Sorry for the second ‘personal’ diary in a week 🙂 and for the second cross-post with dailkos (in the process of shifting :), but I think Zack’s story needs to get out and the truth that these groups (FRC, CC, AFA) are hate groups needs to be further shown. Be forewarned its personal and long. It does have a larger political and social point… but isn’t personal political?
Republic of T has been keeping us up-to-date on the story of Zach, a young gay man who has been forced by his into a ‘reeducation’ camp run by fundamentalist Christians to ‘scare straight’. I can empathize what the poor kid is going through, and we’ll find out more when he is freed in the next couple days. This whole episode has brought back the memories of something I went through as a young gay man, and I need to relate it. It will be long, forgive me. Read it if you wish, I’m writing for me, for my soulmate, for my child and for every boy and girl who finds themselves ‘not normal’.
I was a teenager in the late 70’s. There was an further awakening then of GLBT people, Stonewall had occurred, Harvey Milk, two men attempting to marry in Colorado, and more. I knew I was ‘gay’, or at least I knew I was romantically and sexually attracted to men. I had known since I was, well, since I can remember being attracted to anyone in that way.
I even had a friend, a male friend, who today I would call a boyfriend, but then called my best friend. We did everything together and were inseparable. We loved each other and expressed it to each other every day. We expressed it in words and intimately. We knew we were going to spend the rest of our lives together, off in some Alaskan cabin where people would leave us alone. He was the center of my universe.
There was a another center of my life then too. Faith. I had always been a seeker. I went to church services of local Catholic, Baptist, Buddhist and Quaker places of worship. I asked everyone and anyone who would answer about faith and belief. I had a set prayer I would ask every day “Help me find truth” were my last words every night before I went to bed. Eventually, when I was 17, I found the Mormon faith. Much of it (the universality of salvation, the mother goddess, the word of God not restricted in space or time) rang so extremely true to me. I converted in days. It became a center of my universe.
Two centers pulling at and pushing each other away. I could not reconcile my love for my soulmate and my love of my faith in God.
My boyhood love temporarily solved that problem for me the day he took his own life when we were 18. The day I found my first love dying before me, the day he died, that day haunts me still. It was the day the center of my universe vanished.
But that is not what this entry is about, it is about how i dealt with the other new and growing center, my faith and what it told me of my sexuality. My faith become my center. And my faith told me that the sin of homosexuality was next to murder in seriousness. It was a plain and simple declaration in church meetings. I could not have committed any worse sin unless I killed him with my own hands. It was a heavy burden to bear.
And I made every effort to rid myself of the burden. For did not Jesus say,
Come unto me, all ye that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you, and learn of me; for I am meek and lowly in heart: and ye shall find rest unto your souls. For my yoke is easy, and my burden is light. ( Matthew 11:28-30 )
I had a lot of things to contend with (I was not allowed either to ‘hold the priesthood’ because of my ‘black blood’.. a long story for another day), but this was my greatest battle. I prayed everyday, I beseeched God, I read the scriptures, I did good works, I accepted Jesus’ burden, I even went on a mission.
I knew God would change me if I devoted my life to Him. I would be freed of the burden. So I went on a mission. I spent two years of my young life ministering to deaf children and adults. I taught them how to cook, how to read and write Korean. I taught them about the gospel and the beauty I saw in it. And I did change. For two years my life was devoted to someone else, to my fellow man and God. I had no room in my heart or mind for anything else. I rarely gave my sexuality or any sexuality a thought, I didn’t become ‘heterosexual’, and occasionally my ‘homosexual’ feelings would return, but it wasn’t a burden. It was a blissful two years filled with service and one of the most intense spiritual experiences of my life.
But then I returned home and so did the burden. Ten fold. Devoting my life to God did not make me heterosexual. If anything, it only made me realize even more that I wasn’t. I went to Brigham Young University, and as a relatively intelligent, not ugly :), returned missionary, I was good marriage material. i started dating hoping that would change me. It wasn’t working. So I sought help from my Bishop.
