Imagine, if you could even think of the horrific situation, where a 20 year old “pretty white woman” was abducted by six black men and women, raped, stabbed, made to eat rat droppings, drink from a toilet, threatened with death if she tried to escape and tortured for around a week.
Imagine, not only what living hell that poor woman went through, but also the fact that she was still undergoing treatment for her injuries around a month later. Imagine the 24 hour outrage on the cable news, the papers, every caring human being, not to mention the outrage by the racist people who would be decrying this, “the culture that promotes animals like this”, how this was a hate crime and the potential revenge for these horrific acts.
Imagine that the suspects all had prior arrests and records for prior crimes, including one who was arrested for murder of an 84 year old woman but pled to a lesser charge of manslaughter. We would hear about this for months, and we would all know her name, the suspects names, backgrounds and every little development in her treatment, the case and the potential blowback to the community.
Now that you have finished imagining this hell that the poor woman was subjected to, ask yourself if you have ever heard the name “Megan Williams”. I bet you haven’t. I know I didn’t – at least before today when I got an email about this matter.
You see, Megan Williams is black. And all of what you just imagined actually did happen to her a few short weeks ago, yet there has been so very little reported on this case. No round the clock commentary on CNN. No “panel of experts” talking about the degradation and breakdown of the justice system that allowed these six to even be in a position to kidnap, rape and torture Ms. Williams. No calls for protests or help for Ms. Williams or her family in this time of need. No “on the ground” reporters with live updates at the local jail, courthouse or even interviewing the locals.
No “special segments” advertised on any of the major news networks and programs. At least none that I have seen. But if you look at ABC News’ web site’s US News page, you will find a story about Natalie Holloway’s mother “still holding out hope”. And the big poll on CNN.com is whether Britney can get her life back.
I am white. I couldn’t even begin to imagine the subtle racism or discrimination that occurs on a day to day basis. I wouldn’t even try to put myself in a position to discuss experiences, dirty looks, out of line comments or anything else. No matter how much I am against this and no matter how much I speak out against it, I probably can’t do it justice or appropriately capture the emotions, anger and frustration of those who experience this.
All that being said, I can speak and have spoken out quite a bit about the “missing pretty white woman” syndrome that has taken over the reporting arm of the US corporate media. When was the last time that a missing “non-white” woman was reported as missing for more than a few minute segment? What kind of coverage would a story like this get if Ms. Williams was a “pretty white woman”? And whose family has lots of money?
Yet, once again, we have a stark contrast here. Ms. Williams is not white. And I have no idea as to whether she is pretty or wealthy, but neither of those mean anything. What does matter is that she was kidnapped, brutally beaten, tortured and threatened with death by six white people in West Virginia. And that these six people have long records, her life is scarred beyond repair and unspeakable acts were committed against her while she was imprisoned by thugs and criminals for a week.
What also matters is that this got very little ongoing coverage, and the volume that the media silence speaks when the victim isn’t white, young, pretty and wealthy.
Why else wouldn’t this story get the coverage it deserves?
also in orange
Coverage of this incident certainly fell far short of what other stories have received. Not to provide justification, but those stories receiving great attention usually involve a missing victim or an unknown assailant. Here, the identities of all parties involved are known. As a result, news agencies are left with nothing about which they can provide their usual sickening speculation.
That may be true, but do you know how many black children go missing every year? Or, for that matter, poor white children? It’s national news if some rich squirt vanishes, but if the child is the wrong color or belongs to the wrong economic class, they’re just a faceless statistic.
The poor(of any color) have always been invisible and nothing much has ever changed for them and probably never will…I’m feeling particularly cynical and depressed today.
THANK YOU for this diary.
It never ceases to surprise me. This story is BARBARIC. Where are all the anguished op-eds about criminals not staying in jail? Not valuing life? The culture of depravity? Being too lazy and sorry to work?
Cricket chirps.
Byrd took to the Senate floor to denounce the torture of dogs by a person not in his state. Has he denounced the torture of a person IN his state?
Megan Williams–who courageously decided to be identified–will need years of care to recover from her torture. Why does her story garner little attention? And why has the punditocracy fallen mute?
Doesn’t fit the narrative. But I think we knew that already.
I’ve been wondering about the lack of coverage too, and I can only assume that the West Virginia tourism board or something got to the news media and paid them off. Ok, kidding….but when you look at the mug shots of those people they embody every single unfortunate stereotype about the area. I wonder how much of it has to do with everyone writing off that segment of society and not considering them even worthy of news coverage?
If that situation happened in a middle class suburban area I think it would have exploded in the media even if the victim was black. I think poverty is the difference here….not discounting race as well.
By US National Media standards, this ain’t a story.
No loose ends, no rich folks, no celebrities. Bunch of poor crackers fucked up a poor black girl (though they wouldn’t phrase it quite that way). No Humans Involved, no reason for the desirable advertising demographics to be made aware as it might make them uneasy.
This, as we all know, is what corporate media is.
Yes.
And as Carl Lee Haley might have put it, they deserve to die and I hope they burn in hell!
Yes, I agree and sometimes the quick and easy answer is also the right one.
I dunno.
It’s deeper than that.
Where are all the national screamlines about Carol Anne Gotbaum?
Granddaughter of a MAJOR Dem labor hustler…Mafia connections and all…dead in Phoenix Airport after being “detained” by Homeboy Security-type assholes.
Where’s the outrage?
Because she was headed for rehab?
Because she has old left-Jewish-labor-crooked Dem-bloodlines?
I mean…
She IS “white”.
Right?
Too far left to be Right? I mean…white?
I dunno.
It’s getting complicated out there….
AG
It’s not so complicated. Right-wing-Republican-influenced Media will report whatever works for their favor, their agenda. Be damned the Jewish Dem whitie.
If it’s not a person the Right can play off for their advantage, they won’t be playing.
Yeah.
But my point stands.
It isn’t NECESSARILY about race.
It is about alliances.
Witness Clarence Thomas.
AG
It’s very simple to work out how this would be framed by the right wing noise machine.
From the AP:
RW talking point, “She is a criminal, just like the alleged perpetrators”.
RW talking point, “A bunch of crackheads in a rundown trailer in West Virginia. When you run with people like that, you have to expect shit like this. After all, that’s what “those people” do.”
RW talking point, “That tells you everything you need to know right there. She is a street person.”
And so it would go. She’s a drug addict with a criminal history, hanging out with other drug addicts in a rundown trailer. And she was prone to disappearing for weeks at a time so her mother wasn’t really even worried until the police found her. That would be the storyline. And the subtle implication and the unspoken validation to all the listeners in winger-land would be that, yes, “those people” are all criminals and crazed druggies who torture each other.
And the biggest belief validation for them would be contained in this:
Hmmmm…..black girl in a relationship with a white guy? Yep, they would think, maybe she got what she deserved.