Turkey voted to fight against ISIS/ISIL, but that doesn’t mean they have any interest in saving the Kurdish town of Kobani, just over their border from Syria. ISIS forces have the town surrounded, and the people there have been asking for the Turk’s help to prevent a massacre.
In the morning Turkish Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoglu told journalists in a briefing in Ankara that his government would do what it could to prevent the mainly Kurdish town of Kobani [a/k/a Kobane], known as Ain al-Arab to the Arabs, from falling to the militants of the Islamic State, formerly known as the Islamic State of Iraq and Sham (ISIS).
“We wouldn’t want Kobani to fall,” he said.
The Kurds, however, tell a different story, one that describes Turkish delays and stalling tactics while fierce fighting around the besieged town continues, virtually non-stop, despite American air strikes. The Turks tanks literally standing by at the border in sight of Kobani observing the ‘show’ as outnumbered Kurd fighters and civilians die. Kurdish leaders are naturally angry at the lack of assistance from the Turks, and have threatened to end the peace talks between the PKK (Kurdistan Workers Party) and Turkey should Kobani fall and ISIS fighters massacre its people.
If the Turks fail to take action and protect the Kurds in Kobane, Kurdish leaders said this week, peace talks within Turkey could be at risk.
“The siege of Kobane is far from being just an ordinary siege,” Abdullah Öcalan, the imprisoned leader of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), said in a message relayed to supporters from his cell. “It does not only target the democratic gains of the Kurdish people but would lead Turkey to a new era of coups.”
The Kurds are extremely angry, not only with the Turks, but also with the US led coalition, for not doing more, though I’m not sure how much more we could do, to be honest. Turkey has the ground forces available to save the town in place and nearby. They have chosen, so far, not to use them. In light of their long running conflict with the PKK, and the fear of an independent Kurdistan on their border, this isn’t a surprise, even if it is disappointing and in my view wrong-headed. Allowing a city of 40-50 thousand people to be slaughtered when you have the means to save them is not only immoral, but likely to lead to further PKK attacks inside Turkey in the future. If the Turks really want peace with the Kurds, this is not the way to go about it.
However, it shows that the situation in the region, in Syria and among our so-called coalition “partners” opposed to ISIS is far more complicated and treacherous than is typically portrayed in our nightly TV news and by our so-called “foreign policy experts” who pontificate for more American military intervention as a solution to all the Middle East’s problems (e.g., Senators John McCain, Lindsay Graham, et alia). It also demonstrates the ineffective and counter-productive nature of all our military interventions in Iraq, Syria and elsewhere in the Middle East. The invasion and occupation of Iraq started a series dominoes falling and inflamed the region in violence. We have yet to see the end of the consequences that continue to flow from that ill-fated mission not-accomplished.
Reason 298,752 why the US should make an independent Kurdistan a reality by the end of Obama’s Presidency. I know the Turks are our allies, but so are the Kurds. And if the Turks are going to be dickish like this, apply the necessary pressure by floating trial balloons about an independent Kurdistan.
I think Iraq would also have a problem with that which right now is an important detail with ISIS running around all over their territory.
Why in the world ‘should’ we do that? If the Kurds had their own country right now they would be able to defend it!
If we had ‘created’ it for them, everyone would be screaming how we should now be sending troops in to defend them. I’m tired of it all, if they are so freaking tough, they should be able to fight off ISIS, yet they seem completely unable to do so.
The Turks have no obligation whatsoever to help them , not when if they do that city will be sending fighters over their border within a year.
Perhaps the Kurds need to learn that their ‘leaders’, the ones that want independence, are not able to defend them.
.
isn’t that a major violation of the Prime Directive?
Your opening: “Turkey voted to fight against ISIS/ISIL.”
This is not in the mandate Erdogan asked for.
○ US Vice President Biden says Turkish President Erdoğan admitted ISIL mistake
○ ISIL Militants In Swap for Turkish Hostages
○ Turkey In Alliance with ISIS – Undermining Obama’s Policy In Iraq
Erdogan signed on to toppling the Assad regime. If he doesn’t now like all the unintended consequences, well, tough shit.
Kurds and PKK beware of attacks by Turkish armed forces, our NATO partner …
Watch, Erdogan: “VP Joe Biden is history for me!”
Cross-posted from my diary – Flawed Reasoning and Misleading Projection On ISIL Origin.
Aren’t the Turks doing the right thing?
Keeping the hell out?
Not sending in ground troops and only making thins worse?
Especially in a region where they have an….equivocal…history?
Or is that just good advice for
The Focus of Evil in the Worldthe U.S?It could also be negotiating from a position of strength. “PKK, if you want us to act in Kobani then we need a permanent agreement with the following terms…”
I was just thinking the same thing. The weird opportunity that the horror of ISIS represents is for all these antagonistic groups to practice some collaboration that could lead things down a slightly better path in the region. That is only because of the common enemy but it still might lead to some brokering. If Turkey goes in to help now, they will also gain a certain moral upper hand which is then also attached to the idea of a rationalizing central power overcoming for the common good the intensity of localized identity.
Reading the news headlines, it must be so. President Erdogan of Turkey demanded an apology from VP Biden for his remarlks and accusations at the address of Turkey admitting mistakes made from which ISIL was able to flourish. The truth must remain hidden …
Headlines in Turkish media today:
First thing that leapt to mind on this story: The Soviet army in WWII, camped just outside Warsaw, waiting till the Germans had destroyed the uprising against them before driving the Wehrmacht out, sweeping into the city, and rounding up and shooting what was left of the resistance so they could take it over for themselves.