In the midst of some of the brouhaha here lately, I told a story of an childhood incident that left a decided impression on me. I don’t tell that story to make anyone feel guilty, or to garner pity or anything… but for the lesson it taught me, that I’ve since tried to live up to. Ductape mentioned that I should make a diary of out it, but I didn’t really want to do that, and wasn’t sure how to anyway… but then I remembered… I already had, last year. I’m going to repost this here, even tho it’s a bit dated, just because it tells a bit of where I’m coming from. I hope others will also tell some of their experiences and lives and maybe we can reach some of this “convergence” that scribe described so beautifully. Anyway, here goes:
I think of the era in which I grew up to be the best of times. Others…? Eh, they think of it as the opening of the floodgates of Hell.
Yes… I grew up in the 60’s and 70’s, in California.
Born in 1958, I am at the tail end of the Boomer Generation, so I was surrounded, from birth, by discussions of equality, challenging authority, challenging tradition, changing the world. Although I didn’t at the time realize the magnitude of the tragedies that were the deaths of John and Bobby Kennedy, and Martin Luther King, I shared in the sorrow because those around me were sorrowful. But not defeated. No cause depends on just one person, but is built up from the many individuals who decide that now is the time; enough is enough.
[more after the fold]
My older brother was the hippie of the family and would bring all sorts of interesting people home. I spent hours listening to their discussions about war and peace, about justice and equality, overthrowing the establishment, building a new society and peace and love, man. I was too young to join them in their endeavors (and quite often, it seemed to me, some of them were too… chemically enhanced, let’s say, to do much of anything anyway), but I loved sitting in the corner and absorbing their thoughts and dreams. Did I ever thank those young men and women, not that much older than I was, for their idealism, their belief in the ability to create a better world, their willingness to protest and to fight for what they believed in? I know some of you are still around, still fighting the fight, leading the way, still dreaming and believing that change is possible. Thank you.
The older I get the more I realize how unique my upbringing was in one respect, for that period of time. In our home we were raised to believe that “our kind” was humankind. Not just through meeting people of different cultures at school, or at events, or in books, but by having them a part of our lives. The known and loved faces of my childhood were Black, White, Mexican, Japanese, Italian, Irish, African, Indonesian, Gay, Straight and in between. Gatherings and parties at our house were like the UN, before the UN was cool.
My mom… divorced single mother, business owner, with three children, didn’t join peace marches or organizations of any sort, that I can remember. What she did is live every day as an example, whether she knew it or not. I learned much just observing her kindness and courtesy to all individuals, regardless of their “station in life”; the respect she commanded just by respecting others, and recognizing the dignity and humanity in everyone, regardless of who they were. It was up to them to live up to that respect. Or not. She still treated them the same.
It’s my belief that you can talk about tolerance to your children all you want, but it’s who you invite into your home and life that seals the lesson.
For me, life was good. But as we know childhoods eventually end. Bigotry, hatred, racism are no respecter of age or reason.
It’s pretty devastating when you are 10, and at a school friend’s apartment for a birthday/pool party, to have the apartment manager come racing out, screeching that you… and only you… must get out of the pool RIGHT NOW, we can’t have a Negro child in there or we will have to drain the entire thing!
This was my first remembered encounter with the dreaded (but to be pitied) Ignorant Person my mother warned me about. And, I noticed, they were just as ugly as she said they would be. (A lot of things were tolerated in her household, but being an Ignorant Person wasn’t one of them).
I still remember everyone gathering around me, back in the apartment, as I sat shivering on the couch, not from cold. They apologized for the manager, but explained that of course I would understand if everyone carried on swimming without me, here there are books and a TV and we’ll be back soon. I nodded an agreement that I didn’t exactly feel, and watched them all walk away, out the door and back to the party.
I think it was at that moment that I decided that if ever it came down to a choice of standing with someone against an injustice, or walking away, I would choose to stand, to the best of my ability. Sometimes I’ve failed, over the years, made the wrong decisions, took the easy way out. More times, though, I have been fortunate enough to have the courage make that stand, even when it would have been easier or more comfortable to walk away.
This, to me, is part of the essence of liberalism.