One of the greatest mistakes of my life. My Bishop reaffirmed to me that this was a grevious sin that I need to repent of and change. He referred me to the department in the Kimball Tower where I could get therapy. I started with individual therapy where I was told that I am and receive what I ‘want’, what i truly ‘want’ and if you are not that and don’t have that, you haven’t truly ‘wanted’ it. I graduated to group therapy in addition. But after a couple semesters all the therapy got me no where but hating myself more.
It was then another therapy was suggested. I would try anything at that point, to be lifted of the burden. It turned out to be ‘aversion therapy’, though not electroshock, it was as insidious. Photos of gorgeous men would be shown, near pornographic and then I was given a substance to drink (I assume it was syrup of ipecac, but am not sure then or now) that would induce vomiting. I was then forced to smell it. I was then shown photos of women, on another occasion, this time the room smelled sweet and I was given water or juice. Repeat over and over again.
Pain, suffering, hatred of myself for not changing and hatred of my Church which was quickly changing to hatred of God. That is what the therapy gave me. My cries to God got louder and more insistent. Why was I given a burden that was going to make me hate God?
The semester ended. It was the summer of 1983. My parents had moved to Seattle so I spent the summer with them. I arrived a destroyed man. I now knew that God hated me, the Church hated me, I hated me, I hated myself with a passion. I might as well have been a murderer. I could be no worse than I was. My mother and stepfather noticed the change. I was in a serious depression and it showed. I wanted to do nothing and talk to no one. This was the young man who before was interested in everyone and everything, who loved life and all the amazing things in it. My step-father attempted to intervene. He did not know at the time what was destroying me, but he knew I was seriously in trouble. We had a talk alone one day. I wanted so much to tell him, to tell him all the horrid things that happened to me, how much I hated myself, how much God hated me and that is why I was so depressed. But I did not. I don’t remember what I said to him, only that it would work itself out.
The next weekend I even went to a gay bar to ‘see’ for myself what ‘being gay’ was like. I hated myself even more. The bar was nothing special, just a restaurant and bar with a few good looking men in it, but the very fact that I was willing to go…
It was then I decided the only solution was my teenage love’s solution. He was right. It was the only way out of the pain and hatred. I found a place in the cascade mountains that had spectacular cliffs. I resolved to go camping, but not for the views. And I did. I told my family that I needed some time to think and wanted to go backpacking (which I did a lot). I gathered my things and planned. I made sure that I would be there on a weekday, when there were few other campers.
I arrived at the site, a spectacular cliff overlooking a river, forests and mountains in the background. I arrived with the determination to jump off that cliff. I was not scared, I was strangely at peace with what i was about to do. Now I would be free of pain and hatred, and maybe for a brief glimpse I could see my love again. It seemed so right.
I went to the edge, took off my backpack. I planned it out. I would pray and then sing a hymn and jump. I prayed, a long prayer of accusations and complaints. I told God He was cruel and hateful and I did not wish to live with Him. In the same breath I begged for forgiveness. I was a weak child and after years still could not find the answer, could not lift the burden. I cursed God again for not lifting the burden.
And then I sang the hymn that was supposed to take me off the cliff. It was How Great Thou Art. i am not sure why I chose that song, I guess it was because it was one of my favorites.
It changed my life. When I got to the second verse
“When through the woods, and forest glades I wander,
And hear the birds sing sweetly in the trees.
When I look down, from lofty mountain grandeur
And see the brook, and feel the gentle breeze.Then sings my soul, My Saviour God, to Thee,
How great Thou art, How great Thou art.
something happened. Perhaps it was real, perhaps it was from inside me, it does not matter, for that day I could hear everything singing with me. The trees, the birds, the rocks and the water. They were singing the hymn. I could turn to the trees and hear them sing, I could turn to the boulder next to me and hear it sing. The world was singing with me.
And I burst into the most violent and enduring sob of my life.
In all honesty, I can not explain now, nor then, what it meant. What the message was supposed to be, if any. I could not explain. If it was my heightened state or God or the actual world singing, I can not tell you.
