Today’s quote comes from the Reverend Jeremiah Wright, retired former Pastor of Barack Obama’s church, Trinity United Church of Christ. This is one of those comments that was so “controversial” it forced Obama to denounce it as “inflammatory and appalling” and also to remove Rev. Wright from a minor position in Obama’s campaign. It was made in a speech that Rev. Wright gave at Howard University in 2006. Let’s examine it closely:
“Racism is how this country was founded and how this country was run. . . . We believe in white supremacy and black inferiority and believe it more than we believe in God.”
“Racism is how this country was founded” is a true statement. Go take a look at the Constitution if you doubt me. Blacks who were slaves in the South are deemed as 3/5ths of a “white person” for purposes of apportioning congressional representation. The Constitution also expressly permitted the importation of slaves until 1808. The word slave is not mentioned, but the euphemistic references to “all other persons” who were not free makes it clear to what the document was referring, as do records of the debates regarding the Constitution at the convention in Philadelphia in 1787.
“We believe in white supremacy and black inferiority and believe it more than we believe in God.” I grant you that this is hyperbole, but hyperbole that is justified by our own history. Thomas Jefferson, the author of the Declaration of independence believed blacks to be an inferior, cruder, more animalistic race of humanity. Even Abraham Lincoln, the Great Emancipator, made statements regarding the inferiority of the black race, and initially believed the problem of freeing the slaves could only be solved by re-settling them in a colony in Africa.
In the post-Civil War era, we have a long history of excluding blacks from white society and from white privileges, despite the language of the 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments. Of course, we have the era of Jim Crow in the South, but there was an contemporaneous, though less often noted version of this in the North and West; the aptly named “Sundown Towns” which kept blacks from residing in them both formally, under the law, and informally, through the use of violence and intimidation, and often the simple refusal of real estate agents to sell homes in those places to anyone who wasn’t white.
Nor should our long history of violence against African Americans and other minorities be ignored. From lynching to the Klu Klux Klan, from the wartime imprisonment of Japanese Americans in concentration camps to today’s use of such camps to hold Latinos suspected of being illegally in the United States, from the best selling apologia for racism “The Bell Curve” (which claimed that the lower IQ scores of African Americans was hereditary) to John McCain’s casual use of the racial slur “gooks” during the 2000 Presidential campaign, our society offers demonstrable evidence of a continuing streak of white supremacism among the dominant white majority. We try to hide it, we try to pretend it doesn’t exist, that we have “moved on” and live in a post-racial era, but that is a lie.
Indeed, the types of smears and other attacks against Obama’s candidacy have consistently had racist overtones. Yet, he is the one who is expected to “denounce and reject” the statements of anyone even marginally connected to his campaign and to immediately remove them from any position they hold, while the two remaining white candidates in the race, McCain and Clinton are permitted to retain key persons and accept key endorsements from people who have made outrageous remarks. The best example is perhaps McCain, who is allowed to accept the endorsement of controversial conservative pastors who believe it is our destiny wars to eradicate Islam from the face of the earth, who claim that Hurricane Katrina was God’s punishment against New Orleans for homosexuality, and who stated after 9/11 that the attacks were the fault of “pagans, and the abortionists, and the feminists, and the gays and the lesbians who are actively trying to make that an alternative lifestyle, the ACLU, People For the American Way — all of them who have tried to secularize America …” I ask you, whose religious supporters have made the more controversial and outrageous remarks?
There is only one explanation for why Obama was forced to kowtow to the American media last night and repeatedly repudiate Reverend Wright’s statements while McCain skates away relatively untouched. That explanation can be described in one word: racism. Hagee, Parsley and Falwell are white conservative Christians. They are permitted to do and say outrageous things with little fallout for them personally or for the political candidates they endorse and support. Rev. Jeremiah Wright, on the other hand, is black. Anything the least bit “controversial” he says, no matter how grounded in fact, is simply too much for white Americans to hear. And so he and his opinions are used to attack Barack Obama in ways that the views of Falwell, Hagee and Parsley, far more extreme and controversial white ministers are not used to taint John McCain.
