I haven’t seen the Mueller Report. No one I know has seen it. None of the columnists and pundits were are opining on it have seen it. What they and I have seen is a self-serving memorandum that attorney general William Barr sent to the chairmen and ranking members of the congressional judiciary committees. This is one reason that I won’t be joining my colleague Joshua Alvarez in his end zone dance that “the Mueller report [didn’t] amount to much of anything.”
If you want to know what part of the Mueller investigation matters, it’s not the part that sought to prove that Trump told the Russians to hack into the DNC, DCCC and John Podesta’s email. It’s not the part that looked into any possible coordination in how and when that hacked information was utilized. It’s not the part where they tried to discover if the Russian fake-news troll factory in St. Petersburg coordinated with the campaign in some way. These theories were floated and run down by Mueller’s team, and they seem to come up short of anything they were willing to bring into a court room. It’s these theories that could collectively be called “collusion” and that William Barr was able to inform Congress had not been proven.
What we need to do here is to take a step back and reflect on how these theories all got started in the first place. In the summer and fall of 2015, few people were taking Donald Trump seriously as a candidate for the Republican nomination, but he was getting a lot of attention from the press mainly because he was famous and outrageous. He said a lot of politically incorrect or unorthodox things, but one of his themes was particularly curious. He kept saying nice things about Vladimir Putin and making excuses for his murderous behavior.
In 2015, most American politicians were concerned that Russia had been busy interfering in elections and boosting far-right white nationalist parties on two continents, downing passenger jets, throwing journalists out of windows, poisoning and assassinating people in their homes on foreign soil and killing others with radiation and military grade nerve agents. But Trump was different. He approved of Russia’s move into Syria on the spurious rationale that they would fight ISIS there rather than prop up the genocidal regime of Bashar al-Assad. He doubted that Putin really had any journalists killed and stated that even if he did it was no worse than the things the American government does on a routine basis. In addition to being crazy, these comments made no political sense.
Trump’s rhetoric about Putin was odd enough that it aroused suspicion that he had some hidden financial motivation that explained it. In October 2015, Republican donor Paul Singer, through his magazine The Washington Free Beacon, contracted with Glenn Simpson of Fusion GPS to investigate Trump’s foreign business ties, including with Russia. This contract ended when Trump became the presumptive Republican nominee, but the suspicion didn’t go away and the Clinton campaign retained Fusion GPS to continue their investigation.
As it turns out, the suspicions were correct. The same month that Paul Singer hired Glenn Simpson, Trump signed a letter of intent to build the tallest building in Europe. The location was Moscow. For more than three years afterwards, Trump would deny that he had any financial ties to Russia or was pursuing any business deals there. Every one of those denials was a lie.
So, to summarize how this began, Trump said things about Putin and Russia that made people suspect that he was either protecting or pursuing business interests there. That is precisely what he was doing. He lied about it. The Russians knew he was lying about it. This gave the Russians leverage over Trump, because they could reveal his lies at at any time. They could have sunk his chances of winning either the Republican nomination or the general election, but they refrained from doing that. Instead, they sent emissaries to talk about sanctions relief. They launched a massive multi-faceted campaign to damage Hillary Clinton and assist Donald Trump.
Without rehashing all the familiar contacts between Russia-linked operatives and the Trump campaign (which now number 102), we shouldn’t have any difficulty understanding that Russia cultivated and assisted Trump because they wanted to get out from under the sanctions that were imposed on them after they annexed Crimea. Putin also felt a personal animosity toward Hillary Clinton, but that was secondary and still related to the issue of money.
If you stop and think about the rumored “pee tape” for a minute, it’s clear that the reason people were willing to believe it is because they needed some explanation for Trump’s behavior. It seemed obvious that Putin had something he was holding over Trump, so maybe it was good old fashioned kompromat with hookers from the time Trump went to Moscow to host his beauty pageant.
But it didn’t need to be that at all. Trump was pursuing (and then hiding) his Moscow Trump Tower deal, and that alone was enough to compromise him.
After the intelligence community established that Russia was responsible for hacking the Democrats, Trump inexplicably refused to credit their findings. He did this on the campaign trail, in the presidential debates, and even after he had been given detailed intelligence briefings. He continued to do it when he was president-elect. He even resumed doubting the evidence after he had officially accepted it.
After the election, the intelligence community went further and declared that Russia had intervened on Trump’s behalf, and at that point he may have felt that it was a way of denying him full credit for his victory, but his denials began the day that the leaks were first blamed on Russia, way back in June 2016.
Once elected, he immediately signaled that he would move to lift sanctions on Russia, even as the Obama administration was putting down new sanctions as punishment for the election interference. The contrast is what caused the first scandal of the Trump administration and the resignation of his national security adviser Michael Flynn.
