For today’s World Health Day, the World Health Organization (WHO) seeks “greater access to life-saving interventions and a ‘continuum of care’ approach” for mothers and children. Each year, 10,600,000 children die before the age of five, and over 500,000 women die in pregnancy or childbirth.
From the diaries by susanbhu: Lorraine has spoken passionately, consistently, and attentively for women’s and children’s issues, and does so again for World Health Day:
IF TODAY is “Make Every Mother and Child Count,” then how many African women equal one Terri Schiavo?
Africa is the mother of us all, and yet, one of her women will be raped while you are reading this.
Some facts for you to ponder:
From the link above:
Fact #40: In South Africa, it is estimated that a women is raped every 83 seconds: only 20 of these cases are ever reported to the police. (Vetten:1996, Tribune:1991)
Fact #41: More than 90 million African women and girls are victims of female circumcision or other forms of genital mutilation. (Heise: 1994)
Fact #42: In Uganda HIV infection is 6 times higher among young girls than boys with the difference in rates beginning as early as 9 years old and reaching a peak for the age-12-19 years old. This is due to old men seeking young girls for sexual exploitation with the belief that they are free form HIV. (Ministry of Health- Uganda)
Fact #44: In Zimbabwe, domestic violence accounts for more than 60% of murder cases that go through the high court in Harare. (ZWRCN)
Fact #45: a study in Zaria, Nigeria found that 16 percent of hospital patients treated for sexually transmitted infections were under 5. (UNFPA)
If today, every woman counts, then let’s talk about the women of Africa, and how little they count. In 1994, we sat on our hands while one million Rwandans were slaughtered. Today, we sit on our hands while women are the victims of campaigns of war rape in Darfur, Uganda, the Congo.
Just for example, the women of Darfur, who are now trying still to get to Chad. This from the Women’s Commission on Refugees:
One of the most disturbing aspects of the situation was the lack of reproductive health care available to the refugees. The systematic and widespread rape of women and girls in Darfur by the Arab militia, the Janjaweed, is well-known, but reproductive health care to prevent suffering from further trauma, including unwanted pregnancy and sexually transmitted infections, including HIV, or to address psychosocial needs is non-existent. Survivors had no way to report sexual abuse and exploitation. In addition, preventing maternal and neonatal mortality was not a priority. Visibly pregnant women were not given clean delivery kits and transport for women suffering life-threatening complications from pregnancy and childbirth was not always available.
It’s impossible to know how many women have been raped, but a group of refugee men told us that more than 200 women were raped in their community and that every family had at least one woman – a mother, sister or daughter – who had survived rape. They described how the Janjaweed attacked their villages and abducted young girls and women and would rape them over a 3- to 4-day period and then return them to the village.
Clearly, reproductive health care must be an integral part of the emergency response in Chad. But it’s not. What will it take to ensure that it is part of this response and in other future crises?
Here’s one possible solution: Representative Lowey and Senator Biden have introduced bills in their respective chambers that would create organized responses to humanitarian disasters, responses that recognize that it is often women and children who bear the cruelest brunt of these and thus provide emergency maternal/contraceptive/post-rape care. These are HR 1413 and S559.
You can ask your congressional representatives, especially if you live in one of those districts where your rep felt obliged to interfere in the Schiavo case, and ask him or her to support women in crisis NOW.
While there is peace in South Africa, there is no real peace for women.
In South Africa, a woman is more likely to be raped than to learn how to read. In South Africa, rape carries with it the increased risk of AIDS infection, and the government does virtually nothing to distribute anti-retroviral medications to women and children who have already been victimized. Women are five times more likely to be raped in South Africa than women in the United States. Nearly 10 percent of South Africa’s inhabitants are HIV+. The solution for some? Rape insurance, which will help to pay for the health costs associated with being violated. The very idea makes me weep.
