Steven D wrote a kind word today about Supersoling and Alohaleezy. It appears that in the intermittent time I spend lurking on various blogs, I have overlooked some hurt, or slight, or kerfuffle that has led my friends to indicate their intent to leave this place. It is hard to read Steven D’s words and not find him a good man. Kind and caring. Decent. I will always remember him as when I first made his acquaintance, at the September 2005 march on D.C., covered in a blizzard of sun screen, ready to do battle with fascists in order to shorten the war in Iraq. If I thought him less effective, I would call him Quixotic. But decent. A decency that gives me great hope for humanity in general.
Among his kind words was one gem: Prodigal. A sprendthrift by definition, but more often associated with the biblical allegory of the favored son who has disappointed, yet is embraced in his failure. It is this sole word which has inspired me to pen some thoughts.
I will always have a soft place in my heart for this blog and the people who populate it. When I discovered the blogs in 2004 (and I don’t mean to use the phrase “I discovered them” in the sense it is often used in conjuction with Columbus), I was sorely in need of a family like you (yes, the collective you who are reading this). Having finished my first novel about the descent of our nation into an anti-terror fascist state, I felt quite isolated. I thought perhaps I was a solitary lunatic. And the big orange place was cold comfort, as I realized the only radical idea it embraced was replacing a Republican oligarchy with a Democratic oligarcy.
The Booman Tribune, however, was a home to me. It only covered about one square foot on my desktop. But it was a boundless refuge of thought, laughter and friendship. Realizing that you are not a solitary coyote howling at the moon is a powerful thing. Knowing that others also see the empire as it decays, just under a fresh coat of paint — that knowledge is empowering.
Arthur Gilroy wrote once about the power of blogs, comparing them to jazz. And too, comparing how jazz was ultimately sold out to the powers that be, as the blogs ultimately must be — under our system of order. But that diary recognized the beauty in humanity coming together. To share wild thoughts. The world was not always this way. Will not always be this way. Fundamental change is possible. Such beauty in sharing these thoughts in a group. And such power.
One day, I read a diary about a woman going to Crawford. Another day, I was on a trip to D.C. to be inspired by a half a million souls (Sept. ’05 — and if the media tells you one man less, spit in their eye and call them a liar). The next day, I am embarking on a full year of honest, hard work as an activist. In a few short months, I am leading dozens of volunteers into the streets. To challenge power locally. I’ve held a mother who donated her son. I’ve cried while addressing an assembly of like minded citizens. All inspired by the jazz that flows from the voices of this very site. There is no power like people coming together — to witness it in the real world — it is a thing of beauty. A power to make your voice quiver and crack. To suck emotion right out of you and into the air.
And you people here (you know who you are) know that power. You started the blogs abuzz a bit. Operation Yellow Feather. Petals for Peace. It was all cummulative and good. All from this community. This family as it were.
There were mornings when I awoke and believed The Booman Tribune was at the tip of the revolution. And perhaps it was. Or perhaps I was a fool. Or something in the middle, more likely. This place, for me, for some several moments, held the promise of actually making an impact on the world. That people actually held some power.
Prodigal.
In my own experience of what the pond is, or was, it all started to fall apart a bit right around the time SusanHu left. Hard feelings. Splits among a formerly united band. Is this the way with left-leaning groups? The cliched way. Too independent to get along for long, before breaking over heartfelt issues.
When Ductape somehow became something of an enemy, my own spirit died a little. Honestly. The man assisted in bringing the Indiana Legislature to heel on women’s issues, if my memory serves. Just how did we sacrifice our ally?
And on and on. What had been a movement to me, perhaps only of my own invention and imagination, had become a soap opera.
It is ironic to me, that the end of Super and Alohaleezy seems to come based on a dust-up involving Military Tracy (and I have only a most limited understanding of these matters — not overly concerned with reading every comment that might better explain the nature of today’s proceedings — so forgive me my misunderstandings). Tracy, to some extent the motivation for me to view the blogs as a revolutionary tool. Super, a voice for peace, similarly inspired.
It is almost enough to make one laugh. Were it not a sad end to promise.
Prodigal.
Me. I am a lurker again. A watcher of soap operas. And commentaries. And beautiful words. Ocassionally, I am so moved as to write a few thoughts in response. Or a whole fucking diary. Often, I am moved and do not write a single syllable. As is a reader’s wont.
