While it’s true that there is a new breed of Democrat in the U.S. Senate, and that the senators who have been elected post-Iraq fiasco are infused with quite a lot more backbone than their predecessors, the reason that Harry Reid was finally able to pull the trigger on the nuclear option is because the oldest and longest-serving senators in the body were finally convinced it was necessary. The oldest sitting senator is Diane Feinstein, and she was not an easy sell.
“There are many of us that really wanted to keep things the way they were, because that’s the way they were,” said Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.). “One thing I know: that you learn from history. And right now we can’t let the present be the future. So you’ve got to make the change, or this becomes a body that doesn’t mutate.”
That’s kind of an odd way of putting it, especially since mutations are usually a problem and the abuse of the filibuster was basically an unwelcome mutation in Senate norms. Yet, I understand Sen. Feinstein’s point. Sen. Patrick Leahy is the President pro tempore and has served in the Senate for nearly 39 years. He, too, was very reluctant to change the rules, but, as the chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, he is responsible for ushering President Obama’s nominees onto the courts. Unless the rules were changed, he could not do his job.
Other long-serving senators went along, too. Among them, Max Baucus (34 years), Tom Harkin and Jay Rockefeller (28 years), and Barbara Mikulski (26 years), all saw no alternative to changing the filibuster rule. Of the true old-timers, only Carl Levin of Michigan could not be convinced that the nuclear option was necessary.
What distinguishes the younger generation of Democrats isn’t so much that they are less tolerant of obstruction, but that they are less likely to let themselves get pushed around. Here’s the youngest senator, talking about dealing with the Republicans’ antics:
“There’s a time to reach across the aisle and there’s a time to hold the line,” said Sen. Christopher S. Murphy (D-Conn.), the body’s youngest member at 40, who was elected in 2012. “And I think so far this year Democrats in the Senate have done a very good job of mixing across-the-aisle compromise with some heretofore unseen spine-stiffening.”
The time has come for Democrats to take a harder stance against the tea party Republicans, he said.
“These folks have come to Washington to destroy government from within and will use any tool at their disposal,” Murphy said. “To the extent that we have the ability to take tools away from the tea party, we should do it. And one of the tools was the filibuster. Another was the belief that Democrats would cave in the face of another shutdown or debt default.”
For Murphy, the failure of the Senate gun control bill earlier this year was the final straw. He took on the issue of gun violence after the Newtown school shooting in his state in 2012. A bipartisan bill crafted by Sens. Joe Manchin III (D-W.Va.) and Patrick J. Toomey (R-Pa.) had 55 votes but failed to advance.
“I was a proponent of filibuster reform coming into the Senate, but I became a revolutionary on this issue when we lost the gun bill,” Murphy said.
The new generation lives in less fear and is willing to fight. Maybe it’s because they weren’t scarred by the Carter/Mondale/Dukakis elections or by the post-Sept. 11 bullying of color-coded terror charts, duct tape, and mushroom clouds, or maybe it’s because the progressive wing of the party got organized online and began to carve out a space in the national dialogue that made it permissible to be a liberal again.
Whatever it was, I welcome this new development.
A strong progressive movement offers Democratic politicians a choice:
You’re going to get bullied by Republicans or you’re going to get bullied from the left by your own party’s liberal wing. Either way, you’re going to get bullied, so you might as well go along with the potential bullies who presumably share your basic impulses.
The progressive wing of the party can meet in a phone booth, and still have room for the DJ and cash bar.
Ask President Dean.
Well, they do that every year at Netroots Nation, which occurs at some pretty swanky phone booths if that’s what you call them.
And where do you find a phone booth anymore, even one of those little 2-ft shelters with a phone under it? That idiom is going seem pretty archaic in a decade.
Ah, President Dean, the chief executive who followed President Nader and preceded President Stein. Of course, President Warner, who did host a swank room at one of the first Netroot Nation events, has tremendously benefited from bringing that DJ and cash bar.
Dean had the support of every right-thinking progressive and every real Democrat.
Which isn’t enough to get the nomination, never mind win the general election.
It’s funny — he only reason people get to complain about Obama selling them out is because he sold them out. Absent that, you don’t get to do it in the first place.
It is not enough if you can’t sell the good folks of Iowa in the Iowa Democratic Caucus. Remember, Dean came in third in Iowa.
The key to making it happen is making Iowa, New Hampshire, other early primary states progressive enough in their political culture to elect a progressive Democratic candidate. Third parties also have to assemble a sufficient number of electoral votes, which also requires transforming the political culture of a sufficient number of states.
As long as the game is money, “selling out” sufficient to assemble the resources to win in as you say inevitable.
Progressive can’t sit comfortable in the left coast and New York enclaves and think that they will ever have national power over policy. There is a substantial amount of work on changing the political culture required. And that requires destigmatizing some of the words used to dismiss progressives, like “liberal” and “socialist”.
A helpful exercise for progressive is to figure out how to conduct that transformation in a small, deep-red state. The one that would make the MSM’s heads’ explode would be a progressive Congressional delegation from Mississippi as well as a progressive governor. At the moment, the mayor of Jackson MS is a progressive, but that is the limit of the base there.
Dean shouldn’t have bothered with Iowa. Iowa is all about local politicking and getting to know local party bosses. Joe Trippi (after playing Hamlet with “to compete or not compete”) thought having outsiders go door to door with personal stories would win the day. If Dean had kept the national campaign going and acted like Iowa got more attention than it deserved, he in all likelihood would have won New Hampshire and would have been poised to win the nomination. The caveat is we don’t know the lengths the national media would have gone to destroy him.
Iowa only matters if a candidate acts like it does. Watch: Chris Christie won’t bother with it beyond token appearances. Dealing with a caucus of a small state that elects candidates in an irregular fashion is a tremendous waste of resources. A victory there only matters if it is hotly contested.
Our number one concern, within the Congressional leadership, should be Rep Steve Israel, the DCCC chair. He is blocking a major leftward shift potential by his poor and corrupt handling of the DCCC affairs. A little ‘game’ that TPTB run goes like this….
We won’t run anybody to defeat your head guys as long as it goes both ways.
So for Steve Israel, that means that even though he is in a 0 PVI district AND there are 9 such districts AND The NRCC is running a candidate in all the other 0 PVI districts, isn’t he lucky?
Howie over at DownWithTyranny has been shouting out about this disaster for a while now.
Nancy! Wake Up! Wake Up!
Someone needs to remind Steve Israel that there are 435 seats in the House of Representatives and wave elections have been lost by not having a candidate to take advantage of the new public mood. And that he doesn’t have folks figuring out how to take down Steve King, Michele Bachmann, Louis Goehmert, Virginia Foxx, and Darrell Issa, he’s just warming a seat and checking a box on his resume. That sort of malpractice in other times would earn him a primary.