I set my brother Andrew up with a blog back in the Spring and he wrote quite a bit for a short while, although he stopped abruptly on June 24th. It’s a struggle for me to write about him for so many reasons, and it’s probably best to let him speak for himself whenever that’s possible. I encourage you to take a look at what he was thinking about and struggling with because I think there’s a lot of wisdom in it.
You can never tell a person’s story completely, and you certainly do them a grave injustice to reduce them to simple labels. My brother was many great and admirable things, but he also suffered from depression and he eventually sought solace and comfort in alcohol for problems that he felt he was powerless to overcome. And, one by one, the addiction took from him all the things he loved and cared about, including in himself. He sought treatment many times and waged a battle that lasted, I guess, about eight years.
By the time we got him into treatment for the last time, he had lost everything and had earned the estrangement of the people who cared about him the most. Honestly, at that point, I think he had days if not hours to live. But, where other rehabilitation centers had failed, his last one succeeded. As he explained it to me, the difference was that they gave him unconditional love, and that was the one thing that he needed to believe that redemption was possible and worth seeking.
They patched him together as best as they could. And then he left to live in a recovery house where he spent the last eight months of his life. He came by our house often. Last week, he looked after his nephew while we went to the Memorial Service for our friends’ mother. You can see on his Facebook page that he made a real impact on the folks he lived with at the recovery house. They say he was a “good friend” who “would give you the shirt off his back if you needed it.” Sometimes, he’d turn down an invitation to come to dinner because he wanted to make sure a friend had a ride to work.
He spent most of his days at the library looking for the kind of work he needed to meet his obligations to his family, but those kinds of jobs don’t come easily to a 55 year old man who has burned his references and is in ill health. He focused on that and on his recovery and on making a positive difference in the lives of the people he interacted with on a daily basis.
He told me that after a lot of effort he had managed to get on Medicaid, but I don’t think he ever went to a doctor. If he had, he might have known how near to death he was.
There’s a lot more to my brother than his last sad months, but these were the last miles that I walked with him. And, in the end, what mattered to him were the kinds of things he wrote about on his blog.
In one of his posts, he ruminated on a song by Ray LaMontagne that spoke to him for obvious reasons.
Empty
By Ray LaMontagneShe lifts her skirt up to her knees
Walks through the garden rows
With her bare feet laughing
I never learned to count my blessings
I choose instead to dwell
In my disasters
I walk on down the hill
Through grass grown tall
And brown and still
It’s hard somehow
To let go of my pain
On past the busted back
Of that old and rusted Cadillac
That sinks into this field
Collecting rain
Will I always feel this way
So empty
And estranged?
and of these cut throat busted sunsets
These cold and damp white mornings
I have grown weary
If through my cracked and dusty
Dime store lips
I spoke these words out loud
Would no one hear me?
Lay your blouse across the chair
Let fall the flowers
From your hair
And kiss me
With that country mouth
So plain
outside the rain is tapping
On the leaves
To me it sounds like
They’re applauding us
The quiet love
We’ve made
Will it always feel this way
So empty
So estranged?
well I looked my demons in the eyes
Lay bare my chest
Said do your best
To destroy me
I’ve been to hell and back
So many times
I must admit
You kinda bore me
there’s a lot of things
That can kill a man
There’s a lot of ways
To die
Yes, and some already did
And walk beside me
there’s a lot of things
I don’t understand
So many people lie
It’s the hurt I hide that fuels
The fire inside me
Will I always feel this way
So empty
So estranged?
Here’s part of what he had to say about this song.
I believe people will relate who have experienced loss, trauma, profound disappointment, addiction, unrequited love, wear from the windchill of life, or just about anything that throws a person inward with a belief they are alone with their problems, solutions and being. The converse is someone who is continually directed towards relationships with others and outside things and to things greater than themselves. I know that for me, a lifetime of concern over personal and political battles, especially recent ridiculously needless battles, has too often left me weary, hopeless and bored.
