Washington Post columnist Kathleen Parker is appropriately appalled by Donald Trump, who she refers to as a “a mean, narcissistic, bloviating SOB.” She accurately describes him as “the ultimate personification of a variety of vices (greed, intemperance, gluttony, wrath, pride).”
But, you know, someone must be blamed for his popularity, and it can’t just be the people who support him. It must be all of us.
So, for example, it’s not just that Trump personifies vice, it’s that “our culture” has embraced vice.
We’re all consumerists who are six seconds away from stampeding our neighbors in the local Wal Mart as we seek the latest “deal” on a holiday gift. And we’ve all embraced relativism, so we’re incapable of making basic moral judgments.
These past several days marking the season of gratitude have been emblematic of the moment when someone like Trump could become king of the heap. Consumerism run amok is what we tamely name Black Friday, the super-sale day when you’re as likely to be trampled (occasionally to death) in a stampede for The Deal, the art of which is in the eye of the beholder.
Consumer-itis seems to become more acute with each passing year, infecting even our relationships. We quantify other people as we would any commodity, making them into things, not quite human. She’s not this enough; he’s not all that. Indulging and gratifying ourselves, instantly and without reserve, we’re no longer subject to the traditional inoculations of conscience — shame, embarrassment and fear. We never judge because this would be to suggest objective standards in a subjective world of relativity.
As Tonto said, “Whatcha mean ‘we’, paleface?”
Almost everything I write makes some appeal to shame or embarrassment, and unlike in France, I don’t think lack of fear describes anything about our political system.
Parker’s complaints that people engage in gluttony on Thanksgiving and gifting on Christmas are as old as the modern versions of these holidays. Have these things gotten worse?
It sounds like the perennial bitching about “kids, these days” and their devil’s music.
Anyone who isn’t paid to say differently already knows what’s changed that makes it possible for Donald Trump to lead the pack in a Republican presidential nominating contest.
And it’s not how much turkey we eat or how hard we try to save a few bucks on Christmas gifts.
If you want an explanation for Trump’s popularity, start at the beginning with the simple stuff.
Who is the candidate who ought to be in the lead?
When Parker can answer that simple question, maybe she can explain all that candidate’s vices away and convince us that we’d all be on board if only we weren’t so busy being judgmental about our friends and gorging ourselves on turkey and pie.
No.
What’s different this time–what’s broken–is the American right and the Republican Party.
You want more shame and embarrassment?
Consider for a few moments how this happened to the Grand Old Party and examine your own small role in it.
And examine why, even now, when you fear the natural repercussions of your career as a GOP fangirl, you are blame-shifting and attempting to make this our fault.
“Our culture” didn’t just get this way on its own. And “our culture” is made up of tens of millions of people who aren’t going to vote for Donald Trump or any of his shitty competitors.
“We” aren’t the problem.
But… but… but…
BOTH SIDES DO IT! BOTH SIDES DO IT!
If the entire political spectrum is corrupt, then no blame can attach to one side more than the other! It cannot be!
How can you possibly take that crutch away from poor, poor Kathleen? How can you possibly expect that poor sheltered thing to peek outside the comfortable cocoon of the Village and distinguish among the barbarians at her gated community?
Ask yourself who benefits from the widespread adoption of this point of view.
Remember:
Don’t vote — it just encourages them.
It’s all a shuck — and the smart people have already seen right through it.
Nobody I know votes — they’re beyond all that.
No voter suppression program is as successful as the voter who suppresses himself.
Exactly.
The “centrist” BothSidesDoItTM is the BigLie that enables all of the little lies that the Republican party is able to cast out time and time again.
If BothSidesDoItTM, then your vote doesn’t really matter, and you might as well stay at home.
And then the fascists come out and vote, because they know better.
If voting didn’t matter, they wouldn’t be spending loads of money and passing loads of laws, trying to make it as hard as possible to vote. That’s the tell.
If nothing else, pick a candidate you like. If they aren’t on the ballot as the major party candidate, vote for the person that your favorite candidate is going to vote for. If you instead stay home and let the perfect be the enemy of the good, then at best, you aren’t a part of the solution. In reality, you’re actually part of the problem, but I know that view is often frowned upon around here.