I love being a liberal. Sometimes I even love being a Democrat. We’re not in the least bit perfect, thank the gods.
We debate things to death, go to bed thinking we’ve done a good job, wake up with a new outlook on the matter and debate it all over again. We have that blessedly cursed ability to see many sides of an issue; forget just shades of gray… someone usually throws some fuchsia and lime green in just to make sure we have everything covered.
We tried so very hard in 2004 to walk lock-step, which is basically antithetical to our nature. But boy, did we try. The wildly beautiful discordance of our multitude of voices attempting to sing the same song (often to distinctly different music), will not soon be forgotten. Nor should it. We accomplished much, if not what we most wanted.
We are still more than they ever will be.
There is great beauty in our variety. To me, conservatives are dull monochromatic creatures (vultures, maybe?), while liberals, progressives, Democrats… we range from fierce hawks, to brilliantly hued and flamboyant tropical creatures, to the softest, most helpless tiny warblers.
I wouldn’t have it any other way. We stand up for all, are made up of all.
Right after the election, in the midst of anger and grief and recriminations, when we are still being beaten about the head daily with words flung by pundits and prognosticators and charlatans masquerading as the godly — “It was gay marriage. It was Hollywood, it was atheists, it was a documentary, it was him, it was her, it was you, it was whatever I want you to believe it was no matter what…blame them, they lost the election for you. ” – we’ve done what we do best. We’ve talked, we’ve debated, argued, planned, searched our policies, our souls and Google; should we retool, refit, reform, get religion, make a new presentation, wrap a package up differently, embrace the middle, move left, move right, yell, whisper, march, organize, or simply pull the covers over our heads and wait it out.
What we didn’t do… except for a very few… is say, “Let’s walk away, we can still have our party without them.”
I love our principles. I love standing with people who realize that “equal rights for me, but not for you” is an unacceptable contradiction. Who believe that justice should be more than just a word carved on a courthouse wall. Who believe helping those with the least among is us not only a good thing, but also the right thing to do. That, regardless of your political persuasion, you should have a vote, and that your vote should count. That our actions should a true reflection of our ideals, not just phony posturing. That torture is not a moral value.
I love most of all that while we necessarily squabble and debate, pull in opposite directions in an effort to reach the same destination, argue passionately and forgive wholeheartedly, and probably always will, that the debate is over how best to achieve our goals and stand up for ourselves and others. Not whether to stand up at all.
I’m sorry that you were singled out and made to feel inferior – no one should have to feel that way, especially a child.
Someone told me we are not a community here; that this is just a business. I disagree.
The vast majority of us are still willing to listen and learn. Respect is a two-way street.
Oh, I think we are a community here… that people care enough to talk things out, even if they disagree, and find some way (hopefully) of coming together again… well, that’s part of what makes a community, no? Of course, it’s also a business (remember to click the ads!) which will probably have its own issues, but not just yet.
Nanette, I want to write something that would do your beyond brilliant diary justice. Something intelligent. Something savvy and smart…
But all I really want to post to you is.. I don’t know you, but if you were in my space right now…
I’d just want to hug you and tell you I love you.
Janet
Nanette, thank you for being you and sharing your essence with us.
People forget how recently those times were. Thank you for the story, and thank you for using that pain to grow and learn.
story in the other thread, one of the things I have not been able to get out of my head, you told then of the little white children, who took turns coming in, all wet in their swimsuits, dripping the water in which you could not splash, to keep you company.
Where are they now, those little white children?
Do they ever remember that day? Are there some who maybe have never been able to forget it?
How did it change their lives?
Or did it change them at all?
How many of them just accepted it as one of those things, that’s the way things are?
And what of their children?
After 911, when so many children, Arab, South Asian, Iranian, even Indonesians and Latin Americans, were told that this or that event, party, overnight band trip, had been “cancelled” or “postponed,” as those children sat, watching from their windows as their erstwhile playmates passed by, on their way to the cancelled and postponed events, were there any little white children who stopped in front of the house, bounded up the stairs, floppy pajama dog in hand, and remembering to remove their shoes at the door, announced that they had come for a sleepover?