But you people here. You now make me feel like a prince. I am no longer an alienated individual. Alone, watching a once great nation on its paces toward the grave. I look to the right. To names as familiar as childhood friends. And I read what moves me. How uncannily the movie “Children of Men” predicts our future. How war with Iran is just a Gulf of Tonkin away.
To write is a violation of my particular parole. A pledge made to those concerned for my well being. No mortal danger. Just concern. Over concern, I’d say. But I’ve made promises. That I am still moved to break. Because who does not like to feel like a prince among friends.
I’ll leave with these thoughts.
Recent events at Daily Kos make me believe Arthur Gilroy’s warning about how blogs will become tools of less power than that deserved for the voices of united men and women. There, voices are increasingly silenced by gatekeepers. It is one square foot that has been truly sanitized for the safety of John Kerry and Hillary Clinton.
It is my fervent hope that The BooMan Tribune continues to be a community. A family. A place for isolated voices to find comfort and kinship. To that end, I join Steven D. in lamenting the loss of my friends Supersoling and Alohaleezy. May we always welcome back the prodigal. To be nourished by their words. To provide comfort for their isolation.
It isn’t the time to leave the city.
You have no idea how good it is to see your words here.
I agree olivia. I miss terribly his unique way of writing/his diaries more than I can possibly convey here. Terry has a true gift for writing.
[Holds up left hand to stop this praise, waives fingers of right hand to keep it coming.]
Too kind. Whole place has some great writing. Truly.
I’ve been thinking of you often. I remember you telling me you were mostly a lurker once. I didn’t understand that so well. Took a couple of years.
Best.
To change the subject …are you working on your next book? You have to let us know when it’s done so we can go out and buy it. I liked the characters so much that I have been really looking forward to reading about them again.
And excellence always deserves praise.
Second novel is being reviewed by a small press. No decision yet. I’ve got no great hopes. But I’ll be sure to let you know.
That’s cool. Of course I’m not biased or anything but I don’t see how they could not like it if it’s as good as the first one.
Bjoe,
What a beautiful statement. I`m following the fingers of the right hand, not because you call for praise, but because you deserve it.
I don’t like the reason for this post Joe, but it is good to read your thoughtful words. I also don’t understand the whole brew-ha that occurred. I read a few comments after the fact and still don’t understand it all. Guess what I do understand is two more good people who write well and care about our country have left the pond. At times I wonder about how liberal we liberals are. A great strength or potential strength of the left is our diversity. In my view, we don’t have to agree all the time to be effective. There is room for diversity on issues but I hope not so much on vision. I believe, perhaps naively, that most here and at other “progressive” sites share a similar view of where we want this country to go. To get there will take the contributions of millions of us. We may not all be soul-mates, or even like each other, but respect for that similar vision should be the glue that binds us together. It saddens me when discord has a paralyzing effect on communities such as this. So many times I am inspired by what I read here, tonight is not one of those times.
I have decided to become a lurker here, but I just wanted to say that this is one of the most insightful comments I have read here in a week.
is that it is like a fractal. Patterns form and break apart and reform. There is no constant here, nothing to grasp and hold on to. Just moments of sheer emotions, laughter, tears, shouting and those mingling with wisdom, foolery, intellectual honesty, intellectual deceit. We are lucky when we witness the best in us and we are sad or angry when we are prisoners to the worst in us. But we are all connected and our saving grace is that I can hear the sincerity in you, and you can forgive my tactless moments. I can savor the petals campaign, I can be grateful when we make some tiny bit of progress, and I can harbor hope and feel despair reading our collective works.
I’ve been in tears a few times over the last couple of days. Your diary brought a few more.
Yesterday, as I watched the hurt return here and saw the strong but fragile bonds we have developed begin to look like they were falling apart, I wanted to write a diary about why this blog and all of you have been so important to me in the last year and a half.
Today I lost my will to do that. Who knows what tomorrow will bring?? But if I never get to the place to do it myself, you did if for me here.
So thanks BJ.
Take good care.
I’ve been trying to catch up with whatever happened. I know one thing–as a part-time lurker and contributor–I hope two amazing women choose to stay here.
These two paras totally sum up for me the power of the place that Booman created here and the community that you all built:
And then of course the sad fracturing of the blogs and the disapperance of people power from the net communities:
And of course AG’s brilliance and foresight:
Brilliant writing Boston Joe. You’ve so captured the essence of the site and my feelings about it.
Boston Joe. Thank you. I believe your words have the power to heal some of the hurt. Thank you.
