National Guard soldiers stood between the surging mob and the buses there to evacuate the desperate out of the abject misery of New Orleans.
The troops were processing some 25,000 refugees spilling out of the squalor of the Louisiana Superdome on Sept. 2, working to keep families intact as they worked their way up the line of thousands.“For God’s sake, please don’t separate yourself from your children,” screamed Air Force Capt. John Pollard of the Texas Air Guard’s 149th Security Squadron into a microphone. Pollard screamed numerous times. “Keep your families together. You need one another.”
But his amplified voice only reached a few rows into the mob.
As desperation and uncertainty grew, however, parents who wanted to ensure survival for their infant children starting passing them forward. The crowd moved them ahead, hand over hand, and presented them to the Guard members at the metal barricades separating them from the buses.
Pollard said he saw “thousands” of babies passed forward that way over two days of evacuations, despite urgings not to do so.
The soldiers and airmen had no idea what to do with the babies, so they would order the crowd to pass them back to the parents. But the crowd would often respond saying that they didn’t know which direction the babies came from. Nonetheless, the infants would be passed back over the mob, eventually disappearing out of the troops’ view…
Maj. Ed Bush walked alongside the mob with a megaphone and pled, until his voice gave out, for those in line to stay with their families. But many told Bush that they had already sent children and women to the front of the line because they heard from other evacuees that that was what the military wanted.
Some said they had sent their children by themselves to the buses because they thought it more important to get their kids out of the intense heat, humidity and filth.
Bush told the evacuees that they had acted on “a very bad rumor.” But, calling it “the only solace I can offer you,” he told the civilians that they didn’t have to worry because everyone was going to the same place – the Houston Astrodome.
That changed while buses were en route….more
For a while, the missing children got a lot of media attention. CNN even devoted a third of their screen to little baseball cards of them for couple of days.
At one point, sometime near the end of Cleansing Week, the day after Shepherd Smith forgot himself, and screamed into the camera, TV feeds showed someone in a uniform megaphoning to a crowd that buses were coming, and that people should “choose one family member.” Buses did not actually come for a couple of days, but the understanding was that when they did, infants, and possibly some elders, would be allowed to board them. The rest would be empowered to continue their natural expiration process without government interference. The “bad rumor” Major Bush mentions.
Throughout history, thus has been expressed the heartbursting ferocity of parental love. Faced with death, mothers and fathers have passed their babies forward, thrust them into the arms of strangers, thrown them from moving vehicles, raging waters, exploding skies, burning buildings. It is an instinct stronger even than self-preservation – species preservation, the anthropologists tell us, and it is the reason why in certain target zones of the world, no matter how much food is witheld, bombs are dropped, and disease cultivated, birthrates are highest.
There is something in us that is determined to grasp at any chance to save our children no matter what happens to us, even when the chance of saving is slim.
there are more than 2,000 children, many of whom are Black, who remain separated from their parents, authorities said. The center, officials say, has received 17,454 calls since the hurricane, the largest effort ever to re-connect families….link
The National Center for Missing & Exploited Children can only count the ones about which they have received calls. With the fate of so many of the parents, grandparents, uncles and aunties “unclear,” many more babies who were passed forward are not on a list.
We can certainly hope that the hands who received them last were good ones, that they will be fed, and loved, and cared for, but the reality of society being what it is, some are now in situations such that their parents, had they known, would have kept them in their own arms to die with them.
As the cessation of media coverage shows us, it is not a subject mainstream America cares to contemplate.
Of course, not all who were passed forward are babies. Some are old enough to be aware of what happened, and if they continue to defy America by managing to reach adulthood, they will remember.
This is sickening. What else is there to say?
This reminds me of Jewish parents getting their children out of Germany when Hitler was in power. Enough said.
Thanks for always making us think, DTF. Your writing is the epitome of “Comfort the disturbed, disturb the comfortable.”
* that * i would do.
but i’m not sure any survival instinct would compel me to pass my baby through a crowd like that. of course, i may well just be talking smack, since i don’t have any children and i’ve never been stuck in a hurricane-ravaged city.
the whole goddamn thing is just so completely, unfathomably fuckerpantsed.