Since Trump has been in office he has continued to say and do things that indicate or strongly suggest that he is indebted somehow to Vladimir Putin. Here are some examples:
1. Advocating that Americans pull their troops out of the Far East.
2. Advocating that Americans pull out of Syria and arguing that the Russians only want to be there to fight ISIS.
3. Arguing that Crimea rightfully belongs to Russia because many ethnic Russians live there.
4. Saying NATO is obsolete.
5. Refusing to commit to the protection of former-Soviet NATO members in the Baltics.
6. Refusing to commit to the protection of NATO member Macedonia.
7. Attacking the European Union.
8. Calling the European Union a “foe.”
9. Supporting the United Kingdom’s split from the European Union.
10. Supporting the same Euro-Skeptic far right white nationalist parties that Putin supports.
11. Attacking and undermining the governments in London and Berlin, which present the strongest resistance to Putin’s influence in Europe.
12. Attacking the U.S. intelligence community and federal law enforcement agencies to undermine their credibility with the American public.
13. Decimating the Department of State.
14. Pulling out of the Trans-Pacific Partnership
He also arranges to meet with Putin privately whenever he can, and the results have been suspicious every single time. When my colleague Joshua Alvarez says that the “the narratives of Trump-the-Manchurian-Candidate” and “Trump-the-Russian-Agent,” have been debunked by the Mueller Report, he doesn’t have much to support his claim.
With the firing of FBI director James Comey, the intelligence community made a decision that they could no longer avoid the main topic raised by Trump’s behavior with respect to Russia. He actually crowed to the Russian ambassador and foreign minister in an undisclosed Oval Office meeting the next day that he’d fired Comey and thereby released great pressure off himself. While he was doing that, he divulged sensitive information about Syria that we had obtained from the Israelis. New FBI director Andrew McCabe authorized a counterintelligence investigation into Trump within the week. Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein quickly authorized a Special Counsel investigation which then inherited the counterintelligence investigation.
This wasn’t a look at what the Trump campaign had known about the hacking or how they might have coordinated with the Russians during the campaign. It was a look at whether the president was compromised in some way and under the influence of a foreign power.
This is the “real” Mueller Report, and we have not yet heard a peep about it. Before anyone does any end zone dances, we need to see the conclusions of this report. And, as NBC News reports, that will allegedly happen soon:
Two senior U.S. officials told NBC News on Monday that the FBI is prepared to brief congressional leaders on the counterintelligence findings of special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation.
The FBI opened a counterintelligence investigation into President Donald Trump, and the letter sent to Congress on Sunday by Attorney General William Barr about the Mueller probe is silent on the question of whether investigators found that Trump or anyone around him might be compromised or influenced by Russia.
The officials said they expect the FBI to brief the so-called Gang of 8 — the leaders of the House and the Senate and the chairmen and ranking members of the intelligence committees — in closed session.
No briefing has been scheduled, a third U.S. official familiar with the matter said, but one of the officials said it could happen within the next 30 to 60 days.
In the weeks and months before the Mueller investigation concluded, I began to worry that Trump had succeeded in making everything think the main concern was “collusion.” On January 22, I wrote A Compromised Administration Is as Bad as a Colluding One, and on March 20, I wrote, It’s Not the Collusion, Stupid! It’s the Compromise. These were efforts to refocus people’s minds on the primary thing that matters. What matters is not what William Barr reported on to Congress. What matters are the counterintelligence findings of special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation.
As a public relations matter, Trump had a fantastic week and now he seeks to demolish his enemies for seemingly having come at the king and missed. In this, he’s being inadvertently assisted by a lot of pundits and reporters who bought into the idea that the problem is that Trump may have cheated in the election. The problem has always been far deeper and more serious than that. The problem is that Trump is appears to be compromised and unable to fulfill the duties of his office.
Obviously, we must see the evidence of obstruction of justice that William Barr dismissed, and clearly Trump is facing investigations into everything from his charities to his hotels to banking, wire and insurance fraud to the conduct of his inaugural committee. But the main thing we must see is what our counterintelligence experts have concluded about the president. That’s the real Mueller Report.
Thank you.
I just don’t know how much more slowly you can type to press this point but glad you made the effort, again.
As I’ve mentioned before, Trump has had some sort of relationship with the Russians going all the way back to the late Soviet period.
And when his daddy’s money finally ran out, around 2005, the Russian oligarchs that are part of the larger de facto Putin regime started raining millions of dollars on Trump for money laundering purposes. Both Don Jr and Eric have said, they don’t rely on US financing, which they wouldn’t get anyway because their money comes from Russia and/or Russian money laundered through Deutsche Bank.
