I have two stories I would like to share with you. One, I would call bad news. And the other, perhaps good, if I could be permitted to make such value judgments. I will try to make this short. But those who know my history will forgive me rambling a bit, I trust.
I would not have written the first story, I think, had it not been for the discovery of the second. But I came across the second story, just five minutes ago, laying on my kitchen floor. It is handwritten in neon-yellow highlighter on plain white typing paper. Its words are laid out in the landscape style. And while it is poorly edited, it makes up for this defect by being brief and genuine (I presume). And this second story, it allows me now, to overcome my guilt, and record the first story.
Neither story is fiction. What I say is true, as best I can report as a student of reality.
Story No. 1
A few weeks ago, I was a disillusioned voter. I am very tired of party politics. I believe both parties to be agents for continuing a status quo that enriches the elite, and keeps the rabble stable enough so that things can continue as they are.
I do not want to mislead you. I am still of that mind. The idealist that lived in my heart for thirty plus years was wounded with this war, and died completely on the operating table, as I struggled against the indifference of American public opinion about the war. Until we can learn to look at the children of the world as we look at our own children, we are hopeless. And I’ve come to believe we are hopeless for an age.
But a few weeks ago, as I listened to Mr. Obama give his Iowa victory speech, I was moved. I believed again. At least for a moment. That history will wash away this stain. That my country will continue to move on to proud new moments. I saw a leader that night. Not a black man. But a man who could restore hope to Americans. I thought we were witnessing the emergence of a new community. The beginning of the fruition of the dream of Dr. King. Men and women not judged by their color, but by the content of their soul. It was a wonderful moment for me. To remember the feeling of hope. I thank Mr. Obama for letting me feel that again. It extended as far allowing me to vote in a primary.
Then came New Hampshire, and the questions of race and secret ballots. And I was wary. But I had faith that America was ready. Like I was ready. Surely there were some hicks who could not see beyond race. But as a nation. We are ready, I reasoned.
This weekend, however, I was with old friends for a reunion of sorts. Let me set the stage. A small house. A working class neighborhood. Lower to middle class. A small manufacturing town. A Democratic stronghold until Reagan. And fully returning to a Democratic stronghold after Reagan. Perhaps ten of us. Most of us are nearing mid-life now, if not already past it. The sample of people, mostly men, mostly high-school graduates. All white. A few women. Most all with a few beers in them.
The conversation turned to politics. And I spoke of the hope I felt from Mr. Obama’s speech. It took approximately fifteen seconds after I finished speaking, for me to realize that Mr. Obama is not likely to be a successful candidate in the national election. I hope it is untrue. But from these core-Democratic voters, I heard the verdict. White America — at least the one I grew up with — much to my surprise, is not ready for a black candidate, I was told. There was no way, I was told. I am ashamed of the words I heard. I will not write them here. And I dearly hope that I am wrong. That this sample — a sample of my friends — was not representative. I dearly hope that Mr. Obama will go on to win. To help us end this divide. I have hope. But the reality was wounding.
Story No. 2
Editor’s note: I translate this verbatim (with the exception of excising a name), as it was written by my seven year-old daughter. It was not an assignment. I believe it was prompted by what she has learned in school, and perhaps by a recent TV documentary about Dr. King, and perhaps by her overhearing some of the political conversation described in story number one above. I made no efforts to edit it for content.
I think Marten Luther king Jr. was right! The guy who killed Martne he – should’et killed Marten. My dream is that know one smokes and no guns! The guy who shot Marten got put in jail and died. No food or water and it smelled! If we did’et have Marten – I would’et have my friend Asha [last name omitted.]
Editor’s closing note: There was much smoking at the political discussion I mentioned in Story Number One above.
Change happens around us, even when we are not looking. My wife took my daughters to the polling booths on primary day. One day this country will be in their hands. And then to their children. And we will have leaders of all races and sexes and sexual orientations. Because men and women of vision sometimes speak. And their words are recorded by the human heart. And by modern technology. And time keeps rolling along. Until the truth, in the end, the truth.
Happy MLK day my friends.
Sounds like you have a dream, Joe.
Well, you’re not the only one.
When I was seven it was my dream to persuade my dad to stop smoking. By the time I was seventeen I had joined him on the nicotine express.
I didn’t lose him until I was thirty-seven and I’m sure it was almost as painful as it would have been earlier.
Listen to your daughter’s dreams, you are the hero that’s closest to her. If you’re smoking, stop. She’s going to need you for a long time. Believe me, it can be done. That was one of my last lessons from my father – don’t put it off.
Here endeth the lecture – don’t get me started on the beer.
I don’t smoke Alice. My house is smoke-free. It is my sense that this line in my daughter’s essay had to do with the smoking my daughter saw at this somewhat obscene political conversation (and perhaps an imperfect expression of her own disapproval of the content of the speech there). Though this is just my conjecture.
I’m sorry about your dad, though. My mom is on the same train. It is coming to the final stations.
You can lecture at will, I will not be giving up my beer. 🙂
I was like you Joe, I though we as a nation were ready. These primaries may only be scratching the surface of the bile and hatred our countrymen have been concealing. All you can do is vote and stand behind Senator Obama and have the audacity to hope.
