Are you as sick as I am of the 24/7 “JonBenet non-story” coverage? Then it is a good time to scratch this surface and see what squirms underneath. There is a fantastic piece at Slate today. Here is a taste:
This story allows us to fulminate against trivial problems while ignoring huge problems close to home, meanwhile wallowing in self-righteous porn babble: We are able to use the half-clothed bodies of children as centerfolds while professing shock that anyone would so display them.
For kids really do not fare very well in our culture: Millions of children are, in fact, abused in unspeakable ways. Five hundred thousand kids every year are classified as “throwaways” (children whose parents or guardians will not let them live at home, as distinguished from “runaways”). As many as 800,000 are beaten horribly. Even more are subject to emotional abuse and neglect. How much attention do they get? Instead, we focus our attention, almost all of it, on stranger-danger: things like abductions, of which there are between 100 and 200 annually. Our carefully controlled outrage is generated for our own purposes, certainly not to protect the children.
Then we get to an all important fact that our society wants swept right under the rug:
And when kids are indeed abused, who is doing it? Mom and Dad and Uncle Ted and Aunt May. As little as 2 percent of child abuse is committed by strangers. Again, why are we exercised over JonBenet?
We know who the boogeyman is, he is us when we are talking about women and children. Most women are attacked by those they know, not strangers. Their muderers are most often their own husbands or boyfriends but this doesn’t play well enough to the media who needs us in fear constantly. People are more easily swayed when they are afraid which is why corporations and our government wants us afraid. They are the ones trying to manipulate us, whether it is to by a new product or a government wanting more power and understanding that fear will be the mechanism by which people will hand it over to them.
Now that corporations own the media and there is little regulation as to how much they can own, a few of them are giving citizens the vast majority of what they ingest. Those same corporations give heartily to the Republican Party and their K Street representatives want more all the time. Right now Rove and the Administration want something, they want Iraq, Israel’s dismal failure and Bush’s fall from grace buried until the November elections and the JonBenet non-story is just the ticket. They are putting a mentally disturbed man front and center in an investigation that was full of holes from the get-go. My hunch is that the news organizations already know how weak the case is but push it loudly and we must begin to ask why.
There is every reason to believe that the corporate-owned media and their lobbyists want things from the government and right now there is something this Administration wants from them. If there is a deal made in hell being played out right now, it’s best to be on the lookout for it and to me this situation is not passing the smell test.
Spot on Wil! How many more times and for how long are people going to continue to fall for this “diversion of the Week” crap? When there is something to hide, something to down play. . .on comes the sensational something or other to distract joe and jane average ‘merican. Sweet little deal the administration and the media have made with each other, eh?
Wolf, wolf, wolf. . .the cries are endless, it has come to the place where we wouldn’t know a wolf if we were staring it in the face.
Good call, Wilfred.
Thanks Shirl, as always.
This whole thing stinks to high heaven and the facts will win out in the end, but until then we have to watch our public airwaves highjacked to give Rove time go implement a new plan to get R’s some traction before November.
Great job Wilfred. There is so much about all this that literally turns my stomach. I just can’t bear it that the news media gets all wrapped up in what this man ate on the airplane trip and what movie he watched. I know we’ve seen it all before, but this time I JUST CAN’T BEAR IT!!
There are so many millions of children around the world that might survive if we gave just an ounce of this angst to their plight.
These are the moments when I think all is probably lost for this country – the fact that we would amuse ourselves with this crap and actually portray it as news. We are lost.
Thanks, NL.
If only it was about the children but it’s not by a mile. The fact that there is scant public outcry about this is a crying shame.
One valuable lesson we can all gain from this episode is that if you are ever arrested in a foreign country for something you did or didn’t do, you know, one of those countries with REALLY bad prisons, you can cop to a high profile crime in the U.S. whenever the administration needs some news cover and get a free ride back to the U.S. and even get some good champagne with your shrimp dinner on the ride home so you will have plenty of energy when you arrive to tell all the reporters at the massive press conference that you have no comment before you proceed to the relative comfort of a U.S jail.
Mrs. Betty Bowers / Snakes on Planes: John Mark Karr
oh how i love betty bowers, that site is brilliant satire.
the FBI web-site correctly, 1,365 children under the age of 18 were murdered in 2004.
Could we get some round the clock coverage for that?
That would require some publicity for the fact that most kids die at the hands of their parents, step-parents, boy-friends of their moms, siblings, etc. Wouldn’t look good for family values. Wouldn’t look good to advertise the almost complete shut-down of the child protection system in some states because of loss of federal funding. And what would the TV stations do during sweeps weeks without the inevitable “stranger-danger” video news stories?
I seem to remember that Channel 4 had an expose (sorry about the pun) on nudie golf a few years back – maybe 5 years now.
I have heard many horror stories from students about step-dads and mom’s boyfriend and mom not believing her own daughter. This is why parental consent laws are jokes.
It’s precisely for that reason that I never thought the JonBenet story was big news the first time around.
Whatever political motivations might or might not be behind the prominence of the current series of events, the thing I always found disturbing about the public obsession with JonBenet Ramsey is that it smacked of mass voyeurism — a sort of mass vicarious enjoyment of child rape and murder. The same kind of instinct is presumably behind the rack of true crime paperbacks in grocery stores with their lurid photo sections.
I’m at a loss when it comes to suggesting what could be done about the phenomenon, but I do find it creepy.
I think that the JonBenet story was so big for two reasons.
The first is the sheer media coverage. Some people just get caught up in the hype.
The second is creepy. People were fascinated by video of that little girl all dolled up. I don’t wear that much make-up in a year. I am sure that there were plenty of people who saw those videos and passed immediate judgment on the parents.
It also allowed the Thai media to get away from the hideous political mess the country is in and gave some cover for the Thai PM whose bodyguards have recently gone on a rampage beating up anybody who boos him in public places – this has included a 5-year old kid and a 60 year old man to date and the demonstrators then get arrested while the assailants are allowed by the police to walk away.
So it has the same use over here. All I can say is thank God he was deported so quickly.