Reverend Wright may be guilty of hyperbole, but he told the truth. We are a nation which continues to treat minorities differently than whites. You only need look at one statistic to see that this is the case: the infant mortality rates among African Americans versus the same mortality rates among non-hispanic whites. There are literally hundreds of studies which show a continuing discriminatory effect on African Americans today, but no one in the media ever makes much of them. Instead they are far more excited about a story that confirms their own stereotypes about angry, ungrateful black men, such as this controversy about Rev. Wright. It is a narrative which fits with a prejudicial mindset regarding African Americans which they have held since childhood. A mindset which they are often unaware is based on bigotry.
Because that is how our society operates. We still work to segregate the races, we just no longer use the law as the primary force to accomplish that end. We whites still grow up with prejudicial views of African Americans, because that is what our families and our media pass down to us. If the racism is less overt in many cases, less open to the public eye, that does not make it any less real, nor any less a destructive force in our society.
Reverend Wright simply committed the ultimate sin for a black man in our country. He told the truth about the racism that still exists in the hearts and minds of many white people. And that is why he has been castigated, and that is why Barack Obama has been forced to denounce and reject his words. Because white people are in denial. We don’t want to hear about this evil, we don’t want to see this evil, and we sure as hell don’t want any “uppity negro” speaking about this evil.
What happened to Reverend Wright and Barack Obama only confirms the truth Rev. Wright spoke back in 2006. And that is the saddest comment on our society today that I can imagine.
Damn straight!
What I hope we have here is an identity crisis where the knee jerk reaction of ostracizing the messenger is replaced with a long look in the mirror.
Not to want to disturb Falwell’s remains, somewhere below raking hot coals for his horned master, but Jerry was fighting against miscegenation long before he got bent out of shape about abortion or gays.
Of course, Wright spoke indelicately, but he talked about what doesn’t get discussed in the polite white world.
all those who are handwring and playing double standard should aither recall Robertson’s statement over 9/11 and Katrina. Also I invite them all to listen in on the religious sermons aired on radio.
In any other country those sermons would be considered hate talk.
McCain gets to keep Pastor Hagee.
I was already on the other side of the fence about not voting for Clinton because of the way she ran her campaign. But when Wright is paraded across the TV sets of America and Hagee and Parsley are not, it isn’t just me who will sit this one out if Clinton gets the nomination. I imagine that the attack on a black preacher who was speaking the truth, and the failure of any Democrat to come to his defense, will cause many more African-Americans to tell the Dems to kiss our collective asses. Democrats can’t win the presidency without the African-American vote.
What’s sad is so-called “progressive” bloggers didn’t even try to understand where Wright was coming from. Many just called him racist and anti-American like some knee-jerk GOP nationalist would.
There are many White Democrats who hold racist views. The dirty little secret that Geraldine Ferraro has forced out in the open.
There’s a reason I no longer post at DailyKos. There’s a reason I would never associate with FDL or OpenLeft. It’s no secret.
Well, I’m glad you post here. Your views and perspective on issues is much valued by me.
I missed it when you left dKos.
Personally I rank OpenLeft as the worst. I’m convinced that they occasionally allow a front page guest post on diversity in the blogosphere for the sole purpose of making it clear that they won’t tolerate any real communication or discussion about diversity in the blogosphere.
It’s a pattern. About every six months a guest poster posts something on the front page and at the very top of the comments is an obnoxious and abusive comment from Matt Stoller berating the diarist for daring to say whatever they said. It’s an excellent way to make clear to their community that they have no interest in those discussions and you, the commenter, should enter into them at your own risk because you will be abused, mocked and ridiculed if you dare.