I know your shocked hang in there they may vote for the man anyway. Talk is cheap. Dr. King knew some of his “white brothers” were pretty fucked up. So it shouldn’t come as a shock to you or me. You end up living in a bubble when you take the time and thought to be politically correct and not a racist idiot. People without that simple decency will normally wait until your not around (or their drunk) to spew their crap.
Hang in there its MLK day enjoy that fact. That was a battle in itself. Here in Virginia the state celebrates Lee, Jackson, King day. Two racist traitors to their country sharing the day with Dr. King. To me thats just spitting on a man’s memory.
Good diary Joe. Also could someone tell Hillary that Dr. King marched for the African American minority and not white women. During the Nevada debate that was freaking embarrasing.
Take heart, Joe. The wave of change is unstoppable, though its sometimes glacial pace is unsettling. We all want it to happen faster, but sometimes, as tough as it is, patience is required.
I was watching Eyes On The Prize last night on PBS. It is hard for me to fathom, as the scenes unfolded on my television screen, that these events have actually occurred in my lifetime. The beating of peaceful marchers on the Edmund Pettus Bridge, the turning back by police batons of women, children and young people for simply marching to a courthouse, and the beating death on the street of a white minister, who was called a white nigger by the killer just before his head was bashed in with a club. And the killer was never brought to justice. I don’t know how old you are, but for me to consider that I have lived in a time when these kinds of actions were considered justifiable and were legally sanctioned is almost incomprehensible. So, in a sense, the fact that these kinds of events, which were almost routine at the time, are almost unheard of now gives me some hope that we are slowly moving in the right direction. This helps me keep some perspective, though it is hard sometimes to take much solace in it.
You are doing your part to help move us forward. You are raising children in a home where race or sexual orientation is not the defining characteristic or measure of ones humanity or worth. That is what it is going to take. People like you and your wife and all the other families doing the same thing. The immoral stain of bigotry and racism will continue to be marginalized and stamped out if we can just continue to lead our children by example. There’s not much we are going to do to change the minds of people in my generation who are already set in their ways. It is the children that we have to look to as our hope for a better future.
I always enjoy reading your posts, Joe, and it’s good to see you posting again.
But, I have to tell you the truth as I see it: If MLK, Jr. was alive today and — magically — unchanged from the person he was during the last year of his life, I don’t think he would endorse Obama. Oh, he would be gratified that a black man was a leading contender for the presidency. (If he had lived, we might have seen that happen sooner.) But, I don’t think he’d support Obama just because he’s black…
He’d listen to Obama’s message of hope and putting a let’s-move-on band-aid over the putrid wounds inflicted on this country by Bushco and preceding corporate-owned presidents. And he’d say, “What about the poor? What about the destruction of the working class? Will there be no accountability? Will there be no justice?”
I think if he listened to all of the candidates and looked at there proposals, he’d endorse Edwards. I say this as someone who marched with King and was part of his movement beyond Civil Rights to Poor People’s Rights. I believe THAT’s why they killed him.
I agree that King would not endorse a black man simply because he was a black man.
But if you compare their actual voting records, Obama is more progressive than Edwards.
Which matters more? Words, or deeds?
would not be for his policy statements, that he would garner my vote, but for his message. It is not quite — the person I’d most like to have a beer with standard — but it is not far from that. It is the person I most think can rally us to the awesome challenges that we face.
But I cannot disagree with you about specific policies. The voting records for most Democratic congress people make me cringe. If you supported the war, the bankruptcy bill, the patriot act, FISA crap, a judiciary that scares small children — well, it is hard to support those who had a hand in any of those acts.
MLK III agrees with me.
http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2008/1/21/20374/9951/597/440783
We need someone to fight for the rights of the downtrodden. Not unite politicos in a center that is actually far right. Did you read the interview with Obama in the AJC where he thinks Bush’s idea of throwing a few hundred dollars at people is a good idea? Sorry, no link. You can look it up for yourself.
The way I see it the media is owned by conservatives and they don’t want progressive actions or a president who would encourage legal actions that would bust up their power. So all the coverage is about the two candidates they believe can be beaten by McCain or Romney. Hillary carries tons of baggage, will be attacked mercilessly and will respond like a raging shrew. Obama is black and as you learned at your gathering a lot of people aren’t color-blind yet. And he’ll be blugeoned by his lack of experience.
But, even if Hillary or Obama should win, Those Who Rule will still be safe because they own them every much as they own their Repug dogs.
Who’s getting the media blackout? Who’s a real threat to them?
Ever see the movie “The Candidate” with Robert Redford. I think something like that happened to John Edwards on his way to the Senate. He did what his handlers told him to do. Then he went out on the campaign trail with Kerry, saw real people again and remembered why he’d gotten into politics in the first place.
The first thing he did after that stolen election was set up a poverty resource center. He’s back to his roots now and doesn’t listen to DLC advisors anymore. He’s ignored and losing the votes but every time Omama steals part of one of his speeches or Hillary shifts in the wind he’s blowing, he wins. The center moves leftward and we win. It may only be words but the other two aren’t talking aout busting up the media monopolies or holding corrupt corporations accountable for the evil they do.