: (
From the point of view of the parents. You know that you will be cleansed, you will do anything for even a small chance for your child to live.
Because if you keep him with you, there is not even a small chance.
I have children; if it were a choice between hoping for their survival and almost certain death for them, I would pass them forward.
This story says so much about the humanity and good sense the people of New Orleans showed in an untenable situation. It also speaks volumes about the so-called “rescuers”. It is disheartening.
You would. My younger sister was in a bad vehicle accident. Her vehicle was upside on its partially collapsed roof and she and her unconscious husband were trapped inside. The people outside her vehicle feared it would explode (gas was leaking) with them inside. She unbuckled the baby from the safety seat and passed her out to strangers. She said it was the hardest thing she’s ever had to do. You do it when you don’t think you’re going to live.
So while the media was telling us all about the bad, bad people looting and raping, parents were taking extreme action to save their kids. Imagine the feelings of desperation and betrayal these parents must have now.
I’ve also heard that hundreds of foster kids have been misplaced. What a disaster.
choose one family member.”—- Sophie’s Choice?
oh god, that movie…* shudder *
how can such evil exist in the world?
It may hve been even more than a desperate struggle to save the babies The View from Lott’s Porch. This was published on the 9th (behind a subscription wall at The Nation, but google is our friend). We know other so called rumors are absolutely true. Out of Beaumont and Pt Arthur people were still loaded onto buses and planes iwth no word where they were headed… I suspect the “separatng” by design is true as well.
OT I ahve the DNC commission on presidential nomination on Cspan.
These people are devoid of energy… just lifeless. Very telling. INCLUDING DNC Ex Com member Alexis Herman, originally from NO and whose calls into FOX all about her mother and sister and “faith in the lord” were disgusting. Never a word over the great and terrible transgressions going on… in a city where she supposedly cares about anything. She was all faith and forward. Cosy happy talk with the FOX hosts.
Frankly, serf family ties in a feudal society do not benefit the lords.
Exactly. was re reading the stories and writings from the era of The Weeping Time. The large 1857 sale of 429 slaves from a single plantation. held for weeks and days in the horse stalls pending the sale. Then families split up… the rain that fell for three days during the sale at the Savannah racetrack.
Frankly the horrors in NO (particularly) sent me back to that time.
We have not changed.
And now, they are saying that most of the dead will not even be identified…..
And there is no big push to hire more people for the CEMC in order to help reunite families, dropped off the radar screen, like so much else.
This is just unspeakable — meanwhile, we are presented with the ongoing story of “white girl gone missing in Aruba” —
I don’t think our species deserves to live.
any pretense that we’ve overcome the legacy of racism in the US has been erased by Katrina and it’s aftermath.
And I don’t believe that the multiple repulsive public statements from people like Bennett and Murry are an accident.
Next election the republicans are going to play this out to a revolting degree. They’ll attack Hispanics (immigration, poverty) and they’ll attack Blacks (poverty, underclass, ‘moral’ issues) We should be prepared for this as best we can because it’s going to be terrifying and deeply divisive. Perhaps Senator Obama will make a stand. heh
Oh, and Louisiana is now a red state.
Oh, and Louisiana is now a red state.
It already was and has been hasn’t it? Or was that a bit of snarky flouish at the end there?
Or was that a bit of snarky flouish at the end there?
No, not at all. The governor, Lieutenant Governor and one of their Senators are Dems. If you look on the ironically named Democrats for Life homepage there are a shitload of elected Dems from LA. John Breaux is from LA.
In the last SUSA poll Bush’s approval went up in both Mississippi and that’s not entirely due to the fact that lots of land-lines are down, it’s because many Democratic voters have died or are part of the diaspora.
Yes, but they appear to be, by and large, strongly conservative Democrats – certainly far more conservative than the progressive senator currently being excoriated on a variety of blogs for sounding just a bit too much like a “sellout” for people’s taste in his inaugural diary at DailyKOS.
In 2004, Louisiana voted overwhelmingly for Dubbya, to the point where even if Kerry had gotten the votes of everyone else on the ballot for President, he’d have still been 250,000 votes short:
2004 Electoral Results in Louisiana
(Louisiana also voted for Dubbya in 2000).
