Jose Padilla, center, is escorted to a waiting police vechicle by federal marshals in this Jan. 5, 2006, file photo. He has been on trial in Miami for most of this year, charged with conspiring with al Qaeda to detonate a “dirty bomb” in the United States.Photo by J. Pat Carter, AP
On Thurday August 16 2007 A federal jury convicted Jose Padilla of three counts of conspiracy
in a trial that was the culmination of five years of a criminal proceeding that is among the most shameful in the history of the United States justice system.
I am not an apologist for Jose Padilla, I belong to no “Free Jose” organizations nor am I a member of any “Jose Padilla defense funds,” although maybe I should have been, maybe we all should have been because when they throw away the keys to Padilla’s cell we will also throw away any pretense to being a nation of laws, a nation that respects human rights, we will throw away a large measure of what once made us a great and civilized nation.
I am also not a terrorist, nor am I a member of any terrorist organization and that declaration alone, in the modern, mandatory, cocoon of fear within which we are now required to live by governmental decree, is probably enough to have a tap placed on my phone and a couple of guys who look like the Blues Brothers parked in front of my house at odd hours. After all, if I have nothing to hide, why would I bring it up. Under the new Department of Justice rule book I must be indictable for something.
Jose Padilla was arrested over five years ago in May of 2002, picked up in Chicago after returning from Europe and allegedly carrying over 10 grand in cash. He was held for about a month as a material witness before Attorney General John Ashcroft delayed a trip to Moscow in order to announce that the US had discovered a plot to explode “dirty bombs” inside the country. Padilla was branded as the “Dirty Bomber” and George Bush declared him to be an illegal enemy combatant.
Padilla was a small time criminal, a US citizen born in Brooklyn, he had lived in Chicago and been a member of a street gang known as the Maniac Latin Disciples. He had been in prison at least once for aggravated assault after a gang member died as a result of fight in which he was involved. While in prison Padilla converted to Islam under the tutelage of someone who is reported to have preached a non violent, mainstream version of the religion. He attended mosques in Florida for years with one of the men who was convicted with him.
Padilla was probably a bad actor, I have seen nothing in his resume that would lead me to hire him as a youth counselor, but was he a terrorist? Who knows? That is the problem.
Had the government arrested him and presented it’s evidence in a court of law, as is done every day, in conspiracies great and small in every city in this country, had Padilla been afforded the guarantees of the constitution of the nation of which he was a citizen, we might have learned the truth.
Now we probably never will, because what the government did was search for shortcuts, the law was inconvenient, due process, criminal procedure, rights of the accused, all that stuff was an impediment to the speedy production of positive results in their war on terror public relations campaign, which followed on the heels of 9/11 and continues unabated to this day.
Padilla was shipped off to a Naval brig in Charleston to spend the next three and one half years in total isolation, held in constant darkness, or constant light, under extremes of temperature, subjected to physical and psychological “enhanced interrogation methods,” the Bush administration’s Orwellian euphemism for torture. And the government got nothing. Nothing.
When all was said and done, after more than three years of criminal treatment, the government, faced with the likelihood that the courts were about to require them to put up or shut up, finally indicted Padilla on the three conspiracy charges of which, last week, he was ultimately convicted.
Padilla was never charged with being a member of al Queada, he was never charged with being a dirty bomber, he was not indicted on nor was he ever charged with any what was alleged at the beginning of this exercise in injustice over three years before.
Our current Attorney General, Alberto Gonzales last week called the conviction of Jose Padilla and his co-conspirators ” a significant victory in our efforts to fight the threat posed by terrorists and their supporters.”
If holding an American citizen or anyone else, for years, years, in military custody, without charging him with a crime, subjecting him to torture during the entire period, and then failing to indict or convict him of anything close to what they originally alleged is “a significant victory” then it helps me to understand their constant claims of significant progress in Iraq or in the “War on Terror.”
Make no mistake, this was no victory. This was a failure of our system of justice deliberately brought about by an executive department and two Attorneys General who had, and have, nothing but, disdain, in fact, utter contempt for the American system of justice and for due process of law.