What then, must we do? We cannot stop rape in South Africa, but we can continue to pressure our government to lift the international gag rule so that proper information can be dispensed. We can also support people such as Eve Ensler, whose V-Day Foundation works with the proceeds from performances of The Vagina Monologues to do such things as establishing “safe houses” in Africa where girls who refuse genital mutilation can find sanctuary.
The next time you hear someone defend the sanctity of life, or the culture of life, you ask them, does life only count if you’re an American?
Lorraine, this stopped me dead in my tracks:
“In South Africa, a woman is more likely to be raped than to learn how to read.”
Bless you and people like Eve Ensler who are doing this important work.
P.S. See also: “Bounlid’s baby,” a BBC/WHO special report about six infants and their mothers in various parts of the world.
Lorraine, I’ve recommended your diary (twice! on dKos and here) to thank you for bringing up this story, which indeed deserves wider exposure, but I have doubts or questions about several of the statistics you bring up.
Again, this is NOT to undermine your post, or to contest the importance of the topic, but i do think it is important to use the numbers in ways that actually underline the problem rather than give excuses to say “oh, it’s not so bad”, which is certainly not the case.
I appreciate your comment. I, of course, left all my data at home, but let me dig it up and I’ll post the stats. You’re right that it’s important to back this stuff up.
http://www.sundayindependent.co.za/index.php?fSectionId=1042&fArticleId=2238856
The articles consistently say that S.A. has the highest rate of rape in the world. Estimates are 1 in 3 women will be raped. Which roughly parallels the 30 percent stat.
More here:
http://www.rapecrisis.org.za/statistics.htm
“Although the Law Reform Commission estimates there are 1,7 million rapes a year, on average only 54 000 rape survivors lay charges each year. Why? It is because rape survivors are treated so badly by so many.”
So, one every 15 seconds then. Terrifying.
Worth questions, Jerome (and I see that Lorraine has addressed them), but one clarification, if I may:
Mali and Niger can qualify as Moslem countries, but Burkina Faso and Benin should not be (though they often are). I lived in Burkina Faso for two years, and close to its border but in Togo for two more (and have travelled in Benin)–these countries, as one person said to me, are “33% Moslem, 33% Christian, and 100% animist.” They have huge Christain populations, which is often forgotten, as are the sizeable chunks who keep to traditional beliefs.
I don’t know about the Gambia…
Also recommended: Jerome A Paris’s diary on the French health care system.
I was excited — when I got my monthly statement from DISH — to see that they’ve added an African station (ABN America) to their international programming. Like their Arab, Chinese, and other international programming, there’s an extra cost. For now, I’ll get what I can from LINKTV, aired free on DISH, which does a marvelous job of exposing us ignorant Americans to how people live around the world.
Once again, Lorraine, you keep the important issues front and center.
That it feels as if there is nothing one can do.
Of course there is always something that can be done, when there is the political and social will to do so. Thanks for writing this up and also pointing out Eve Ensler’s work, I wasn’t aware of that. Or the bills making their way through congress. That would be a good start.
I’d say we’d do better to remove the beam from our own eye than the mote in our neighbors, hence the need to focus efforts back home.
I’d like to ask this question. Is this South Africa situation any better or worse than diamond and cell-phone markets that are dependant upon slave labor?
Here’s an idea. Let’s roll up with a bunch of preachers and convert them all to Buddhism. That’ll eliminate the brutality and injustice in this proud motherland once and for all, won’t it?
I’m not saying your concern is unappreciated, just that you can’t exactly land in a foreign nation, surgically remove deeply entrenched social mores that offend you, and replace them with ones you feel are more palateable. It doesn’t work. You may as well throw firecrackers at a rolling boulder. This isn’t mere conjecture, nor an informed hypothesis, it’s cold hard, frequently reproduced fact.
According to a 2003 study 27.9% of pregnant women in Africa were HIV positive.
