.
My earlier diary: Murder of French Cézus/Areva Manager, A Mossad Hit in France? The French murder investigation has gone nowhere and has been covered on a French blog with now 5000+ comments – On Sept. 5, four people were brutally murdered near Chevaline, a village in Haute-Savoie, France.
[Update2]
-
BREAKING NEWS – I found an extended article in Arabic over the Saad al-Hilli family from someone
who knows the family history and befriended Saad in the last decade. See my comment below … * link
I don’t recall a mention on this blog, but others have written about a D-notice censoring the British press and an helicopter flight from Chambéry Airport to Geneve with three assassins shortly after the Chevaline massacre.
No trace left of D-notice at Indymedia UK. From a number of blogs a reference is made to a journalist from Manchester, however no links or names are given. Searching the Internet I found this “hidden comment” at Indymedia – The UK failed to protect Saad al Hilli. I can hardly believe this is the original article link as the post makes no sense. Unless someone can provides us with substantiated information, I’ll have to disregard the D-notice as false.
Iranian and Israeli Propaganda
A number of blogs copied a single statement and the only reference I could find it came from a single source, the Iranian state propaganda outlet Press TV. It’s interesting to note the fact it was in Iranian news is a worthwhile given. The (mis)information is …
“I copied the few commments on the indymedia site, earlier, just after the DA-notice comment from ‘Manchester based Journalist’, but not including the comment of 15:12 quoted by Anon here, concerning General Yossi Ben Hanan (chief of defence at Paris Israeli embassy) picking up three unknown others in helicopter at Chambrey Airport (close to the scene).”
This information was rehashed on a few blogs known for far fetched conspiracy theories. In the international media, there were just seldom a mention of Iranian or Israeli link to the Annecy killings. The British media did go after the Iraqi al-Hilli family and were just as conspirational, without any facts or simple analysis, there must be a link to the billions of Saddam Hussein and the Baath party stashed away in Switzerland or Caribbean tax havens.
The Iranian article, which I didn’t find, mentioned Yossi Ben Hanan in Paris. That is not speculative, he is operating within France for businees opportunities between France and Israel.
TEL AVIV (MarketWatch) — Flying under the radar is helping to put Israel’s defense firms very clearly on the map. Stealth technology, including unmanned aerial vehicles, is a specialty for Israeli military technologists, who will be displaying these intelligence-gathering devices, along with other wares, at the Paris Air Show
“For the past 60 years, Israel has been a combat laboratory,” said Yossi Ben Hanan, a retired major general and head of Sibat, an Israeli agency that coordinates defense-related exports and cooperation for the government. Yechiel Assia, director-general of the Israel Export & International Cooperation Institute in Tel Aviv, says innovation has been born out of the country’s conflicts.
Who’s showing what at Paris Air Show
At a recent news conference, David Arzi, chairman of the institute, said the 11 Israeli companies exhibiting at the Paris Air Show could sign as much as $800 million in new contracts there. See slideshow of aircraft offerings at Paris. The companies are Aeronautics Defense Systems, Bental, Elbit Systems and its Tadiran Communications subsidiary, Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI), Orbit Technology, Plasan Sasa, Rada, Rafael, SGD Engineering, and Star Defense Systems.
Major Gen. [Res.] Yossi Ben Hanan is on record as having witnessed Dagan killing his captives in a heinous way. Also, after their release from duty, several Israeli soldiers who committed serious crimes stated they were influenced by the horror of what they saw and what they were ordered to do by Dagan.
Furthermore, I’m not happy learning so little about the AMS 1087 enterprise, director James Barnett and secretary Saad al-Hilli. The office building is located on MoD government property, area well known for its nuclear underground shelter. More to follow …
- Ams 1087 Ltd – Aerial Photographers & Surveys in Swindon SN5 7XG
- SSTL Paper – A High Performance EO Small Satellite Platform & Optical Sensor Suite [pdf]
- Satellite Spots Syria’s Iranian-Made Drones – July 2012
- Did Iran spy on French Alps murder victim’s satellite firm?
