I was born in 1969 so my introduction to the world was perfectly timed to provide a sense of discontinuity with the past. My older brothers, both born in the 1950’s, had memories of a time before the major civil rights legislation of the 1960’s. They witnessed the English Invasion and Jimi Hendrix and Janis Joplin when they were alive. They watched our cities burn in race riots and saw Malcolm and Martin and Robert get assassinated. They were glued to the television when the Chicago police beat protestors during the Democratic National Convention of 1968, and when we landed on the moon in 1969. They faced the prospect of being sent to Vietnam if the war continued to drag on.
For me, all these things were in the past, and everything that came before them seemed as distant and foreign as the black and white footage of our World Wars. What did The Bee Gees have in common with Buddy Holly, or Diff’rent Strokes have in common with My Three Sons? The rupture in time was so extreme that it seemed impossible to me that the 1950’s were less than twenty years in the past.
Of course, I went to high school and college in the years immediately prior to the internet, and this created another rupture in time. Talking to my children, it can sometimes feel like my childhood experiences are similarly foreign to them. But I don’t really think the second rip in time comes close to the first. Anyone sent from the present back to the 1980’s or early 1990’s would not feel like they’d entered an entirely different country or culture. Nothing has happened, even the internet, the cell phone, and the end of the Cold War, that is as monumental as the introduction of the pill or end of Jim Crow or the trauma of Vietnam and Watergate.
But I think that is changing now. I believe we’re entering a second period like the 1960’s, and what’s really driving it is the arrival of a generation that does not share our assumptions about the virtuous past. My generation rallied against apartheid in South Africa in an amnestic way, as if we hadn’t maintained the same type of system right up to moment of our conception in the mid-to-late 1960’s. But that meant that we thoroughly rejected that past. What we were less likely to reject was the narrative of our country’s founding or the heroic stories of settling the West. We were taught to question colonialism as practiced by the Europeans, but we were somehow exempt from that criticism.
In today’s context, it’s the difference between pushing to take down relics of the Old South and pushing to take down every statue of a conquistador or slaveowner. This is happening here in America, but it’s also happening in Europe. There’s a new reckoning and a different moral judgment about the past, and much like Gone With the Wind is suddenly seen as far too celebratory of a way of life that was indefensible, so too is the idea of honoring someone like Cecil Rhodes.
We’re entering an iconoclastic age, where old symbols are smashed to make way for a whole new way of looking at the world. How we police our cities is most definitely a central part of this, and how we go about incarcerating people will probably come next. A lot of it is going to go too far and too fast for people of my generation, just as the changes in the 1960’s challenged even the progressive-minded people behind the New Deal. There will be a new kind of backlash as two irreconcilable worldviews are forced to live together within the same population and electorate. Many from my generation will evolve and adjust, and others will fight back with everything they have.
But what I’m pretty sure about is that twenty years from now, the last decade will seem as strange and distant as the 1950’s looked to me in the 1970’s.
I hope so. Major cultural change always cause disruptions, of course, but if the Democrats manage to control all three branches of government next year I will feel a huge weight has been lifted off of our ability to brighten our future.
I was born in “63, so between you and your brothers. I have memories of the earlier times, last wisps of that more idealistic time. I remember landing on the moon. I very much remember Watergate. The day Nixon resigned felt like a triumph but it got undercut when Nixon was pardoned by Ford. But then Jimmy came along and there were still gasps of idealism.
I missed the earlier time, when Dylan was singing “Blowing in the Wind” and it felt like everything was going to be transformed for the better. I very much remember when cynicism settled in and became fashionable. We’ve been there ever since except that those your age and younger, as you said, don’t remember anything earlier so rather than holding it as a reaction to an idealism disappointed, it’s just the world as it is and always was.