I think it’s quite clear that the problem will sort itself out. Karma is ultimately inescapable. Individual human lives are quite inconsequential, and the actions of this generation will determine the course of the country for decades, even centuries to come. The forces at work which cause this situation are larger than any human or group of humans ability to control or even effect noticable change.
The plight of these women is indeed unconscionable, but I’d rather see congress’ time and money wasted in futile efforts to make this country a better place than throwing it absently away at the troubles in South Africa. There may be a rape every eighty seconds in South Africa, but in the U.S. it’s roughly two minutes.
How can you help?
If you’d like to try to help victims, get to work in a women’s shelter.
If you’d like to try to prevent women from becoming victims, get to work in a boy’s juevenile detention center.
If you like to write letters, try to get funding for those types of places, and other mental health and social services centers.
Sure, even that is a small potatoes and will likely result in a negligable impact, but you’re more apt to notice piss in a pool than in an ocean, right? Not to mention how much more satisfying it is to look your salvaged charge in the eyes when you grant them life.
But I suppose the important part is feeling like we’re making a difference, so disembodied, non-quantifiable effort expended on phantom causes halfway across the globe is far more satisfying than the daily realization that for all your hard work and determination directly with the victims and perpetuators of such crimes you may as well be banging your head against a brick wall.
It’s amazing that you think I don’t care about what happens to women in America. A pretty arrogant, condescending assumption on your part. I’m a little surprised by the tone of your response.
Perhaps it is pissing in an ocean. Perhaps I shouldn’t care that women are mutilated and raped a half a world away. Maybe I should only care about the women I can try to protect in my neighborhood. Maybe we shouldn’t offer to support humanitarian efforts that would pay attention to victims of rape campaigns in the Sudan. Maybe we’re better off with the global gag rule, where we withhold money from organizations that offer abortion as a counseling choice. Maybe I should just shut my eyes really tightly and hope that if I help one woman here, that’s all that matters.
Yeah. It’s fucking overwhelming. But ask Eve Ensler if the fact that a couple dozen girls in Africa are not being genitally mutilated in Africa because of the house she helped to build is worthless. Ask those of us who labor every day to try to speak up for women in our communities and our states and our country whether it’s useless. I have daughters. They matter to me. You may go bang your head against a wall. But I’ve got better things to do.
Please forgive me for miscommunicating.
I’m sure you care deeply about women in America. My intention was not to disparage you or your efforts. Of course, some times the fingers get away from you when you’re on a roll.
I can say, honestly, that I don’t care.
Actually, not that I don’t care, but that I feel there are more immediate ways for me to focus my energy for the good of the world, and that there are more pressing concerns for the government of America.
As the situation in South Africa, horrible as it is, has no impact on the interests or safety of America and its citizens, the American government has no responsibility or business being involved.
The money and resources squandered in wars against undefinable enemies such as african rape, drugs, and terrorism could be far better utilized within our own borders.
Yes, I know to the women who are mistreated, there is a very definable enemy in these situations, true, but the community is allowing the practice. The fact remains that if there is no local authority to stop this, any attempt at foreign authority is pointless.
Yay, Eve Ensler saved some girls from losing their ability to have pleasurable sex. Their children will still be born into the same conditions they faced, and will have to be saved all over again by the next Eve Ensler.
We (“civilization” that is) have been saving and remaking savage Africa ever since we discovered it, and look at where it has gotten us.
The fact is that the intended role of the American government is to protect and serve the citizens of America, not Africa, not Iraq, not whatever. You can’t swing a plague infested rat in a third world country without hitting an aid worker at least partially funded by American dollars. We provide more in the way of aid and economic stimulus than any other world power already. While there is a requisite amount of funding expected of any world superpower, I fail to see how we aren’t measuring up to our obligation.
I’m curious as to the relation between this discussion and the abortion funding issue, though. Abortion is neither a cure for AIDS nor a rape preventative, and with the medical conditions one imagines in South Africa, I’d be skeptical of the safety of any such procedure, legal, counseled, or otherwise.
