From my blog.
However much Israel’s war of choice is sold to its Jewish majority as a war of necessity, this doesn’t work with Arabs. Least of all with Israel’s own 1.3 million Arab citizens, many of whom are also victims of the increasingly savage missile attacks, and nearly all of whom watch Arabic TV stations.
He says anyone watching the Arab channels gets a very different picture from that seen on the Israeli channels. While the Israeli channels depict a difficult but just war, the Arab satellite stations show constant attacks against civilians. The number of bodies seen on the screens every hour could change someone’s opinion of the justness of this war, and Israel is viewed as the instigator.
These Israeli Arabs, or Palestinians, were disenchanted with the “Jewish state” of Israel at the outset. This is due not only to solidarity with their kin in the occupied areas. Nor is it only due to the apartheid-like law reserving 94 percent of land for Jewish purchase only; nor to the one excluding Muslims from serving in the military (thus limiting their eligibility for social benefits) as well as in the police, the security services, and the prisons (though not as inmates); nor to a host of discriminatory statutes ranging from a 2003 “emergency regulation” restricting the right of Arabs to naturalize their families, to lower children’s allowances for non-Jews. It is due to the sum of all these, and more generally, to systematically occupying the lowest rung of the socioeconomic ladder:
In addition, Palestinians encounter problems of overcrowding. They own less than three percent of Israel’s land, and less than 50 percent of that land is under their local authority’s jurisdiction. The severe lack of appropriate, updated urban plans for their neighborhoods has created a serious housing problem. This shortage has resulted in a high population density, as well as more than 10,000 illegal houses threatened to be demolished under court order.
These data are from 2000, but things are hardly better now. For further reading, see this book entitled The Other Side of Israel, written by an Israeli Jew who, as it happens, grew up in apartheid South Africa.
On top of this one now has the simmering resentment over the brutal, meaningless destruction of Lebanon, with its consequent missile rain over Arab and Jew alike.
It’s common in Israel to talk about an ‘Arab population bomb’; indeed, several of the aforementioned discriminatory practices are justified in terms of such. But unless a constructive ‘Operation Change of Direction’ be launched, and soon, some Arab Israelis may well find themselves at their wit’s end. That could involve far uglier bombs than childbirth.
That is quite an amazing feat by Olmert, and one that was probably not quite planned.
It has been said that Jews in Iran have more rights than Arabs in Israel. Obviously that depends on what rights one wants to obsess over, but there is certainly some truth in it in terms of equal access to benefits.
More to the point why do so few still not talk the demographics that Israel fears. Their policies to both the Palestinians and their own Arabs can be explained by their fear of “their” state having to worry about one person one vote if a majority are Arab/Palestinian. Israel will not stop at anything to avoid this.
.
7th August 2006, 7:55 pm by Robert
Andrew Sullivan at Time Magazine’s Daily Dish says that the author Jostein Gaarder is an anti-semite, quoting an article by Gaarder in the Norweigan Aftenposten.
Sullivan claims that Gaarder is calling for the “obliteration of the state of Israel”, but on reading Gaardner in translation, I think that’s a serious misrepresentation of what he is trying to say. Gaardner repeatedly uses the word “apartheid” to describe Israel’s policies and structure. And if he, like many of us, sees an apartheid regime in Israel, then why should he not wish to call for its demise?
More on Gaarder
7th August 2006, 8:15 pm by Robert
Nevertheless, Gaarder’s essay is highly problematic. “We do not recognise the state of Israel” is not clarified in the way I attempted in my previous post, which invites the criticism slung at him by Andrew Sullivan and (no doubt) many others.
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
.
MT. HERZL, Israel (Jerusalem Post) Aug. 8 — IDF Chief Rabbi Brig.-Gen. Yisrael Weiss was evicted from the funeral of slain reserve soldier Yehuda Greenfeld by the soldier’s family, Army Radio reported.
Greenfeld’s sister, in an emotional outburst, blamed Rabbi Weiss for the eviction of Jews from Gush Katif and screamed at him to leave.
“I don’t want you here,” she shouted. “You’re driving people out of Gush Katif. I want you to remove yourself from my brother’s funeral. I want you to get out of here.”
The boot of an Israeli soldier is seen at the scene after a rocket attack in the Kibbutz of Kfar Giladi near the Israeli-Lebanon border.
…
In her last conversation with her brother, she said she “beseeched him to come home,” because serving in Lebanon right now was inconsistent with both of their political views. She said that soldiers from Judea and Samaria were being sent to fight, and in return they were being evacuated from their homes.
Shoshi shouted that Yehuda had died for a state that would soon drive his widow and children from their home in Ma’aleh Michmash in Samaria. “What does Olmert care?” she asked.
Ousted soldier gives IDF Chief of Staff Lt.-Gen. Dan Halutz ultimatum
First Sergeant Hananel Dayan-Meged, a tank driver who was cited as an outstanding soldier, and was expelled from his unit for refusing to shake hands with IDF Chief of Staff Lt.-Gen. Dan Halutz at the ceremony for outstanding soldiers at Beit Hanassi on Israel Independence Day. Meged, whose family was evacuated from Gush Katif in August, said that he would not shake hands with someone who had been responsible for removing Jews from their homes.
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
.
Hallo Sirocco,
Need to close your diary Famous Author Excoriates Israel with < /em > to end Italics.
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY
.
Just got hit by readers from Der Siegel with reference to Sirocco’s translation of Jostein Gaarder’s essay – Famous Author Excoriates Israel
World Map
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
▼ ▼ ▼ MY DIARY