It’s easy to get inured to polling results that demonstrate that a significant part of the American population barely has enough brain capacity to operate their lungs. It’s hard to imagine how a brain that can simultaneously hold that the president is a Muslim and that he is at fault for being a member of Reverend Jeremiah Wright’s congregation can figure out how to simultaneously pump the heart and regulate body temperature.
And, therefore, it’s sobering to realize that a plurality of Republican poll responders think the president was born outside of the United States (44%-29%) and a big majority believe that he is a Muslim (54%) rather than a Christian (14%).
Consider the latter proposition. Republican poll responders are almost four times more likely to be wrong about the president’s religion than they are to be correct about it, and a third of them are too stupid to be sure one way or the other.
Okay, so there are a lot of dumb people in the world. This is not a newsflash to anyone.
But they’ve sorted themselves into this conservative movement in a rather striking fashion. Among just Jeb Bush supporters, the people actually get this question more right than wrong (29% say Obama is a Christian, 22% say he is a Muslim, and 50% are not sure). Thus, even among the most “rational” subset of Republicans, nearly three in four are fucking clueless about one of the most basic biographical facts about the president.
This didn’t just happen. Millions of people didn’t wake up one day and tell themselves, “Hey, I think Chris Christie is a Christian Scientist but maybe he’s not, I don’t really know.” If you ask Republicans if Bobby Jindal is Hindu, Muslim or Christian (all real possibilities given his ethnicity), they’re going to do much better at identifying him as a Christian. What happened is that people were deliberately misinformed about the president’s religion through chain emails and social media and hate radio programs and conspiracy websites and by, yes, Republican politicians and spokespeople who expressed their own doubts in public. No one did this with more prominence that Donald Trump, and we can see the results. Sixty-one percent of his supporters think the president was born in Kenya and 66% of them believe that he’s a Muslim.
If Democrats and Democratic operatives tried to convince the public that Rick Santorum is a Zen Buddhist or Bobby Jindal is a Muslim, I cannot imagine they could ever produce numbers with anything approaching the kind of success that Republicans and Republican operatives have had in casting doubt about the president’s beliefs and background.
So part of this is about differential gullibility in the bases of the two main political parties.
But part of it is also about motivation. You have to ask why so much time and effort was put forth to misinform people about President Obama.
And it can’t be as simple as seeking a political advantage, because Democrats could have launched a subterranean war on Mormonism in 2012 in an effort to sow distrust among more conventional Christians, particularly evangelicals who compete with Mormons for converts. This was not done, and would have been done if some restraining factor didn’t prevent it.
In essence, the Democrats left a potent avenue of attack on the table because it would have violated their principle of religious toleration to wage a war on Mormonism. Of course, the corollary here isn’t that we might have raised Mormonism as an issue and raised suspicions about it. The corollary is that we would have deliberately lied about Mormonism to make it sound many times more suspicious and threatening than the truth could ever warrant. We didn’t do that, either, despite it being plainly in our electoral interests to do so.
What the Republicans did was create an electorate that didn’t previously exist. Sure, the gullible people were there already, but they weren’t misinformed and they weren’t sorted politically.
The reason this was done by Republicans, I believe, is because the conservative movement has determined that they can hold onto power a little longer despite demographic changes and the browning of America if they can sharply increase their share of the white vote. And the way to do that is not to figure out what these people need and offer ways to give it to them, but to get them to think more in terms of their whiteness. Whites go over here in the right column and everyone else goes over there in the left column.
This is the rationale. It has the potential to work, and it’s already working on the state and congressional district level, helping Republicans control legislatures throughout the country and in Washington DC.
It’s a transparent effort to ramp up racial animosity as a way, probably the only way, to avoid softening their positions on their conservative ideology. If they don’t do this, then they’ll have to recraft their appeal, which means that conservatives will lose control of the Republican Party– one of only two viable parties in the country.
Once you understand what has happened in this way, everything else begins to make more sense. And you can see why the RNC’s advice to pass comprehensive immigration reform was rejected by the Republican-led House of Representatives because they’re the ones benefiting from the racial polarization of the country and higher levels of tribal thinking among whites. Senators, by and large, do not benefit from this since they have to run statewide.
Now, this leads to an interesting place, because, looked at this way, Donald Trump is almost a savior for conservatism despite being a heretic on several items on the traditional conservative movement’s agenda. He’s a savior because he’s completely internalized the strategy that will allow them to continue on without moderating to appeal to a changing electorate: make whites think more about their whiteness.
Meanwhile, Jeb Bush, who is much more conventionally Republican than Donald Trump, is pursuing the exact wrong strategy which is to moderate conservatism and get away from bashing minorities.