And if there was such a child, did his mother sigh as she packed Pajama Dog, remembering a hot day long ago, a dripping swimsuit, watching TV with a sad little girl trying to be brave?
And after 9/11 some parent’s children made it a point to befriend the Arab children; to sit with them in the cafeteria, to sit next to them on the bus. I know three of them.
And after 9/11 some children’s parents overcame shyness to talk softly to the woman with the headcovering in the grocery store; to smile at her when she made tentative eye-contact. Some children’s parents still do that to this day. And it hurts when others jump to conclusions about where her heart is.
It hurts and saddens me too, if others see me as a racist just because I’m white, because of how others who are white may have treated them. I’ts sad that the quiet efforts like those of that parent above, go unnoticed, so thank you for helping honor all who do what they can in thier own smaller circles.
Local people here also reached out. Making the effort to befriend Muslim families, and assure neighbors that they were safe, walking with headcovered Muslim women in an attempt to prevent insults and hate being thrown at them, putting together groups to guard mosques (although fairly early on it was realized that who most needed guarding were the Sikhs, cuz of the turbans, so some guarded them too) and more.
Some of it was pretty funny, though… I still laugh when I think of the mayor, chief of police, and I think the sheriff… all huge, lumbering white guys, going to a mosque to show solidarity. They were all valiantly trying to seem like this was something they did every day, but there they were sitting on the floor in their business suits, wearing little scarves on their heads (sort of like what Condi wore to see the Pope).
I have no idea what that was about, because the Muslim men I know wear sort of knit caps. Maybe that is the visitors attire, but it was still funny.
Speaking of the Sikhs and Turbans,
I had an experience in a Chicago airport just after 911 that was my first disturbing look at the dangers that Muslims and others that resemble them in American’s eyes like the Sikhs faced. There was a couple, man and woman waiting at the gate with the rest of us. I took them to be Sikhs and they were in traditional dress, with the man wearing a turban. The looks on the faces of the people around me were actually frightening. This poor couple. I can’t imagine what that must have been like. I felt guilty because of being a white American at that moment.
The only thing I could do that might help them feel a little less visually attacked and help ease my guilt was to make sure I caught their eyes long enough to give an understanding nod and a smile. They didn’t smile back but I could see that they understood my gesture.
What an awful, awful feeling.
See, there you go again Ductape, shattering that illusion of yourself as the grizzled old terrorist that you worked so tirelessly to build.
Absolutely beautiful!!
dressing-down I gave to some of those lady ice dancers for the abominations that resulted when they did not call me before dressing up, you would tremble in your snow boots!
I can assure you, I minced no words. Especially where feathers and failed attempts to honor Bjork were concerned. The TV is still vibrating.
I’ve wondered too, where are they now, and how they turned out. We didn’t keep in touch much after our year at the school… but they were all good kids. I’d like to imagine some of them turned out to be parents just as you describe :).
Wow Nanette, thanks so much for posting that again. I’m reading it at work and had to go take a break because it literally brought tears to my eyes.
I can’t help but think that my childhood was like being raised in the home of the apartment manager. I remember my (otherwise) sweet old grandmother making incredibly racist comments. And I also think about going to 10th grade in a public high school in East Texas the year before it was forced to integrate (didn’t happen until 1971 – but that’s a whole other story). All my adult life I lived under the illusion that there weren’t many black kids at that school. Then years ago I got out the yearbook. There were so many black faces!! And it shames me to my core that I just NEVER SAW THEM.
While my experience was the mirror opposite of yours, it wounded me. And you remind me that I will do all I can to heal from that wound – so that I SEE what is happening around me and never look away again.
I was born in 1950 and grew up Jewish in a predominantly Catholic neighborhood. During the 16 years I lived there, I was sometimes spit on, called names, kept out of
some homes, and when I was 8 run over by kid on a bike who called me “a dirty kike Christ killer.”
But my story is different from yours because along with those haters, there were other people in the neighborhood who welcomed us into their homes, there were parents who treated me like one of own, there were kids who were my best friends, and there were older kids who looked out for us like Pete who told the boy on the bike that he had better never show his face on our block again.