Just words, I guess. But we are all good people here. I think. This is/was a good place. Nothing is static. Hope the spirit of what was lives on here or elsewhere.
Welcome Joe. I won’t say welcome back, for you have never really left in my eyes. Just welcome. Thank you for the many kind words.
I muct have looked like some horrid ghost with all that sunscreen lol. And then we had a cloudy day to top it off!
But it was a great day, and great friends to march with, you among them.
I remember when an errant “3” was about the worst you could ever expect at this site.
.
LOL
Yep. Remember a few myself, spreading ‘4‘s and suddenly seeing a 3.80 average. Thinking holy moses, it wasn’t I was it! Usually turned out it was alohaleezy or BrendaStewart spreading plenty of love. You could expect a well meant ‘sorry’ and some (((hugs))) in response.
Good to have you writing such a beautiful essay, it’s even better than the FAQ as I mentioned yesterday to a newcomer. Keep us abreast of your activities BostonJoe and don’t stay away for such a long period.
All wisdom and joy to you BJ!
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
Nice seeing you, too, Oui.
Hey Joe – good to see you!
You ARE a prince, write on –
Hey yourself. The evil BostonJoe, not an infrequent visitor to this very keyboard, would suggest that I may have lifted the term prince from Machiavelli, with all its contextual meaning. The good BostonJoe, however, would never suggest such a thing.
The world is going to change someday. Isn’t it?
Is already changing as we speak. But ours not to know why and how –
David Bowie knows something:
You know I meant prince in the ‘charming’ mode, right?
Ductape put his religion before the blog or the progressive cause. His over reaction to the Muhammad cartoon that Susan posted was ridiculous. He was also some sort of expatriate living in the states and then bashing the whole idea of an enlightened and free thinking society by putting Muhammad before his adopted country’s ideals of free speech. He broke Susan’s heart and humiliated her. I’m glad he’s gone. The blog meant the world to her it was obvious. She also seemed like a sweet person.
I do not know what has happened with Leezy or Super but I wish they would continue to post here. They are far different people then Ductape Fatwa. They are not hypocrites like him.
Oh BTW hello.
Hello, man!
Good to see you.
Your observations about SusanHu and Ductape are not my own. I’d say a key phrase in what you quoted from my writing above is “in my own experience.” I am not always gifted of clarity of thought. But when I am — perhaps when I am at my best — I am a an extreme relativist. Meaning, as I use the term, I find little or no absolute good or evil in the world, rather believing that our individual perceptions and thoughts are most often the sum total of our cultural and historical grounding. We all see the world through a different window. Perhaps all seeing some part of the same reality. But it looks very different to all of us at different times. I come to this viewpoint after dealing with witnesses and jurors for over a decade now. Reality is illusive in human terms. So at my best, when I remember this frailty, I speak in terms of what the world means to me, and hope that others can share the reality I am glimpsing.
SusanHu and Ductape were both viewing the world from very different windows. As were all participants in that event. Some of us, I believe, saw the viewpoint more clearly from Ductape’s side of the street. Many, from the opposite side of the road.
The pivotal question, in my own view, is, these many months later, is not so much which side of the road you witnessed that reality from, but how open one is to viewing reality as a very subjective experience.
I always found Ductape to be a very wise thinker, very capable of pointing out to others that there are different views in the wide world. Often with an incredible wit. I also found him more than willing to acknowledge his own role as a fallible viewer of reality. He was adept at arguing his viewpoint, but did not foreclose other worlds of thought.
I say these things about Ductape, not as a slight to SusanHu. That was simply my imaginings of the man, as capable of flaw as any imagining might be. As for SusanHu, I share some of your imaginings of fine qualities for her.
In a perfect world, the people on opposite sides of the street would remember that they are still all custodians of the street itself. I think we all chose teams in that incident. And let it overshadow what was, in my view, a very good dynamic at work here at the Trib.
Who was right? Who was wrong? Hard for me to say. Hard for anyone to say, when you view reality as I have explained. Everyone makes judgments. Dynamics change. And on we go into a new era. Though, the idealist in me — the one who wants to believe in good and evil, would like to believe that the change that unfolded dealt a blow to a valuable good. Our community of interest. An agent of change.
The other fights that have developed over time. Ripples, as Alice had David Bowie say above. Ripples from that stone — as close as I could witness it.
Oh well, too many words. Over-analysis paralysis. All a sound and fury signifying nil.
