This is a personal tale. Tony Snow’s tears triggered the telling. The days of delay does not affect the deliverance of the message.
This story is about Tony Snow, a homeless man, humanity, and me. I will begin with Press Secretary Snow. My focus will not be on the unforgivable term, though I too struggle with its usage. Instead, I will discuss what for me, was a more meaningful lesson.
In this day and age of snarky, once known as snide, rude, and crude, it was a delight to witness genuine emotion.
Tony Snow exhibited feelings, heart-felt, and deep, at his first news conference. The novice Press Secretary was asked what might have been considered a casual and innocuous question; journalists inquired of his Live Strong bright yellow bracelet. These bangles are as ubiquitous as clothing itself. They can be seen anywhere, everywhere; rarely are they worn with significance. Still, when queried of this wristlet, Tony Snow paused. He was sincerely and visibly choked up. For a time he could not speak.
Moments later, with a quiver in his voice, and tears in his eyes, Snow replied. The Press Secretary was sobbing softly as he spoke. He told this audience of journalists that he was a survivor of colon cancer, an illness that had taken the life of his mother when he was very young, seventeen years of age. Snow stated, that years ago, such a malady was considered fatal; however, with the use of modern technology, he was able to fight the disease and live on. He was thriving and staying strong. While acknowledging all the turmoil over health care in America, Tony Snow said, with thanks to the quality attention he received, he was here and enjoying life.
This event was newsworthy. Tony Snow, a White House Press Secretary cried. His tears were not exaggerated or put on. They were not meant to evoke empathy or sympathy. These were not the playful antics of a plotting personality. The tears were not those of a clown or a court jester; they were unexpected, unadulterated, untainted by position or pretense. The cries sprung from a man who had suffered, and was given reason to reflect; they were from one that learned.
At a younger age, Mr. Snow might have forced himself to suppress the sniffles. He might have feared what people think, would say, or do if they witnessed a grown man cry. Snow in his twenties might have been concerned that a man in his position, appearing on television, and working within the White House cannot show sorrow or sentiment so publicly. However, I suspect with age comes wisdom. Experiences teach us empathy and we evolve. Still, sadly, few of us ever expose our emotions or ourselves. His story takes me to my own.
While my pain may not have been as life threatening, it did cause me to ponder. The care I received was not in a hospital; nor was it from medical personnel. My mentor had been through much and had much to teach me.
Today’s older and wiser never expected to be. They are from a generation that rallied round stating, “You cannot trust anyone over thirty years of age.” They meant it; they believed it. Few ever thought they would live beyond that age.
The youth of the sixties was certain that they were more informed and aware than their elders, and possibly, they were. Probably they were. These rebels were willing to question everything and every authority. I do not challenge that idea. Humph, I live it, bathe in it, and believe it to be vital. Nevertheless, in some subtle ways I think this cynicism has worked against us. It has created a counter culture that no longer feels anything but anger.
Anger has replaced action; in a sense, anger has evolved into apathy. [I offer this aside for those not familiar with the way in which I define action versus reaction. For me, actions are loving, caring, creative, and productive. Reactions are the result of fear, hurt, and pain. They are often counter measures and thus, counter-productive.]
No, it is not that all persons are unconcerned; they are not. Many are “activist,” in a reactionary sort of way. Nevertheless, too many are indifferent to the way in which their thoughts words, or deeds affect others and the ultimately result in an unwanted outcome.
People walk around spouting the words “I don’t care.” They do not care about other than their interests, their friends, family, and themselves. I myself work so hard to avoid using this pervasive phrase because “I do care.” I have come to realize that if we do not care for or about others then we care not for or about ourselves, because, in truth, we are all connected. “No man is an island.”
“If you love yourself, you love everybody else as you do yourself. As long as you love another person less than you love yourself, you will not really succeed in loving yourself, But if you love all alike, including yourself, you will love them as one person and that person is both God and man. Thus he is a great and righteous person who loving himself, loves all others equally!” – Meister Eckhart from The Art of Loving, by Erich Fromm, page 56
In the world today we work hard to forfeit and fight against connections. Walk down the street and watch, as the faces of others turn away from your own. Smile at your neighbor and notice how often they do not beam back. They as you are in a hurry, preoccupied with their own thoughts, their own worries, and their own fears. They have no time to engage you or yours.
Weeks ago while wallowing in my thoughts, I was engaged; I was drawn to a sign. I was driving from Lowe’s Home Improvement Center going to PetsMart, and traveling down highway 441. I was pondering my recent decisions and determining what was to become of me. I had recently made extreme changes in my life. I had entered the world of the unknown. Fear had become my unwelcome friend.
For years, I had lived happily in my habits. I went to work. I swam; I wrote and I cooked great quantities of healthy food. I played with my babies. I chatted with friends. I lived in a home I made my own. On occasion, I would walk around the lake. Life was good, very good. Nevertheless, I sought more.
For decades, I lived in California. I had never wanted to live in that state; still, my family moved there and since I love my family, I followed. I never regretted that decision; however, I did not feel connected to this territory. For all the years that I lived there I was never willing to say, “I am from California.”
