Imagine for a second that you are here living in the United States without legal permission. What’s the number one thing that can fuck up your world? Obviously, it’s interaction with legal authorities who will demand to see your documentation. Are you more or less likely than a U.S. citizen to exceed the speed limit? Are you more or less likely to shoplift? Are you more or less likely to do a snatch and grab robbery on the street. To truth is, you want to keep your head down and avoid attention. That’s why it’s no surprise that studies show that undocumented immigrants are less likely to commit crimes, including violent felonies, than legal immigrants or citizens. They have too much to lose. An arrest could lead to deportation not only for themselves but for other members of their family.
But that’s not what Donald Trump says. During his acceptance speech at the Republican National Convention, he claimed:
“The greatest invasion in history is taking place right here in our country — they are coming in from every corner of the earth, not just from South America, but from Africa, Asia and the Middle East — they’re coming from everywhere, and this administration does nothing to stop them. They are coming from prisons and jails, from mental institutions and insane asylums, and terrorists at levels never seen before.”
The New York Times reports that “June had the lowest monthly total for illegal crossings since January 2021,” and fact-checkers find no evidence “to support that other countries are sending their murderers, drug dealers and other criminals to the U.S.” He’s just lying.
But notice something else. He’s complaining about immigrants coming from every continent except Europe and Antartica, where only penguins and researchers live. His fans waved “Mass Deportations Now!” signs at the convention, but they weren’t concerned about either Belgians or penguins. They’re convinced that there’s a conspiracy to replace white people with non-white people, and they want non-white people tossed out of the country by the millions. This very much includes Indians from the subcontinent. And that’s why there is so much anger from the right that J.D. Vance was selected as Trump’s running mate.
The problem is Vance’s wife and kids.
The wife of Republican vice presidential candidate JD Vance, Usha Chilukuri Vance, and the couple’s children have become the targets of backlash for their Indian ancestry.
Chilukuri Vance, the daughter of Indian immigrants who grew up in San Diego, as well as RNC speaker Harmeet Dhillon — who is Sikh and Indian – are facing anti-Asian hate from far-right figures online.
Posts appear to have spiked this week following Vance’s nomination criticizing Vance for marrying someone who is non-white, expressing concerns about an influx of Indian immigrants as a result and the so-called Great Replacement conspiracy have garnered hundreds of thousands of views according to individual post engagement figures.
It’s similar to criticism made of Kamala Harris who also has Indian ancestry. This reminds me of the cognitive dissonance I have understanding how Stephen Miller, a Jew who grew up in Santa Monica, California, became Trump’s point man for mass deportation programs. J.D. Vance has joined a fascist movement that considers intermarriage between whites and non-whites as part of a sinister plot to destroy the white race. They want his wife and kids deported, and they consider him part of the problem. How can he sleep at night? How can he face his wife and kids and say he’s doing what’s best for them and people like them?
I have no earthly clue how to answer that question. Being vice-president of the United States is certainly an alluring prospect, but it shouldn’t be attractive under these circumstances.
There are a lot of reasons to question Vance’s character, but this is right at the top of the list.
I get that there’s going to be some cognitive dissonance around the race thing, but the logic behind “immigrants bad except my wife” is pretty clear. To right-wing men, an immigrant woman isn’t a threat. Or at least, the nature of any threat is different and much less severe. The Mexican immigrant takes your job, rapes your daughter, and raids the liquor cabinet. The immigrant woman is here to clean toilets and if she’s lucky she can marry J.D. Vance. It’ll show those American feminists how replaceable they are when when Mr. Vance chooses to marry an immigrant woman with traditional values.
Now in reality, Usha Chilukuri was born in the US and has – from the perspective of a Nazi – taken things rightfully belonging to conservative men: a position at Yale and a legal career. And I suppose from the perspective a conservative woman, she’s replaced a white woman Vance might have otherwise married.
But in the optics, she’s just a mail-order bride and there’s nothing wrong with that at all – again, I emphasize from a conservative perspective. She has traditional values (they would assume) and it shows that Vance isn’t racist. That’s a win-win.
It’s a fine topic for conversation, I suppose. But there’s not a lot of juice there. It’s far better to emphasize that Vance would love to see a nation-wide abortion ban. That and other regressive policies that will hurt all kinds of people.
Paraphrasing here, but, first they came for a bunch of people who weren’t like me and I didn’t really give a shit because I benefited from it. When they came for my wife and kids I was like ‘oh shit’ but it was too late.
If Trump and fascism are able to win and implement all the things they want to implement, watching JD’s family get boxcar’d up will get a laugh out of me. That’s coming from my privilege as a straight white male who can pass as a Christian lunatic, but there it is, survivalism at its finest. I’ll defend myself, my family and my community. Fascists are nowhere in that list. JD Vance, his wife, and his kids, can get got by the people who put him in power. Not my problem.
Start building up resilience now. Part of that is accepting that we’re on a trajectory and that a lot of the people guiding that trajectory are going to get boxcar’d up eventually, if they win…just a little later than everyone else. That’s how fascism always works. Trust the system I guess.
Sure, vote. Knock on doors. Send postcards or whatever. Dodging fascism is of course the most optimal solution.
But if you aren’t exercising your second amendment right, right now while you still have it, I consider it an own goal and will continue dumping that talking point out while it’s relevant everywhere I interact with “lefties”.
-If you don’t know who, just google the quote. Guns ain’t just for fascists, but they love it when “lefties” think so.
-US Fascists today.
Are you going to allow it to be bloodless?
They interviewed a young Latino Republican and asked about the mass deportation. He was fine with it because it wouldn’t affect him–he’s an American citizen.
Clearly he does not know his history.
I guess he never watched the movie “La Bamba”
He went to Yale didn’t he? and a hillbilly: yeah I was born the day before yesterday too.