Good to see you though.
Are you coming to the Pentagon march? Maybe we can get with Super he said he was going in a comment the other day. I’m going to make this one no matter what! Bush is about to push us into the abyss. If not I know your involved thats for sure. 🙂
My heart will certainly be there. Life is running at a pace that makes it difficult for my body to follow. But I’d rule nothing out or in at this point, and if I’m able, I would very much like to make the acquaintance of all the BooTrib crowd again.
BJ, you have so well described my own views as well as yours. I guess that makes me an extreme relativist as well. This morning there seems to be a break in the cloud cover over my own head, and a glimpse of the sun, in terms of understanding my own role in recent events here, and what is right action for me at this point.
I need to step away awhile, and let my own idealistic self have a rest because she gets out of control sometimes, and loses her way. She seems bound and determined to believe that there is always some way for good people to stay together if they really want to, if only they can find the solution and then work very hard at it.
My wiser self, however, views things another way. She knows nothing is ever static for long: not the bad stuff or the good. She knows we all come together, however we do, wherever we do, to exchange whatever we are meant to exchange with each other, and almost always, pleasant or painful, it’s something we each could put to good purpose, if that is our choice.
This morning, she also reminded me that that elusive state of togetherness that we all seek, that we call “community”, is really not a “place” at all. Whether it’s a website or a three dimensional neighborhood or a town, the place is just that: the “place” where we meet and come together to form this state of being we call “community”.
I know I will have to live with my “littler self” forever: that part of me that isn’t so wise, and is very very human and thus very fallible, that wants to hang on to places where I have found precious others and the sense of “belonginess” we all seem to seek
and need. So goes being a mere human, huh?
But for now, I need to spend some more time with that part of me, that wiser part, that tells me it’s ok, it’s all really ok. Others are wherever they are on their own pathway, and that gets pretty messy at times, when we’re all never at exactly the same place along life’s road.
She is also reminding me of all the other “places” where I’ve been: where, for precious portions of time, I could live “in true community” with others, and how I fought and cried over seeing them change and dissolve themselves, only to find another, then another, and still another.
But once that determined, idealistic part of me become fully engaged, she’s like a hungry dog with a bone.
Time to ground her for awhile, (again!) till she gets a grip!
Thanks, Joe, for your steadying hand.
You took the words right out of my mouth, sister.
Best to you scribe. Wise woman. I can’t imagine someone who has lived parts of the life you have shared here, who couldn’t be endowed with great wisdom from the journey.
BJ, I wish I could give you about a thousand 4’s for all that.
It reminds me of why I’m greiving the place where so many views came together to expand my vision. It has been continually becoming less of that for me over these last few months. But I miss it and greive its loss.
You are indeed a wise man – as is our friend Ductape, wherever he is today.
I really miss that guy, too. He made me laugh. It is hard for writers to make you actually laugh. He did that for me.
Thank you, BostonJoe. Its a pleasure seeing you here and reading such good words all in the right order and stuff to say what I would’ve tried to say if I could get those feelings and understandings I have to comply with grammatical construction and words and word orders and such.
Ummm yeah ditto. Thats what I was gonna say. That was beautiful man.
Pleasure is all mine blueneck. Don’t you go all modest about your own words. That is a laugher.
I’m in the process of launcing a new law firm, oh by the way. It has been great fun (I never thought I’d use those words about the law again).
Glad you got a chuckle. I had a good belly laugh last night the likes of which I haven’t had in a long long time. It was cathartic, wonderful, healing laughter. I have a drawing of a fat buddhist monk looking up at the moon and laughing full out. I felt that kinda way last night.
And I’m happy to hear about you opening a new firm. I know that you will do well and do good. I live with a lawyer so I understand the rewards and the frustrations of legal practice. I wish you enough boring cookie-cutter cases to make a good living and enough exciting and interesting cases to keep you stimulated. 🙂
Joe,
Thanks for your thoughtful words.
But I won’t think of those now gone as prodigal. They did what they thought was needed, and I couldn’t second guess their actions. But there was no waste in fighting for what they thought was right. They are always welcome, as far as I am concerned. But not for being prodigal, only for being themselves.
I’d never second guess them either. I just know I sometimes feel overly appreciated here, and it a good place to return to.
HERE HERE!! There have to be some rules of course(not so many as to stifle) and people will come and go for various reasons. The spirit of the people on this blog to make a difference in the world is fabulous and I hope they keep at it!!!