I also believe that feeling is not necessary.
Coming up, I will be posting thoughts which may describe a simpler path for staying awake in every moment in an easier state; more pliable but unyielding to life’s hard-edged conflicts. I think I can safely say I have spent many, many of my adult waking hours developing awareness and skills around it. I have in no way been always successful. In fact, I have failed beyond my wildest imagination, tempting total ruin. But having learned and applied a few lessons from my failures, I also have experienced some serene success. Your mileage may vary.
During Andrew’s last full day on Earth, President Obama was in West Virginia talking about addiction. He was primarily concerned with the opioid epidemic, but that was also a concern of Andrew’s because in the circles of recovery we are burying friends and acquaintances on a near-daily basis who are succumbing to opioids. Nearly every time I talked to him over the last few months he began by telling me the story of someone else who had relapsed, overdosed and died. Most of the people he was devoting himself to helping were trying to recover from an opioid addiction. If he’d want anything, he’d want people to understand the severity of the problem our nation has with depression and addiction, and how inadequate our response has been so far.
In fact, this desire of his is the sole reason why I am writing this at all, because at a time like this the inclination is to gloss over the tragic stuff, the embarrassing stuff, and to celebrate the good times and the accomplishments and the best that a person was able to offer.
But, I’ll tell you, Andrew had eight months sober. He was fighting. He was trying to do the right thing every day. And he was giving the best he had to offer. The end of his story is tragic but it should be inspiring, too.
I want people to know that he had recaptured the good in himself and he was applying it to help others.
There are countless people out there right now who are fighting the same fight, behind the same eight ball, at the bottom of the same unscalable pit. And they need your love and a helping hand, and a system that can find a way to give them some support and medical attention.
I’m proud of Andrew. I’m proud and honored to have walked these last miles with him.
I’m so sorry for your loss. It sounds like your brother was a helluva a man who had lost it all and was in the process of recovering it — and using his new-found wisdom to help others. We need more people like that, not fewer.
It’s a real disgrace in this country that so many people consider their fellow human beings disposable; this view is reflected in current policies toward addiction and mental health. That has to change if we aspire to be a civilization worth of the name.
You honor your brother by sharing his struggle. Peace, comfort, strength and courage to you and your whole family.
It sounds like Andrew found redemption before his time was up. I hope someone reads this and takes inspiration from his story. Thank you for a touching piece, Martin.
Thank you for sharing this with us. It is beautiful. I’m sorry you lost your brother. Your post is going to stay with me today.
Martin, this post is going to stick with me a long time. Somehow, in my heart, I think this fact would well please your brother.
I just have no other words right now.
Peace.
That’s a beautiful and heartbreaking eulogy.
I’m so sorry about your brother. I know how difficult it is, so soon on the heels of your loss, to talk about it. But I also believe it’s important to speak aloud the good and even the sad parts about a loved one. It helps you and it helps those around you to take the painful steps to heal.
Your brother sounds like a smart, compassionate man who got dragged into addiction. Some people can exticate themselves, others can not. Even though he struggled, it seems that he had gotten back on his feet, and had even begun sharing himself with those in his own situation. That says a lot about his good character.
I hope you and your family find solace and peace.
Long time reader – First wanted to say how sorry I am. Second you wrote a beautiful post here and I wanted to tell you that. Won’t ease the hurt and grief but wanted to tell you, you wrote something very special here.
Again just want to say how sorry I am for you and yours loss.
Martin, your words make me cry. You’re a good brother. You had a good brother.
What a great eulogy. I’m glad he was able to get sober at the end. I hope I can have half your grace if I ever get into a similar situation.
Martin, thanks so much for sharing the story and your thoughts and feelings. When it comes to addicts of whatever sort, the loved ones are alway helpless to some degree, but it sounds as if you handled it with equanimity and your love for him never wavered. I’m sure that meant a great deal to Andrew in his struggles.
