Things have really sped up for the Mideast Peace Train in the last 36 hours. John Kerry, the US SoS, visited Israel to talk to PM Netanyahu, on the unscheduled way to Geneva to finalize the first stages of an Iranian accord with the P5+1. While in Israel he gave an interview to reporters from Israeli TV Channel 2 and the Palestinian Broadcasting Corp. His forthright words sent a shockwave through the Ziosphere.
Some straight talk from Kerry…
Kerry: Why do you want to build in what will eventually be Palestine?
US Secretary of State John Kerry launched an unusually pointed public attack on Israeli policies in the West Bank Thursday, calling settlements “illegitimate” and warning that if current peace talks fail, Israel could face a third intifada and growing international isolation. Kerry made the comments during a joint interview with Israel’s Channel 2 and the Palestinian Broadcasting Corporation.
“I know there’s cynicism. I know so many people don’t believe anything I just said… And I know there are people who have grown used to this,” Kerry said, referring to the current relatively peaceful stalemate in Israeli-Palestinian relations. And particularly in Israel. Israel says, `Oh we feel safe today. We have the wall, we’re not in a day-to-day conflict, we’re doing pretty well economically.’
“Well, I’ve got news for you,” he said, referring to the Israeli public. “Today’s status quo will not be tomorrow’s or next year’s. Because if we don’t resolve this issue, the Arab world, the Palestinians, neighbors, others, are going to begin again to push in a different way.”
Some Israeli pundit response….
Frustrated Kerry’s Peace Critique A Heavy Slap In Netanyahu’s Face
A patently bitter secretary of state asks why Israel keeps taking Palestinian land, and why the Israeli public doesn’t seem to care about it.
For the first time since he managed to restart the talks in July, Kerry dropped his statesman-like public impartiality, and clearly spoke from the heart — and what emerged were a series of accusations that amounted to a forceful slap in the face for Netanyahu. It was a rhetorical onslaught that the prime minister cannot have expected and one he will not quickly forget.
For Netanyahu, watching Kerry’s from-the-heart interview must have topped what was already a pretty lousy day. In Geneva, the six world powers were inching toward a deal with the Iranians that the prime minister fears would leave Tehran with an enrichment capability even as the sanctions are eased — something Netanyahu considers a “historic error.”
More Israeli media response…..
Kerry Slams Israel’s West Bank Policies, Warns Of 3rd Intifada
Turning to settlements and Israel’s presence in the West Bank, he added: “If we do not resolve the question of settlements, and the question of who lives where and how and what rights they have; if we don’t end the presence of Israeli soldiers perpetually within the West Bank, then there will be an increasing feeling that if we cannot get peace with a leadership that is committed to non-violence, you may wind up with leadership that is committed to violence.”
He also said ongoing settlement construction risked creating the sense that Israel was not “serious” about wanting a permanent accord. The US, he stressed, considers “settlements are illegitimate” and believes that “the entire peace process would be easier if these settlements were not taking place.
So how does all this sit with Netanyahu? He gave a short youtube video response here, in which he said… (My bold)
“I understand the Iranians are walking around very satisfied in Geneva — as well they should because they got everything and paid nothing, everything they wanted. They wanted relief of sanctions after years of grueling sanction regime, they got that. They paid nothing because they are not reducing in any way their nuclear enrichment capability. So Iran got the deal of the century and the international community got a bad deal.
LOL, those Iranians are better Jews than we are! (snark) Wingnut tears, so sweet. (If they don’t go all Samson on our asses!)
.
My new diary – Obama On Way Towards Grand-Slam In Diplomacy.
If John Kerry and Sergey Lavrov illustrate their determination …
STEP 1 – Resolve CW issue on Syria
STEP 2 – Arms embargo and a political solution for Syria
STEP 3 – Resolve nuclear issue of Iran with president Rouhani
STEP 4 – Finalize a peace treaty between Israel and Palestine
Obama made a courageous decision stepping away from 35 years of biased US policy on the Middle East.
Angry Arab states Saudi Arabia, UAE, Qatar plus Turkey and Israel. Praise from Russia, Iran and Iraq (Maliki).
With Kerry might be best to wait awhile after he “talks tough” to see what gets done. Mere months after doing Israel’s and KSA’s bidding by bellowing for Asssad’s head, he’s now ready to throw Israel and KSA under the bus? But his “tough talk” was limited to “ongoing settlement construction” which isn’t different from decades of US hand-wringing as Israel gobbled up more and more territory. Israel will treat it like just another line in the sand that is easy enough to cross.
I disagree. The Israelis are too shrewd to not see the handwriting on the wall. They have always, deep down, feared this day. Kerry’s words mark, quite decidedly, the ‘tipping point’ that has been yearned for so long by so many. Remember, Obama is a Time Master. He is adept at feeling the shifts in the public sentiment and acting at the perfect time to make the transitions in question with minimal blowback. That’s the reasoning behind “keep your friends close, but your enemies closer” that the good Godfather relies on. The dust-up with the Hegel nomination showed the way forward by exposing the Lobby ever more plainly to the American people. Remember that Sat Night Live skit that didn’t make it to live TV but was prominently seen on the web? Would you blow the donkey for Israel? So who will stand up for war now? It’s getting down to neo-cons and zionists now. And don’t think that Democratic Lib-Zio Senators won’t be feeling the heat. They will be talking big for a little while longer but they won’t want to be cast as fellow travelers of the Zionists soon enough.
Nope. This is a consequence of the US-Israel-KSA pact overplaying its hand in Syria and Russia and China saying “not this time.” Erdogan getting cold feet with his new BFF. Cameron unable to deliver approval for the bombing. Hollande befuddled and punked.
Putin saved Obama’s butt and the price for the rescue is but some serious negotiations with Iran and possibly a cessation of more land grabs and settlement construction building in the remaining Palestinian territories.
Im not sure a U.S. Secretary of State has ever spoken out so truthfully to Israel. Right on John Kerry! We need to start worrying about our moral standing with Palestine. Israel has some wacko Nazi mentality when it comes to the suffering in Gaza and the West Bank.
Bibi Netanyahu the bully is getting blowback from the administration now. Speak to our congress and get standing ovations. Our own president speaks and hillbillies are yelling liar from the gallery. Time to have a policy in the Middle East more in tune to our own interests and not Israel’s. Geneva looks promising.
That was the feeling I got when I saw those stories. I said to myself “Kerry said what?!” The tone is completely different than what anyone in the US Gov has spoken before. Coming out from under the hasbara umbrella into a new day.
.
Well, that’s certainly true. You can’t be an honest broker if you are not at least cowering under, if not actively spouting, the hasbara of the moment. That is the natural order process, or am I uninformed? (s)
Kerry has certainly gone off the reservation there. His tone was so extraordinarily different and discordant that it was instantly recognizable to those watching the scene. And he spoke directly to the people! The nerve of it.