As far as going forward, it’s hard to predict. But we know that demographic changes are happening. There’s been seismic shifting happening under the surface for a long time. It’s why we sprang first one way, with Obama, and then the other with Trump. It’s been a time of flux. At some point a tipping point will come and there will be no return, and I’m sure everyone here feels it can’t happen quickly enough. It’s coming. I don’t know if we’re there yet because we’ve not yet felt the backlash to this latest chapter of BLM. I’m watching for it. There are wisps of steam but they don’t seem to condense into dark clouds. Not yet anyway. So I hope and pray that maybe we’ve crossed the Rubicon. But I don’t trust it. Not yet.
1966 here. I mostly remember the cynicism. That became the fashionable pose to our detriment. There was a tentative change in the air around 2008. I really need there to be some hope that the shift that seems to be happening is sustainable going forward. The “left” I came of age with was bitter. Grew worse with age. Right now, there are many of us who want and need voices of hope, voices of change. After what has gone down this year already? There is no going back to some imagined normal. There is only discovering what our lived experience will be in the future. If we’ve finally crossed the rubicon that sweeps white nationalism to the margins? I’ll be able to breathe a much needed sigh of relief.
“They faced the prospect of being sent to Vietnam if the war continued to drag on.”
Too damn right. And since it had been around all of my life – seemed like the odds of it going on another 3 years was pretty good. So I volunteered for McGovern – handing out flyers, canvassing doing office work. That war shaped my politics more than anything else in my life…
The main thing I’d add to this is that change is going to happen now incredibly fast. It took the country 102 years from the end of The Civil War to the turning over the ban on interracial marriage (1865 to 1967, Loving v. Virginia). It took just 19 years to do the same for gay marriage (1996 DOMA Act to 2015). The difference: The internet, the cell phone, social media, more messages everywhere, more awareness, more sensitivity, more issues in your face. We are going to get whiplash from the number of changes and alterations to our society. I’m all for it. I’m an old man who still teaches. I tell my students to push hard and make changes.In the words of that well know sage, Larry the Cable Guy: “Get ‘er done!”
I hope you’re correct about this next decade being a lot like the 1960’s. Over the years, I’ve watched too many people who rebelled during the late 1960s become right wing Fox viewers. It will be interesting to see if they shift the other way, because some of them were just doing the fashionable thing at the time. However, if their Social Security and Medicare are threatened, they’ll definitely be out there with “the kids”.
Right-wing authoritarian fascism has been slow-burning in the US for the past 80+ years. House Un-American Activities in 1938, codified in multiple practices by Taft-Hartley in 1947, and of course outright explicit Empire that had only been tinkered with previously. WWII made us the victors, and to the victors go the spoils or whatever.
Booman writes:
That “feel” of the culture being the same, is one of the aspects of a slow creep of fascism that doesn’t go about changing things all too much at once.
There is a book published in the 1950s, about the arrival and then normalization of right-wing authoritarian fascism in Germany. They Thought They Were Free: The Germans 1933-1945 by Milton Mayer.
In that book, an oft-quoted passage explains how fascism creeps in and voila, shit hits the fan. I will quote it below.
What I quoted of you, and what I bold quoted of Mayer, is similar. The forms of things seem the same, when they really aren’t. Fascism is often like water to fish, or air to land animals – totally surround them, yet not noticed.
What got Mayer to “wake up” from his slumber was his son using fascist rhetoric without even knowing it. I have to hope that the video footage of fascists murdering black people today is similar for our society – a wake up call. This is way more than just that police forces are racist. Police forces are used by fascists to control a population.
A blue-tsunami in 2020 and the required follow-up tsunamis in 2022 can get us on the right track, but just defeating Trump is not enough.
External Empire, now made ever-more distant by usage of death robots instead of boots, has to be ended, if we ever want Internal Empire aka the Police State, to end.
The 2020 Police Riots show just hold hard it is to stop the Internal Empire…it’s going to be a lot tougher to stop the External Empire – American Exceptionalism codeword bullshit that is hollowing out this country.