A recent Open Letter to me from In The Woods caused me to delve a bit deeper, so I could respond fully to the suggestion that I have misdirected my feelings.
I also needed to re-read my original diary to see what I had said there that seems to gave left some with the impression that I intend to sit by hopelessly while walls fall down around me. I learned more about myself in this process. I learned that the democracy that I see dying, that I have been grieving for a long time, and I finally need to let go of, was really just a dream that lived in my mind all these years.
It’s the dream democracy I was taught exists: the one they told me meant that we all were of equal worth, and that there would be equal opportunity for all. The dream democracy that promised liberty and justice for all, and the one in which anyone could reach the “American Dream,” if only we worked hard enough.
I’ve believed in this democracy with every atom of my being since I was five year old, standing at attention and saluting the soldiers coming home from WWII.
I have now lived for 65 years in this democracy, as a woman who was widowed young, raised children alone, and who has completed over a half century in the work force. My life experiences themselves have proven to me, without a single doubt, that this democracy was indeed much more of a dream, than it was ever my reality.
(Just as it was always a dream for the thousands of those I’ve cared for as a nurse who has worked mostly with the poor chronically ill, the disabled, and elderly of all races.)
Equal rights were not automatically granted me by this democracy. I had to fight like hell for every one of them I’ve ever gained. Justice? Equal l opportunities? Almost always, these cost far more than I could afford on my salary.
I should have buried this dream years ago, but even in the hardest times, I hung on hard, and kept fighting. Someday, we would change all of this, and democracy would come to mean what they told me it meant, for ALL of us, not just those higher up on some “hierarchy of worthiness.”
Any maybe it will be someday. Maybe it’s your generation now, ITW, who are still fighting hard within the political system as it is, who will bring it about. Maybe it will take those who have experienced a different kind of democracy that I have, to do it this way.
But I don’t want to fight anymore to preserve a FORM of democracy that is not working for all of us, and has never worked for all of us. A form of democracy whose benefits are only fully available to those who can afford them, and who otherwise meet certain qualifications such as skin color or gender or some other material based standard of worth.
No. I am done with that. For whatever time I have left here, I am turning my efforts away from a form of democracy I was never allowed to fully experience and for sure won’t now, as an old, poor, disabled lesbian.
Whatever energy I have left, I intend to use as best I can for the time I have left. For me, this means speaking up and speaking out as effectively as I can, wherever I can, from whatever I’ve learned from my own life experiences and learning. It means reaching out to young people wherever I can find them, to empower them to believe in thier ability to change things. It is all I have to offer, and I offer it freely, with no need to convince anyone to think or act as I do, an no intent to tell anyone else that their view or feeling or choices are wrong.
If I’ve learned nothing else along my way, I certainly have learned that my own view is limited to what I can see through the lens of my own my own mind’s eyes, my own values and beliefs, and my own life experiences. I know do not possess anyone else’s truth, only my own.
But as you share your you perceptions and truths here , it expands my view, and shows me aspects of things i did not see that you did. In that way, I see much more than I can see with only my own lonely lens. This, as Martha says, in a good thing, I think.
Honestly, I have never read anyone here say all they were willing to do now is sit down and cry in their lap over a dying democracy. I sure didn’t. I’ve never sat crying my lap in 65 years and I see no reason to begin now.
I see those of us who may have lost hope in this FORM of democracy, and in this political SYSTEM, say we want to stop spending out energy that way, and instead find other ways to contribute to changing things.
Who knows which way might end up working? And why can’t they both be right?
What I do know is this: we need each other along the way, even when our ways may diverge. I know I will always need other good courageous people beside me to lean on when I need to lean, to draw courage from, to share the good and the bad with. People who know my name and want the same tings I do for the country.
I sincerely hope we do not let our different views or our fears or anything else separate us. We truly are not each other’s enemy.
The enemy is over there.
Look. See it?
That butt ugly monster with all the greedy, hate filled tentacles?
Sure doesn’t resemble anyone who hangs out at this pond.
My apologues for no decent formatting. I don’t know WHAT the heck happened to the paragraph breaks, they just keep disappearing to places I cannot find when I hit submit. I ever retyped this whole thing once, to no avail.
Hi scribe, to get paragraphs to come up after using preview you have to use this code >br< reverse the arrows to use and if you want to line spaces between paras, you just do two entries of the code on different line, hope that is clear….
I agree with the sentiments you expressed in both diaries, especially from the point of view (mine) of an elder american who has lived through a lot in this country in my almost 63 years.
.
to your diary serie —
Lettin Go-Moving On: Part XX
It’s very difficult to analyze and comprehend, so … please keep writing!
“But I will not let myself be reduced to silence.”