Thanks for sharing .. I have no words. Addiction is a family matter .. it must have been hard on everyone. You were there for your brother Martin .. sometimes unconditional love is just not enough.
○ Caron Renaissance by Sid Goodman
What a beautiful and real tribute to someone you obviously shared a complicated lifetime with.
So sorry Andrew’s gone. So glad you were able to walk with him through the end of his life. He sounds like a beautiful person. Sending love & comfort, Martin, to you & everyone in Andrew’s life.
Your brother must have had immense trust in you, matching your hopes for him. As someone who works with people who have become estranged from their loved ones, I understand the difficulty of watching someone’s addiction erode his life. My condolences on the loss of another beloved member of your family.
Thanks for the courage to share this. Dealing with addictions is something that our society fails to do well, given its tendency toward stigma and fulfilling a “you’re on your own” attitude as an excuse not to provide technical resources and care. You have tried in your posts on addiction to awaken the rest of us to these issues. This community is richer because of your engaging us on this issue.
Thank you for sharing your loss. Both of my brothers are dead now and addiction was the cause. I have such feelings of deep sorrow when I think of them, but we all grow with the experience of giving unconditional love, finding acceptance, and giving and receiving forgiveness. May you find peace as you mourn your brother’s death and reflect on his life.
I was sorry to hear your brother died last week and now to learn that he was a fellow addict brings that loss a step closer.
I’m a 58 year old alcoholic/marijuana addict with two decade long or so periods of abstinence. I’m a veteran with a law degree who currently manages a halfway house. I don’t want to die without drinking or using again, but I also know that if I use that once I push that button my usefulness as a person is over.
FWIW, addicts in recovery are about the only people in our society who voluntarily give up, one day at a time, that which they most want. Imagine having to forego contact with your children, if you have them, forever, with the caveat that you can see them at the expense of the destruction of your life.
Steve
God bless you both.
While addiction is surely a dreadful disease, in reading Paul’s words and Martin’s here, it’s clear that Paul struggled with depression for many years, if not his whole life.
I worry that depression is something that our current social structures more or less foment. This notion of tiny ‘nuclear’ families of 2-3-4-5 people, living in a series of while rectangular boxes, where they watch tv and sleep and park, seems very unnatural and unhealthy to me.
A vibrant daily social life seems almost precluded by our modes of living and working, yet it is the only path to happiness for most of us.
Every moment of every day, I miss living and working in a community that nourishes me continually, and allows me to convince myself that things are going to be ok.
I agree. it’s tragic that Andrew probably found that kind of extended community on the other side of his addiction in his last months.
BooMan, thank you for sharing your feelings and insights into your brother’s passing. You never know who might be helped by it.
Having spent some months as a student learning about addiction to alcohol and later as the coordinator of an employee assistance program, I got to know a lot more about this problem than most people and still, feel that I barely scratched the surface.
There are two ways out. The ultimate in bottoming out and sobriety. Neither are easy. And, they affect your family and friends in either case.
It’s a tough story to write and in the “old” days would have been swept under the rug. This way, the way you chose, helps us all. Thanks.
Thank you for sharing this, Booman. Heartbreaking to read.
What a beautiful tribute to your brother. “Everyone you meet is fighting a hard battle”, and I’m sorry that your brother’s battle was so difficult and and painful to him and to everyone who loved him. Peace.
Thank you for sharing that with us, Martin. I can’t have been easy. I hope you find some solace in knowing he helped others in their time of need. That is a far greater gift than most of us realize in this life.
Thank you for opening up to us about this deeply personal and difficult time. My sincere condolences for you and your family, I hope you can find some measure of peace.
Thanks for sharing all of this, BooMan. Your brother made quite a journey. He was a very brave man.
My deepest condolences to you and your family. Your brother’s conscious choices about how he wanted to spend his time and use his energy have inspired me to want to take better care of my moments. I have shared this with a friend whose 19 year old son committed suicide (he was addicted to heroin) and another friend (a recovering alcoholic)who counsels women who are working with their addictions.