I didn’t realize as a young child what a gift my neighbors and friends had given me but by my early teens as the civil rights movement began to gain force, I had come to recognize the importance of standing against injustice. So from that almost opposite point, I arrived at the same conclusion that you did: “[I]f ever it came down to a choice of standing with someone against an injustice, or walking away, I would choose to stand, to the best of my ability.”
I was remarkably unknowledgeable when I was young. Two of my best friends in Jr. High were Jewish…but I had no clue at all what being Jewish was – am not sure they did either, as we all loved that song “The Israealites”, but from what I remember, we all thought it was like the Northern Lights… only someplace in somewhere called Israel. Then I started reading books by Chiam Potok and others, and got a bit more educated.
It’s funny, the different directions we all come from to get to the same place…
You are my inspiration, but then I think you already know that. ๐ You have the one quality I admire most in the world, which is the ability to stand your ground with confident firmness while maintaining clarity of thought and speech that never flags in kindness. I never sense a single shred of self pity in you, but I hear a lot of empathy for others, even when you’re l00% disagreeing with them. You stayed here and kept talking, while I had to vanish in order to keep my head on straight. I believe yours is by far the better way. So I’m going to follow along behind you and practice doing what you do from now on. ๐ So watch out–that’s not the FBI that’s watching you, it’s me. (I know you never EVER intended this to turn into a Praise Nanette session, and I apologize for maybe embarrassing you.)
to make me cry (and be embarrassed!). BUT… I’m not gonna do it ;).
Thank you for your kind words.
Gosh, I wish I could have read this months ago Nanette. But then it really doesn’t matter because I’ve sensed all along the same things in you that I sense in 99.999 percent of the other fine and beautiful people here…inherant goodness and compassion.
falls upon the pond sending glittery ripples of love throughout the hearts of those that dwell here. I so appreciate this diary. I too will stand with you Nanette. You truly make me want to be a better human being. We are blessed by your sharings here.
You have tapped us on the shoulder, made us turn away from the turmoil just for a moment, and have given us a wonderful gift… convergence, and hopefully, healing. What beautiful thoughts. Thank you, Nanette.
Quite simply, thank you for sharing this with us. I feel honored to have read this.
I am so grateful you are here.
Such a painful experience, that somehow, you managed to emerge from with a even bigger heart than you had.
Nanette, I’m speechless. But, The force of your story has compelled me to say something.
(1/2 hour later)
It turns out my speechlessness is a serious barrier, but I’m very glad you’ve reprised your diary.
Everything I love about being a part of the motley liberal crew too. It is never boring when you go some place with us!
Being singled out for whatever reason, is that moment in time that either wakes one up or causes one to hide the rest of their lives.
We all get them, some are more labeling than others.
Mine was at 12 when I went to sign up for Little League baseball and the coach laughed at me saying “Girls don’t play baseball with boys.” I was devastated. I played hard ball better than my brothers and neighborhood boys. I was mortified, humiliated, cried and just about quit playing and loving baseball and began on my road for equality.
So eventually, it turned out to be a very good wake up call for me and my humanity. There have been many others.
One of the little life lessons I try hard to practice in my everyday life is to try and celebrate the similarities instead of pointing out the differences. We all have a lot more in common than one might be led to believe.
I’ve come back to this diary time and again in the last 2 days to leave a comment and then sit and stare at the white empty space because I can’t think of any words to do justice to how I felt reading your diary and thinking also of a little girl who certainly turned into a woman of enormous compassion whose comments always seem have a quiet dignity to them.
The mosaic of your life shines through and rewards us here with your diaries and comments..Thank you.
I’m glad you said this.
I, too have read Nanette’s diary several times and wanted to say something. I was her age in the fifties and don’t remember ever interacting with people of colour. My father occasionally said the “N” word and my mother lambasted him for it. My very kind and good grandmother was afraid of “the coloureds”. It wasn’t until I was a teenager that I saw the horrors of racism and American apartheid, and was galvanized to work for social justice.
This story is so sad and shameful. Although I was not there, it is a part of my childhood, and I know I would not have been equipped to act any differently than the white children who shrugged and went on swimming. But I know my daughter would have raised hell if such a thing had happened in HER childhood, and that is some progress.