A journal of an attempted campaign–
crossposted at http://robfornj.com
I write this in advance of anticipated disappointment. I have one more day to achieve a signature goal, and barring a miracle I’m not going to reach it.
Perhaps I should start from the beginning. It has been my intent to run as a Democratic Candidate for New Jersey’s first Congressional District in the United States Congress. I harbored no illusion that I had more than a thousand-to-one shot of winning a race like this, I merely hoped that I could make some noise and draw attention to some key national issues from the progressive left side, and show at least some token opposition to the George Norcross machine. A bit about George Norcross– anyone can Wikipedia or Google him, but noteworthy to mention is that he is Chairman of one of the largest insurance brokerage firms in the country, Chairman of the board of Cooper Health System, and majority owner of the Philadelphia Inquirer. He is known as the unofficial head of the South Jersey Democrats, and could be the most powerful man in the state.
My impetus for running was a moment of disgust– I’ll let others judge if that disgust was warranted or naïve. Until February 4th 2014, the 1st District seat had been held by Rob Andrews. Facing an ethics investigation in the house, Andrews announced his resignation as of February 18. This had the immediate effect of making the house investigation go way and let Andrews plan a soft landing at a regional law firm.
Within 15 minutes of the news breaking (give or take a few minutes) Steve Sweeney, the president of the New Jersey Senate endorsed State Senator Donald Norcross, brother of George. Before sundown, all Democratic members of the U.S. House endorsed Don Norcross, both senators, and almost every mayor, assemblyman, and freeholder in the South Jersey region. The fix was in. I am not disparaging Don Norcross. I think he has a decent, but not great record as a State Senator for the four years he has been in office. Rather I wonder if he was so much better than anyone else who could have run. Why the instant free ride? And why did the endorsements fall so quickly, and so obviously planned in advance?
There are two potential answers to those questions. One is that Don Norcross is so popular and so effective that everyone clamored for him to run as a white night for the Democratic party in District 1. That could very well be. It could also very well be that no one, up to two incumbent US Senators dared withhold their support. The truth, as the cliché, goes, will be left as an exercise to the reader.
A word about endorsements from the South jersey wing of the Democratic party– It’s no badge of honor to have those endorsements. They covered themselves in absolute shame the way they sold Barbara Buono down the road in a quid pro quo to save their seats against the insanely corrupt and malevolent governor we have in Chris Christie. She had no help at all. George Norcross ostensibly endorsed her in January 2013 and then did everything he could to make sure her campaign was undermined. But that’s no shock. He has a really good “working relationship” with Christie. Google is again your friend here.
Regardless, your essayist–an IT professional, part-time artist, and armchair political junkie– said to himself, “Damn it, somebody ought to run against him just on f-ing principle! (Your essayist has a bit of a coarse tongue). As my spouse listened to me rant (and talk about a shoestring campaign built on making my own website, writing to all the blogs I usually just lurk or comment on, and trying to reach other disgusted people) she suggested (and I agreed) that I should see if anyone else was planning on running. There were two people- a grad student who dropped out after being discouraged by Norcross’ support, and Frank Minor, mayor of Logan Township in Gloucester county with a population of about 6000 people. What little I found of Minor in the press had him “considering”. His strong points were he was apparently considered as Buono’s running mate, and has touted not raising taxes while he’s been mayor. OK. I wrote to Frank Minor asking him if he was serious about running– saying I’d rather help someone run, but I needed to do something. I waited several weeks and never got a response.
That left me in back to my nagging compulsion. My wife (who was wisely dubious about this plan) asked me to speak with people I trusted and see what they thought. Them and my Tea Party Dad all said it would be extremely tough and near impossible, but no one said NOT to do it. My Dad, God bless him, encouraged me strongly.
At this point we are about 3 and a half weeks out. So what are the requirements?
