Here’s the official position of the editorial board of the National Review which very much does not want Georgia Republicans to bend to corporate criticism and undo their new voter suppression reforms:
A variety of factors have led to the capture of America’s major corporations by the social-justice-warrior wing of the Democratic Party. Corporate C-suites and legal and human-resources departments are increasingly staffed by products of woke university educations. The “diversity and inclusion” business sector is now itself an $8 billion a year industry. Corporate managers who are not themselves left-wing culture warriors are easily pushed around by a vocal minority of their employees or customers brandishing boycotts, lawsuits, and Twitter mobs. This is especially prevalent in sports, entertainment, and journalism, where prominent employees wield outsized public platforms.
How’s that for erudition?
William F. Buckley had his problems with liberal groupthink at elite universities, but he didn’t speak with this level of broad contempt for higher education.
As far as the magazine’s well-educated editors, they see pressure from elites as undesirable on every issue.
One result is that sports leagues, Hollywood, and big business have gotten into the habit over the past decade of threatening to pull their business from states whose legislatures pass laws that do not meet the approval of the cultural Left.
We have seen this pattern over and over with laws in Indiana, Arizona, North Carolina, South Dakota, and other states that addressed hot-button topics ranging from immigration to religious liberty to transgenderism to same-sex marriage. What has followed, in nearly every case, is that state governors have folded like a cheap suitcase rather than stick up for the democratic right of a free people to pass laws through their elected representatives, chosen in free and fair elections.
It’s true that Buckley opposed the Civil Rights Movement on the theory that white southerners, as the more “advanced race,” had the right to maintain their culture even by undemocratic means. But he eventually joined the 20th Century. Today, his magazine is defending discrimination against gays and demonization of foreigners as “religious liberty.”
They’re unlikely warriors against corporate influence, especially in defense of know-nothing populism. It’s also rich that they insist on a system where the people get to choose their elected representatives in “free and fair” elections ,but they’re doing it in a piece that rationalizes the lack of free and fair elections in Georgia.
So the National Review sounds just like every other Trumpist media organ, demanding that ultra-conservative culture warriors stand tough against scolding from big Georgia employers like Delta Air Lines and Coca-Cola that are unhappy with voter disenfranchisement.
Since NR published this article, Major League Baseball made an announcement:
Major League Baseball announced Friday that it is moving the 2021 All-Star Game out of Atlanta in response to a new Georgia law that has civil rights groups concerned about its potential to restrict voting access for people of color.
The 2021 MLB draft, a new addition to All-Star Game festivities this year, will also be relocated.
In a statement, MLB commissioner Rob Manfred said the league is “finalizing a new host city and details about these events will be announced shortly.”
Presumably, this underscores rather than undermines the Editors’ argument, which is that “the best medicine for corporate overreach is for state officials to stand their ground and call the companies’ bluff.” Except, it looks like the Georgia legislature had the losing hand.
It’s not like the state’s Republicans didn’t try to follow NR‘s advice. Before recessing for Easter on Wednesday, the Republican-controlled House retaliated against Delta’s CEO Ed Bastian by eliminating a jet-fuel tax break. They were angry about Bastion’s public criticism of their new election law. But the state Senate took no action, so who was bluffing?
Now they have no All-Star Game, and it’s wholly because the Georgia legislature doesn’t want people who look like they might play for the Atlanta Braves to have ballot access. They want to be able to throw their votes out with phony signature checks. They want the legislature to overrule state election officials and declare the loser the winner of an election if it suits their interests.
The U.S. Congress may pass an election protection bill that overrides Georgia state law, but until then the Republicans can call as many bluffs as they like. They’re not fooling anyone. Today, Major League Baseball pulled the plug. Tomorrow it could be Delta. It’s not a sign of virtue that you support anti-democratic legislation, and the National Review isn’t even convincing as a populist advocate for narrow minded bigotry. They sound ridiculous in this role.
5
5
Republicans are waging a culture war because they know their agenda is unpopular. The establishment GOP made a deal with Trump: enact our agenda (tax cuts, deregulation, rightwing judges) and in return, we’ll have your back if the Democrats try to hold you to account. And the establishment GOP got pretty much everything it wanted. They learned from Trump that they can enact their agenda by keeping their base distracted with culture war nonsense.
It’s really starting to look like 2021 is going to be the inaugural year of the “War On Christmas” having Walmart and Target identified as the actual villains. For the last 20 years I’ve been befuddled by the psychic disconnect of Bill Reilly (in the old days) and Fox and Friends (currently) clips demagoging the banishing of Christmas from the public square by political actors/socialists while the secular messaging of the holidays was economic/capitalist in nature.
I’m guessing this year they’ll take it straight to the stores and the corporations, tie it to masks and make it pure culture war against all external forces. I’m having a hard seeing how this is not how this particular fascist movements shrinks to political irrelevance (albeit while maintaining super dangerous cultural relevance), and remaining a threat to return. Wishful thinking?
At present rate masks will not be around at Christmas..
While I agree that we likely won’t be wearing masks, I have to believe the outrage and the mask-as-signifier-of-oppression will remain as burning ambers is the dark fires of right wing resentment.
This anti-corporate message seems from a distant perspective to be a coordinated and ginned up attack on the culture proper in a way that I don’t think I’ve witnessed in my lifetime (maybe after the 2008 bailout?, but even then, that was messaged by the right wingers I knew then as a government takeover of formerly pure and true corporations.
What struck me most, out of all of the above, was NR’s assertion that is was supporting “the democratic right of a free people to pass laws through their elected representatives, chosen in free and fair elections.”
This “woke” culture they complain about exists because in large parts of this country we have not ever had free and fair elections.
I live and work in a very Trumpy part of rural Caifornia (my county is 60% registered republican), and I had a conversation recently with a neighbor who essentially said “I don’t know why anyone wants to vote by mail. Voting is so easy. You go to your polling station and you cast your ballot.”
So I asked him: “What is the longest you have ever had to wait to vote?” He said “maybe ten, fifteen minutes.” I said ” me too! My longest wait was fifteen minutes, max.” Then I asked, “so, how would you feel if you had to stand in line for 8 hours to vote?” He looked at me with a blank stare, like he could not understand the question.
I would love to see a big push for the JLVRA that includes the message that making people wait in long lines to vote is blatant voter suppression.
Republicans have been using polling station wait-times a a very effective tool of voter suppression. (My first real awareness of it was what they did in Ohio in the 2000 presidential election.) It is time that tool is removed from their tool-box.
5
5
Not anti-corporation. Just anti-corporations that don’t tow their line. So tobacco, oil, and ???