I cannot thank you enough for this powerful, loving tribute to your brother.
I’ve thought carefully about this situation for the last day or two. It’s sad and tragic. We can all be overwhelmed by addiction. It’s all too easy. The pull of drugs (alcohol, opiates, marijuana, tobacco) is strong. The human experience for thousands of years is that we have used alcohol, probably pot as well, also opium. We like to get high. I enjoy a glass of wine. I used to smoke dope in college, and dropped acid 3-4 times in college as well. Interesting experiences.
But we also must remain vigilant. These drugs are always overstimulating our pleasure centers, and we all like to have our pleasure centers stimulated.
Thank you, Martin, for sharing this time. It’s good that your brother was fighting, and that he had made some measure of progress. I myself always ask if I ma over-using. One sister had to quit drinking entirely, and also a brother-in-law as the alcohol got too strong for them. They couldn’t do moderation. Sometimes I have trouble with that too.
But we always have to ensure that we are maintaining the balance. And I thank you and your brother for the reminder.
Did your brother leave a family of his own?
Yes, an ex-wife and three children, two sons and a daughter.
The kids in particular are the most important at this time, as you only get one father. They must be teens or so. Please be nice to them. I am sure that you and CG are doing what you can. I hope that all the family helps them as much as possible.
As I get older, I appreciate family more. We come into this world and have a few family members. While we are teens and in our early 20s, we value our friends. But they go their separate ways, and we have family left. At the end, it’s family that is there. Not being sentimental or so, but it’s tremendously good that you saw and talked to your brother on the last day or so. Keep that memory close.
I’m sorry for your loss. Your brother seemed like a great guy. I hope his ex-wife and children are okay.
As someone who got the help that I needed when I needed to decide between the bottle and a fuller life, I can say that the unconditional love Andrew spoke of is crucial. It pissed me off to hear my wife and others say that it would get better when I was at my lowest, but it was true. As I´m sure you know, the same is true for you and those Andrew has left behind.
As someone who tried to help a couple of my brothers who did not want sobriety despite the severe and broad problems alcoholism was causing in their lives, I can say that extending unconditional love to family members under these circumstances is complicated and difficult. It did use up my good will for them, and their good will for me. That causes me pains that don´t go away, but they are pains I can live with. I couldn´t have lived, REALLY lived, without dumping the drink and the emotional abuse.
I´m glad Andrew was able to maintain a length of sobriety at the end. I hope he was able to begin rebuilding some of the bridges burned, but the new bridges he was burning had great value to him and others, I can see.
Thanks for being a friend and sharing this with us, Martin.
¨…new bridges he was building…¨, I meant to write, of course.
Thanks for the kind words for your brother. I’ve been down that road and it’s sad to hear of his struggles, but I’m heartened he could spend his last few months proud of himself for being sober and on a good path of life. My heart is with you and the rest of his family – I know you all have suffered greatly over the years.
Oh Booman, my heart doubly touches yours and your family. My son struggled for over 30 years with his depression and addiction. He too had wonderful friends in recovery who knew and appreciated him. He too, loved music – his guitar – and composing. He too lost his battle with this cunning, baffling dis-ease. When we cleaned out his public housing apartment we found this:
“without love
whats the fighting for?
without hate
can we be any more?
we ain’t faceless names
in a crowd to be ignored.
we’re everyday faces in common places
and more.
I see peace in your eyes
on a friendly shore.
it’s the passage back to the place
where I was before.
Prism of light
welcome me through the door.
When The Man spoke to me
I weren’t scared anymore”
It brought me peace.
I’m so sorry, Booman. I have been going through this with a family member for a long time and I really feel for how tough this has been and continues to be for you.
I hope you can find peace.
I am so grateful for this reflection about your brother’s life and death. I am inspired by so many parts of it, and maybe a tiny bit wiser about what really matters. I am so sad at your brothers passing and so happy you are with us to carry the torch.