I’m not bleeding for Jose Padilla here, I doubt if Jose even knows who he is at this point.
By accounts that I have read he has been driven insane by the circumstances of his confinement. It is reported that as part of the process of breaking him down he was forced to sign documents with the name “John Doe.” One of their goals was to relieve him of his personal identity, they succeeded, all too well.
The government on Thursday convicted “John Doe” of three counts of conspiring to participate in terrorist acts. They can do the same to me, more importantly, they can do the same to you.
They have spared no expense of time, energy and money over the last six years. they have gone to great lengths in establishing shortcuts that enable them to investigate, arrest, imprison and torture any one they want, at any time and for any reason.
To this government, this Cheney/Bush administration, this criminal enterprise that is destroying America one liberty at a time, we are all, each and every one of us “John Doe.”
Bob Higgins
Related Story
Window Into a Terror Suspect’s Isolation
Taking away your identity has to be the creepiest of the psychological assaults on a person’s mind. That more than anything in the entire article made me truly sick to my stomach. The ramifications of denying that you are ‘you’ has to be deadly even if absolutely nothing else was done to you.
There’s no way Padilla can be normal at this point and his sentencing is almost beside the point also as he’s already been sentenced to a life of mental instability…and doubtful he’ll ever get any real help for that.
I agree with the writer on all points.The confinement of without a lawyer of an American Citizen, by the mere classification of a President saying he was an “enemy combatant.” No due process, no habeas corpus, no visits from an attorney. Few recall the D.C. Circuit chastized the A.G. for arguing Padilla was an enemy combatant on Appeal and when it was apparent the A.G. was going to lose placed Padilla in criminal proceedings.
I find it difficult to believe a word the government says. Padilla and his “dirty bomb” was trotted out by Attorney General Ashcroft as a part of the terror program of the Bush administration to make Americans afraid enough to throw away their civil liberties. It’s significant that that dirty nuke that the Bushies used to terrorize their own fellow citizens was never mentioned in Padilla’s trial. It’s gets more ridiculous when one gets one’s mind around this legal ledgerdemain: Padilla was accused and convicted of a conspiracy to recruit Qaeda operatives. According to the court records, Who did he recruit? Himself.
I wonder if it’s a conspiracy to weaken the public health if I buy a Whopper by recruiting myself to buy and eat one?
I find it difficult to believe a word the government says.
Indeed.
If the Government had a case they would have made it. Plainly they were straight out lying. Not one true word.
All roads lead to Jerusalem
From 1986 to 2004, Israel kept Mordechai Vanunu in a tomb sized cell with no window, most all of it in solitary confinement. Vanunu was drugged and interrogated without legal council and convicted of treason during a closed door trial. For the first two years of incarceration, a camera and light were on constantly. If Vanunu ever did nod off to sleep, “A guard would come and shine a brighter light into my face and say, ‘Just checking if you had committed suicide yet.'”
In 2002, President Bush declared U.S. citizen, Jose Padilla an enemy combatant and he was stripped of all rights and detained at a Navy brig in South Carolina where he was held in solitary isolation for 43 months and denied access to an attorney for two years.
Forensic Psychiatrist Angela Hegarty examined Padilla last year and concluded the extreme isolation and torture had left Padilla essentially brain damaged, “What happened at the brig was essentially the destruction of a human being’s mind.” http://www.democracynow.org/article.pl?sid=07/08/17/1323250
Padilla is devoid of a personality because of the cruel and inhumane treatment he endured for three and a half years. Vanunu has endured cruel and inhumane punishment for the last twenty-one years and has a challenging personality. Vanunu is justly paranoid for Israeli Security monitors his snail mail, email and telephone calls. He is justifiably angry at the injustice of being prevented from leaving Israel , which is all he has wanted for the last three years.
the rest:
Vanunu’s Other Woman from Florida
http://www.wearewideawake.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=619&Itemid=173
This is government lawlessness beyond anything in history, including Stalin’s Soviet Union and Hitler’s Nazi Germany.
It is both crazy and shameful that a jury would convict, based on the prosecution’s “evidence.”
We are in trouble.