Analysis Paralysis: Miers and Statements by Republicans
(Cross-posted at Daily Kos, my blog and My Left Wing)
First a disclaimer. It is pretty much assumed that Bush cannot hand me a SCOTUS nominee with whom I will be happy. Therefore, it’s imperative, for me, to try to get someone who doesn’t make my skin crawl.
Having said that, I’m torn on Miers. I’ve seen all of the speculative arguments about whether or not she is a raging far-right evangelical wingnut and then further speculative argument about why she is not a raging far-right evangelical wingnut.
So I took a time-consuming approach. I researched public statements made by Republican Senators and the Independent Senator from Vermont in a effort to get a feel for which way the wind was blowing. Upon reading their statements, I cam up with the following regarding the Miers nomination (purely subjective): Opposed, Neutral and Favorable. Unknown was assigned if I simply couldn’t find a public statement by a Senator. Below the fold is my analysis of these statements and perhaps some conjecture as to what it all means.
Read More