What about Israel and its media? I had provoked my readers by linking early on to the possibility of a Mossad hit on both Sylvain Mollier and Saad al-Hilli because of a possible collusion in espionage of Cézus/Areva secrets. However a long-shot, in the past 3,5 months the police investigation has been puzzling and has provided few to no answers to what took place that fatal afternoon.
JC Online: Conspiracy theories, Mossad and the tragic Al-Hilli murder by Jennifer Lipman
Contrary to Iran speaking out, the Israeli media which is under military censorship was unusually silent. I did check on a daily/weekly basis and never was the Annecy murders mentioned. This too is worthwhile noticing. In my diary at Booman, there was one reaction from a journalist focused on Western media issues with Israel. That article is written in the attack mode accusing the western journalists and pundits of knee-jerk reaction to Israel, anti-Israel bias and of course the anti-semitism accusation. This too is telling us something. There are just too many coincidences of the persons present at parking Martinet when the shooting started. Which person holds the key to this heinous crime?
Update [2012-12-26 05:05:55 by Oui]: Changed title to diary from “End of the Year : Loose Ends Circumstances Annecy Killings”
Alps murder: Truth about Saad al-Hilli’s’family feud’
BAGHDAD (The Telegraph) Dec. 23, 2012 – Journalist Colin Freeman visited Iraq and talked to family members of Saad al-Hilli.
The theory goes that Saad, a Shia Muslim who was strongly anti-Israeli and supportive of Iran and their Lebanese militia allies, Hizbollah, might have accessed sensitive technology secrets of use to Israel’s enemies.
“We used to discuss politics in our online conversations, and I was surprised by how radical he was – he was very supportive of Palestine, Hizbollah and Iran,” said Hussain. “If he tried to give his technology to one of those Middle Eastern powers, he would incur the anger of their rivals. I have no proof of this, but if he was stuck between them, there could be some consequences.”
Hussain al-Hilli points the finger at Israel, saying Mossad would not hesitate to wipe out anyone offering to help Tehran, just as they have done with scientists involved in Iran’s nuclear programme. Others, though, think that if Saad had been hawking secrets around, it is just as likely that he fell foul of those he was trying to sell them to, either because the deal went sour for some reason, or to silence him afterwards.
(The Independent) Dec. 25, 2012 – A targeted killing? Investigators are convinced that the murderer was already on the scene and could not have known the random itinerary of the holidaying al-Hillis that day. Investigations of a family quarrel or an Iraqi connection – exaggerated by some press reports – have come to nothing so far. The same goes for the French cyclist, Sylvain Mollier, who was trying out a new route and lost his way. Despite insistent reports to the contrary, French investigators say that they are “99.9%” sure that Mr Mollier was not the gunman’s prime target.
A professional killer? The gun was an antique: a Swiss army Luger from the 1920s or earlier. It fell apart in the gunman’s hands. Fragments of it were found at the scene. One of them has recently yielded a trace of DNA, which may yet help trace the attacker. On the other hand, that DNA may belong to Zainab al-Hilli, aged seven, who was beaten and left for dead.
[Killer X left no traces of dna on the victims or at the crime scene. This would indicate a well planned and military or professional hit – Oui]
Diary about the Mossad “Free Zone” at Schiphol Amsterdam Airport – Airport and Telecom Security Run by Mossad.
Tags: SIBAT Paris General Yossi Ben Hanan–Chambéry Airport– More Aeronautics near Annecy crime scene?
.
This will keep interest in the mass killing for the next few weeks. Interesting, reporter went to Iraq meeting distant family members and visited the home in Baghdad, Adamiyah district.
The route taken by the assassination investigation: French pointing finger at UK al-Hilli family – British at Saddam Hussein money laundering and source in Iraq – Iraqi family in Baghdad deny link to Saddam’s billions as baseless and offer UK SSTL and EADS industry, pro-Iran stance and a intelligence hit (Mossad). The UK wall of silence, his contract job in the aeronautics industry and MI5 scrutiny. Back to square one.