So, sure the immediate incentive for Trump to cozy up to Russia was the potential blackmail that Trump Tower Moscow presented but the secondary and related reason was the money laundering (and the associated wire and tax frauds). The third reason was that Putin is a white nationalist and fascist, which partly explains Putin’s subversion of Europe (Brexit, French election interference, etc.). And as we know, Trump genuinely likes strong men and white supremacists. So, Trump was the perfect candidate for Putin (except I’m sure he also knows that Trump is irredeemably stupid).
Some of this should be in the counter-intelligence report and all of it should be but whether it is or not is unknown to the public.
Thank you for this excellent documentation of the facts and how we got here. I will save this for reference as this situation unfolds, as what I am sure will ultimately be recorded as a truly shameful saga in American history.
That said:
“This is one reason that I won’t be joining my colleague Joshua Alvarez in his end zone dance that “the Mueller report [didn’t] amount to much of anything.”
I couldn’t agree more. I know how the press can be but I am still astounded to the extent that media people, damn near everyone on the right and even some on the left are essentially saying the Mueller report “puts the matter to rest” if not outright agreement that it exonerates Trump, when no one has seen the Mueller report. Its clear Barr’s summary is problematic, politically and legally, because if it wasn’t the Trump/GOP wouldn’t’ be fighting so hard to keep the full report from Mueller hidden from the public.
Hopefully democrats in the House will get Mueller and others involved on the public record, and get the full report released sooner rather than later. When they do, all this crowing going on about exoneration will prove to be a Pyrrhic victory, at best.
Can Nadler subpoena Mueller to show up before the House Judiciary Committee? And if he can, why hasn’t he yet? If he can, the subpoenas should have been sent out first thing Monday morning.
They should have been sent out right after they had a chance to digest the Barr Whitewash, which would have been on Sunday.
I understand the need for introspection and consideration before making “big” moves, but I fear House democrats are dithering. Maybe I missed it but the formal request for trump’s taxes should have been sent already. Hearings should already be scheduled for Jared and Ivanka over their use of private email and other media, especially now that Graham is calling to reopen the Clinton email investigation. And subpoenas for Mueller and his prosecutors should be on their way as we speak. Maybe they are.
Some dems have said, forget it, we need to focus on winning in 2020. Let’s focus on health care and other issues. Okay, but is it too much to ask for them to walk and chew gum at the same time? I know what it is, as usual, they are afraid of the overreach republicans are warning them with will become reality, so best to slow walk this and ultimately do what amounts to nothing. But by accepting the false formulation that Mueller exonerated Trump, which is what they would be by “moving on” they give Trump ammo to argue yes, this was all a witch hunt by Mueller and his “17 angry dems.”
If nothing else, can we at least have talking points for all dems to push back on the steadily proliferating meme that Mueller “exonerated” trump?
I’ll say it again, csm.
Democrats are…and have been for many years…”dithering” because they are frightened that if the truth escapes its present imprisonment it will paint many of them (as well as the Republicans and Trumpists) ever-deepening shades of guilty.
Do you really believe, for example, that Chuck Schumer has been fronting for the Israelis and AIPAC for free!!!??? Out of the goodness of his heart?
Please!!!
I don’t.
Do you really believe that Harry Reid…who came up a professional boxer in Las Vegas during a time when the Mafia absolutely ruled all of Nevada…is or was in any way “clean?”
That Nancy Pelosi…whose father and brother (both Baltimore mayors) were plainly complicit in the Mafia’s control of Baltimore during their terms of office and also complicit in making Baltimore the most Jim Crow major city…with the possible exception of Boston…on the whole Northeastern corridor for decades?
Do you really believe that the Clintons did not lie and cheat their way from backcountry Little Rock to the top of the DC garbage heap? That Monica Lewinsky was not an unwitting honey trap-style agent of professional intelligence operatives? That Obama somehow magically appeared as the {faux) president who would save us all? Look into Rahm Emanuel’s background for more on THAT account!!
I won’t even go on about the Mafia influences in JFK’s career, Nixon’s Bebe Rebozo/Spiro Agnew mob connections or how “lucky” it was that JFK was shot in LBJ’s Texas.
And mob ally Jack Ruby took out the one remaining possible witness to the truths of the mater?
By some sort of “accident?”
The beat goes on.
And on and on and on and on and on…
Someone…some group (or groups) of power-holders…are continuing the DC blackmail traditions originally established by J. Edgar Hoover, and has the goods on all of them.
Bet on it.
It’s a tricky situation.
Trump’s enemies…competitors, actually…blow the whistle on him, and what happens?
Someone…someone who does not want that whistle blown…blows one on them!!!
Tit for tat.
Spy vs. spy.
