Netanyahu is not listening to the administration and must be dealt with in a way that he will understand.
A group of progressive-minded U.S. Senators is trying to convince the Biden administration to do more to force Israel to allow humanitarian aid into the Gaza Strip. The main idea is to use a provision of the Humanitarian Aid Corridor Act that specifies that any nation that stands in the way of America providing civilian aid cannot receive military aid. The allegation is that Israel is guilty of stymying American assistance to Gazans and therefore should get cut off.
The letter, written by Senators Sanders, Chris Van Hollen of Maryland and Jeff Merkley of Oregon, is signed by some of the Democratic Party’s most progressive members: Senators Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts, Mazie K. Hirono of Hawaii, Peter Welch of Vermont, Tina Smith of Minnesota and Ben Ray Luján of New Mexico.
The cut-off wouldn’t be complete. For example, they’re not calling for a ban on defensive systems like the anti-missile Iron Dome that protects Israel from rocket fire. But Congress just passed a supplemental bill that provides $10 billion for offensive weapons for Israel, and this is a spigot that could be turned off.
This demand isn’t really inconsistent with what President Biden has stated himself in recent days.
Biden said a potential Israeli invasion of the Gaza city of Rafah, where more than 1.3 million Palestinians are sheltering, is “a red line” for him, but said he would not cut off weapons like the Iron Dome missile interceptors which protect the Israeli civilian populace from rocket attacks in the region.
And this is being signaled pretty strongly, for example, in the following Politico article:
President Joe Biden will consider conditioning military aid to Israel if the country moves forward with a large-scale invasion of Rafah, according to four U.S. officials with knowledge of internal administration thinking.
Biden’s openness to taking this step reflects the extreme strains in his relationship with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who has rejected subtler efforts by the Biden administration to rein in his conduct of the war with Hamas.
While Biden has not made any decision on limiting future weapons transfers, officials said that he very well might do so if Israel launches a new operation that further imperils Palestinian civilians.
“It’s something he’s definitely thought about,” said one of the officials, who like the others, was granted anonymity to speak freely.
So, we can really see the letter from the progressive senators as part of a coordinated pressure campaign on Israel rather than a pressure campaign on the administration. The intelligence community is also sending shots across Bibi’s bow.
“A new U.S. global intelligence assessment says that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s hold on office ‘may be in jeopardy’ and suggests Israel will fail to achieve its aim in the Gaza war of completely eliminating Hamas,” the Wall Street Journal reports.
“While challenges to Netanyahu’s continuation in power have been widely discussed since Hamas’s Oct. 7 attack on Israel, it appeared unusual for American spy agencies to offer their analysis of an allied leader’s political prospects in an unclassified document.”
For more that a month newspapers in Israel have been reporting that Biden privately refers to Netanyahu as “an asshole.” This is from March 10th in the Times of Israel:
There have been multiple reports in recent weeks that Biden is fed up with Netanyahu, including that he has referred to the prime minister as an “asshole” in private on multiple occasions.
Biden has expressed frustration to confidants, according to NBC News, over his “inability to persuade Israel to change its military tactics in Gaza.”
He has publicly denounced Netanyahu’s hard-right coalition and become increasingly public about his frustration with the Netanyahu government’s unwillingness to open more land crossings for critically needed aid to make its way into Gaza. In his State of the Union speech, he announced plans to build a temporary port on the Gaza coast to facilitate direct delivery of aid.
According to Politico, Netanyahu claimed the initiative to ship aid to Gaza via the sea as his idea and denied that people in Gaza were starving, as attested to by locals and relief organizations.
I’m sure Biden is not impressed to learn that Bibi is taking credit for the temporary port idea. Nor is he going to he happy with Netanyahu’s appearance before AIPAC in Washington DC on Tuesday where he said he will attack Rafah and doesn’t give a shit what any ally has to say about it.
“But let me be clear,” Netanyahu continues, “Israel will win this war, no matter what.”
Netanyahu says in order to do so, the IDF has to operate in Rafah, otherwise Hamas will “regroup, rearm, and reconquer Gaza.”
…He offers a broadside against Israel’s allies, telling them, “You cannot say you support Israel’s right to defend itself, and then oppose Israel when it exercises that right.”
“You cannot say you support Israel’s goal of destroying Hamas, and then oppose Israel when it takes the actions necessary to achieve that goal,” he goes on.
“You cannot say that you oppose Hamas’s strategy of using civilians as human shields, and then blame Israel for the civilian casualties that are the result of this Hamas strategy,” Netanyahu insists.
He says that they are holding Israel to a standard on civilian casualties that no other country is held to.
“None of these pressures will stop us,” he pledges.
In an oblique message to Biden, Netanyahu says that “the overwhelming majority of the American people stand with us. I know that the overwhelming majority of Congress stands with us.”
I’m not sure the political argument is persuasive to the Biden administration or the Biden campaign. It’s not unlikely that Biden will lose the election because of lost support from Muslim communities in Michigan and Minnesota, or just generally from younger voters who side with the Palestinians. But it’s not just about politics. It’s about good policy and doing what’s right.
I think Biden is going to have to make good on his threats with respect to Netanyahu. Military aid has to be cut off.