It is clear from this article Kadhim al-Hilli was a prosperous man in his own right, a business man and anti-Saddam Hussein as I have stated from the start.
A development project has been proposed in 2012 for this district of Baghdad: Av62 spanish architects and Adhamiya project in Baghdad plus video.
Have thought about this — not that I’ve gotten anywhere, not surprising given the paucity of information released. What I can’t get beyond is that it was an exceedingly unlikely location for the vacationing al-Hilli family to journey to either by design for sightseeing or by accident. The entrance to that road is clearly marked that it’s narrow and an a dead-end for cars. However, it was reported to be a frequently used cut-through path and road for cyclists. Reports that I saw suggested that the British cyclist said that a car passed him as he approached the site which suggests that both cyclists were traveling from the road to the path, but that report could have been in error and they were traveling in the opposite direction from the path to the road.
The al-Hilli family was at the site some time before the first cyclist. Up to an hour before but no less than half an hour before. So, we can discount that the killer(s) arrived earlier and was laying in wait for al-Hilli. What can’t be discounted is that it was a rendezvous. With whom? For what?
Mollier and al-Hilli? If so, why bring the family? If it were some espionage hand-off rendezvous between the two, it seems unlikely that Mollier would have proceeded in the presence of al-Hilli’s family.
.
Escape route white car (Peugeot 206/306?) witnessed near Chevaline
Video taken in front of the home of Sylvie Lecoeur. Location is in Chevaline, intersection of Chemin rural dit de la Grande Combe and Chemin du Moulin. The supermarkt was located in Doussard (time stamp 16:00 hrs), perhaps Supermarché Au Regal de Savoie a 3 min. drive to the point where she met the white car. So the white car traveled on Chemin de la Corbette / Chemin rural du Pré des Granges à Ugeret. In Armand he made a left on Chemin rural de Chevaline à Armand from where in a sharp right turn he would meet Sylvie Lacoeur at the intersection with Route de Chevaline. Escape route via Doussard on Route de Pont Monnet (D281) and turns left on Route d’Annecy (D1508). This is a major route Ugine – Faverges – Annecy.
Oops, missing link of map Shopi supermarché in Doussard, looking towards mountain range and Route de la Combe d’Ire. So unlikely an experienced cyclist as Sylvain Mollier lost his way and “taken the wrong road” as prosecutor Eric Maillaud told the media. Too many instances of misinformation leaked to the press as speculation gained momentum.
BTW Using Google-maps satellite viewer gives a good impression of roads and Route de Chevaline up to bottom of hill (multilingual sign) leading to parking and crime scene.
.
[Translation from Arabic through Google with some minor necessary correcyions – Oui]
.
Start here at link of my comment …
@Peter – Quite interesting, did you do a reverse lookup on this email account?
Perhaps as demonstrated by Gen. Petraeus and Paula Broadwell recently, via a mutual email account exchange messages through concept emails without sending them.
If Saad al-Hilli was naive about net security, I would not be surprised by the Nigerian hacking his bank account and what about any foreign intelligence agency tracking Saad al-Hilli for many years and through gps knew exactly his whereabouts traveling across France to Annecy and set up an ambush as soon as he arrives at the isolated location of layby Martinet parking beyond Chevaline.
.
From Marilyn C. Tomlins’ blog: Family cousin and other family speaks out
@Sophia Thanks for your contribution and interest in this murder case. Have you seen my comment @Booman Tribune? It is a Google translation from an article written in Arabic by Hussein al-Hilli mid-November. Link to the original Arabic article can be provided by Marilyn Z. Tomlins by email.
Google translation is pretty off mark. From Arabic to English “al-Hilli” translates to “ornaments” and “son” is seen as “daughter”. I don’t mind that much, I get the intention of the article after re-reading it, but may miss some important clues.