It’s all projection, all the time with these willfully ignorant Republicans. Cause and effect, decisions and consequences are for the little people.
That’s how they sleep at night.
Slash taxes, budget doesn’t balance – the Laugher Curve didn’t fail, Social Security must be cut.
Go to Iraq destabilize the region – who coulda knowed – 5th column Democrats didn’t clap loud enough.
Spew bigotry and hate for 60 years – Trump leads the polls – damn Hollywood liberals and Planned Parenthood sluts.
White, privileged, rightwing Republicans are never wrong, it’s axiomatic.
……”She’s not this enough; he’s not all that… . We never judge because… .” Huh??
Beyond what appears to this guy to be a rather significant contradiction in Ms. Parker’s thoughts, I agree Booman, the collective “We” didn’t create this mess. An entire generation of Faux Noise may have helped set the stage though for conservatives to fall off the wagon.
‘
As if the MSM has never gone all in for a celebrity, wannabe politician for high office. George Murphy, Ronald Reagan, Arnold Schwarzenegger. (Fred Thompson, but they couldn’t catapult him to the nomination.) Or low office, Sonny Bono. iirc Al Franken wasn’t accorded a similar level of deference when he ran for the Senate, but perhaps in MN he was.
What pisses off the media folks about Trump and Carson is that they didn’t anoint either of these celebrities. And they’ve been miserable failures in trying to turn Jeb? into a celebrity.
I don’t suppose telling this highly paid GOoP enabler to look in the mirror will do much good. She is blind and oblivious, and is paid to produce feeble schlock like this claptrap.
It’s sorta comic that the American Right has for 50 years blamed the communist left for the decline of American values, and the rising tide of “vice” and waning of the Christian virtues. Since this very decline is now supposedly fueling Trump, the left is now to blame for his popularity (with GOoP voters!) Very convenient.
As Jesus said, Kathleen, “Black Friday ye will always have with ye…”
Yes, nothing can ever be the fault of the “conservative” movement or the Dr Frankenstein(s) who sewed the various body parts onto the monster or the Team coaches who called the appalling plays. Or the plutocrats who funded the movement (and who also created and foisted Black Friday madness on us, Kathleen.) She looks out at the ugliness of late capitalism and Fasci-servatism and blames not the princes but the peasants. Typical helot mentality.
So now when their monster won’t obey its creator it’s EVERYONE’S fault, including those who dissented and objected to every word of conservative crapola and warned of proto-fascism for years. Including especially the (anti-materialist!) hippies, no doubt.
Yes, Kathleen, we do have a problem of societal decline–that enormous numbers of otherwise useful citizens have been cretinized by 30 years of ingesting conservative sewage broadcast into their homes and monster pick-ups on a daily basis. That after 30 years of daily living in a toxic environment (contaminated by the princes and dukes of Black Friday-style capitalism) these citizens cannot think straight, cannot reason adequately and are motivated by rage, resentment and hatred of their gub’mint. And that they have (very logically) decided Der Trumper makes a lot of sense to their (now) deranged minds. The way has been prepared, but the dissenters are (really) to blame.
That Trump makes sense mostly to those who want to vote in Repub primaries seems to go unnoticed in her lofty analysis. But that is of course the entire point of the exercise.
Trump is doing well in GOP circles without contributing much to WaPo advertising revenues. Time to pay your bribe, Trump…
And exactly how many Democrats are planning to vote for Trump, Kathleen?
This was the same woman who was shocked, shocked that Sarah Palin’s followers went full metal virtual lynch mob on her when she wrote critical column about Palin.
I was trying to remember what it was that caused non-conservatives to think kindly of Parker for a short while, and your post reminded me.
Other than hearing about how much they don’t stand with black lives matter but oppose the shooting of McDonald, this Thanksgiving was fairly uneventful.
Although mom was definitely listening to some fascist shit this morning. Kept turning it off when I walked by to make breakfast like she’s hiding it.
At least she recognizes that you disapprove. Good start. Perhaps someday she’ll be interested in knowing why you disapprove.