But I can tell you the effect it had. Because after my hours long sobbing, when all my strength was gone and I then slept on that rock through the night. I got up and went home.
I was not happy. My problems were not solved.
But it was the turning point of my life, for from that day foward I pulled myself out of my self-hate. From that day forward I regained my love of God. From that day forward I regained my faith. I eventually was pushed and excommunicated from the Church, eventually stopped therapy (though I would go through therapy for another 6 years, though a much more benign therapy).
I look at my life now, with a family that loves me, a soulmate who is my companion and love, a daughter who I cherish with a love I didn’t know I could have, a life filled with friends and that is wonderful and sweet, and most of all a growing and deep spirituality and love of God.
And I compare that to that young man 20some years ago who had little but fear, and hate and sorrow and I marvel. That journey from self-hate inducing therapy and ‘faith’ to today was a long and ardous one. And I am blessed to have had people in my life who held my hand along the way, my parents, my siblings, my friends and even strangers. My souImate and my daughter. I could not have made it alone. It was their true Christ-like love that guided me to this place of joy and strength. In them I have found God.
It is why we must help young men and women like Zack, so they also can free themselves from that hate that some call love and find their way to what happiness and love our. My story is what makes me hopeful and sad. Hopeful that lives can change, sad that so many would have us live in hate and fear.
That is one of the most moving and powerful things I’ve read in recent memory. Thank you for sharing your story.
I hope Zack and the others get the “happy ending” you have found.
I know I’ll do what I can to help.
I read this and have sat, trying to think of a response, for more than 10 minutes with no luck.
Your life seems like the moon to me: full, vibrant, glowing with the reflected light of all your rich experiences.
So happy that you have found your soulmate. And I remember the photo of your beautiful daughter from yesterday. What a lucky family you are.
I also am at a loss for words. Your story has really moved me. I just thank the good spirit of the universe for speaking to you and am so grateful that you were listening!!
Your story is another affirmation that the personal is political, and that we were put on this earth to take care of one another. I cannot tolerate that people who claim to embrace a message of love and hope would be so cruel to those they consider different.
I’m glad that you have found joy in your life, and I’m grateful that the “spirit” came to you on the cliff that day and let you decide to live. Your example is a bright light.
hoped and prayed for God to make me straight…didn’t take. (I didn’t go quite as far as you, but the suicide thing was in the back of my head for years). I keep hoping we’ll move forward, that newere generations won’t have to go through this shit, and in many ways we have. But Zach’s parents remind us how far we have to go.
It gives me hope that someday I’ll find my soulmate!
I never had those thoughts of suicide due to my homosexuality, most likely because I have never been involved in organized religion. It is so disheartening to hear how destructive some organized religions can be, for every person involved. In an ideal world, organized religions would be a powerful force for good, reconciliation, inclusion, and strength, but time and time again people get torn down, shunned, or destroyed by people who have used their religion as a tool for hypocrisy.
(to be clear, I’m not knocking all religions here, just wishing many of them would do a better job at showing more of what should be one of their basic tenets: love)
how closely tied these “we’ll cure you kid from being gay” outfits are to the “we’ll cure your kid from smoking pot” hellholes?
I’m not sure. Here’s a look (from Zach’s blog) at the rules behind the “fix teh gay” program. I’m guessing the “get your kids off pot” places rely on similar methods of surveillance and interrogation, of demanding absolute control over the inmate’s life.
lotta overlap, but not the same. Most of the totalitarian rehab joints are relatively secular, tho Scientology’s turning their “Narconon” empire into a big moneymaker. They scored a lot of airtime on local radio all over, the morning after the Medical Marijuana ruling. Always dropped their tollfree number.
Thanks for sharing it with us.
That hymn verse is one of my favorites too. There are magic mornings as I drive to work when the leaves in the trees are so clean and clear; when birds and squirrels are playing; and I’m so lucky since the daily commute takes me by a stream and lake, with ducks… How can anyone leave such an ineffably beautiful place? How sad that some carry such heavy burdens that they can contemplate (let alone act on) such an urge.
