Talk about making money off people’s misery and desperation. This takes the cake for running, jumping and standing gall:
For $35 per person – $28 for children – a New Orleans company is offering bus tours of some of the city’s most misery-stricken spots, including the Superdome, the Convention Center and neighborhoods ravaged by Hurricane Katrina.
Residents disagree over whether the tours are crass and morbid exploitation, or a good way to help people grasp the enormity of the disaster and keep public attention focused on New Orleans’ plight.
The three-hour tours, called “Hurricane Katrina – America’s Worst Castastrophe,” were announced last week by Gray Line New Orleans, with the first one set for Jan. 4.
I saw the hippie tours of the Haight-Ashbury on one of CBS’ news reports during the Sixties. I didn’t like it either. Especially when it turned into a virtual shooting gallery after the Summer of Love. The news crews ran through again. And black folks, who were mostly populated in the Lower Haight area at that time were caught up in the heroin madness, too.
Here’s more:
The buses will start at the edge of the French Quarter, then drive past the Superdome and Convention Center, where thousands suffered in the heat for days without food or water. The tour also may include the destroyed marina and neighborhoods like the flooded Lakefront, Gentilly and eastern New Orleans areas.
Company vice president Gary Hoffman said he intends to show “the utmost sensitivity” to those whose homes were destroyed. After all, he said, they include about 60 percent of the company’s 65 pre-Katrina employees, including himself.
The company will give $3 per ticket to Katrina-related charities, he said. The tours will use major thoroughfares only and employ minibuses rather than big tour coaches, Hoffman said. Smaller streets and the Ninth Ward will not be part of the tour because “that would be too intrusive,” he said.
Hoffman also observed that tourists are already going through destroyed neighborhoods on their own (and risking angry survivors and environmental waste). Might as well make money off it, he figures.
Unfortunately, victims can still be seen on city streets, with some living in tents and in cars near their wrecked homes and who are trying to salvage their belongings. One critic, in the Reuters’ version of the story, had this to say:
“There should be tours, but they should be linked with people who are displaced and coming up with a plan of action,” said Corlita Mahr, a hurricane victim who works with the grassroots People’s Hurricane Relief Fund.
I still don’t like it. People have a right to their own privacy, not only in their homes, but even in their own communities.
I asked someone from the Orange Zone recently to take exterior pictures of my old home in New Orleans. But s/he went further than that. S/he ventured into the ground floor of the house but stopped at what had been the living room and dining room. While the door to the house was wide open, and the house appeared from the photos to be completely empty, s/he did not go further into what had been my grandparents, my mother and I’s bedrooms, and what we called the back room “out of respect.”
I was glad to get the photos. We no longer own the whole house and the last time I was there, I could not get access to the lower level, which has had few tenants since we finally left New Orleans in 1968. The foundation has long been undermined by the shifting, waterlogged soil. The flat, which took in the entire length and breadth of the house, would flood without benefit of rainstorms.
I would not be surprised if the house was bulldozed and knocked down. I would mourn, because it took in the first fifteen years of my life. I had the feeling that my grandparents’s shades were still there, and that was why no one could live there any more. As s/he sent me the photographs over e-mail, I would tell him/her who lived where, where my grandparents’ big radio was located in the house, and the Queen Anne chairs and dining room table, and the fact that the wood floors have been replaced by cheap linoleum, that my grandmother’s third and last husband put in the tile that still decorated the pathway, and that there were once trees and bushes and flowers and lizards and mosquito hawks and cicadas. And where Mr. Joe’s bar once stood next door. And that it was almost all gone.
Memories are all that is left.
But respect is something that appears to be missing out of the Gray Line owner’s plans. For every house, store, park or church, people dwelt and made love and joined prayer circles and practiced dancing the second line, and made groceries and grunted at their TVs and laughed at Morgus the Magnificent and lived out their lives.
New Orleans is not a zoo.
I don’t care if Gray Line Veep Gary Hoffman does live there–he’s not a carpetbagger. But he should know better.
It would be the same as someone climbing into his neighborhood to catch a look.
Ghouls…
For the few that might approve of the “capitalism” taking place, I think the many that would be offended should be spared the intrusion. There has to be more than just dollars and cents on a company’s spreadsheets if they want to avoid losing sight of humanity.
Ghouls…
Damned right. The whole thing is just disgusting.
So…when are you asking Boo & Susan for a special Katrina section?
:<)
I absolutely cannot thank you enough for all of your work.
I hope to talk with them.
American entrpreneurial free enteprise at its finest! I wish I could be shocked.
Can still be thoroughly disgusted though. Thanks for sharing this.
My grandmother took one of those hippie bus tours through Berkeley & the Haight in the 60’s. Even as a kid it sounded like some perverted safari tour. Too scary to walk among the natives on the street.
that disney is thinking of adding a Katrina attraction.
I just shake my head. Some people will EXPLOIT anything for a buck.
Kind of similar to what the republican congress does to the average American citizen.
I heard a blip on CNN that disney is thinking of adding a Katrina attraction.
Please tell me you’re joking. Please.
There are just no words for that.
Too many people have no concept of decency. But thanks for not letting NOLA/Katrina fall off the radar.