Hmmm, hadn’t thought of it that way before. That gives me some peace of mind, I guess. It was some men and women talking about Trump and refugees, and I could hear her thinking out loud about how she “at least respects Trump about this, as opposed to Obama…”
As a kid I wondered how fascism could so easily rise to power democratically. I guess now I know.
“Brainwashing” people isn’t that difficult. All that’s needed is to hook into a pre-existing shortcoming (need for approval within a group) or wacky belief (religion). Once in, plant seemingly consistent notions that “make sense.”
Fear and hate.
They win more than they lose in Democracies.
OT:
UH HUH
UH HUH
GOP Candidates Take Different View of Heroin Crisis
November 27, 2015
excerpt:
Several GOP presidential contenders have advocated treating the nation’s growing heroin epidemic as a health crisis, not a criminal one. But most stop short of advocating the same approach to other drug laws, notably those involving marijuana and crack cocaine, which disproportionately affect African Americans.
Such views highlight the resonance and reach of the opiate epidemic — but also a persistent racial and geographic divide in American politics. The heroin epidemic has overwhelmingly hit whites. It has also skyrocketed to the top of voters’ lists of political priorities in the same bands of America — rural states, the suburbs and notably the early voting state of New Hampshire — that track directly with where Republicans must perform well to win back the White House next year
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/gop-contenders-are-talking-about-drug-abuse-but-racial-and-p
artisan-rifts-persist/2015/11/27/af5dfa14-87c0-11e5-9a07-453018f9a0ec_story.html
OH HELL NO!!
Nobody who voted DEM is responsible for Rat-On-Top-Of-Head Man.
Near as I can figure, Trump is very popular with the people he’s very popular with, and nearly all of those are Republicans.
Even then, even at his peak (about a week ago), only 43% of Republicans supported him.
According to an Reuters/Ipsos poll released yesterday, this has dropped to 31% in the past week.
http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/11/27/us-election-trump-idUSKBN0TG2AN20151127
Thanks for the perspective here.
Trump is not an electable candidate in the general election. No way at all. He’s now said and done so many vile things and offended so many voter blocs that I no longer believe that even an October black swan event could win him the Presidency.
His chances of winning the Republican nomination is higher than zero, however, and that is distressing.
Much.
Lost in the Carson collapse is that the grifter’s votes seem to be heading to Trump (at least in the national polling):
http://elections.huffingtonpost.com/pollster/2016-national-gop-primary
What’s most distressing to me is that Trump is not worst than any of the other “candidates”. He just says out loud what the rest imply. But anyone who’s been paying attention knows they advocate what Trump does. That’s what irritates me most about the Trump coverage. The mainslime media are so happy to attack him as an outlier.
Well, that’s close to true, but conveniently for the other GOP POTUS candidates not quite true. Trump’s most ridiculous statements and positions (Muslim database, mocking disabled people) are outliers. It allows the other candidates to say “I’m not that guy!”
I agree that the other GOP candidates’ campaign platforms do not differentiate themselves significantly from Trump’s, other than the Donald’s unworkable mass deportation plank.
How can you probably take that crutch away from inadequate, inadequate Kathleen? How can you probably anticipate that inadequate protected aspect to look outside the relaxed cocoon of the Town and differentiate among the barbarians at her private community?
gcse tuition harrow
If I ignored history I might buy this.
But I know some history, and I don’t.
Barry Goldwater in 1964 was every bit the nut job Donald Trump is.
Remember Reagan in ’80: welfare queens driving Cadillacs and trees that created more pollution than factories.
Christ, Robertson took second Iowa in ’88. PAT fucking Robertson.
And then there was Huckabee in ’08, and Bachman, and Santorum.
Sorry, I don’t buy the GOP is broken this time. They have been broken for a long time.
If there is something different this time – and I don’t think there is – it is to be found on Facebook. Trump is ahead because he doesn’t back down to outrage. This is a significant part of his appeal.
Iowa is a strange place. It’s full of little farming towns founded by oddball Protestant sects from Germany. Not typical of the US electorate at all. At one time it might have been. Two positive things about Iowa, no mountains, and good German food, particularly the pork.