You want to know what a Louisiana Democrat can sound like? Go back and listen to Governor Blanco’s joyous announcement that troops were now “locked and loaded” to deal with the “problems” created by the people trapped in New Orleans. That IMO speaks volumes about the fact that we should not be using default labels like “Democrat” and “Republican” to describe what it is that people really think and feel.
John Breaux is not someone who I would have held up as a an example of a “real Democrat” either……(and if you think he is, just look at his record before his retirement.)
You want to know what a Louisiana Democrat can sound like?
Look, shanikka I’m the last person to mourn the death of the Democratic party in Louisiana and for precisely the reasons you mention. If you read what I’ve been saying here about Blanco you will see a refusal to defend her and resistance to the notion of a partisan defense of that woman. There’s more than what you mentioned that we already know. The authorities in Gretna called her office before blocking the bridge out of NO to people trying to evacuate. They’re acting as if they have cover for their policy of shooting over the heads of children and elderly people in wheel chairs trying to get out of a flooded city.
That IMO speaks volumes about the fact that we should not be using default labels like “Democrat” and “Republican” to describe what it is that people really think and feel.
Quite so. Racism isn’t limited to republicans. The difference is that those people who didn’t have food or water for 4 days, those American citizens being shot at trying to cross a bridge we all helped pay for, overwhelmingly voted for Blanco. How horrifying and dysfunctional is that? And don’t get me started on Breaux.
Every Dem pol involved in this debacle was a member of the DLC and, ironically, pro-life.
Obama is clearly trying to rhetorically transcend the current polarization and, at least when addressing issues of central importance to those of us concerned with the continual lurch of the dem leadership towards conservatism, he clearly failed. I’ve many quarrels with his analysis, no hope of communicating these differences of opinion and people aren’t upset with ‘just one vote’.
I was extremely worried about this when it was happening. The various “ID bracelets being put on all children” so they could be easily put back with their parents did not convince me. As disorganized as the feds were, I could not believe they were handling this appropriately. I did not dream how badly they were handling it.
What I still do not understand is why they would not work harder to keep families together. They obviously did not try hard enough, if they tried at all.
And what, in the end, disturbed me the most was that the government did not immediately start a photographic database of the children who were without families and vice-versa. Rather, we have the lame and ineffective searching through multiple locations, phone lines. Certainly the organizations doing this are working hard to reunite families. However, having multiple organizations with many points of contact, formats, types of information, etc. is terribly difficult, particularly for parents and for children who are doing the searching. There should have been one central place from the begnning.
You are correct. Children are going to grow up remembering this. And their parents, relatives, and siblings will remember this.
And yet, we have all prepared and being executed, this truly nasty and racist semantic game already being played out: anti-immigrant, anti-Black, etc. Just yesterday I heard a woman on NPR defend payouts to churches who took in Katrina folks on the basis of “their churches have been trashed for weeks, the least we can do is pay them for their expenses”. I may not have the words exactly, but that is close.
I’d like to wring their collective necks!
I heard it too — “the carpets have been trashed” (in Houston churches), we deserve to be reimbursed…blah, fucking, blah. I wish I knew a good tax lawyer, hey where is bonddad?? I want to know what receiving OUR money from the fed. govt. does to these “faith-based” organizations’ tax expemt status.
We are tax expempt but we will happily take your tax money — that shit don’t play with me.
Yeah, my thought if they are taking our tax money, they should damn well lose their tax exempt status! I dont’ mind churches – I used to work for one in the long, long ago. But I don’t want one penny of my money going to a religious organization. Not a red cent.
cannot speak for themselves. Thank you. The number of missing children from Katrina is staggering. I could not figure out how that many children could go missing until reading this. CNN is too busy now with the one missing person in Aruba to concern itself with thousands of missing children from Louisiana.
Considering that the bus destinations were kept secret from the passengers until the bus was on the road and the trip was underway and that the parents of these children had no means of communication until they reached shelters themselves, it’s no surprise that there is confusion. Also missing are identifying documents, photographs, birth certificates.
