Things Are Not Improving

Oops:

Iraqi tribal leader Abdul Sattar Abu Risha, a key figure in U.S. efforts to turn local residents against al-Qaeda in the restive Anbar province, was killed today by a roadside bomb, U.S. military and Iraqi sources confirmed.

That’s Sheikh Sattar shaking hands last week with George W. Bush. Back in June, Time Magazine described Sattar this way:

General Odierno, an Iraq veteran with a reputation for cold-eyed realism, has cited the military’s partnership with formerly anti-American tribes in the restive Anbar promise. There, U.S. Marines have supported a coalition of tribes, known as the “Anbar Salvation Front,” fighting al-Qaeda. The group’s leader, Sheikh Sattar al-Rishawi, is ostensibly cooperating with the U.S. and Iraqi forces to drive out the foreign fighters who make up much al-Qaeda’s ranks in Iraq. And since the alliance has been in effect, the number of attacks against U.S. forces in Anbar has halved.

But that’s only part of the picture. Sheikh Sattar, whose tribe is notorious for highway banditry, is also building a personal militia, loyal not to the Iraqi government but only to him. Other tribes — even those who want no truck with terrorists — complain they are being forced to kowtow to him. Those who refuse risk being branded as friends of al-Qaeda and tossed in jail, or worse. In Baghdad, government delight at the Anbar Front’s impact on al-Qaeda is tempered by concern that the Marines have unwittingly turned Sheikh Sattar into a warlord who will turn the province into his personal fiefdom.

As should be obvious from this description, it wasn’t necessarily al-Qaeda in Iraq elements that killed Sattar. In Washington, this guy was some kind of hero. In Anbar, he was a warlord that was known for highway robbery, who was cooperating with the occupiers and throwing people in jail without just cause.

Our country is having a debate about Iraq but it isn’t a debate that is even remotely connected to reality.

Author: BooMan

Martin Longman a contributing editor at the Washington Monthly. He is also the founder of Booman Tribune and Progress Pond. He has a degree in philosophy from Western Michigan University.