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
You have it exactly, Scribe. And maybe it is those of us who are of an age that just can no longer work within the so far unworkable framework that we believed would triumph in the end.
In some ways, holding on to that elusive dream of equality for all, opportunity for all, freedom and justice for all after 60+ years of believing it for all we are worth, it seems akin to the definition of insanity: Continuing to do the same things in the same way expecting different results.
Many of us can no longer “hold our noses” and vote for the lesser of two evils. Those that feel that is the best way, should by all means continue to do so.
Certainly it is not a shut up with head in lap. More than ever it is speak out, challenge, question and inform, especially the 18-25 yr olds and younger. It is to encourage them to understand how the system was supposed to work and find the inspiration and encouragement to make it work. It is to instill a desire to have interest in how the government is supposed to work and what they can do to make sure that it does.
I think the reflections that I have been through, much as your own, have brought me to a place of absolute non-partisanship. I cannot see a political party that embraces what I expect from our Republic. And that makes me think I might be able to teach some classes somewhere that people can become informed about what is happening in their country. What is being perpetrated in their names. Information, the light that quells the darkness.
I will forever care, and I will forever be a progressive, far left, socialist. . .but I can no longer say I am a Democrat as they do not represent these ideals at all, even their lip service falls short of it. I will pick and choose and encourage those candidates that do understand things in the way that I do and are willing to stand in their integrity.
I encourage and applaud every one that is engaged in an active solution, no matter how different from mine it may be.
Go forward and do it the way it makes most sense to you, and I will do that as well.
Brava Scribe!
Sequels often disappoint. This one surely did not. Thanks.
With deepest respect, I understand better now where your heart is and where you intend to take your energy and I applaud you both for your work in the past and your direction for the future.
More and more I believe that what distinguishes what I would support from what I would oppose is the belief in your dream of democracy.
I choose to pursue that dream (however poorly realized today) through a political party in which I see the most potential – not from its “leaders” but from its base. It is for and with those many that I hope we can move towards a new stage of democracy to answer the latest surge of the anti-democratic forces.
We may work on two sides of a different wall, both in the same direction, both with the same goal.
I hope someday the wall is broken and that the Democratic Party once again can be home for more of those working for your dream. In the meantime, I hope you hold close your dream of democracy, it is the only hope for our country and needs you to keep it alive, if only in your heart.
Thank you, and please accept my respect for your determination to do what you can in your own way.
I have a deep faith that in time,somehow, somewhere, people will figure out that when all is said and done, we are indeed more alike, inside, than we are different. A time when we can honestly work from a shared desire for what will best serve the common good now, and for thowe to come.
I suspect this kind of change will come not from the top down, but the bottom up, beginning in individual hearts and minds brave enough to reconsider what the most important aspects of life are, other than the need to acquire goods, status and power. These things are not, and never will be, the only measure of a will lived, sucessful life.
Again, thank you for this wonderful dialogue. Yes, we are indeed going in the same direction via different routes.
This line is especially poignant to me, though seeing it from someone who is 65 is kind of like seeing a twelve year old girl in black lace, but anyway.
Someone told me today, and quite correctly, that voices like mine are not always pleasant to hear.
It was one of the best compliments I have received.
I will not, I honestly do not believe that I can praise the clothing of naked emperors, go along to get along, try to dress the truth in pretty words so as not to “offend,” call torture “misconduct” to avoid making the torturers or those complicit with “look bad,” or “feel guilty,” politely pretend that bigotry is unintended, nonexistent, or both, ascribe motives other than rank, sewage-raw greed to those who rip the bellies of golden-egg-laying geese, dignify brutal warlord cartels with the title of “nation” because not to do so is “inflammatory,” as if the firebombs that rain on children, mothers fathers and grandfathers alike were not inflammatory, disavow the principles established at Nuremberg, or forget the effects of the propaganda principles established in the Reichshauptstadt, agree to call colonialism “progressive intervention” for the sake of somebody’s pet politician, or fail to use the only thing I have to make, if it is possible to do so, maybe, one person think.
At this point in my life, I no longer have anything to prove, or anything to lose.
I do not aspire to fame, fortune, acclaim or accolades.
Someone who is 65 today, even given the recent decline in US conditions in this regard, can reasonably expect at least two or three more decades of life. I have been told for at least a couple of decades that naturally, at my age, I should not expect to live much longer. I was truly sad when those doctors died.
But for whatever time I have left here, I will do my best to do my duty to be a voice that is not pleasant to hear.
And scribe, if the day comes when you are no longer able to make it quite all the way to pleasant, stand tall. Your heart is pure, and you know what the Christians say about people with pure hearts. š