I share your hope that the babies will end up “in good hands.”
Live children have a considerable cash value on the free market.
It is not a subject that will be attractive to television sponsors, and the networks have made a very mature and pragmatic decision to focus on other aspects of the storm’s “aftermath.”
Yes. And the Black children of N.O. and elsewhere who are displaced, are what I call “value negative” children. Our society charges them with a debt on birth to be paid via substandard schools, housing, public services, etc. And if they still do well, then, finally they are counted as being worth something as citizens. And held up as false ideals for all of the other children who are born indebted beyond all ken (and I’m not speaking of our national debt when I say they are born with this negative value).
Baghdad on the bayou. Americans are now, in some tiny measure, undergoing what Iraqis have had inflicted on them for a dozen or so years now.
And, as ever, it is the least and most powerless and poorest who are suffering most.
Those FEMA thugs should be tossed, without resources or identification, into the most devastated parts of New Orleans and Biloxi and the Gulf coast. And left there. May they rot, god damn their souls.
I never thought I’d have to say this, but I am truly ashamed of this country.
Americans are now, in some tiny measure, undergoing what Iraqis have had inflicted on them for a dozen or so years now.
It’s unfortunate that the overwhelming number of Americans having this inflicted on them are also the same Americans who, overwhelmingly, were against the invasion and occupation of Iraq from the get go.
Thank you for this beautifully painful, timely, diary about this heartbreaking reality about the lost babies.
It stands as a needed talkback and slapdown of truth to this disingenuous and hateful tripe published as a WSJ editorial by eugenicist Charles Murray this week, essentially contending that the parents victimized by Katrina — particularly the Black ones, although the racial code word “underclass” is carefully substituted throughout — cared almost for their children or they’d have (colloquially speaking) gotten off their asses and gotten a job:
Yet all those “thugs” without the “[]ability to get up every morning and go to work” who are so “self-destructive” passed their most precious possession – their babies — ahead in the line, in the nightmarish thong, so that they could be saved, even if it meant saved away from the sheltering arms of their family.
You can probably imagine what I’d like to do to the Charles Murray’s of the world when I focus on just that one fact.
(I hope you don’t mind, but I’m going to link to this diary on my blog when blogger stops hiccuping and I can post again. It’s so well written – and I figure you’ve said it far better than I could.)
ever you like, I will be honored, but undeserving, most of it was written by news writers. 😉
Mr. Murray’s view is a very popular one. It does tend to be more popular with people who have never known want, who have never struggled with the dilemma of whether to purchase food or medical treatment or electricity, in Mr. Murray’s world, “welfare” means getting a big fat check for several thousand dollars every month, and a free apartment, probably with a swimming pool, and food stamps buy a month’s worth of food. And champagne.
He is correct about one thing, though. While job training is sorely needed, that is not the most pressing issue. The root of the problem is insufficient income, a concept Mr. Murray will probably not have a keen appreciation of.
When a day’s labor, anybody’s labor, doing any job at all, falls below the price of a day’s survival, the society has transitioned from a capitalist economy to feudalism. It does not matter how early you get up in the morning, or how hard you work at Wal-Mart. If you are not paid enough money to purchase housing, and food, and medical treatment, one way or another Mr. Murray is going to pay.
The private security industry is very excited about the future. Mr. Murray will be empowered to use the money allocated for his children’s college fund to pay gunmen to stand guard over his fine home, until the fund runs out, at that point he may discover that getting up in the morning has become quite difficult.
Russ Feingold has an excellent idea, that networks should devote special air time in an effort to reunite such families. He is one of the few politicians who ia familiar with this problem.
story out of New Orleans, rumor or no, that has made me squeamish about my children’s safety.
It’s an odd feeling. Having only been a parent for just short of 2.5 years, it’s a feeling I haven’t known for long.
Desperation in absentia, perhaps. An empathetic desperation for what those people went through. For myself and my family were we to ever be faced with such a situation.
I shudder at the thought, and I look at my children differently. My daughter with an urge to protect. My son with an urge to raise him well. Both with a need to teach them that the Right is wrong, and that progressive thinking is what I hope they learn from me.