Major kudos to Howard Dean. He’s running way out front of lying Ken Mehlman again:
Dean is making a wonderful frame, one that is well voiced here and on other liberal blogs, and injecting it into the mainstream media. &n
“In 2006, it’s going to be immigrants — that’s who he is going to scapegoat next,” Dean said of Bush. “Once again, the Republicans create a problem so they can think to come in and solve it.”
I’m f’ing ecstatic that Dean has the ability to look around the corner, see what the GOP strategy is going to be, and start interfering with that strategy this far out. By calling out the Republican’s tactics, he gives the Democrats a chance to continue pointing out that the GOP way is divide and conquer and they don’t give a crap what tool they use to accomplish that.
Dean offered an alternative to Bush’s guest worker proposal:
Dean said the government should have an “earned legalization” program in which immigrants who contribute to society and pay taxes should be able to earn the right to become citizens.
The DNC chairman also criticized Bush for not working with Mexico to confront America’s immigration problems. “Work with Mexico to improve economies in rural America and rural Mexico, and you will stop the flood of people wanting to come to America,” Dean said.
Dean’s alternative outshines the Bush proposal, by extending the right of citizenship (not merely the watered down quasi citizenship offered by Bush) to those who prove they can be responsible citizens (as an aside, I find the implication that every illegal is unworthy of citizenship just becuase they came here illegally illogical; what about wet feet dry feet, hmm George?) Bush’s plan offers upheaval and chaos for guest workers every three years and marginal personhood status. And besides, do we really want to be like Saudi Arabia and Kuwait?
GOP Response?
“Dean’s blatant mischaracterization of Bush’s agenda is his best effort to mask the Democrats’ unmistakable lack of a plan and any connection with voters on issues that matter,” Bounds said.
Notice the conflation of immigration issues with border security? Dean didn’t say a damn thing about border security, the topic was immigration. The GOP is working to employ the weak on law and order frame on the Dems. Don’t let ’em do it.
Thanks Howard. Keep up the good work.
Update [2005-12-4 12:50:32 by lapin]:More from this morning’s WaPo
Speaking to the fall meeting of the Democratic National Committee (DNC), Dean pledged Democrats would offer tax policies aimed at middle-class voters, a plan to provide health insurance to all Americans, immigration proposals that offer a path to legalization for illegal immigrants and defense policies that would protect the nation and expose the “hollow promises” of the Bush administration.
—
The Democratic meeting came at a time of growing confidence within the party that 2006 could bring significant gains in Congress and the statehouses because of Bush’s low approval ratings and public anxiety about Iraq.
But Dean said those conditions alone are not sufficient to produce Democratic victories. “The collapse of confidence in the Republican leadership is not enough to elect Democratic leadership. We have to stand up for what we believe.”
I’m sure very few of us here would have any trouble speaking our minds in a public forum; I hope Dean’s statements will help give courage to those who may have felt cowed in the past and held back their views. Now we need our Congressional Dem leadership to develop a consistent message that coordinates with the DNC’s and start broadcasting that message clearly and often.
Thanks lapin, Howard is certainly a great leader, I hope he is getting stronger by the day.
(good links)-It looks like we are going to have to keep up the fight against slavery for a long time.
Dean’s OK.
But, gay marriage hasn’t gone away as a GOP “divide and conquer” wedge issue. Gay marriage is under attack in Mass., and gay rights are under attack around the nation – and the Democratic Party hasn’t done much I’m aware of to help out in this fight.
Dean’s innoculation campaign on immigration is very smart politics, yes, but I don’t see much concerted effort to support gay rights coming out of the Dem. Party, and the party’s continued slide towards a “faith based” politics demonizing secularism amounts to a strategic disaster of enormous proportions.
I just wish more people likeJoe “he doesn’t speak for me” Biden would shut the f up and listen to Dean. Dean really is a straight shooter and the leader we need to get out in front of the republican spin machine. Thanks Lapin for a fabulous diary.
So the Republican response on all things is: Security, security, security. . .and. . .Democrats don’t have a plan. And they’ll keep saying that even in the face of a Dem like Dean laying out a PLAN.
I like what he’s doing:
Dean Hammers Bush On War, Immigration
As I read Meteor Blades diary about Iraq just now, I couldn’t help but think about how the “positioning” of all the Dems like Kerry and Clinton during 2003 and 2004 has left us in such a huge mess.
Just imagine where we would be now if Dean had been the Dem’s presidential candidate. Even if he hadn’t won the election, the Dem’s would now have a leg to stand on in our position on the war.
We need to listen to Dean. He’s been right on so much in the past!!
Dean is able to pick up on the buzz much faster than the old guard Dems.
I have been hearing my Repub neighbors and family hammering on “those illegals” since Katrina. They didn’t want to talk about Katrina (other than blaming the victims) because it was such a mega-failure. Let’s talk about The Sanctity Of Our Borders, instead.
The party of Us and Them just loves a distinct brown group to demonize.