My analysis of Saad al-Hilli’s mindset is his strong pro-Shia religious feelings. Therefore he has become very upset by the so-called Arab Spring, an uprising of Arabs seen as a Sunni revival, sworn enemy of Shia in Iraq and Iran. The hardship in Syria is primarily caused by the foreign fighters or Sunni Jihadists coming from all over the world to overthrow the Assad regime. Money and arms flowing to this cause from Western powers in conjunction with the GCC countries. The opinion voiced by Saad al-Hilli towards the Palestinian cause is where both Shia and Sunni share the same emotional, political and religious concern.
This strong fundamental belief by Saad al-Hilli determines his path in life and preference towards returning to Iraq or perhaps even living in Iran, a country it is rumored he had recently visited (on his Iraqi passport?).
Could it be Saad al-Hilli with family attempted to flee Britain and tried to escape with the money in his father’s Swis bank account? I still keep open the option he had a meeting set up with Sylvain Mollier at the isolated layby Martinet near Chevaline. The fact that SM was employed by Cézus/Areva has been negated by a lot of misinformation. The French investigators, family, colleagues and friends have been hiding behind a wall of silence. A politically motivated and foreign intelligence asassination still can’t be discounted.
I definitely think Saad al-Hilli has been monitored by foreign intelligence especially since the Adlene Hicheur case I mentioned in earlier comments [Oui 12-28-2012 at 01:40:17]. Both had worked at Rutherford’s Laboratory. The intelligence “vetting” process is continuous and unrelenting. It is even possible secrecy concern was the reason SAH was let go from his contract work at SSTL.
I fully agree with your statement …
In regards to Arabic translations:
FIRST and FOREMOST, you can often discern events, etc. by assessing what is NOT BEING SAID, and by WHO is NOT talking! Sometimes translations exist when not one verbal cue is initiated. When you learn to “see” that language, understanding becomes more apparent, as does misunderstanding when cues are misread! A deaf person SEES FAR MORE than the average person!
.
Iran has a well educated population and are established in scientific research. One engineer from Surrey won’t make a difference unless he could provide specific knowledge of SSTL satellite imagery research.
The Mail on Sunday has discovered that in December Mr Al-Hilli visited a sub-division of SSTL called DMC International Imaging, which has recently signed a contract with the Chinese to help map the country via satellite imagery. DMC also has a lucrative satellite-mapping deal with Russia and is working with the Foreign Office in Afghanistan to monitor illicit opium poppy cultivation. Mr Al-Hilli, a civilian contractor, has worked as a mechanical design engineer at SSTL for the past two years and was popular with colleagues. Several are listed as his friends on Facebook, but mysteriously none posted any comments on a tribute page set up on the social networking site.
.
Post Zainab
12-30-2012 at 10:44:59
Oui / Marilyn & all…
Here is my translation for the article… Hope it helps.
Zainab
——————————————-
.
Visitors reading my diary @Booman here and here. Many times the referring URL is from the Marilyn Z. Tomlins blog.
Sitemeter reveals IP address of server location of provider linked to readers. Interesting to find out a few locations are in desert regions of the US, Bahrain and Israel. In some instances the IP address appears to reveal an intelligence service. Other instances, the IP link is hidden and “Unknown” appears on the listing.
Locations as Southern Governate Bahrain – Central Informatics Organisation or a military complex Ames Research Center at Moffett Field in California. When you live on an estate, it may even reveal the individual as this example in Switzerland. This global interest continues daily and my first dairy has been shared 314 times of which an uptick of 43 in the last 10 days!
Marilyn your blog has become a center piece of trust and a great discussion with some depth. A jewel to continue into the new year. I fully agree with the above contributors.
[cross-posted from French blog]
.
Commission for Independent Research and Information on Radioactivity (CRIIRAD)
h/t blog CM
Issue of Trait d’Union in 2003
“L’obligation de subir nous donne le Droit de Savoir” Jean Rostand (1894-1977)
Lists under its index:
Compte rendu de l’A.G.