For me, weather is not a superficial subject; it influences the way I feel. The climate in “Sunny Southern California” is not that. A maritime malaise fills the sky until late afternoon. The June gloom begins in May, and it affects me. I wanted out.
Since childhood, I reveled in Florida weather. The topics were my treasure. Therefore, I decided to move South and East, to go where my heart was. However, much was not as I expected.
I planned for my employment. I intended to do as I had done for decades in California. I did not fear financial ruin; I trusted all would be well. After taking time to complete my house, I returned to work. “Returned” is not the right word for this is a different state, city, and circumstance. What was once my bread and butter, my staple, my stability, now left me nauseous. The nuances are too numerous to explain.
Upon entering the work force, I was repelled. I knew I could not do this. Worry began to fill my mind, my heart, my soul, and even my dreams while asleep. On this day, as I drove to the store, I was in a stupor. I stopped at a red light. I was in the left-hand turn lane. A homeless man was standing on the medium. He held a sign expectedly asking for money. I had none. I rarely carry any and even if I had, I always leave my purse in the trunk. I knew I could not give him change; I did not have enough for myself. In truth, I worried I would soon be him.
I did not wish to meet his eyes, to see his soul. I could not face my own and his presence reminded me of whom I might become. I did, however, read his sign. It said, “Imagine me being you, and looking away.” Oh my, that was exactly what I was imagining, my life could easily be as his. I believe there was more on the sign; however, in this moment, I recall my feeling overwhelmed more than all the words that took me there.
In an instant, I remembered that a week earlier my father had taken the toll-way. He had left the change in my car and told me to keep it. I might need it at some time. Perhaps if I ever drive the turnpike, the change will do me good. When he said this, I thought, `not likely.’ I will never waste money on such a highway. I had tucked the quarters away in the side pocket of my car door.
When I saw the man, I knew the money was meant for him. My father was always giving to the homeless. He would not object to my doing so also. I pulled the quarters out and called to the destitute and scruffy man. I extended my handful of change apologizing as I did so.
I explained this was all that I had and though I knew it was not much, I hoped it would help. [Tears are flowing again as I retell this tale.] He sweetly smiled and explained, “There is no need for you to apologize.” He said, “Say God Bless.” I was reluctant. I believe “Thou art God.” Yet, I was not feeling the least bit divine. I reject religious overtures; too often, they seem insincere. However, coming from this man, in this moment, I decided to oblige. I thought `I am okay with this.’ Thus, I said, “God Bless.”
The gentle man then replied, “If you say God bless and I say God bless than all will be well.” Perhaps it will. Whether God is within, above, or throughout, even if God does not exist other than in the recesses of our minds, I believe what is God, or the personification of such, is “goodness.” If we say and act upon all that is good, if we remember and consider that we are all connected to our neighbors and treat them with reverence, all will be well.
This week, Tony Snow was reminded of his humanity, weeks ago I recalled mine. Imagine what the world would be if we each chose to be human and humane daily, if we chose to connect to each other and ourselves.
References For Your Review . . .
- Fox anchor named Bush press secretary CNN News. Wednesday, April 26, 2006
- Understanding poverty and homelessness in America By Gerry Roll. Yahoo News. Monday May 22, 2006
- Tony Snow gets personal in first on-camera session CNN News. Tuesday, May 16, 2006
- Couric failed to question Snow about “tar baby” remark Media Matters. Wednesday, May 17, 2006
- The tears of Snow, By Michael Scherer. Salon.com May 17, 2006
- Tony Snow Has 1st On-Camera Press Session, By Jennifer Loven, The Washington Post. Tuesday, May 16, 2006
- Snow Pick May Signal Less Insular White House, By Jim VandeHei and Michael A. Fletcher. Washington Post. Thursday, April 27, 2006; Page A01
- Tony Snow Cries During First Formal Briefing Massachusetts News
- Snow Meets the Press By John Eggerton. Broadcasting & Cable, Tuesday, May 16, 2006
- FNC’s Tony Snow Has Colon Cancer By Don Kaplan. Fox News. Tuesday, February 15, 2005
- Tony Returns to the Microphone! By Tony Snow. Fox News. April 21, 2005
- FOX News’ Tony Snow Among Possible White House Spokesman Candidates. Fox News. Wednesday, April 19, 2006
- Press Briefing by Tony Snow James S. Brady Briefing Room. May 16, 2006
- “Don’t trust anyone over thirty.”
- Erich Fromm, Biography By Dr. C. George Boeree
- Meister Eckhart
- Homeless in America By Raven Tyler. NewsHour. December 11.2002
- Homeless in America Witness for Justice. May 13, 2002
Betsy L. Angert Be-Think
I have looked away from this Tony Snow moment. My first instinct was that it was a mere ploy to gain sympathy.
How much of a disservice do we do to ourselves and the world when we hate our enemies too much to allow their humanity?
Bless you Betsy, and all my enemies, too.
Dear blueneck . . .