This is fucking dispicable. And to add insult to injury – 3 bucks from every ticket goes to a Katrina-related charity. 3 bucks! Why not set up a donation fund where people can donate the whole $35 (or $28 for their children) to a Katrina-related charity.
Amen.
Hate to play devil’s advocate even slightly on this one, because I’m viscerally repelled by the whole idea. But the tour business in N.O. is extremely competitive, $3.00 is probably close to the profit margin. Of course, if Gray Line can break even while maintaining its market presence it’s probably doing better than its competitors and it’s not a small struggling company. But remember the guides need the work, because they usually work on commission. It’s still tasteless, but the 3 bucks isn’t really the issue.
BTW, Shays’ questioning of Blanco weds. wasn’t just off base, it was cynically dishonest: Moldy City
n/t
No one ever went broke underestimating the crassness of the American people.
I have no doubt that plenty of people will go on these tours and make all the appropriate noises at the destruction and guide-speak but will never once actually consider the lives of the poor of New Orleans, either before or after Katrina.
I had to think about why this is so disgusting. I never miss your New Orleans diaries, Sista. I like to think that somehow I share your sorrow, and am not so low as to want to take a tour of it.
Ultimately, it is the concept of profit that repels me. There is so much better use that could be made of those funds that people are willing to part with.
It’s just sad that the capitalists find the way to exploit people’s interest before the humanists do.
“Get some devastation in the back,” Sen. Bill Frist told a photographer in tsunami-stricken southern Sri Lanka.
Sen. Frist was accompanied on the trip by Sen. Mary Landrieu.
.
Monday through Thursday – a 4 day real: Survival of the Fittest
Same circumstances – I hope they didn’t clear the poo, waste and chemicals – in the Superdome.
Tickets to be paid in advance, no refunds. Republicans are eligible for a discount. Families are welcome.
Minimum number of contestants 15,000 men, women, children, elderly.
“Treason doth never prosper: what’s the reason?
For if it prosper, none dare call it treason.”
▼▼▼ READ MY DIARY
for keeping us informed. The MSM has certainly moved on and doesn’t look back.
Will the tour guide say something like, “Now look on your left to see Katrina victims still living in tents.”? WTF! This is beyond vile!
On the other hand, maybe some of these tourists will have their hearts opened and write big donation checks when they get back to their hotels…
I wish I believed that you are right about those donations but people find it remarkably easy to disconnect from reality when it suits.
I think it was Monument Valley that really drove this home to me. The place is full of tourists who take pictures, pay the Navajo to take them on tours that include visiting Navajo homes, and then gush about what a wonderful experience it was. The actual lives of the Navajo are completely invisible to them; they just see a quaint homesite in a pretty landscape and never acknowledge the desperate need that would drive a people who have an intense sense of privacy to open their land and their homes to strangers. If people who go on tours readily accepted the reality behind the tour itinerary, the Navajo in Monument Valley would be filthy rich by now.
When I used to live in NYC it used to drive me nuts when tourists would stop to ask me, big smile on their faces, for directions to “Ground Zero”.
The idea of people looking out the tour bus windows at this neglected city at those less fortunate as tourists reminded me for some reason of a TheThe song:
So many need to keep a separation between themselves and unfortunate OTHERS.
funds for the levees. 1.9 billion I believe, has been appropriated, although I am waiting to see the money.
Gov. Blanco had her day in Congress, and said that America is in for some dark days if it believes that rebuilding Iraq is more important than rebuilding an American city.
for continuing to speak out for the victims of Katrina. There are still thousands upon thousands without a home and Grey Line thinks it is okey dokey to make a few bucks off their misery. Do you have an address or email where we can write to this scumbag?
Link for venting, scroll down. This is the official page where you can make reservations for the Katrina tour.
http://www.etix.com/travel/servlet/onlineSale?action=viewTourDescription&route_id=11123&fran
chise_id=69
Thank you my friend. I just sent them a scathing email denouncing this obscenity.
We visit every March (not for mardi gras) and I think we will again in ’06.
I hope NOLA Habitat for Humanity does keep all their donations in New Orleans, as the woman assured me when I got them on the phone. I have to trust.
The last 2 weeks I’ve collected $500+ in exchange for 2 dozen necklaces. I collected no funds for myself. What I’m getting out of it (besides being happy people care) is inventory reduction and advertising for next May when the farmer’s market opens again.
A bus tour. Where the happy tourists can gawk out the window and take lots of digital photos and videos that they can show to their friends back home, as if they’re just back from Disney World.
People who give a damn about the lives that have been crushed by the forces of wind, water, and government disdain won’t be riding the freaking bus. They’ll be on the ground, reaching out with both hands to help the residents of those shattered neighborhoods start over. Anyone who wants to spend $ 35 on a bus ride should find someone who’s been uprooted by Katrina and give that person $ 35 to pay for bus rides to work in some city that’s too far from home.
The people on the bus will more likely be looking for a thrill, congratulating themselves on being in some way superior enough to have avoided such tragedy. The bus window is just another TV screen, another way to avoid the grubby fingers of reality.
out from under that board. Oh, it’s a little baby. Ain’t he precious? Is that one a Creole or a Cajun? Aw, he’s got him a little rat. Gimme that camera, Earl.