It’s very effective. It appears from the comments that they’ve achieved a community that is mostly white men. Maybe a few others just for show. But mostly white men.
ripping on them:)
Talking to Stoller was funny…I got the feeling at YK in Vegas that he really couldn’t believe he was wasting his time talking at a black person. I say ‘at’ because as much as I talk, I probably said 4 words and wasn’t even trying to have a conversation with him. That boy loves the sound of his own voice. He could barely look at me and when he did, he’d get this sneer, shake his head and look away. At first I thought it was just me, but the other two people noticed it too. Then I saw him talking to someone else and he was fully engaging. But what sealed it was when he walked in the room and it was me and one other guy. He then wondered a question out loud instead of just asking me point blank. Then got pissy I didn’t answer him.
But you’d have to remember that this is the same guy who answered charges to the severe lack of diversity at YK by continually point out that MARKOS IS LATINO! That still kills me, like when Gina would brag about all the black people on the board of YK and I’m like, “What a load of shit. That’s just me.” And she still didn’t take my suggestions until some other white person weighed in or suggested the same thing later. Ha!
Yeah, the blogosphere is sooooooooo colorblind.
That story doesn’t surprise me. Let’s face it – you were a ‘waste of time’ because (a) you were black, (b) you were a woman and (c) you weren’t either another big name blogger OR someone who could help him become a bigger name blogger (i.e. no fame factor).
I discovered at YKos how many big name male bloggers had no social skills – especially around ‘girls’. I’m shy; but at some point I learned how to pretend I wasn’t shy for at least as long as it took to be polite. They apparently never were forced to learn this. (Exceptions of course for people like k/o, who were great.)
So I can fully picture the scene you describe. You were the double whammy – black AND a woman. I make them nervous; YOU put them into full panic mode. Aaaaaack – must escape as soon as possible!!!! lol 😉
One of my favorite moments at MyDD was when Chris Bowers was forced to admit there was no diversity on the front page at MyDD and then he posted a 736 word job description (yes! 736 words!) that basically boiled down to: only people exactly like Matt Stoller and Jonathan Singer need bother to apply. It was hilarious and sad at the same time.
I saw that bit at DK…ugh. It’s another one of the many reasons I can only take reading orange in small doses.
Like maryb, I’m glad you’re here.
Your absence from the Garish Orange Site is its loss. I’m glad to find you posting here.
Chicago is all Democrat but I wouldn’t drive into Bridgeport and expect some love from my fellow Democrats. I’d expect a bat to the head.
There is no evidence to suggest that Clinton had any part of this.
Jon Stewart on the Daily Show rolled over on this issue and denounced Wright for speaking the truth.
White supremacy is too ingrained in America for the media and even the liberals to even see it. Especially see it in themselves.
Way back in the early 1960’s, while I was still in grade school, I came up with a variation on the national anthem that is as true today as it was when I was a little boy.
My county’s full of shit.
Its run by hypocrites
and fascist creeps.
Land where our fathers lie.
Land where the innocent die,
from hate and greed.
Of these we sing…
You get the idea.
The more things change the more we turn back time.
Infant mortality is only the tip of the iceberg of institutionalized American racism. The real Jim Crow institution is and will always be the Jim Crow War on Drugs that Barack Obama supports more than he repudiates. He has attacked his own minister more forcefully than he has denounced the crime and violence promoting anti democracy drug war.
“Not god bless america but god damn america” is not the truth or the untruth — it is rhetoric, opinion. That was the center of the tempest that blew in when the video surfaced. Did you really think Americans were going to rise up en masse and say yeah, god damn America, and if that’s what Obama thinks he’s my man?
The rev sounds like he sees a lot of realities that whites and strivers of all ethnicities don’t want to hear about. But the rhetoric only makes change all the more impossible. I don’t know how much the rev intended his speech to go beyond his own small circle, but what he ended up accomplishing is scaring voters away from Obama, and from Democrats, and from racial healing. It’s funny how self-styled lefties condemn Kucinich or Nader, for example, for tunning annoying “vanity campaigns”, but then turn around and demand that Obama turn around and support the rants of every windbag who happens to be black.