I’m not sorry I voted for McGovern and I’m not going to be sorry that I vote for Edwards.
Very nice summary, counselor. I, too, have been impressed with John Edwards. I am dreaming of a pissed-off, anti-corporate Edwards as an Attorney General. And I like that image, very much. I also like how you spin out his positive effect on the campaign even if he has no chance of winning. I loved how Obama acknowledged his narratives as valid, and powerful, during the debate last evening. Edwards does give a wonderful narrative.
I agree with Lisa. I think it has become fashionable, through a lot of effort by the media and a lot of the blogosphere, to paint Obama as someone who does “a lot of fancy talkin” but, in reality, he is just another Hillary-style centrist. The fact is, Obama has a progressive record. Is he the perfect candidate? Probably not. Is he a liberal’s liberal? I would say, no. But if you’re waiting around for that, well, you might as well stay home every election day.
They say a leopard can’t change its spots. And one thing is for certain, Hillary’s spots are there for everyone to see. My Republican friends like to talk about how “liberal” Hillary is. Maybe to them. But not to me.
As a liberal, I don’t trust Hillary Clinton. If I have to, I will probably vote for her. But if I have a choice, I will strongly consider other options.
Hi Joe, I’m truly sorry about your friends, it’s always a blow to the heart to find people you like(or liked)spew forth attitudes and prejudices that are abhorrent to you…no matter what ‘reason’ they give for it.
Thank the Great Spaghetti Monster for your daughter or I’d be completely depressed. Tell her for me would you that she just made this much older heart feel just a bit better today.
I sometimes felt I’ve lived my entire life on the outside wondering how I happened to escape most prejudices.(I can’t take a lot of credit for this I seemed to just be born this way) I meet someone and if they think MLK is great then they hate gays or they hate Mexicans or whatever…always have to hate some group of people and I have never understood that and never will. It does make for a very small circle of friends though unfortunately.
When I was much much younger and naive I surely thought after living through the 60’s and 70’s and race riots and Civil Rights marches and the last wave of the feminist movement that by now the children growing up then would have put all this ugliness to the side but I guess I was expecting way too much of human nature…we still have segregated Proms for shit’s sake.
I remember also being asked those silly questions in school about how you’d change the world etc most kids said they hoped for world peace/end to hunger and I always said(and still do)that I wish there was no such thing as prejudice and sadly I usually got looked at if I was saying something not quite right…because most people continue also to believe that they are not prejudiced.
I continue to believe that prejudice(of any kind) is the very greatest scourge on humanity because it takes away our own humanity. It reduces humans to scared tribes always fearing what the ‘other’ may do to you or take away from you.
I think I’ll go read a few of MLK’s speeches and see if I can find some solace in his inspiring words.
Thanks for the words CI. I will pass along your message to my daughter.
I do take solace in great words. Even if the reality is not here yet. At least hearing people say great words (MLK/Obama/whoever) — it makes me want to stick it all out. Believe that some day, it will be right.
The power of words alone: this is why one of Orwell’s main themes in 1984 was the use of language. Note also a similar use of language by BushCo — distortion & simplification, seeping like a virus into mainstream media & then public discourse, so that we become unfamiliar with the connection between language and the perception of truth.
It’s this connection that gives words their greatness & the cumulative deafness serves the powers that be very well.
War is peace. Right?
Freedom is slavery.
Ignorance is strength.
Absolutely right.
Rereading MLK’s speech about Vietnam is always amazing..words strung together so powerfully and lyrically as to make you weep at the beauty/ideas, morality and humanness shining through and enough to make you weep at the dearth of great orators now who can make you feel even a tiny bit of what King could when he spoke.
Something else about his speeches I noticed even more this year. He doesn’t talk down to his audience, the vast intelligence shines through in his use of words, phrases and quotes. Thinking of what we’ve been reduced to with bush now seems even more of a travesty as to bush’s lack of intelligence and not being able to string two words together without sounding like a ignorant buffoon. How could our country go from MLK to bush in such a short time?
Words do make the world go round.
I still believe that sometimes if one person stands up, others will notice and maybe even follow. The good fight is still worthwhile for many reasons, not the least of which is our kids. FSM help us all.
Peace
May his noodly appendage touch us all. Pax.
and I enjoy your posts a great deal. As a man with much the same background (lower MI, lower to middle class friends, reletively progressive outlook, married with kids, etc) I am sorry to report that the outlook is much the same with my group of friends. My guess is that many of my friends simply won’t vote this time around (some of them don’t anyway, despite my efforts) because they aren’t voting for a woman and they certainly aren’t voting for a black man. Then, of course, there are those who vote party line repub…
I hold out hope for the continued movement toward acceptance of all as equals, but we’re not going to see it in our generation. Perhaps in our children’s.
Good to see you WW. Thanks for the comment. Glad I’m not the only one here seeing this (even if this sucks). Maybe the rest of the country will pull us through this year some how.