And…
Stalemate vs. stalemate.
Disgusting on every level!!!
So it goes.
These people?
They deserve each other.
But the people who are repeatedly harmed by all of this hustling?
They do not even know that it’s been happening!!!
How could they?
Their media doesn’t tell them.
They’re so busy…and so worried…just trying to survive that they simply don’t have enough time and energy available to pick apart all of the lies.
But…be of good cheer.
It’s all going to come to a head eventually.
Wave after shitty wave is going to continue to buffet us before it’s all over.
Just keep swimming.
“The alternative”…as Churchill said in another mortal context…”is totally unacceptable!!!”
Swim on, friend csm.
Swim on.
This tidal wave of bullshit and deception too shall pass.
Bet on that as well.
I am.
Later…
ASG
My problem is that whatever we see won’t change any minds. The “Mueller report” became a magic talisman to too many people.
Sure, why would seeing a report no one has seen change any minds?
I think you’re missing my point. I was saying that the pro-Trump GOP isn’t going to support Trump any less because of the Mueller report, and I think some envisioned a massive loss of support for Trump as a result of this document. Opinions of Trump are set – lots of us despise him, a curious few still support him, and he could eat live kittens on TV and that wouldn’t change.
Maybe I’m misreading your comment, but it MATTERS to me and should matter to the whole country for the actual report to be made public. I don’t care if it doesn’t change one Republican’s minds. Most of the ethical ones seem to have decamped anyways. I also don’t want to be told that as a Democrat I have to go off and find another shiny object because this matter is settled. It isn’t and the Truth should matter to everyone of us.
Again, if I misread your comment, I apologize. But I am truly so very angry about this whole thing. Moreover I’m tired of Republicans winning the media framing when they behave so badly and so immorally and a supine complicity media supports that framing. It is all just so blankety-blank wrong.I will continue to fight until the truth is told. Anyone who’s been watching Trump from the get-go knows that he has obstructed justice, over and over again.
P.S, I’d also very much like to see for myself if Mueller is the stand-up guy we’ve all been told he is and that he was/is capable of transcending his Republican loyalties. Perhaps, too, as Dahlia Lithwick has written at Slate about Mueller that “perhaps his report was predicated on caring about facts. Our world is about who can claim victory the quickest.”
Facts Don’t Matter
I just write my comments too fast. I didn’t mean to imply that we shouldn’t see it – I think that’s vital.
What we have so far is William Barr’s report on the Mueller Report. Why all the news outlets think that is somehow definitive is beyond me. The notion that Barr’s report is objective and comprehensive is silly.
We are still waiting for the actual report, or at least to find out how much of it we will see, and when.
Because Democrats don’t make the obvious point as to why it’s not, that Barr is in the bag for Trump and that that’s why he was nominated.
Excellent. It is the totality of his actions that convict him. I was personally offended by his lone meeting with Putin in Helsinki and his spiking the ball with Lavorov after firing Comey to the point of illness. Stupid I know but this shit gets to me.
I don’t want to give him a pass on other things either. He violated campaign finance laws, a felony I am told, but they say a small matter. That was obstruction.
‘Russia if you’re listening….. and you will be rewarded mightily’. Marcy says there were several of these quid pro quos.
The princes and Manafort meeting in Trump Tower and agreement to repeal Magnitsky Act under the quise of adoptions. It doesn’t matter it didn’t happen. The intent to do so was there. And Rat Fucker Stone arranging for those Russian stolen emails via Wikileaks. Trump mightily talked up Wikileaks. I heard it a dozen times. How did you know that sir?
And Trump Tower in Moscow. That one really sucks. I bet the Kurds would like a sit down with him as well.
Anyway, I want the whole enchilada. Drag Mueller in front of the committee. Let’s hear what he has to say for himself.
Not to defend Trump, or minimized his subservience to Putin. But in context, I can’t read that quote as a quid pro quo. What he said was, “you will be mightily rewarded by the press.” Trump was fully aware how the “liberal” press was going after Hillary’s emails tooth and fang, and may have been simply expressing his delight at the potential windfall for his campaign
if Russia were to carry out that hack. The NYT would have been gleefully picking at Clinton’s carcass.
Trump: “I don’t have any links to Russia”
Media: “Here is publicly available evidence of 99 links between Trump and Russia”
Barr: “Mueller didn’t find any links between Trump and Russia (besides the 99 you already know about because they are public knowledge)”
Media: “TRUMP VINDICATED!!”
Brilliant!
Booman, you tie it all up quite brilliantly. This is a great summary and I know I will be returning to it over and over.
All of this is true, but the question is, will the report ever be seen? I’m guessing not. Maybe if the Republicans are decisively defeated next year.