Wow, just 200 signatures. OK, 200 signatures from people registered to vote in your district. Oh, 200 registered voters in the party whose nomination for whom you wish to contend. And each gatherer (mainly me) would have to get all the signatures notarized. Not difficult. Or…
So the first things I did were as follows: I registered a domain name (kudos to my unnamed buddy for suggesting http://robfornj.com ). I opened a new website account (in addition to my art site http://rooktoven.com ). I set up WordPress, and commenced to writing an introduction as to whom I was and what were the central tenets of my campaign. Then I made the announcement on Facebook and started to think about signatures.
I figured I`d start where I work (the firm has about 60 employees). This is where I started to realize it isn’t so cut and dried. I knew not everyone was a Democrat there, but figured a majority were. Not so fast. Lots were independents. All would have signed, but rules are rules. Some lived in Pennsylvania, some lived out of district. I asked my kids’ preschool teachers, and sitters, and local friends. No one who was eligible turned me down. But that still wasn’t many.
I spent some lunch periods, and some time before dinner for a few days going to businesses in Collingswood and residences, again, those who were eligible almost always signed, but still I didn’t have a lot of signatures.
Then I got sick. I had four days of mostly being in bed, after that I worked, but wasn’t feeling in shape (due to crap in the lungs) to walk around a lot. I lost almost two weeks. If you have ever seen the Shawshank redemption, you will hear Morgan Freeman’s voice echoing what enabled Aandy Dufresne to escape. Pressure and Time. Money can obviate the need for both of those in a campaign, but without money, you better have pressure (or patience) and especially time– at least for laying the groundwork.
A few things about me. I’m not a solitary person, but my friends tend to be spread out around the country and (given my non-American spouse) the world. I have friends in Camden County, but not as many as I should. I also have in addition to my older teenagers from a previous marriage a five year old and an almost four year-old at home and my wife and I both work. No family around so we don’t go out a lot without the kids.
Nevertheless, I like interacting with people. At first knocking on doors and talking to people in residences and businesses seemed like cold-calling. But after a while I felt my groove. I enjoyed chatting up strangers, and finding out what they liked about my platform, and hearing what they thought. Those conversations are priceless. But time.
Last night I went to a local coffee shop in where a couple of my favorite local musicians were playing. They graciously let me hang out and approach people outside for signatures. I got around thirty in about three hours (some were from people who thought they were Democrats, but weren’t sure. OK, I have to get overflow anyway. But again, the conversations were great. I talked to a guy who was a Green, who thought the Greens ought to be part of the Democratic party like the Tea party is to Republicans (great idea!). I spoke to a fellow who was frustrated about Christie vetoing an adoption knowledge bill. I spoke to (a few) people who were so cynical about anything ever changing that they thought the system was hopeless. They still signed. It was one of the most enlightening nights I ever had. I felt like I got it. But time.
Today my older son and daughter helped me canvas. It rained hard, all day. We hit houses, train stations, and the mall. Twenty five signatures. I realistically (to account for what could be challenged) need a hundred more. It’s going be tough.
I don’t regret doing this, I don’t regret reaching high instead of running for a local position first, as I’m a firm believer in a non-professional Congress. If I couldn’t be at least as coherent as your typical member of Congress I wouldn’t throw myself out there. I know I can debate well– both in print and face to face. I know I can speak well in front of people. I just wish I had considered the initial part a little more thoroughly. I’ve got until 2pm on Monday before I need to drive those petitions to Trenton. We’ll see how that goes.
I like your platform and I applaud your effort to at least provide an alternative choice to the anointed one. As an old hand at local and congressional campaigning, I have a small piece of advice. If you decide to do another run in the future, get friendly well in advance with a local OFA group. They have access to a very helpful database of voters that can help you target qualified petition signers in your area as well as help with GOTV efforts. Also, a timely plea here at BT might get you at least some technical help on running a campaign such as this one and, who knows, perhaps boots on the ground as well.
Anyway, thanks for stepping up and try not to be too discouraged.
Thanks for the kind words and advice.
I knew databases were out there, just wasn’t sure how to get my hands on them. I should have posted here much earlier, but my thinking was to get the petition drive done first. I didn’t realize that plea may have helped the cause. I wanted to show progress first. Live and learn.
It seemed easy, until I took into account all the little disqualifying factors. I had lots of people who would have signed, but for party registration, or lack of registration. I will say that walking around without targeted residences is frustrating endeavor. Having the map would have made a major difference.