Where is the focus of this intent? What is the action you’re calling for?
Organized response to humanitarian disasters? Isn’t that what the red cross does?
I suppose I’m just feeling a little flustered about the story. There’s a string of horrible numbers and tearjerking rhetoric with no clear call to action other than a snappy talking point comeback.
I’d expect better. Let’s elevate the dialog. Give a number, give a website, give a means to direct action.
Maybe then, we’ll realize that the plight of women in Africa is identical to the plight of African American women in the United States, if not in specific degree of symptom, then in nature of cause.
For until we’re able to actually improve the socio-economic and political conditions of the communities in which this type of inhumanity is allowed to occur, all the safe houses in the world add up to so much band-aids and window dressing.
We need to start clearing away the rot inside this country first. Once we’ve got our own savages dealt with, we can show the world how to deal with Africa, and China, and Pakistan.
Until then, how can we show the way to something that we can’t find ourselves?
This is what I’m saying, in my own special way.
Please understand that I agree with you in spirit, if not execution, and that the only thing I find more abhorrent than straight-up propaganda is emotional politics practiced without dialogue.
While I wrote this, 5 American and 7 African women were raped.
Here is something that anyone who has just a little extra money can do to be very specifically constructive for women/children in Rawanda.
Rawanda Goat Kit sponsored by the hungersite is 49.95.
This provides 2 goats, a male and female goat to a family-many times a woman widowed in the war there and her children
This Goat kid does just more than provide 2 goats.
The goats themselves can graze on land that is unsuitable for other livestock making the goats more valuable in a way as they need no special food or land.
These goats will supply several quarts of milk a day providing needed nutrition for often times malnurished children.
The extra milk can be made into cheese/yogurt and sold for extra money.
The goat manure can be used as fertilizer thus making that land more rich for growing food.
Goats often have 2/3 kids a year enabling the family to possibly start their own small dairies. With these dairies that family can earn money to afford food, health care and education.
Each Goat Kit purchased at the hungersite will then also have the hungersite funding 150 cups of food where needed.
http://www.gearthatgives.com/cgi-bin/WebObjects/CTDStore.woa/wa/product?siteID=220&itemID=26450&
amp;origin=20162
Colorado Governor Vetoes Emergency Contraception Information Bill
In a defeat for women’s health advocates, Gov. Owens pleased the religious right by nixing legislation that would have ensured women received information about preventing pregnancy after rape.
I’m in a lousy defeatist mood today and this continuing encroachment on women’s rights in all things related to our reproductive health and choice simply made my first response…fuck you mr. governor- who can’t get pregnant and will likely never be raped…just fuck you.(and of course no pun intended either)
I know not very constructive but that’s all I’ve got.
For the first time here at Booman’s, I was tempted to give a rating different from ‘4’ – quite different, actually.
What narcisstic views you bring here!
I won’t waste any time arguing with you why social disintegration in LDCs (Least Developed Countries) affects us living in more fortunate circumstances – maybe others will humor you.
You are entitled to your opinion, but be very cautious in using language like this in the future:
I checked your other two comments and found them borderline as well.
I neither know nor care who you are to warn me, but just so long as it’s the metaphor and not the stance you’re calling borderline I might stick around to see.
There seems to be a dearth of disagreement around here so far, and one sided conversations are best kept in church.
Narcissistic, I have been called, Still don’t agree with it.
was already noted in your previous posts.
As was your lack of any humanitarian thought.
Why would you feel at home here?
Opposing views or even degrees or variations of views on any issue always make for a better thread as far as I’m concerned. Makes people really stop and think exactly what and why they believe in a certain issue. So stick around and discuss your viewpoint..although you have made pretty plain where you stand. I don’t agree with much of what you said and am still just trying to formulate some responses to your comments.
and have not asked that s/he should leave.
But I gave a warning on the language, and would suggest that any freeper coming here keep pure spin from their arguments – that’s just wasting our time.
