When Dick Cheney accidentally blasted his friend with a shotgun on Satuday afternoon, he decided to let Katharine Armstong handle the issue of how or whether to disclose than an incident had taken place on her property. Or, at least, that is what we were initially led to believe. The Washington Post reported:
It was Armstrong’s decision to alert the news media. Cheney’s office made no public announcement, deciding to defer to Armstrong because the incident had taken place on her property. Armstrong called the Corpus Christi Caller-Times, and when a reporter from the paper called the White House, the vice president’s office confirmed the account.
Cheney has since changed his version of events. He now admits that he signed off on the decision to have Ms. Armstrong leak the news to a local paper because “I thought that made good sense because you can get as accurate a story as possible from somebody who knows and understands hunting. Then it would immediately go up to the wires and be posted on the Web site, which is the way it went out. I thought that was the right call. I still do.”
So how accurate was Ms. Armstrong?
Here are some of her initial accounts to news authorities.
To the Associated Press via the Washington Post’s Shailagh Murray and Peter Baker:
According to Armstrong’s account, she was watching from a car while Cheney, Whittington and another hunter got out of the vehicle to shoot at a covey of quail. Whittington shot a bird and as he went to retrieve it, Cheney and the third hunter discovered a second covey.
Whittington “came up from behind the vice president and the other hunter and didn’t signal them or indicate to them or announce himself,” Armstrong said, according to the Associated Press.
Cheney’s office referred other reporters to Armstrong for a witness account, but after speaking to some members of the media yesterday afternoon, Armstrong stopped returning phone calls.
She told reporters that the small shotgun pellets “broke the skin” and that the blast “knocked him silly. But he was fine. He was talking. His eyes were open. It didn’t get in his eyes or anything like that.”
“Fortunately, the vice president has got a lot of medical people around him and so they were right there and probably more cautious than we would have been,” she said. “The vice president has got an ambulance on call, so the ambulance came.”
On February 13th, Susan Page of USA Today reported on her conversation with Katherine Armstrong.
Such hunting accidents aren’t rare, Armstrong said, but there are few shootings on record by presidents or vice presidents. Vice President Aaron Burr killed Alexander Hamilton in a duel in 1804. In some ways, Cheney’s accident is more reminiscent of occasions when President Ford drove golf balls into a crowd, beaning bystanders.
“These things happen,” Armstrong said, expressing exasperation with reporters who seemed to know nothing about hunting. “It’s a shotgun, not a rifle,” she said, “and it’s a spray of pellets … not bullets.”
She also told Page that Whittington was sitting up in bed and would probably leave the hospital that day (Monday).
This is what she told Anne Kornblut of the New York Times:
‘This all happened pretty quickly,” Ms. Armstrong said in a telephone interview from her ranch. Mr. Whittington, she said, ”did not announce — which would be protocol — ‘Hey, it’s me, I’m coming up,’ ” she said.
”He didn’t do what he was supposed to do,” she added, referring to Mr. Whittington. ”So when a bird flushed and the vice president swung in to shoot it, Harry was where the bird was.”
Mr. Whittington was ”sprayed — peppered, is what we call it — on his right side, on part of his face, neck, shoulder and rib cage,” she said, noting that she, too, had been sprayed on her leg in a hunting accident.
”A shotgun sprays a bunch of little bitty pellets; it’s not a bullet involved,” Ms. Armstrong said. She said she believed that Mr. Cheney was shooting a 28-gauge shotgun and added that guests typically bring their own firearms.
She told the Houston Chronicle:
Armstrong, who witnessed the accident from a nearby vehicle, said Whittington was knocked down by the bird-shot pellets, breaking the skin in several places.
“It stunned him. He’ll be sore. But he was immediately talking and that was the great thing,” said Armstrong, who stressed none of the pellets struck his eyes or any vital parts. “The vice president had an excellent medical detail and they were over him so fast.”