So, Trump helped create and sort this ridiculously misinformed Republican electorate and now he is the clear beneficiary. But he was by no means alone. It was, essentially, a group project that the Republican Establishment signed off on when they thought it could benefit them in beating Obama.
The blowback is unreal.
There are no gods, only fairy tales. It’s all downhill from there.
It can happen to the best of us, apparently.
Nice.
Best of us my foot. Thanks for reminding us what a trimmer she is.
Errrr uhhhh…
Who says she’s “the best of us?”
Not that she’s the worst of us, either.
Just another pol, trying to get over.
AG
P.S. The full conversation on which this “as far as I know” thing is based seems fairy innocuous, to me. It’s just “Gotcha!!!” political bullshit.
Watch the vid.
I mean…whadda you think?
You think she’s trying to spread rumors about his religion?
Hell no!!!
I’m not exactly a Hillary supporter…especially now that she appears to be very tired…but I do think that she would have been a better president than Obama. Better in the sense that she would have had a much greater initial understanding of how to wield the levers of power in the federal system. How she would have used them? That’s another matter entirely, but at least she would have used them well.
Hey, watch it now. If it’s Trump v. Clinton in November of 2016, you might even find yourself voting for her.
Actually, I occasionally consider voting for the candidate that promises the most turmoil for this country. It’s gotta reform sooner or later…or of course take a total dive as did the U.S.S.R…and a really foolish, contentious preznit like Trump might at least hasten the change.
And then I always find myself saying…”Naaaaahhhh…”
So far.
We shall see.
Won’t we.
AG
Hey, stupid sells. Just ask P.T. Barnum, H.L. Mencken, and umm… “liberal” MSNBC, which is now all TRUMP! all the time.
“Liberal” MSNBC. Yes!!!
And “conservative” Fox News, which was the first network to try to trap Br’er Trump.
Further proof of the existence of the bipartisan, PermaGov UniParty, its corporate owned and operated Governmental Media Complex and the ongoing Preznidential Fix. Violate the rules and both supposed sides go after you.
The American people still don’t see this, even after massive evidence over the past…ohhhh, say 25 years or so.
Mass agnosia.
The state of not knowing what you don’t know.
Even Donald Rumsfeld was smarter than that. At least he knew that there were things that he didn’t know he didn’t know.
Whadda buncha maroons!!!
AG
The meme that Obama is a Muslim goes back to 2004 and a guy named Andy Martin who started the rumor. Here’s a good history of it:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/10/13/us/politics/13martin.html?pagewanted=all
The conclusion I have to come to is that people who say Obama is a Muslim are not necessarily stupid, but rather they are people who believe what they want to believe.
People who believe what they want to believe without looking at factual evidence are stupid, priscianus jr.
AG
Stupid in a special sense, but not the sense most people think of when they use the word “stupid”.
Edward Luttwak, for example, is an asshole, but he’s not stupid.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Luttwak
If you think I’m going too easy on these guys, consider this: you can’t blame a truly stupid person for being stupid, you can merely pity them. But you can and must blame guys like Luttwak and the rest of the neocons for believing what they want to believe without looking at factual evidence. Actually, with them it’s even worse, they do look at factual evidence, they just prefer their own cherry-picked “evidence”.
You write:
I am sorry to be the one to have to tell you this, bit…at least as far as the way this government really runs…”most people” are stupid.
Luttwak is a decorated academic. So what? The same sorts of people…up to and including Henry Kissinger…have in fact been the ones most guilty of throwing their degrees around in various so-called think tanks and other advisory roles over the preceding 50 years or so. Look where that has gotten us.
My good friend 168 St. Papo is smarter than most of them, and his only degree is from the UOS.
The University of the Streets.
Bet on it.
From the Wikipedia article on Luttwak:
Stupid is as stupid does.
Bet on that as well.
AG
It’s frustrating to realize that all the good works and good intentions of progressives and liberals are wasted… completely and totally wasted! on americans.
The internet is bad for politics. Before the internet, I could be blissfully ignorant of just how awful my fellow citizens were. Now it is impossible and I am now disinclined to offer any assistance to anyone except those I know personally.
The internet and the vast media machine it spawned are destroying civil society. This election season – all 2 years of it – will destroy democracy in america.
Good job everyone.
You’re being engulfed by a partial truth. If that were all that’s going on I’d have to agree with you, but there’s a lot more to the Internet than that. Fact checking, for example. In a minute I was able to pull up a news article from 2008 that provides the whole history of the Obam = Muslim smear.