I’m cursed/blessed with an ability to see both sides of an issue (If fence sitting were an Olympic sport I’d try out for it). From what I can see the LIA approach is pretty much in line with treatment models for drug addicts, alcohol abusers, etc. For a loving caring parent who believes that “gay” is a life-style choice that will lead to ruin it looks like a good option.
This issue is one that troubles and pains me even more than abortion or the death penalty. There is such an unbridgeable chasm in the foundational assumptions.
There are those who thoroughly and sincerely believe that one can be recruited into being gay, can choose to be gay (or not)with great ease – like ordering steak instead of salad. Or maybe not with great ease, but gradually falling into an unhealthy habit like smoking or drinking to excess. Which of us, seeing a loved one endangering their health in the extreme wouldn’t implore them to change their ways? What parent wouldn’t make every effort to alter the apparent course of self-destruction? And wouldn’t the concern be even more powerful if they believed that the behavior wasn’t just dangerous to health, but to an immortal soul for eternity? I cannot find the right words to express the depths of empathy and pity I feel for them.
Still, I stand on the other side of that chasm of assumptions. I am a middle-aged female with blue eyes and mouse hair – and I am hetero-sexual. I can’t be any younger than I am and I shouldn’t have to subject myself to painful and dangerous surgery to change my apparent age. I don’t have time to constantly tend to cosmetic improvements of hair and eye color. You can lock me in a room and “brain-wash” me to favor same-sex images – perhaps even effecting a change in behavior – but you will never erase the fact that in the night, in my dreams, when my true self is at play -the opposite sex turns me on! I know both men and women who spend inordinate amounts of time and energy hiding who they are. Pretending outwardly to co-workers, family, etc. that they are not attracted to same sex partners. Even worse – some pretend inwardly, to themselves, and close off a major part of their self-hood and potential for joy. I cannot find the right words to express the depths of empathy and pity I feel for them.
There is that chasm of foundational assumptions – and I despair of there being a bridge that will cross the chasm. Loving family and friends on one side. Loving family and friends on the other side. I cannot find the right words to express the depths of empathy and pity I feel for all of them.
I feel only contempt for the parents.
considered a sin at one time (the sin of Ham)?
Your brief reference to being denied the Mormon priesthood, all because of how you were born, bears so much resemblence to those who are also “cursed by God” because of being born gay.
It is becoming more evident, due to studies, that being gay is a matter of biology, not belief. So, it’s either true that God loves all of us, regardless of race, color, or sexual orientation…or God is a sadistic fuck who creates people who are destined to burn in Hell for living as He created them.
It’s the latter God that the fundies acknowledge, I fear…and as a Christian, I totally reject that God.
‘Nuff said…
I really, really feel for you. And I admire your courage in writing this diary.
I just cannot understand why some others have to be stigmatized because they refuse to believe or partly refuse to believe; because they look different, because they love differently, because they are women.
The word for any deviation from the orthodoxy is heresy.
I call it, fear of the unknown.
To tell you the truth, I was attracted at one time to Mormonism, but thankfully, I backed away. It’s just that most of the town and my friends were Mormons–the pinkest and most precious white people I have ever met.
I doubt whether–culturally–things have changed very much since the revelation that black males could be accepted into the Mormon priesthood. You know for sure that blacks were allowed into the Mormon faith UNTIL it became too politically incorrect and hot to handle during its early years. Hence the revelation so that they could survive as a religious entity in the U.S.
Unfortunately, they’ve been able to attract someone like Gladys Knight into the Church. They are also building a Stake in Harlem as I speak.
Keep writing…I’m quite willing to read more and to learn more.
I guess I am naive, but I never realized this type of “treatment” was ever actually used. This sounds straight out of Clockwork Orange. I am so sorry you had to endure it, but I rejoice that you have found peace with yourself.
I know your story can help other people out there who feel the same things you felt. Thank you for sharing it with us.