This is what happened. The man was badly hurt and initially unresponsive. He had over two hundred small wounds, including deep wounds in his chest that had penetrated through his winter clothing and lodged near his heart. He was medivaced out by helicopter and no one wanted to make an announcement until it was determined he would live. Once they were confident that Whittington would live, they spread word that it was Whittington’s fault, that he was knocked silly, but it was no big deal. He was peppered and bruised. He was doing fine, sitting up, and would leave the hospital shortly.
So, Cheney had Armstrong lie for him. End of story.
Get this!
itself, in the material I read, she says she looked out and saw Cheney’s various entourage running toward him and thought he might have developed a health problem.
So that would indicate to me that she did not actually see the actual shooting, and might not be the best person to ask what happened.
I know. The butt-covering began ASAP!
Yeah, right!
Cheney:
Um, isn’t Cheney admitting by implication here that he isn’t “somebody who knows and understands hunting”?
Leaks, lies and fear is no way to run a country.
With all these damn “leaks” our country should be run by the makers of Depends.
And given that Whittington was hit with just about the full shot count from Cheney’s rifle, it would have been a miracle of coordination for Cheney to have been shooting at a bird moving laterally just in front of or behind Whittington.
Nope, Cheney — drunk, demented or both — really did mistake the old man for a bird, aim right at him… and pull the trigger.
Right after Cheney admits he fired the shot that hit Whittington: Did you get the bird?
Hard to believe from anyone else, but Hume thinks differently than most of us when tragedy strikes.
Q Now, is it clear that — he had caught part of the shot, is that right?
THE VICE PRESIDENT: — part of the shot. He was struck in the right side of his face, his neck and his upper torso on the right side of his body.
Q And you — and I take it, you missed the bird.
I certainly do get tired of these idiots talking down to us like we’re the fucken idiots…so Cheney-who thinks we should take his word on everything as gospel and is supposed to be the GREAT WHITE HUNTER now decides someone elses expertise(so called) qualifies them to make announcements for the Vice Presidents office basically, oh yeah sure I buy that as much as the ‘fact’ that there are WMD in Iraq. And also saying because it was her property is why she should be the one to alert the news..huh?.. So anytime he’s somewhere and he’s not on his own property and it’s news worthy it’s up to whose ever property it is to call the news media?..
I’ll go with your version Boo…and add the possibility of a little drinking maybe going on at that little picnic before the big drive-by hunt. Lobbyists and Quails and Beer, oh my!
Cheney admitted to having a beer, in the link that I posted upthread. I’ve been hunting before w/a buddy of mine…One beer? Right!!!
PS Guess who drove home?
Remember, Cheney is the one who chaired the Iran-Contra hearings and concluded it was primarily a faultless system wide failure. Articles I read today contra-dicted each other on first accounts but one concept rang true from 30some years ago…his head still tilts harder to the right when he lies.
This whole affair doesn’t pass the smell test, especially to hunters.
So far the only thing that Cheney’s said that’s true is
What a guy.
It’s the coverup, stupid. Five days later the shootee is still in ICU and the shooter is spinning like a top.
Peace
Another thing that is bothering me: Cheney told Hume that part of the reason that he didn’t see his friend was because his friend was standing in a small depression.
Even when I thought they were on even ground I wondered why Cheney was shooting at a flushed bird that was so low. The fact that he claims to have shot this man from 30 yards and that the man was below him just makes it hard for me to compute the trajectory.
Was he firing down at a bird?
Hardball was surprisingly good this evening with Matthews ranting about how Cheney is still cherry picking and managing the release of news and how the initial reports all made it sound like Mr. Whittington merely got sprayed in the face when clearly he was shot in the heart. He had on Dr. Bernadine Healy who said that it’s obvious to her that his injuries were never thought to be minor…that he had a bullet in the heart muscle and she’s heard in his lungs and liver as well.
Yeah, just when I thought CM had turned a corner, he goes on to swallow the claim that Cheney has the self determined right to selectively declassify extremely damaging classified information to release as a tool for political gain. (Plame leak)
Paraphrasing, ‘huh, I didn’t know he could do that. Well, we learn something new every day.’
If this is now the defense, why did they waste so many years, money and lives to admit it?
Also, is it over when CM mentions this confession as a ‘tidbit of news’?