Here’s how I look at it. There are, always have been, and always will be stupid people. Also malicious people. Thanks to the Internet, we’re just more aware of them. But there aren’t any more of them than there ever were.
And it’s not a bad thing that we’re more aware of them.
This was always the case. Successful lefty policies make people think they are rich enough to benefit from being republicans.
I believe the strength of the Republican party lies in their religious beliefs and everything is tied to that. Take away the influence of religion, and you take away their hatred of gays, their hatred of blacks and other dark-skinned people, their hatred for birth control and abortion.
It’s ironic that a group that claims to love and follow Christianity behaves oppositely on so many issues. And they profess to care for their fellow man, when in fact they despise so many of them.
I don’t know about your ad market, but here in SW Ohio we’re getting these smarmy, cozy family-loving TV ads that show a likeable white woman chatting casually about what she wants for her country: good schools for her children, availability of jobs for everyone, minimal government that “gets out of the way” and a few other wholesome needs for her family.
And it ends with her saying something about that’s what makes her a Republican. Hoo boy, what a gigantic load of horseshit! What they want is a privileged white “Christian” America. And they will say and do anything to get it.
I don’t agree. White supremacy is primary (as it ever was), not religion. Evangelical Christianity functions as a (cis, straight) white tribal marker. That’s why you see evangelicals supporting obvious heathen Trump.
I think it works both ways. Bible inerrancy valorizes accepting claims on faith, so the mindset is to believe the authority figures without caring about conflicting evidence or inconvenient facts.
You can spew facts at these folks to no effect, facts just roll off like water off a duck’s back.
Large numbers of Americans have always been ignorant, but the avenues to propagandize them were more limited. The internet and social media have now made absolute control of the message (ala Goebbels) more difficult.
As I remember it, this particular lie—that Obammy isn’t really a citizen—was chiefly promulgated and maintained in a subterranean campaign of emails, it wasn’t really spread by the useless corporate media, whose members would claim they attempted to actually inform the public that Obama was born in the US. Although of course they “reported the controversy”, which is damning enough.
Facts are meaningless to those who have closed their minds, indeed presenting ever more contrary facts apparently now reinforces the dearly held belief, according to psychologists. Thus climate denialists cannot be persuaded by more facts; indeed, they are the opposite of “skeptics”. Of course this pattern of thinking makes one effectively an imbecile on selected topics.
Once a major political party adopts an obvious strategy of lies and baseless propaganda as its “message”, and couples this with an omnipresent avenue of advancement like today’s internet, it appears that the 18th century ideal of an “informed citizenry” and a media “marketplace of ideas” in which the “truth” triumphs falls to pieces. And what this means for American democracy is now being acted out before our eyes.
de Tocqueville maintained that American democracy was doomed (although not because rationality was doomed). As long as we had boundless resources and ever increasing standards of living, the precarious political system could operate in a sort of fashion, although all it chiefly manufactured was a crass materialist jingoism and destruction of the natural world as far as I can see.
So yes, this is a wonderfully eloquent and largely irrefutable post by Booman—the “conservative” movement sowed the whirlwind and is now reaping its reward. Der Trumper is the logical endpoint of their methods and their host party might go down to a spectacular (prez) defeat emphasizing the primacy of Traditional Americans. But the imbecilization of huge numbers of citizens that “conservatism” created will now always be with us, and they cannot be restored to being informed citizens with plausible opinions and interpretations of verifiable fact.
The only question is what the next preposterous monstrous lie will be–and there will be no way to eradicate it. How “democracy” will function in such a polluted environment remains an open question.
There is truth in this. Decades ago (1950s-1970s) there was a John Birch Society which published items like a weekly paid newspaper column and a monthly subscription newsletter in which these kind of conspiracy theories were advanced. A very tiny percentage of the population believed them. The Fairness Doctrine kept them out of the mainstream, and there were no other “free” avenues, as the internet is, to get them out to people.
The right wing machine first made in-roads by taking over the fundie churches. Lots of funds were given to establish what we would later call “big box churches” which were essentially GOP vote-generating machines. The 1970s conversion of evangelicals from being what we now call pro-choice to anti-abortion was the key “wedge issue” that got the people to get involved in politics, but without the money it still wouldn’t have been any more successful than your average liberal political organizing force is today.
Of course those churches quickly got to spreading John Birch-like propaganda. Then, when the Fairness Doctrine was killed off in 1986 the next funding target for the right wing was what we now know as hate radio – programs that simply would not have been permitted before quickly became commonplace. Today, drive anywhere in middle America away from a major city and you’ll find that every freaking radio station is a different flavor of conservative propaganda – Xtian propaganda, syndicated hate radio, local hate radio, even the country channels make sure to drop in some good old anti-Obama diatribes between songs.