Actually, I turned away from the Democrats in 1996 when Jim Crow Bill Clinton proudly announced a national record prison population of mostly Black and poor Americans.
Fuck the Democrats and all of their lawn ornament candidates.
There can be no healing when all that healing means is to ignore the festering scabs of historical race and social hate that still stink up the Party.
The Democrats STILL suck shit and Barack Obama proves it to be true with his repudiation of Rev. Wright.
Do you lease a Volvo?
Right now, at the high school just outside my back gate, the Colorado Boulder County delegates are meeting to officially award Democratic National delegates.
We woke up to Hillary signs plastered all up and down the hill and all around the parking lot. Gross pretension.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QFbDpTPd0ac
I really like the way he just goes at this topic head-on, with no dodging or evasiveness. This guy is proving that he can take a punch.
I agree. I personally wish politicians would just all STFU about “god” and Jesus and all the rest of the cult figures, but in the unfortunate reality that is American politics, Obama did a superb job of dealing with this smear attack, and even advancing real discussion. He is in a position that, contrary to fools like Ferraro, takes incredible skill to navigate. Some here are pissed that he refuses to rant like a street anarchist about the real America, but I’d rather see him become president. His candidacy, and the reactions to it, is its own best argument for why this country desperately needs real change at the deepest level.
You’re right. The state of American politics IS an “unfortunate reality”. (And personally, the suffocating, ever-present pall of institutionalized religion makes for a whole lot of “unfortunate”.) Sadly, Wright’s correct about a great many things. But the fact is that even with his repudiation of Wright (which I’m sure Obama did not take doing lightly), I would much prefer to see a President Obama than a Clinton restoration, or (I get nauseous just typing this) a Bush third term by proxy. I would argue there are many more gains that stand to be made by voting for and supporting Obama than by turning away from him over this episode. After all, would Wright himself endorse any other candidate or nominee? And if so, whom?
In addition to that video, I found his interview with Olbermann interesting, where the subtitle says: “Rev. Wright is no longer on Obama Campaign Spiritual Advisory Committee.” I had not realized that Wright was even loosely affiliated with Obama’s campaign, even if Obama says that he was not a political advisor. For the reason of Wright’s remarks about Hillary Clinton alone, Obama is being consistent in removing Wright from any role in his campaign, because he’s done the same with other people in his campaign who’ve gone negative on Clinton.
I am glad to see that whatever remarks Obama has repudiated, he has not denounced his own pastor:
Speaking truth to power in America will never be accepted regarding American white racism. Most of us white folks simply will not allow it.
I was on the verge of supporting Barack Obama until this latest capitulation to the racist dominated American power system.
Rev. Wright is right and Barack Obama is wrong. 100% wrong!
I agree that I was disappointed watching Obama on Countdown last night. Why, I asked myself, is he distancing himself from someone telling the truth? Here’s the answer, one brief sound-bite: “GAWD DAMN AMERICA!” It may be true that the USA deserves damnation but even I don’t like to hear it. And in distancing himself from that one statement, Obama had to renounce the rest.
And what are you going to do? Vote for Hillary or McCain?
I will support any of the anti racist pro social justice candidates of the third parties and Independent campaigns. As I have since 1996.
Voting for Democrats who I know will then spit in my face is no win. For me. Since I do not ever expect to see a president who reflects my social justice values voting for all of the lesser evil candidates just makes me hate myself afterward. So I don’t. I vote for candidates who reflect and respect my social justice values so that these thug Democrats and Republicans will at least have an idea of why I do not vote for them. And they get a count of how many Americans stand for my values. That is the closest thing to a win I can ever expect in any American election.