Also frustrating is approaching people outside a major mall and finding indifference and a lot of unregistered voters (many who weren’t citizens). In retrospect it’s like playing the lottery.
If I were to do it again, I would start at least a year earlier and be smarter about it. It’s not a definite by any means. Even this brief period took a toll on family life, and I’m not sure I could sustain that for a longer period of time– though I only thought this would go until June. I’m not prepared to be half-assed about it. I don’t think I was in this case, just naïve.
It’s great what you’ve done, don’t give yourself a hard time about the results, we can’t control the results we can only control our effort and it’s a learning process. I expect Indianadem will agree and it’s ok that I reply here.
I wholeheartedly agree, Errol. Its a very tough business, even at the county level where I’ve been mostly involved. I did some work on a congressional campaign for 2012 in our district where the GOP is the incumbent and they just dumped tons of cash into the race. We had an outstanding candidate, but we couldn’t overcome the huge cash advantage. DFA jumped in to help, but got no love from the DCCC or Emily’s List, even though a lot of us begged. I’m still pretty mad at them for that.
I remember that great candidate; still hope she decides to run again for US Congress. iirc she’s on a local board right now?
She’s on the county council (county fiscal body) in IU’s home county now and loves it.
Great that you are doing this! any chance you can get some OFA help for the last day of signature gathering? I called DFA to ask the same [Democracy for America | PO Box 1717 | Burlington, VT 05402
Phone: 802-651-3200 | Fax: 802-651-3299;
DFA
http://www.democracyforamerica.com/contact
but reached only message machines. will try again later today, someone might be in, and leave some messages
Impressive what you’re doing.
Errol,
I appreciate the gestures, but I’ve effectively folded the tent for this one. Sigs would have to be in my hand by tonight so I could get notarized and taken tomorrow. Logistically, it won’t happen. As Indianadem sugsested, I should have asked for help earlier.
If I had another week, (or asked here a week ago) it would probably have worked. Today I hit rain, a flat tire, and a community garden event I hoped to mine was cancelled. It’s my fault for being too proud for asking for help at the beginning. I wanted to prove some level of support before doing so, and that was my downfall.
As I said live and learn. I will say if I do it again, I will be smarter, and better girded for battle.
didn’t realize you had to spend the day on notarizing. but not to worry, your approach, to get some results first, is the optimal approach in say launching a fundraising campaign, and I’m impressed you wanted to have something to show first. Also like that you enjoyed the door to door. Hope you decide to try again next time, and the little kids will be older then too
also NJ Sierra Club
Address: 145 W Hanover St, Trenton, NJ, US, 08618 · Directions
Phone: (609) 656-7612
am unable to make any calls tomorrow Monday, but will try some emails and messages today
One more suggestion, if you will allow me. Work on a campaign and keep your eyes open to everything that goes on. Nothing like some OJT. Again, thanks for your efforts. If nothing else its one of those life learning experiences. You’ll never have to ask yourself “what if I had just tried…”.
Thanks for this diary. And for your effort. No doubt the timing of the Andrews announcement was to make it difficult for other people to jump into the race.
If you think you are interested in any public office, build a working group of support long before you intend to run. With a reasonable plan, one can take on an incumbent and not have to depend on opportunistically timing an open seat. So you can have a minimum of 200 folks in your network who could become an initial volunteer base. Which means that you have those connections geographically spread across the jurisdiction of the office you are running for. And they become the base of your qualification list and partition the filing fee cost.
From there, you strategize how to get 170,000 people to check your name in the voting booth and then go do it. Again, geographic spread helps, which means you have to eventually recruit local canvassers, poll workers, and so on.
Thanks for making the effort and for writing about it. Many more Democrats are going to have to do something like this if we’re to get out of the geographical and institutional hole we are in. Financial capture of the Democratic establishment is a real handicap right now.
Marine Corp. Veteran Frank C. Broomell, Jr., is running for the seat in 1st Congressional District. I ask you to check him out at http://www.frankbroomell.com. Spread the word.