Respectful, reality-based argumentation is welcome – as has already been evidenced at this site.
thank you very much, chok and ask.
And I am by no means a freeper, folks, I’m a poet in a punk band, and equally opposed to both parties and their comic spin offs. the power lies with the people, not the stuffed suit aristocrats.
If I get a little effluent in my rhetoric, please forgive me.
back in 1976 when the Sex Pistols and the Damned first unleashed their fury…
Anyway, I think you should explain your partly indifferent (?)/partly derogatory attitude to international humanitarian work and your lack of care. Maybe you’ll receive more understanding if you explain where those views come from.
That’s a good question asking about explaining where someone’s views on an issue might stem from. I’m curious about that myself.
First off, I apologize for the jackedness of the thread that’s occured.
You’ve all really shown yourselves quite hospitible to my jackassery, and for that, I sincerely commend you.
In all honesty, I care deeply about the suffering. I care about a lot of suffering, but where do we draw the line? There has to be someone, somewhere that we can’t save.
Like frog learned, you can’t shake everyone’s hand.
The efforts of the humanitarian groundfighters are noble, yes, and in many situations quite beneficial, such as disaster relief or interdiction in the case of outright, direct violence, but when it comes to the specific plight of a specific group of people out of the thousands that are suffering there…
It just seems like misplaced focus, when there are women in the United States, probably within a hundred miles of each of us, that are just as brutalized. The ones nearer to us, we can actually do something about.
The ones in Africa, well, we can spot treat that, can’t we, save a dozen here, a dozen there, maybe a couple hundred, and that’s good work, great work. But in the end, what’s going to improve the conditions of all the women and men, bepenised they may be, is a change in the cultural mindset, and that can’t be forced from outside.
Why expend so much time and energy on a losing battle, when battles need to be won right here.
It’s not a matter of compassion, it’s a matter of necessity.
We have ten dollars to spend at the fair. The log flume, roller coaster, and hot dog all cost $4 each, we’re going to have to make some tough choices, here.
I don’t know. I probably shouldn’t explain myself any further.
What I’m trying to say, I suppose, is that a Chimp has successfully run for president twice in the last six years, maybe we should consider our priorities before introducing unicorn hunting legislation.
my short answer is that you can do more than one thing at a time, work at getting rid bush’s policies/women in this country being raped and abused and still have some time/money or compassion left over to spread to other countries.
If that’s the case then why haven’t we?
Quite simply because we can’t.
I suppose I should clarify a point here. I’m not saying relief efforts should not be pursued, I’m not saying we should abandon the poor women, I’m saying that they will suffer far worse if we don’t take care of cleaning house while there’s still a house to be cleaned.
More later. 🙂
Punk band huh..do you have a website. My oldest nephew has had many bands and is a punk rocker to the core,(punk tats on his fingers) while my youngest nephew is more death metal and also in a band. Do you read Amp magazine?
So you really don’t believe we are all connected as opposed to the butterfly theory I think that says we are all connected somehow.
Yeah, we gots a website. Check the profile. It’s brand spanking new, so don’t expect much.
In re connectedness, of course I think we’re connected, which is why cleaning up this country will help them in that country.
But that’s a completely different tack on the argument.
In fact, I think I’m gonna write my own.
sorry if my post was misinterpreted. It didn’t have anything to do with your post actually. I just happened to respond in that spot to him. I also didn’t get the impression you asked him to leave at all.
Sometimes this nesting makes for posts that don’t exactly go where I intended them.
I had no problems with your comment.
Just wanted to signal that I agreed with you and that a variety of views are welcome as long as respect is maintained.
I appreciate the fact that you responded to me. I apologize for taking so long to get back to you. First of all, I did post about something specific, and small, that can be done in Africa at
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2005/4/7/15479/61101.