Then the internet and cable finished the program.
It’s amazing that everything – every fucking thing – that wingnuts hold as absolute truths is absolutely wrong. No wonder they think that CNN is liberal – and sometimes they even accuse Fox of being liberal (no, really, it’s not hard to find such accusations). Unless a news source openly labels global warming as a hoax, that Obummer was born in Kenya and is secretly promoting ISIS, that almost all tax money is sent to his brothas in the hood, etc etc then the source must be liberal.
It’s also why they only candidates the base likes are batshit insane. Anything less that full belief in the propaganda just won’t cut it.
This situation is completely outside of human experience. Oh, we’ve had groupthink but never on this scale. We’ve had thoroughly propagandized populations, but never to this level of true believership in absolute lies. We’re blazing a trail and the destination is unknown, but it can’t be good.
“As I remember it, this particular lie—that Obammy isn’t really a citizen—was chiefly promulgated and maintained in a subterranean campaign of emails, it wasn’t really spread by the useless corporate media, whose members would claim they attempted to actually inform the public that Obama was born in the US. Although of course they “reported the controversy”, which is damning enough.”
Yes, that’s exactly how it works. It’s a technique. It’s called the “echo chamber”. Rumors are planted in media with no credibility, then the major media report that the rumor is circulating. According the Lakoff’s well know principle, “Don’t think of an elephant”, this gets the idea into people’s heads without having to assert it’s actually true. So in this sense it really was spread by the useless corporate media. And then if you think of how many politicians (including Hillary in her 2008 campaign), would be reported as saying things like “As far as I KNOW, he is a Christian, and I have no reason to doubt HIS WORD”, this sort of noncommittal assertion is a deliberate device to keep the meme going while avoiding any responsibility.
Every once in a while, the Sis tells me about a ridiculous, stupid, or pathetic meme that’s circulating among Republicans. Not the uneducated, religious, and financially struggling wackos, but the educated, not religious or not fundie religious, and financially well off Republicans. The latest is about Joe Biden. The claim is that his first wife was responsible for the accident, and therefore, empathy for his loss is unwarranted and it shouldn’t be called a tragedy. I sort of screamed that an accident that results in the deaths of a young wife and daughter and severe injuries for a young son is always a tragedy. Assigning any proportional responsibility to the accident doesn’t alter the fact that it was tragic and devastating to the Biden family.
Rick Perlstein wrote about how the conservatives corralled gullible people in The Baffler article “The Long Con.”
http://thebaffler.com/salvos/the-long-con
The following passage is where he begins his argument in earnest.
It would be interesting, that is, to ask Coulter about the reflex of lying that’s now sutured into the modern conservative movement’s DNA–and to get her candid assessment of why conservative leaders treat their constituents like suckers.
The history of that movement echoes with the sonorous names of long-dead Austrian economists, of indefatigable door-knocking cadres, of soaring perorations on a nation finally poised to realize its rendezvous with destiny. Search high and low, however, and there’s no mention of oilfields in the placenta. Nor anything about, say, the massive intersection between the culture of “network” or “multilevel” marketing–where ordinary folks try to get rich via pyramid schemes that leave their neighbors holding the bag–and the institutions of both evangelical Christianity and Mitt Romney’s Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
And yet this stuff is as important to understanding the conservative ascendancy as are the internecine organizational and ideological struggles that make up its official history–if not, indeed, more so. The strategic alliance of snake-oil vendors and conservative true believers points up evidence of another successful long march, of tactics designed to corral fleeceable multitudes all in one place–and the formation of a cast of mind that makes it hard for either them or us to discern where the ideological con ended and the money con began.
It should come as no surprise that Richard Viguerie and his direct mail marketing plays a big role, which means that this process has been going on for more than 50 years.
It probably should have been done with mormonism
Not while Harry Reid was Senate Majority Leader. That’s a pragmatic reason in addition to the ideological one mentioned in the OP.
I think Driftglass fuckin’ nails it with this post from 2006.
http://driftglass.blogspot.com/2006/09/reactionary.html
What has happened is that the base is melting down as we speak, and Trump is simply the toxic plume of smoke, ash and dust that we see erupting from the meltdown, slowly making its way across the land.
Citizens United has pretty much turned the GOP into a contractor, rather than an employer, of fascist goons.
All the GOP really does anymore is post up job openings in government, and billionaires subcontract out the openings to their favorite puppet.