Ahhh, I agree. I am grateful that you read this piece rather than turn away at what some saw as Snow sensationalism and sentimentality [sic].
It is only the giving that makes us what [who] we are. – Ian Anderson. Jethro Tull . . . Betsy
It is I who am grateful. You have put an important reminder in my face today. As repugnant as I find what Tony Snow DOES is, I would not wish his loss of his mother to cancer or belittle his own trials with personal medical pain and discomfort.
As for what he does NOW, he has been effectively neutered from his former more powerful Faux News Role. Everyone now knows that the Press Secretary to this administration, whoever it might be, is the voice of nothingness and deceit, due to such wonderful work by Ari and Scotty…..
Dear blueneck . . .
I agree. He is not the man for me and his decision speaks volumes. Nevertheless, he is human and learning.
I assess Republicans or the majority as this. On an evolutionary and development scale, they are as children. They are clannish. This does not negate their feelings; nor does it diminish their ability to learn and grow. However, for whatever reasons, they are delayed.
It is always refreshing to experience the Repugnant in a humane moment.
I never want to be so insensitive that I cannot feel their pain. To lose a mother at seventeen and then to be diagnosed with the same illness that took a parent away, that is sad.
I trust that his tears were very genuine. I believe that he too will learn. He has certainly placed himself in a position that will confront his basic beliefs. Remember, he too quarrels with Bush! . . However, not in the same manner I might . . .
I love that you created the subject lne as you did.
It is only the giving that makes us what [who] we are. – Ian Anderson. Jethro Tull . . . Betsy
When looking into so deep an abyss as the one that confronts us now, it is all too easy to fall into it. The abyss looks back, you know, and it is a touchy and tough thing to study the abyss, yet not be consumed.
I fancy myself fairly skilled at it, but it always helps to have a companion on the outside looking in with me who will grab my beltloop and give me a tug.
I view the underdeveloped with some love and some consternation. I wonder what it will take for them to wake up and see the next steps on the stairs away from the darkness, and lament that they are so weak as to need to rest on the way up. If I were given to prayer, I would pray for strength for them to continue the climb. As I am, I reach out my hand whenever I can and whenever there is the slightest prospect that it will be received and used as a means of strength for those who would continue to climb.
This all sounds arrogant, I know, and I frequently have to remind myself of the trials and tribulations of others and how those who are less fortunate than I may have many more stairs, steeper than mine, to get to where I believe that I stand. Change for the homeless? Yes, it’s the least we can do. I have walked the edge of disaster a few times in my younger years, but I am relatively safe and comfortable now. I’m not too far removed, and I hope to never be so far removed, that I do not understand the plight of the homeless. They are why we all must do better to do our utmost to improve our world, its government, and our individual compassions.
my reply to you is also to BrendaStewart. please see my response to her.
The commentary that you both have brought to the table is simply wonderful. I am not one who is of the thought to bring more pain to others. I am one who wants to take that pain away for them; however there are those that I think that will soon have the need to reflect on that time in their lives to revive that humanity of which you speak, Betsy. I just hope that the humanity in Mr. Snow, is sincere for his own good or he too will rot in hell with the rest of them.
To lie to ones self is and of the worst sign of unworthiness. God Bless.
Dear blueneck and BrendaStewart . . .
I will offer my thoughts and hopefully these will broaden our mutual understanding.
I have always been interested in politics, well, since the age of five. My natural father was a Right-winged Reactionary Republican, my Mom a very left Democratic Socialist. I viewed their political opposition as animated, not personal, though ultimately my Mom left because she felt my father had no morals, ethics, or values.
Nevertheless, I did not shy away from those I disagreed with, particularly because my Mom and then my [new] Dad encouraged me to question everything. There is no authority; all is up for discussion.
I dated many Repugnants and consistently I was told that I was the only Democrat, Progressive they could discuss politics with. For me, it is not personal. Foundations are often similar; it is that they have not grown beyond a clannish, capitalist stance. They are as children with their toys. They manipulate, denigrate, discriminate . . . it is fascinating.
However, for me, the true need and path to empathy is to look at why they are as they are. Study their history, their family relations, and influences. It explains so much. To do this effective you must not observe from afar. You must ask them of their experience and interpretation of their bonds. Once discovered, if you are as I, you will feel such deep sorrow.
I learned to acknowledge, I couldn’t help them or change them, just as they cannot guide or cajole me. We must choose for ourselves. That is the truest definition of growth. However, we can model, speak, and effectuate change. People are always in flux; expansion is an evolution. Be patient and loving and they will mirror that.
If they are too far from reach and you must separate yourself temporarily for your safety and sanity, trust that the door must be open or you will not know that they have progressed.
I do know, this is all easier said than done and I too have my moments . . . However, if we truly are believers in peace, love, and union, I think we must work to live that philosophy.
What do you think, experience, and observe? Does any of this make sense? It is only my theory.
May your life be full and fulfilling. May [spiritual, emotional, intellectual, and conjointly physical] abundance be yours . . . Betsy L. Angert