I think the problem here is one of meta-theory and everyday life. Do I hope for a world that embraces a more equitable redistribution of wealth? Do I hope for a society in the US that eradicates racism, sexism, and homophobia? Yes. Of course. But unlike say, Marxists, I don’t see the basis for all those problems being economic. I think there are other root causes, and I’ve written about those root causes on DailyKos quite a bit. But understanding the root causes of injustice and starvation doesn’t feed a hungry child today. It doesn’t provide a sanctuary for a child who was about to be genitally mutilated (and if you think that it’s only about sexual pleasure, please educate yourself about infibulation). But giving money to someone like Eve Ensler, or to the Makindu orphanage, makes a difference. And yes. We’ll have to do it again and again and again–but you know what? So far, my experience of life is that we have to do everything over and over again. Life is cyclic–it is not moving in some straightforward trajectory toward either the perfect state or the promised land or the Second Coming. We just keep having to trudge through the same shit again and again.
However, on the abortion issue, for example. We have a global gag rule that prevents this gov’t from giving money to aid organizations that may offer abortion counseling in a package of contraceptive care. A woman who’s been raped should be offered the alternative of abortion. We have barely retained those rights in the US, and they are under attack every day here. But, in areas where our influence extends, we are denying those rights to women in humanitarian crises areas. Africa being one of them. So, I do see a connection there.
Secondly, I’m aware that we’re all doing to die someday. However, as old-fashioned as it sounds, I cling to the ideal that we should fight like hell for the living, no matter what nation or culture they belong to.
I divide my energies. I do what I can in the States, but I remind myself that there are human beings suffering all over the world, and on a day like today, when WHO reminds us that 500,000 women will die in childbirth this year, 10.6 million children under the age of 5 will die, and AIDS continues to rage out of control on the African continent, I did not consider it a waste of my energies to comment on that and to remind all of us that America is not the center of the universe.
So, today, I’ve done some political work here, and I’ve contributed money to an AIDS orphanage in Kenya. The child who may be helped by my money may die anyway. I doubt that he or she is going to live to see a complete turn-around of the system that we’re living in. But if I help to ease his or her suffering for a few days, then that’s what I choose to do.
One war in Iraq = how much aid to women and children, the forgotten victims in all world strife?
One U.S. military budget = how much aid to children, the losers in our adult strife and neglect?
One underground economy in any nation or state = how much food for the poverty stricken?
One recycled “Star Wars” = how much agricultural aid to feed the world?
How much US aid, now restricted to abstinence only,
increases the incidence of HIV/AIDS?
How many arrogant, blind leaders (and followers) continue patriarchal thinking for the purpose of power?
It’s a matter of priorities
priorities
priorities.
Kurdish Women’s Rights Activist Summoned to Revolutionary Court in Iran: Send a letter via Human Rights First’s site.
Thank you, Susan. Just did this.
thanks for the link,susan. Went there, did that.
small, local, indigenous, African.
Microloans can save lives and change them. Sometimes really really micro, a couple of hundred dollars, even less, to buy a few goats, a used sewing machine.
Grameen Bank does this, but large and under UN taint.
I would suggest getting in touch with Africans in your community, get to know them, find out names of people who are quietly doing good things in small places, maybe a mosque in a little village has a literacy class, a rogue nun in a rain forest teaching sustainable agriculture, get hooked up. Be anonymous.
My ex father-in-law used to help adminster this charity, founded by a woman in Oregon, to help AIDS orphans in Africa.
http://www.registerguard.com/africa/revisited20000109.html
Circumcision is the surgical removal of the foreskin of the penis. Done suposedly for hygene, “medical”, reasons. (Men can’t wash?)
Goddamn it,
Loosley? A number of?
source
As well they should.
There are not words to describe the horror.
Just cries by 7 year olds, “Don’t cut, don’t cut…Mommeeeeeeee!” There is precious little Sanctuary for these girlchilds.
Fucking bastards. Call it what it is. Attempt to control by genital mutilation.
I’m going to bed before I turn into MSOC.