Here is a Green Party candidate who does reflect and respect MY social justice values. More so that does Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton.
Cynthia McKinney
It really bothers me that Obama can entertain the idea of including pro-torture war criminals like Hagel and Lugar in his cabinent and the media is fine with that, but Rev. Wright bothers them.
Really is interesting how this country defines extremism.
Not sure what is more dangerous-the racist who spews raw racist slurs or the un-racist who chooses to stratigically interject racist remarks, even subtly, into a national discussion then shouts that it is a rhetorical impossibility for an in-racist to utter a racist remark.
I’m thinking neither deserves to be excused.
Can’t help but believe that the Clintons will go the way of Reagan, as Bill did in 1992, and get out the Reagan Democrats to support Hillary. No holds barred for this last chance effort.
I just came down the mountain from Monticello.
They have an excellent tour of the slave quarters (both in the house and where the old houses used to stand). But there are no plaques with Sally Hemings name on them, and only one brief acknowledgment of her in the literature. Her brother is mentioned much more prominently for his cooking abilities.
I have to admit that I was only shocked by all of the “shock and horror” among the chattering class to these remarks of Rev. Wright. I wasn’t offended by most of what he actually said. The “God damn America” was a little over the top, but compared to things we continue to hear from the white evangelical/fundamentalist set, it was very tame.
In fact, he handled 9/11 better than most. While ignorant white Americans who think their country does no wrong in the world wandered around at the time spouting “They hate us for our freedom,” he was preaching to his flock that we should not be “shocked” to see our own sponsorship of terrorism in foreign lands blow-back to our doorstep. (note that he was not claiming that we “deserved” to be attacked, as many white religious leaders did, because of the “gays and abortionists,” etc. If only we had that discussion as a nation at the time… We’d be a much more peaceful and humbler nation today.
I asked my 67-year old Republican dad (who still thinks America’s not ready for a black president) what he thought of the comments. Was he shocked or offended? No. He’s heard all of these things before from others and they’re hard for some to deal with, but true, and need to be said. And he thinks Obama is handling it in a way (denouncing the statements, not the person) that will be the most productive.
We both agreed that when the networks bleeped out the word “nigger” in the statement “Hillary ain’t never been called a nigger” showed the latent prejudice that is all too common in our (rich, white) media-class. The bleeping of that “shameful word” was more offensive than the word itself.
Hopefully we will all learn and grow from this. It’s long overdue and Obama’s the only candidate that can get us to that better place.
Regarding the good Rev. Wright.
My latest post: Barack Obama: The Second Coming of Bill Clinton?
You write:
NOTHING happened to Obama.
Nothing he can’t handle, anyway..
Handle by adopting the winning ways of his opponents, ‘a course.
FUCK that “back of the bus” shit!!!
The Rev. Wright is now officially under the bus.
Rev. Wrong, according to Senator President-In-Waiting Obama.
So it goes.
AG
he’s been hiding his left-wing moorings all the way thru this process, to the point that you don’t even believe he had them. This is no different and no less necessary.
I hope that you are right, Booman.
I really do.
I hoped that you were right about the other Fitzmasses, too.
We shall see…
AG
When, like Obama has, you adopt the arguments and policies of the oppressors in order to be accepted by the supporters of continued oppression then those who really do oppose oppression win nothing by supporting an Obama.
Rev. Wright, like Martin Luther King and Rosa Parks before him, confronted the institutions of continued oppression in America. Obama denounced him for it.
And had my headphones one, headbobs through Depeche Mode, Nirvana, Billy Holiday, Marcia Griffiths…Then my mp3 player got stuck on 3 Mos Def songs, 4 Talib Kweli songs and 3 Common songs…I listened to the songs, these songs of black empowerment and responsiblity and realized they didn’t say anything that Wright didn’t say. Hell, I bet if you take his words and drop them over a dope beat, those same people who got all uptight over them would be wiggling their asses on the dance floor.