maker, the operator of the plane, or the drone, Washington prefers not to say whether the plane was manned remotely or traditionally, the Pakistani traitors who collaborate with the occupation, all received a benefit, as is the case with all crimes against humanity, all atrocities.
Amrika will take care of the puppet Musharaf as long as he is useful to them, as they do with Karzai, as they did with Saddam Hussein, as they are doing with all of their native overseers.
Thus DynCorp also receives a benefit, as Mush’s pipi contingent will doubtless need to be augmented.
Oh absolutely, our deciding whose a good guy and whose a bad guy has nothing at all to do with how that person is running their country but what is in our governments nefarious interests and big corporations interests to make that arbitrary decision. Just like our dealing with that monster in Uzbeckistan and how well that worked out…for him getting tons of taxpayer money until he kicked us out. I guess you go with the dictator you have, not the dictator you want?
choclate ink:
I guess you go with the dictator you have, not the dictator you want?
That’s what the U.S. is doing with Bush!
To spread the foundations of democracy you need to use diplomacy. To spread the foundations of hate and terror, use a bomb or a gun.
Weapons of Mass Distraction from the real problems.
I wish the word ‘collateral’ was wiped out of all talk of war and what happens to families-men, women and children and babies-who die simply because they are in the way of the war machine was reported truthfully..yeah right huh.
If our talking heads had to actually as duct says talk not about ‘collateral damage'(some sick mind thought up that phrase I’m sure)but what is happening when families just like ours get killed and how that effects the rest of their families and relatives and for not one good gdamn fucken reason maybe they’d get an inkling of how wrong this all is…maybe. Then again if they had an ounce of real journalistic integrity in their blood this is what they would be doing anyway.
I guess though that is the problem isn’t it..the war machine and the talking heads on MSM don’t see those families as just like ours and why they can so callously continue to throw around the phrase ‘collateral damage’ as if it was some inanimate object.
Can you imagine if over a Hundred thousand Americans here were killed by accident from misguided bombs etc and it was not ackowledged at all by anyone and those families referred to as ‘collateral damage’?
What was that that Harry Belefonte just said last week …’George Bush is the Worlds Greatest Terrorist’….
But in this case, there are no “collaterals” even if you accept Pentagonspeak. Because a collateral by its very definition can only occur when there is a legimate target. At best, those who ordered the attack were guessing that the target might be there based on intelligence that will probably never be known to any of us. Was it intelligence of the Ahmad Chalabi type? Or just mistaken? Whatever. Now there are 18 more dead people. And how much new fodder for terrorism?
Resistance and opposition to US policies.
Oh, wait, that is how the US defines terrorism.
speaking of legitimate targets apparently that prick McCain said he apologized BUT if they had to bomb the place they’d do it again cause they had ‘legitimate’ intelligence that one of the bad guys was there…I bet that fucked up apology really will make the people over in Pakistan feel all warm and fuzzy towards us. That ought to make for more than 10,000 marching and protesting and shouting death to Americans….for shit’s sake do these asshole repugs purposely go out of their way to sound like shitty insensitive Americans-rhetorical question.
I’ve been telling my sister that bush(since he took office) was going to get us into WW111 and it won’t be us against the so called terrorists but the rest of the world is finally going to say enough of our bombing other countries and unite against us just like what happened with Germany.
the intelligence of even their most ardent devotees.
Their story is that Zawahiri had been invited to dinner in the town.
Now even if one accepts all the various articles of faith regarding Zawahiri, the war on terra, etc., or even if one merely considers the possibility that Zawahiri might have information that could be embarrassing to the US and its allies, if his location is known to the extent that he can be invited to dinner, why did they not have the inviter kill him, or follow the messenger who invited him?
At the very least, one would suppose that there would be some effort made to verify that he had accepted the invitation and travelled to the village.
The invitation to dinner crap, as well as the whole ‘we thought Zawahiri was there’ story is made up of whole cloth. It was a terror operation, pure and simple, intended to send a message to the people of Pakistan that US is their God now, and if they do not submit to Amrika’s will, their children will be blown to bits.
It is a favorite tactic with both the American political and military leadership as well as with the mainstream American populace, who have carefully considered the consequences, and decided it is worth whatever the price may be.
.
.
Biggest news story past week in Germany, and all over TV reports and documentaries. BND agents were scouts in Baghdad for targeting of U.S. missiles leading up to first strikes The infamous failed decapitation strike on Saddam Hussein was a confirmed target by these two BND agents. They confirmed the Mercedes colonne was present at the restaurant, result was a near miss as Saddam had just left and fifty innocent Iraqis died.
● BBC News – War In Iraq In Depth
German’s Fuchs NBC reconnaissance vehicles used in Iraq.
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
the deaths of tens of thousands of Iraqi’s, over 2,000 soldiers, torture of prisoners, and illegal wiretaps. They’ve mostly forgotten the poor of New Orleans. They’ve ignored the Republican’s budget which kneecaps support for the poor. I’m sorry to say that a lack of outrage over this is not a surprise.
And yet we can’t give up, we can’t accept this acceptance. If there was any lesson to be learned from the Vietnam War, it is the importance of constantly pushing the truth in front the American people until they simply can’t hide from it any longer.
I seriously doubt that any US reporter has given enough shit to even interviewing any one in that area to find out their feelings of this. OH now that would be to simple, now wouldn’t it! Did we see the interpreter for the CSM [kidnapped], of his wive interviewd for her feelings in the murder? Hell no! It is as simple as it seems for them..just go ahead and keep pusing for the goverment of us or the country that this happens in. It is , at least to me anyhow, like these family and extended family members do not exist! Not only are they [the press, mainly us] ignorant and obvilious to the fact of such things, I seriously doubt that they even care! so pathetic!
Editorial from The Frontier Post (hat tip to Ductape for his link):
We just need to keep in mind – that OUR government is a terrorist government- we ARE a rogue state,with no reins in sight.
OK BU$hie- poo? go ahead tap my phone and FU too.
Oh fellow tribesperson, fellow alien–the tragedy is indeed tempered by your masterful craftsmanship as a writer. I have missed your words. You pour salt on wounds–and that is not a bad thing, for salt is a healer, it cleanses, despite the sting.
Wishing you a chronologically incorrect but commonly accepted
Happy New Year….
a candle to the fallen.
(sorry to have made myself so scarce these days, have been busy translating the u-no-hoo[rahs]s! –hubby gets up in the morning to go jogging, says: I’m off to the races, hon. I say, OK, seeyalater hon, I’m off to the racists! )
by our military machine before just someone in a position of power says it is wrong?
How many children must die before CNN reports they are not terrorists?
How many children have we killed?
How many children did we rape in Abu Ghraib and such other facilities?
How many children have we left with no parents?
How many children have we left with no shelter?
And we say we are civilized. And we call others terrorists.
Nice, expressive writing. You touched my heart. Thank you for the piece.