The resolution failed to get the 9 votes in favor with 5 abstentions and two NO votes: the US and Australia. Only Al Jazeera had a LIVE broadcast of this crucial UN vote. President Bush promised the Palestinians statehood by 2005 when PM Ariel Sharon evacuated settlements out of Gaza. Of course, the US negated on its promise. Under President Obama, more of the same and effectively a worsening conditions for the Palestinian people under Israel occupation. Kerry was deeply involved during the last 48 hours to find sufficient opposition against the Jordanian initiative. The 5 states who abstained were: United Kingdom, Lithuania, Rwanda, Korea and ?? .
UPDATE: The resolution failed to achieve the 9-votes majority required to pass. Eight countries voted in favor of the motion – China, France, Russia, Argentina, Chad, Chile, Jordan, Luxembourg – two opposed – US and Australia – and five abstained – UK, Lithuania, Nigeria, Korea, Rwanda.
US Ambassador to the UN Samantha Power said in comments after the vote that: “Instead of giving voice to the aspirations of both Palestinians and Israelis, this text addresses only one side.”
UN Security Council votes against Palestinian statehood | Al Jazeera |
The UN Security Council has rejected a Palestinian resolution calling for peace with Israel within a year and an end to Israel’s occupation by 2017. The resolution failed to muster the minimum nine “yes” votes required in the council for adoption.
The United States, Israel’s closest ally, had reiterated its opposition to the draft resolution earlier on Tuesday. Washington said it could not support the draft because it was not constructive and failed to address Israel’s security needs.
The resolution had called for occupied East Jerusalem to be the capital of Palestine, an end to Israeli settlement building and settling the issue of Palestinian prisoner releases.
The resolution also called for negotiations to be based on territorial lines that existed before Israel captured the West Bank, East Jerusalem and the Gaza Strip in 1967.
Israel had said the Security Council vote, following the collapse in April of US-brokered talks on Palestinian statehood, would deepen the conflict.
The Palestinians, frustrated by the lack of progress on peace talks, have sought to internationalise the issue by seeking UN membership and recognition of statehood via membership in international organisations.
The United States has said they would not support the latest Palestinian-Arab draft resolution, citing differences over how to achieve the shared goal of a negotiating a two-state solution.
“As we’ve said before, this draft resolution is not something that we would support and other countries share the same concerns that we have,” said State Department Spokesperson Jake Rathke yesterday hours before Jordan gave the resolution to the secretariat. Rathke continued, “We think it sets arbitrary deadlines for reaching a peace agreement and for Israel’s withdrawal from the West Bank, and those are more likely to curtail useful negotiations than to bring them to a successful conclusion.”
“Further, we think that the resolution fails to account for Israel’s legitimate security needs, and the satisfaction of those needs, of course, is integral to a sustainable settlement.” The State Department’s comments mark a departure from previous remarks where Secretary of State John Kerry has said the U.S. could not support a Palestinian resolution if the text called for “unilateral” action to achieve an independent Palestinian state.
It looks like the US is becoming increasingly isolated. Only one country voted with it. Even the UK (the creator of Israel) and Lithuania abstained. Australia is moving ever deeper into the dark side.
The explanations the US makes for this vote have no credibility if France and Luxembourg voted in favor and the US vassals the UK, Lithuania, and Korea abstained. I think the US is recklessly depleting its soft power with this latest servile and irrational support of Israel.
Oh, where is the Pope? I know, he got lots of stuff on his plate but, I thought he would have been poking at Bibi by now.
Keep in mind that the resolution would have legitimized Israel’s robbery of Palestinian water. While the US is being its usual imperialist self, these resolutions aren’t exactly “good”.
I don’t see what that has to do with anything, given that the Palestinians themselves wanted this resolution to pass. Also, Russia and China voted for it, which suggests that it was a good resolution.
If we define Palestinian people as Abbas and his accomplices, then sure. I take my cues from EI, Joseph Massad, and Ali on this issue. They all opposed the resolution.
Keep on dreaming. Any further delay will make a Palestinian State impossible. When you are a blogger, you carry no burden of responsibility. The states of Jordan and the Arab Union have backed this initiative. Of course, Israel and PM Netanyahu has blasted this initiative. Yes, the US and Obama in particular is an isolated voice in the whole world as was seen in the UNGA vote two years ago.
“Voting by an overwhelming majority — 138 in favour to 9 against (Canada, Czech Republic, Israel, Marshall Islands, Micronesia (Federated States of), Nauru, Panama, Palau, United States), with 41 abstentions — the General Assembly today accorded Palestine non-Member Observer State status in the United Nations.”
○ Israel and the Rise of Judeo-Fascism
Plus, how was the US isolated? Will Europe stop sending weapons to Israel? Did Britain “abstain” for their own solidarity with Palestine? No. They abstained because then the U.S. didn’t need to exercise its veto, and wouldn’t then be the sole reason the vote failed.
Australia surprises me none. They treat their aboriginal people with the same disdain that the US expresses to its natives.
○ Jewish Neocons Adopt Rwandan Dictator, Kagame
○ PM thanks African leaders for thwarting Palestinian UN bid | The Times of Israel |
○ The Steady Rise of African Zionism
○ Hanging Haman with the Igbo Jews of Abuja
The US is well known for bribing leaders in Africa for their votes …
“Time comes when silence becomes betrayal”. It should be the headline of this news. It has showed something about the independent foreign policy of some countries.
Business Loans | Business Cash Advance
My previous diaries:
○ BREAKING – PM Sharon wins Likud vote!!! (Sept. 25, 2005)
○ BREAKING – Sharon Readies Plan for Total West Bank Pullout by ’08 (Nov. 25, 2005)
○ Israel’s Sharon Suffers Significant Cerebral Hemorrhage (Jan. 5, 2006)