If an atheist Occupy Wall Street backer were the new Cinderella star of the National Football League, do you think Fox News would be giving us stories about the guy that said, in effect, “Yeah, I can see why people admire him, and everyone on our side who attacks him is probably just guilt-ridden”? So why do so many “liberal media” stories on Tim Tebow include passages like this?
Decent people who are proud of their faith, do good things and succeed in life tend to irritate some of us; they remind us of our private failures, so, naturally, we hope they stumble.
That’s from Dan Barry in The New York Times today.
And you know what? It’s not true. For one thing, many of us don’t feel guilty that we’ve had premarital sex or use cuss words. Many of us don’t feel guilty that we don’t glorify God incessantly. (Many of us don’t believe in God and are perfectly comfortable about it.)
What tends to irritate us is people who think they’re better than we are, and who incessantly remind us that they feel this way. That’s what’s irritating about Tebow’s public displays of (moral) perfection.
I would argue that even Jesus himself would agree that Tebow’s showoffy sanctimony is wrong. I know Saturday Night Live has made that point in a sketch, but here’s a quote that’s actually from the Bible; I’ve used it many times on this blog in reference to public figures who desperately want you to pay attention to how holy they are, but I can’t think of anyone in public life who’s deserved it more than Tebow. Tim, here’s Luke 18:10-14:
Two men went up into the temple to pray; the one a Pharisee, and the other a publican. The Pharisee stood and prayed thus with himself, God, I thank thee, that I am not as other men are, extortioners, unjust, adulterers, or even as this publican. I fast twice in the week, I give tithes of all that I possess. And the publican, standing afar off, would not lift up so much as his eyes unto heaven, but smote upon his breast, saying, God be merciful to me a sinner. I tell you, this man went down to his house justified rather than the other: for every one that exalteth himself shall be abased; and he that humbleth himself shall be exalted.
He’s talking to you, Tim.
There’s one more passage from the Times story I’d like to point out:
What, exactly, is it about Tim Tebow that so fascinates and provokes us? …
Part of the answer may lie in the way he seems oblivious to the throaty roars that envelop him on and off the field, as though Tebow is always tebowing, whether kneeling or standing up.
Oblivious? Oblivious? That’s ridiculous. I don’t even think Tebow would say he’s “oblivious.” I know enough evangelical boilerplate to say that he’d probably tell you that God wants all believers to proselytize, to proclaim God’s word, and, well, God has blessed him with the tremendous opportunity to do so before tens of thousands of people in football stadiums and millions of people on television, so he’s just doing what the Lord wants.
Yes, he is — as ostentatiously and self-aggrandizingly as humanly possible. Which is what pisses so many of us off.
(X-posted at No More Mister Nice Blog.)
Tebow takes the very very annoying Geezus crap that you see sports figures exhibit to a new, extremely offensive level. He apparently told a teammate that “Geezus said that we would win this game.” That’s not just blasphemy. It’s mental illness.
I honestly do not know why i am supposed to be upset about tim tebow, other than he can’t seem to complete a pass or something.
Maybe I’m missing something, but it seems to me that if the dude wants to wear his religion on his sleeve, who gives a shit? I don’t believe a word of his religion, but I guess I’m with Jefferson, “it does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are twenty gods or no God. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg.”
I would probably feel differently if he were running for office on a mandatory prayer platform. But for now, he doesn’t strike me as any different than any other athlete. Aren’t they always thanking God for home runs, slam-dunks, and TDs?
I find all that “God helped us win” rhetoric to be annoyingly juvenile, as if I’ve stumbled upon some isolated tribe of stone-age people in the Amazon forest.
I want to study them and learn their pantheon of foolish ideas.
But, in my household, the antipathy for Tebow goes back to some anti-choice commercial he did during the Super Bowl. If he wants to get political then it’s not just about Touchdown Jesus anymore.
I hate the Broncos, always have, always will (no offense Steven D) and so I have no problem rooting against Tebow. Frankly, I hated John Elway a thousand times more than any bad feelings I might have towards Tebow. He seems like a nice kid who means well. He’s a great competitor. I don’t hate the guy, but I hope he doesn’t repeat his effort to use his fame to limit women’s rights again.
“as if I’ve stumbled upon some isolated tribe of stone-age people in the Amazon forest.”
Sounds as if Tebow may be channeling John Frum.
“in my household, the antipathy for Tebow goes back to some anti-choice commercial he did during the Super Bowl. If he wants to get political then it’s not just about Touchdown Jesus anymore. “
yeah, that’s fucking douchey. That antipathy i can understand.
Dude got humiliated today. I’m satisfied.
.
Tebow didn’t play well. He finished 9-for-26 for 136 yards. Bible’s prophecy …
Tebowmania ended with a thud.
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
my understanding was he never plays well.
Why I’m pulling for the Packers to win the Superbowl (sorry BooMan).
Why it is so irritating, to a lot of Christians (and no doubt evanglelicals as well), is that it isn’t evanglism; it’s marketing a brand. And that brand conflates Tim Tebow and Jesus Christ. It’s offensive because it’s trying to brand Jesus with the values of Tim Tebow.
I am bothered by his success because Tebow and his minions seem to think it proves there is such a thing as a god. So when he crashes and burns does that mean there is no god? I never thought the Denver Broncos would be the key to “Life, the Universe and Everything”.
“the key to “Life, the Universe and Everything”.
Dang! All along I thought it was 42. I’m truly devastated!
There are lots of posts everywhere about Tebow, so I have nothing original to add. But I would be curious about how all the Tebow fans would feel if he was a Muslim who faced Mecca and knelt down to give thanks after he threw a touchdown pass.
The NFL would pass a rule to ban it. As they already have for ostentatious celebrations. Ostentatious prayer, however, is now making them a lot of money in merchandise sales, so they’re just ducky with it.
I’ll give Tebow credit – with an apparently limited skill set, he has a ferocious competitive streak that’s won Denver a string of games. However, I have a thing about proselytizers, and he’s the most obnoxious one to come along in a long, long time. I also find him hypocritical – he’s going out of his way to call attention to himself by supposedly deflecting all credit to his God. And, as Boo mentioned, his faith is not neutral – he’s already leveraged his fame to advocate against women’s rights. I hope he crashes and burns, big time.
Go, Satan. Beat State!
WHO CARES? He is a football player. He is not anyone you NEED to pay attention to or read a NY Times article on. I have successfully avoided reading anything about him because I don’t care about sports figures. I watch Soccer when I really have nothing to do on a weekend. I gave up watching football when the game became so stultifying that talking to a bag of tortilla chips became more interesting. If Dan Barry is wrong, who cares, go read about something that matters, like Japan’s stupid whaling decisions or light bulb regulations, or FSM forfend, how to solve the gridlock in congress or NDAA. Sports figures are just there to anesthetize and distract. And in the USA, it seems to work pretty well. So instead of worrying about the fact that a writer’s angle or presumptions are somehow wrong or dissonant with your view, move on to something that matters more and irritates more. Because worrying about what press Tebow is getting is a waste of time and I am sure you have better things to do.
I’ve got nothing against Tebow. Seems like a nice kid. Really cool that he openly declared his virginity; that takes guts. That he participated in some ridiculous commercial; whatever. The guy isn’t going to magically make the right wing fundamentalist agenda become law.
I admire his personal strength and ability to stand in what he believes, even though I don’t agree with it. I am glad he didn’t win the Stupid Bowl though. Man, those right wing Christian fundamentalist types would have become more sanctimonious than they already are.