Sylvain Mollier p. 44 à 45
Unfortunately the pdf found has pages no. 1 thu 23. Possibly an issue can still be bought from CRIIRAD website
Série Tchernobyl (5 numéros du Trait d’Union + la fiche couleurs Tchernobyl)
N° 25/26 (2003) (numéro double)
Dossiers : Bélarus
Compte rendu de mission
En avril dernier, deux représentants de la CRIIRAD se sont rendus au Bélarus, pays le plus touché par la catastrophe de Tchernobyl.
Mobilisation pour la libération du Pr. Youri Bandazhevsky
La mobilisation internationale commence à porter ses fruits et plusieurs éléments nous portent à l’optimisme.
Solidarité des élèves de Drôme et Ardèche en faveur des enfants du Bélarus
En 2002, la CRIIRAD a lancé un appel à la solidarité afin de recueillir des fonds destinés à financer les cures de pectine de pomme.
Dossiers : Sang contaminé
La faillite judiciaire
L’arrêt rendu le 18 juin 2003 par la Cour de cassation confirme le non-lieu général prononcé le 4 juillet 2002 par la Cour d’appel de Paris.
Dossiers : Le Blayais (Etude critique de l’évaluation de l’impact du Centre Nucléaire de Production d’Electricité du Blayais – Gironde)
Plus a cryptic comment here:
Par 82ndAirborne
30 | 10 | 2012 à 07:39
CriiRad…reprends l’affaire à zéro…ça va être vite expédié….
.
Another document found:
CRIIRAD – Proces-verbal des Deliberations du Conseil d’Administration dd Nov. 17, 2006
Présents ou représentés (R) :
Muarice BECAMEIL, Romain CHAZEL, Jacqueline COLLARD, Michel CONTANT, Pierre COULOMB (R), Roland DESBORDES, Pierre FERRANDON,
Luc LESQUIR, Catherine MANEVAL (R), Martial MAZARS (R), Sylvain MOLLIER, Jacques REDOUX (R), Alain REY-GALIAY.
Invitée : Corinne CASTANIER (directrice, non votante)
Absents : Jran Pierre MOURAT, Philippe PERRIN
Dossier : MALVESI / COMHUREX
This is about radiactive contamination of a plant site – dissidentmedia.org
L’usine de traitement d’uranium de Malvési célèbre son anniversaire et se prépare à franchir une étape importante de son existence
avec le lancement du plan Comurhex II – filiale d’Aréva – visant à la modernisation et l’extension du site.
.
Do not come near France’s national interest in the nuclear industry or you will be eliminated – see Mali.
A new link pursued in the motive for the Chevaline murders that “baffles” the French police investigation.
Cross-posted from the French blog – Marilyn Z. Tomlins.
That has been my assumption also and we have looked at other venues which led nowhere. What would have been so important for SAH and SM to meet in person that could not have been exchanged in digital form? Just about any document can be digitalized, names of nuclear scientists or CRIIRAD “secrets” could have found its way to Dubai, Baghdad or Teheran. In France the large group of immigrants from North Africa and the Middle-East makes an exchange of data and transport easy.
In the line of work of Saad al-Hilli, he could have been under MI5 watch and all movements and travel plans scrutinized. If Sylvain Mollier did indeed do work for CRIIRAD, these memebers most certainly would be followed closely by France DSGE intelligence. Just look at the links above, the group works closely with Greenpeace on the nuclear contamination issue in France and Niger (Aréva mining). We all remenber what the fate was of the Rainbow Warrior with later no regrets by the French leadership. DCGE agents were promoted after their brief imprisonment on a Pacific island. Although Israel and the Mossad might have been interested in the job, I believe it to be executed at the local French/Swiss level. The gun used and forensics should indicate the killer’s origin.
Eric Maillaud, frustrated by pursuing the long odds and interviewing hundreds of out-patients from the French/Swiss mental asylums has now decided the lone biker who has not come forward as the likely candidate as killer X. Bravo for the French! Four months on and counting …