Thank you for your moving story. You have had me in tears for a few minutes, trying to think of what I could possibly add to this wonderful diary. I am truly at a loss for words. Keep writing. It helps the healing process. Anything you write, I will read, for that helps me heal as well.
</great big bear hug>
Thank you for sharing this story. I can’t understand anyone subjecting their child to the physical, emotional and spiritual pain of a place like Refuge-I hope Zack can get out as intact as possible.
(I was not allowed either to ‘hold the priesthood’ because of my ‘black blood’.. a long story for another day)
I’ll be waiting for that one with baited breath. So much of this is familiar to me. I spent some time in the born-again world trying to suppress my own cognitive dissonance. Your epiphany on the cliff is what some people call a “peak experience” but what I call a mystical awareness — that moment when for a brief time you actually glimpse the one-ness and harmony of which we are all a part.
Please tell Zack that I will PERSONALLY find him a place to live, a Safe Harbor, if he needs to leave home.
I’ve done it before, and saved lives because of it. I’m more than willing to do it again!
and thank you for sharing it. I believe that by sharing these so-called ‘personal’ stories, we move our global self towards greater healing. And it’s so important to do these days as there remains tons of hate out there… so we must share.
I’m day by day beginning to believe that god is love… and that is that…
that isn’t said best by Silko:
"You don’t have anything, if you don’t have the stories."
Thank you for yours. The real experience, the real pain, the real suffering and anguish–and the real love and joy of real people means far more to people than abstract mouthings.
You found peace. That’s the greatest gift.
That was a wonderful diary and I am happy you shared it. I am not gay but I understood the way that hymn effected you. There is a verse in a hymn, a line really that choked me up for years….
I will break their hearts of stone,
Give them hearts for love alone.
I figured out why after awhile and just last year I finally understood.
God is indeed much bigger and grander than man could imagine and can never be confined by any religion. Your experience reminds me of the time Buddha was enlightened when he was alone and nobody was around him.
I highly recommend the book Siddhartha, by Herman Hesse. Like you, this character recognized that enlightenment only comes through personal experience and not through external teachings.
Don’t get me wrong; I’m not taking anything away from Buddhism or any other religion. But no authority can stand between an individual and their god or lack thereof.
The extreme right youth organization ‘All Polish Youth’ held its ‘Normality Parade’ as a response to last weeks (banned) ‘Equality Parade’.
The wingnut marchers shouted slogans:
‘boy, girl, normal family’ (rhymes in Polish)
Great Poland – A Catholic one
Pedophiles, Pederasts are Euroenthusiasts
Down with Gay agitation
At an news conference after the demo, Wojciech Wierzejski, former head of the All Polish Youth, now a deputy in the European Parliament made some remarks to the press, calling for ‘zero tolerance’ for homosexuals
‘We will not permit any tolerance for people of consciously gay convictions’ (this makes as little sense in Polish as in English)
‘Let’s not hire them for jobs’ and so on and so forth
What a beautiful story of pain and loss and renewal and hope. I’m so happy you’ve found your family.
I am not religious but I’ve always loved that song, How Great Thou Art, it’s just so majestic. And for you to hear the trees and the boulders and the wind singing along with you… priceless.
I spent my brother’s last week with him, years ago, and learned much in that time from mostly gay friends of his that were in and out of the house all the time. How some families treated their gay children, throwing them out of their “christian” homes, leaving them to live or die alone, and just amazingly awful things. I still struggle not to just simply hate, after hearing all that. I mostly succeed.
I also reached a point of ending a life I thought could never be worthwhile. I also awoke to faith, the acceptance of my sexuality, and a love for life. It is hard when very young, and from an unaccepting background to even see your life is worthwhile. If each of us gets past that point, we can find happiness, strength, and courage that we could never imagine before. Thank you for sharing your story, especially with the young and unsure, and fighting against hate. We can’t allow these hateful, ignorant bigots destroy the lives of delightful unique young people, simply over their sexuality.