Casulties Of Iraq Innocents ‘Quietly’ Released

By SABRINA TAVERNISE
BAGHDAD, Iraq, Oct. 29 – In the first public disclosure that the  United States military is tracking some of the deaths of Iraqi civilians, the military has released rough figures for Iraqis who have been killed or wounded by insurgents since Jan. 1 last year.
The estimate of dead and wounded Iraqi civilians and security forces was provided by the Pentagon in a report to Congress this month.
It appeared without fanfare in a single bar graph on Page 23 of the document. But it was significant because the military had previously avoided virtually all public discussion of the issue.
The count is incomplete – it provides daily partial averages of deaths and injuries of Iraqis at the hands of insurgents, in attacks like bombings and suicide strikes. Still, it shows that the military appears to have a far more accurate picture of the toll of the war than it has been willing to acknowledge.
“They have begun to realize that when you focus only on the U.S. it gives the impression that the U.S. doesn’t care about Iraqis,” said Anthony H. Cordesman, a military expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a research group in Washington. “In these kinds of political battles you need to count your allies, not just yourself.”

“According to the graph, Iraqi civilians and security forces were killed and wounded by insurgents at a rate of about 26 a day early in 2004, and at a rate of about 40 a day later that year. The rate increased in 2005 to about 51 a day, and by the end of August had jumped to about 63 a day. No figures were provided for the number of Iraqis killed by American-led forces.”
=
“Extrapolating the daily averages over the months from Jan. 1, 2004, to Sept. 16 this year results in a total of 25,902 Iraqi civilians and security forces killed and wounded by insurgents.
According to an analysis by Hamit Dardagan, who compiles statistics for Iraq Body Count, a group that tracks civilian deaths, about three Iraqis are wounded in the war for each one who dies. Given that ratio, the total Iraqi death toll from insurgent violence would be about 6,475, based on extrapolations of the military’s figures.”
=
“Indeed, the tally is lower than the 11,163 deaths of Iraqi civilians in the war during the same period counted by Mr. Dardagan’s group, which draws its data from reports of deaths and injuries by news services, newspapers and other news outlets.
It is also lower than figures released by Iraq’s Interior Ministry showing that 8,175 Iraqi civilians and police officers had been killed by insurgents from August 2004 through May 2005. Even so, the tallies show that the military has been recording Iraqi deaths by insurgents with some regularity since the first months after the invasion.”

“We were very interested in it,” said Timothy Rieser, an aide to Senator  Patrick J. Leahy
, the Vermont  Democrat who sponsored the amendment to the fiscal year 2006 Defense Authorization Bill that calls for casualty details. “After denying that they keep these statistics, it gives the Congress something concrete to ask them about,” Mr. Rieser said.
The bar graph was made public, but the data underlying it was not, so the figures used for this article were derived from measuring the bars. Colonel Venable said the information had been classified because it could allow insurgents to assess the effectiveness of their attacks. Mr. Dardagan questioned the secrecy, citing regular releases of American deaths.
“We now know that the U.S. military does keep records of Iraqi civilian deaths,” Mr. Dardagan said. “There seems to be no obvious reason for keeping them a secret.”

After months of playing down casualty counts, the inclusion of the numbers in the report seemed to be an acknowledgment of their importance for the military, which has also begun to regularly report tallies of insurgents killed in American operations.
“You can say everything you want about the numbers not mattering,” said Sarah Sewall, a lecturer in public policy at the John F. Kennedy
 School of Government at Harvard University. But the report shows that “we recognize they are important tools for understanding.”

American military officials have said attacks against Americans and Iraqis have been averaging 85 a day for much of the past year.
It is not clear what proportion of attacks American forces respond to, but Maj. Gen. Rick Lynch, a spokesman for the American military here, said Thursday that forces respond “whenever we can.”
Civilians have moved to center stage in wars since the beginning of the 20th century. A 2001 study on civilians in war by the International Committee of the Red Cross showed a shift in a stark statistic: In World War I, 9 soldiers were killed for every civilian, while in today’s wars 10 civilians die for every soldier.
Civilians are important allies for states trying to prevail in wars against violent insurgencies, and the inclusion of the figures in the report seemed to be an acknowledgment of that, Ms. Sewall said.