Man, how grumpy can you get?
It is easy to blame children for some of this. Christmas is their holiday, you say. But that’s just an excuse. Christmas is not the holiday of children. It’s the holiday of retailers, of familial selfishness, of greed, of the child consumer and the childish consumer. It basically represents the opposite of what we need to teach our children.
Just look at Santa Claus, bearded and pot-bellied, entertaining the passersby on the sidewalk. The man who dresses as Santa gets paid to do it. I can excuse him for this – one has to earn a living – but I cannot excuse his employer. In fact, I’m surprised that our churches don’t criticize this. The belief in Santa Claus is worse than heresy, which at least has good faith in itself. Santa is just a superstition for children, a lie for adults, and a generally stupid concept. When my three sons were little, I didn’t have the courage to resist the pressure from society. I pretended, like everyone else. Am I wrong? I don’t know. But what a relief when the truth was revealed; when the boys, very early on, indicated that they didn’t believe in this nonsense!
I have my problems with Christmas, but it is a holiday for children, and for families. I watched Miracle on 34th Street again last night. I always sympathize with the skeptical woman that thinks Kris Kringle is out of his mind for thinking he is Santa Claus. But the movie gets it right. The judge is terrified of the retailers, the AFL-CIO, and the people. He’ll never get re-elected if he rules Santa doesn’t exist. The guy that runs Macy’s is petrified that he’ll lose all the customers that come to visit Santa if he says his Santa isn’t the real Santa. Kringle’s lawyer capitalizes on a practical joke the N.Y. post office plays by delivering all Santa’s mail to the courthouse. How can Kringle not be the real Santa if the U.S. Post Office recognizes him as the rightful recipient of Santa’s mail?
In other words, none of the dark side is covered up. The commercialism, the politicization, the dishonest lawyering, the compromised judge, it’s all there. But what matters is the joy the illusion gives to children.
It’s not without it’s downside. I never fully trusted my parents again after I busted them lying about a present they claimed was from Santa. I was about 6 or 7. I took it very personally that they would lie to me. But I’m a weirdo. Most kids appreciate the spirit of the thing.
I think people just get depressed because the days are too short and they have to spend money they don’t have on people they don’t really like or respect. Kids never get depressed unless they don’t get what they wanted as a gift. But, hey, there’s a life lesson in that, too. Every kid should get dissed on at least one X-Mas. It toughens ’em up and keeps them from getting false ideas about the way the world works.
And don’t get me started on the idiots that think Santa Claus sets a bad example because he’s overweight. Lighten up. He’s got a belly like a bowl full of jelly…what’s the problem?
I was pleased to get my #2 son’s gift, which was a donation in our name to the local animal shelter. We’re trying to influence the rest of the family to head in that direction. I think #2 son “gets it” despite his early in life exposure to the Santa myth 😉
When I was in kindergarden or first grade, I got in trouble for telling my best friend that there was no Santa Claus. I probably just got a talking to with my parents trying to explain that I shouldn’t tell people that Santa doesn’t exist. Can’t remember the logic of it, but I remember the incident.
…the dishonest lawyering,…
Sure, blame it on the lawyers. I knew we’d be drawn into this somehow.
come on boran, you know that post office stunt was b.s.
It was a movie. I’d blame the scriptwriters.
I’m a pretty dark and cynical guy, but Andre Comte-Sponville takes the cake.
I want to send him a card that says “merry Christmas” and sign it “your friend Santa Claus”, just to piss him off even more.
And what a penis! I’m an atheist too, but that hasn’t stopped me from giving Xmas cards and saying “merry Christmas” (and meaning it) to all the church ladies on our block.
If it makes someone happy wtf’s the problem?
I believe. It’s silly. But, I believe …
Merry Christmas everyone.
What a delightful surprise to see you.
Merry Christmas to you too.
Nice to see ya here! Merry Christmas!
Are you all done with the family stuff for the day?
The prodigal BMTer returns! Hi Mary!
I forgot to add the 😉
Hellooooooooo Mary!
Hope you had a wonderful Christmas and so good to see you.
And the same to you! Good to see you here, maryb!
And why wouldn’t you? I still believe in Santa Claus. It’s just that my perception of him has shifted ever-so-slightly since I was a child.
Nice to see you Mary. I’ve been around probably about as much as you have. 🙂
just not as a jolly old elf that lives at the North Pole.
If you’re a kid, and you’re lucky and good, Santa will bring you some gifts.
If you’re really lucky, you get to BE Santa, and give gifts to others. Red suit and beard not required.
By and large The Santa Clause 2 was an OK movie. Not great, just OK. There was one scene in there that I just love, though, and I hope I won’t spoil it for anyone if I tell the story:
Santa, for reasons we don’t need to get into, looks and sounds just like Tim Allen at this point in the movie. He ends up with one of his son’s teachers at a staff party at her school. It starts out as the same dull party everyone expects, until he starts passing out gifts . . . and every single person at the party gets a toy they loved as a child. A favorite game. A Chatty Cathy doll. A construction set that’s not only been out of print for 30 years, the company that made it has long since gone out of business. As his teacher companion suggests, these presents are the sort of thing you could spend a fortune on on eBay.
Now that would be the coolest thing about being Santa Claus.
There are a lot of pleasant illusions for children, and I’ve found the greatest ones to be the ongoing, evolving ones of their own invention or invested with their own perspective.
An old man who keeps track of everything you’ve done and will reward you with presents as long as you don’t rock the boat: not my idea of a happy illusion or a even a useful lie. Parents who tell their kids Santa won’t deliver if they don’t do what they’re told seem to be teaching kids the wrong lesson.
My kids call him the Christmas Guy, and he has a stature in their eyes about that of a Snowman. Both are most interesting when they are “big and squishy.” And holiday gifts (we celebrate several) always come from someone they know, and are Momma and Poppa approved.
It all seems like a racket to me, but I do like the idea of flying reindeer.
I totally agree with Andre Comte-Sponville.