9/11 happened om George Bush’s watch. Who can forget those seven minutes of stunned silence. while he listened to the reading of “My Pet Goat.” But then he moved into action. Spoke with a bullhorn atop a mound of rubble at the site of the World Trade Center to rally America. Told us to go shopping to fight terrorism. Told the rest of the world “Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists.”
And ordered the EPA to lie to the World Trade Center volunteers, firefighters, police, other workers and residents in and around the massive clean-up site that the toxic stew of air to which they were exposed was perfectly safe to breathe.
Now those same, trusting, heroic people are getting cancer as a result of that lie. By the boatload:
(cont.)
NEW YORK – The head of the largest program tracking the health of World Trade Center site workers said several have developed rare blood cell cancers, raising fears that cancer will become a “third wave” of illnesses among those exposed to toxic dust after Sept. 11.
Dr. Robin Herbert, co-director of the World Trade Center Medical Monitoring Program at Mount Sinai Medical Center, said researchers who have screened 20,000 of the estimated 40,000 ground zero workers are “most concerned” about lymphatic and blood cancer cases. […]
“The kind of thing that worries us is that we know we have a handful of cases of multiple myeloma in very young individuals, and multiple myeloma is a condition that … almost always presents later in life,” she added. “That’s the kind of odd, unusual and troubling finding that we’re seeing already.”
Mount Sinai published research last year that said about 70 percent of the workers they screened had developed various respiratory illnesses. […]
An attorney representing thousands of workers and residents said that more than 100 of his clients have blood cell cancers. About eight have multiple myeloma, David Worby said. Most of his clients are in their 30s or 40s, and the youngest is 29, he said.
More than half of all cases of multiple myeloma, a plasma cell cancer that spreads throughout bone marrow, occur in people over 70, and about 1 percent of cases occur in people under 40, according to the Multiple Myeloma Research Foundation in Norwalk, Conn. […]
Said Worby: “It’s not a great threat to the general public, but to people who are already sick and have these blood cell cancers and who gave up their lives … it’s a great threat to them because a lot of them are going to die.”
Yes, I know the terrorists flew planes into those buildings and created all that toxic air. But that doesn’t excuse President Bush from lying to the brave Americans who risked their lives to save others, and to salvage the site of the worst foreign attack on American soil regarding the risks they were taking with their health.
To him, and to others in his administration, it was more important to quickly erase the evidence of this attack, then it was to protect the health of the American people who responded to his call for help, or who did so simply because it was , like the firefighters, simply their job. Actions could have been taken to protect those people from the toxic effects of all that “bad air” but Bush decided expediency was more important than the lives of the people who trusted his judgment, and the judgment of his administration.
Under the criminal law, when someone takes an action that it he or she knows is likely to harm or kill another human being, we call that “a depraved indifference to human life” and such people can be prosecuted for premeditated murder in most states. That is what George Bush and/or others in his administration did when they lied to the 9/11 workers and the people who resided in lower Manhattan. They understood that the toxins released into the air by the attack on the Two Towers on 9/11/2001 were likely to cause respiratory illnesses and cancers among those living and working in the effected area, yet they still deliberately ordered th EPA to lie about these serious health hazards to human life. If that doesn’t qualify as “depraved indifference” I don’t know what does.
Last I heard, I President responsible for murdering innocent US civilians would have committed a “high crime and misdemeanor” justifying his impeachment. So why aren’t we proceeding with an impeachment investigation, or a murder investigation? Someone at the White House gave this order, and I suspect only the President of the United States had the authority to override the decisions of Christie Todd Whitman, head of the EPA and one of the members of his Cabinet. So I ask once more: Why isn’t the House of Representatives investigating this lie, which has killed, and will kill more, innocent Americans as possible grounds for impeaching President Bush?
I guess IOKIYAR* also applies to the intentional murder of Americans.
* IOKIYAR is an acronym for the phrase “It’s okay if your a Republican.”
Steven, your title made me think about an idea. What if after every diary written about the Bush misadministration – the title included the words “Still No Impeachment.” Keep it front and center.
Yes. Great idea.
no to impeachment:
Al Gore against any attempt to impeach Bush
Now the thing I always remember is Gore putting down the black caucus appeals for investigation into the vote. I felt then as I did when Kerry just accepted the vote: “we have to at least have a fight on this!” But no, no fight. Gore said he thought the only next step was revolution. I think the next step would have been an airing of what had happened in the vote. Now we see terms like “vote gating” and nobody is thrown in jail for causing another person to lose their ability to vote. That is just not right.
Christine Todd Whitman was the one who ordered it, but Cheney prolly ordered her. She also had personal conflicts which should have led her to recuse herself if it was any other situation: her family’s insurance interests involved the effected.
She’s testified before Congress that the White House told he to lie.
True, no doubt, but wouldn’t she have considered it to protect her hubby’s business interests?
Actually, what she did exposed her husband’s companies, to potential “bad faith” denial of claims litigation if that was her motivation, especially if anyone can demonstrate her husband or other company reps knew that she was acting in their interest. bad faith insurance litigation can lead to high punitive damage awards in New York.
True but how many payments have they made, just think of the interest saved alone – delay , delay, delay…
Also, remember there were some interesting laws passed just after 9/11….
There have been a lot of interesting laws passed (and/or ignored) since 9/11 my friend. A shit load.
That’s why bad faith claims allow such large punitive damages.
I don’t know how many of you are familiar with this website, but the writing here is some of the clearest and most interesting I have ever seen.
The latest post is a copy of a speak given to a real or imaginary (I can’t tell) Dept. of Rhetoric at a University telling how the Bush administration sees its power to create REALITY. Indeed it builds upon the quote by this unknown Bushie that said
“The aide said that guys like me were ‘in what we call the reality-based community,’ which he defined as people who ‘believe that solutions emerge from your judicious study of discernible reality.’ I nodded and murmured something about enlightenment principles and empiricism. He cut me off. ‘That’s not the way the world really works anymore,’ he continued. ‘We’re an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you’re studying that reality — judiciously, as you will — we’ll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that’s how things will sort out. We’re history’s actors…. and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do.'”
Anyway, there is so much hear that the best advice is to just read this post and think what has happened. It is brilliant, and best of all it shows how this flight into Rhetoric over reality may well be coming undone dooming the participants of this dangerous and deadly fiasco. Let us at least hope so!
Yes, TomDispatch is a very good way to keep informed and avoid the news filtering of the corporate media.
Here’s a link to the article in which that quote you give appeared. The whole thing is a must-read. There has been speculation that “this unknown Bushie” was Cheney.
One thing is most certainly beyond all doubt: to this administration, (and who knows how many others before this one) ordinary Americans are 100% expendable.
We are to be led by the nose, used, abused and exploited however best serves the goals of the power elite, whether it kills us or not. Matters not a whit, as long as we keep breeding enough replacement stock.
This… is the kind of government we have elected to run Americ, and that we continue to allow to run this country.
I was once so very proud to call myself an American. Now, I am ashamed to be one.